Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions in Section 37 of the C.P.C read along with Sections 14 and 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
  • Section 5 of the Madras Hindu (Bigamy Prevention and Divorce) Act, 1949
  • Sections 28 and 29 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
  • SECTION 8 FAMILY COURTS ACT 1984
  • Order IX, Rule 13 and Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 150 and Order IX of Rule 13
  • provisions in Section 150, C.P.C
  • Order IX, Rule 13, C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions in Section 37 of the C.P.C read along with Sections 14 and 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
  • Section 5 of the Madras Hindu (Bigamy Prevention and Divorce) Act, 1949
  • Sections 28 and 29 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
  • SECTION 8 FAMILY COURTS ACT 1984
  • Order IX, Rule 13 and Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 150 and Order IX of Rule 13
  • provisions in Section 150, C.P.C
  • Order IX, Rule 13, C.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ramakrishnan, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant seeks to set aside a non-speaking order dismissing applications I.A. 1960 and I.A. 1961 of 1996, which were filed to set aside an ex parte decree passed in O.S. 163 of 1991 by the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda. The suit O.S. 163/1991 was filed by the respondents against the appellant and her son Sasi; the respondents claimed to be the wife and son of Sasi and sought maintenance, value of gold ornaments and an alleged amount due to the first plaintiff. The suit was initially filed as an indigent petition (POP 106/89) and later numbered O.S. 163/1991. The appellant alleges she did not receive communications from her advocate and that the suit was decreed ex parte on 13-11-1991. She discovered the ex parte decree only upon receiving notice in the execution proceedings and immediately filed I.A. 1960 and 1961 of 1996 to set aside the ex parte decree and to condone delay.

The applications were noticed and a counter-affidavit was filed by the respondents opposing the applications. The applications were posted for examination of the appellant on 22-7-1997, but the Sub Court advanced the matter suo motu to 27-6-1997, giving notice only to the appellant’s counsel. The counsel sent a letter to the appellant, but it reached her on the evening of 27-6-1997. When the matter was taken up on 27-6-1997, the Sub Court dismissed both applications for default, rejecting the counsel's request for a short adjournment. The appellant appealed against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order of the Sub Court dismissing I.A. 1960 and I.A. 1961 of 1996 for default (by rejecting a short adjournment when the appellant was not personally served with the advanced date) is legally sustainable.
  2. Whether the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda had jurisdiction after the establishment of the Family Court, Ernakulam, to entertain and dispose of applications filed after establishment of the Family Court for setting aside an ex parte decree passed prior to the Family Court's establishment (i.e., whether jurisdiction in such matters vested exclusively in the Family Court under Sections 7 and 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant did not receive information from her advocate about developments and only learned of the ex parte decree when execution proceedings were served.
  • The appellant filed I.A. 1960 and 1961 of 1996 promptly on learning of the decree and sought adjournment when the case was advanced; rejection of the adjournment and dismissal for default was unjustified because the appellant had not been personally notified of the advanced date.
  • The Sub Court lacked jurisdiction after the Family Court, Ernakulam was established (per Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984) and therefore the Sub Court's order is vulnerable on jurisdictional grounds as well.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents filed counter-affidavits opposing the appellant's applications (the opinion records that they opposed the applications, but does not state the detailed content of those opposing arguments).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.N. Kalathi v. Ellammal, AIR 1964 Mad 463 Support for the proposition that territorial adjustment/transfer can cause transfer of business and that a court within the new territorial jurisdiction alone may entertain an application to set aside an earlier decree. The court relied on Ellammal to analogise that jurisdiction transfers can operate to prevent the original civil court from entertaining applications after territorial/jurisdictional change and to support the position that Family Court would have exclusive jurisdiction post-establishment.
Union of India v. Anandi Lal, (1995) 1 Current Civil Cases 559 (Raj) Illustrates that after commencement of the Administrative Tribunals Act, the courts that passed prior decrees lose jurisdiction to entertain execution/applications in matters now vested in the Tribunal (analogy to Sections 7 and 8 of Family Courts Act). The court used Anandi Lal to show that statutory exclusion of jurisdiction (by a later statute) operates to vest jurisdiction in a specialized forum and that the civil court ceases to have jurisdiction to entertain subsequent proceedings of that nature.
Srinivasa v. Hanumantha, AIR 1922 Mad 10 Authority cited in Ellammal concerning transfer of business upon territorial adjustments under Section 150, C.P.C. Cited (via Ellammal) to support the proposition that transfer of territorial jurisdiction results in transfer of business and thus of jurisdiction to entertain subsequent applications.
M. Guruswamy Naicker v. Sheikh Muhammadhu Rowther, AIR 1923 Madras 92 Earlier Madras decisions on transfer of business arising from territorial adjustments (cited in Ellammal). Relied upon (through Ellammal) to reinforce the legal principle that territorial changes transfer judicial business and jurisdiction.
Narasimha Raju v. Brundavanasahu, AIR 1943 Madras 617 Earlier precedent referenced in Ellammal on transfer of business following territorial adjustment. Used as supporting authority (through Ellammal) for the rule that jurisdiction and business transfer with territorial changes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court divided its analysis into two main strands: (A) the procedural fairness of the Sub Court's dismissal for default, and (B) the jurisdictional effect of the Family Courts Act, 1984 on post-establishment applications to set aside pre-establishment decrees.

A. Procedural fairness (dismissal for default)

  • Facts undisputed: the applications were originally posted for 22-7-1997; the Sub Court advanced the hearing suo motu to 27-6-1997 and notified only the appellant's counsel.
  • The appellant's counsel informed the appellant by letter, but the appellant received that letter only on the evening of 27-6-1997.
  • The Sub Court took up the matter on 27-6-1997, rejected the counsel's prayer for a short adjournment, and dismissed the applications for default without giving the appellant a sufficient opportunity to be present or to be heard.
  • Conclusion on this strand: the learned Judge was not justified in dismissing the applications; the order was passed without giving the party sufficient opportunity and hence was liable to be set aside on procedural grounds.

B. Jurisdiction under the Family Courts Act, 1984

  • Statutory framework: Section 7(1) confers upon Family Courts the entirety of jurisdiction exercisable by district and subordinate civil courts in respect of suits/proceedings specified in the Explanation to Section 7; Section 8 excludes the jurisdiction of civil courts within the territorial jurisdiction of the Family Court.
  • Chronology and effect: Family Court, Ernakulam was established by notification dated 6-6-1992; a Judge was appointed by notification dated 7-7-1992. From at least 7-7-1992 the jurisdiction of civil courts within the Family Court's area in respect of matters in the Explanation to Section 7 stood excluded and vested in the Family Court.
  • Nature of the underlying suit: the reliefs in O.S. 163/1991 fall within the clauses of the Explanation to Section 7(1), so the jurisdiction civil courts once had in respect of that suit would be statutorily vested in the Family Court upon its establishment.
  • Disposal prior to Family Court establishment: although the ex parte decree was passed before the Family Court was established (so there was no automatic transfer of the pending suit), the critical question is whether a civil court can, after establishment of the Family Court, entertain applications filed after establishment to set aside such pre-establishment decrees.
  • Court's interpretive conclusion: there is no saving provision in the Act preserving civil courts' power to exercise jurisdiction in respect of suits and proceedings already disposed of prior to the Family Court's establishment. The wording of Section 7 indicates that all jurisdiction previously exercisable by civil courts in respect of the categories enumerated—whether pending, to be filed, or already disposed of—vests in the Family Court. Thus, post-establishment, only the Family Court has the jurisdiction to entertain applications such as those to set aside ex parte decrees and to deal with delay-condonation petitions related to them.
  • Analogous authorities: the court observed that Madras and Rajasthan High Courts have taken similar views in analogous contexts (citing Ellammal and Anandi Lal). Ellammal was relied upon for the principle that territorial/functional transfers can vest jurisdiction in another court to the exclusion of the original court; Anandi Lal was relied upon by analogy to illustrate that specialized forums created by statute (Administrative Tribunals) exclude civil court jurisdiction even in respect of actions arising from decrees passed earlier.
  • Conclusion on this strand: entertainment and disposal of I.A. 1960 and I.A. 1961 of 1996 by the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda after the establishment of the Family Court was without jurisdiction; the impugned order is therefore liable to be set aside on jurisdictional grounds as well.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; the impugned order set aside.

Direct effects and immediate procedural consequences ordered by the court:

  • The dismissal of I.A. 1960 and I.A. 1961 of 1996 by the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda is set aside (on both procedural and jurisdictional grounds).
  • The Sub Court is directed to forward I.A. 1960 and I.A. 1961 of 1996 to the Family Court, Ernakulam with appropriate endorsements and notice to the petitioners, for entertainment and disposal afresh in accordance with law.
  • The entire records in O.S. 163 of 1991 must be forwarded to the Family Court, Ernakulam along with the applications.
  • Parties will bear their respective costs.
  • The order on C.M.P. No. 4207 of 1997 in C.M.A. No. 184 of 1997 was dismissed and the appeal disposed accordingly.

Broader implications and precedent: the court articulated and applied the legal principle that upon establishment of a Family Court its jurisdiction (under Section 7 read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984) replaces that of the civil courts in respect of the specified categories of suits and proceedings, and that this exclusion extends to applications filed after establishment even in relation to decrees passed before establishment. The opinion relied on analogous authorities (Madras and Rajasthan decisions) to support this position. The judgment directs a practical procedural course (forwarding applications and records to the Family Court) intended to avoid unnecessary delay, but the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel statutory construction beyond the application of Sections 7 and 8 and existing analogous authorities.

    Devaki v. Chandrika And Another

    Ramakrishnan, J.:— The simple relief prayed for in this appeal is to set aside a non-speaking order of dismisssal for default of an application, I.A 1960 of 1996, filed by the appellant for setting aside an ex parte decree passed against her in O.S 163 of 1991 on the file of the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda. However, two important questions; one of jurisdiction of the Court and the Other of procedure, arise for consideration in this appeal.

    2. Facts required to be stated are thus: The suit O.S 163 of 1991 is one filed by the respondents against the appellant and her son who is not a party to the appeal. The first respondent is the mother of the second respondent. Respondents have filed the suit claiming that they are the wife and son of Sasi, one of the sons of the appellant who has been impleaded as a defendant along with her in the suit. The prayer in the suit was for a decree for realisation of a total amount of Rs. 33,801/- being past maintenance for 3 years along with the value of gold ornaments weighing 4½ sovereigns and the amount of Rs. 5,001/- alleged to be due to the first plaintiff. Originally the suit was filed as an indigent petition (POP 106/89). On receiving notice, the appellant and her son Sasi have entered appearance and filed their objection through a counsel. Later, the POP was allowed and the petition was numbered as O.S 163 of 1991. Thereafter it is the case of the appellant that she neverreceived any information from her Advocate and the suit was decreed ex parte on 13-11-1991. She came to know about the ex parte decree only when she received notice in the E.P filed for executing the decree against her. Immediately thereafter the appellant filed I.A 1960 and 1961 of 1996 to set aside the ex parte decree and to condone the delay in filing the application to set aside the ex parte decree. On receiving notice, the respondents have filed counter-affidavit opposing the prayers in the applications. The applications were posted to 22-7-1997, for examining the appellant. But thereafter the Court suo motu advanced the case to 27-6-1997 giving notice to the counsel for the appellant. Even though the counsel for the appellant has sent a letter intimating the advancing of the case to 27-6-1997 to the appellant, the same was received by the appellant only on the evening of 27-6-1997. However, when the case was taken up on 27-6-1997, the learned Judge dismissed both the applications for default rejecting the prayer for a short adjournment made by the counsel for the appellant. Aggrieved by the order dismissing I.A 1960 of 1991 appellant has preferred this appeal.

    3. We may first consider the question whether the impugned order is sustainable in law or not. The facts noted above are not in dispute and as such we are of the view that the learned Judge was not justified in dismissing the applications, I.A 1960 and 1961 of 1996 rejecting the prayer for adjournment made by the counsel for the appellant. It is a case where the applications were adjourned for the examination of the parties to 22-7-1997 and the Court has suo motu advanced the case to 27-6-1997 without issuing notice to the parties directly. The notice of advancing the case was given only to the advocate and the letter sent by the advocate was received by the appellant only on the evening of 27-6-1997. As such it is a clear case where the appellant cannot be blamed for her absence in Court on 27-6-1997. In the circumstances we are of the view that it is an order passed without giving the party a sufficient opportunity to prosecute the same and as such liable to be set aside for that reason alone.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant has a further contention that the Sub Court. Irinjalakuda had no jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of the application as such jurisdiction of the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda stood excluded as per Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (for short “the Act”) on and after the establishment of the Family Court for the area within which Sub Court, Irinjalakuda is situated. In the circumstances, it was submitted that since the Court had no jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of the matter, the impugned order is liable to be set aside on that ground also.

    5. Admittedly, the Family Court, Emakulam was established by a notification dated 6-6-1992 and the area falling within the jurisdiction of Sub Court, Irinjalakuda came within the jurisdiction of the said Family Court. But a Judge for the Family Court, Ernakulam was appointed only as per a notification dated 7-7-1992. As such at least with effect from 7-7-1992, if not earlier, the jurisdiction of all civil courts within the territorial jurisdiction of the Family Court, to entertain suits of the nature specified in the Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act stands totally excluded as per Section 8 of the Act. In this case going by the nature of the reliefs prayed for in the suit there cannot be any doubt about the fact that the suit in question was one falling within the purview of the provision in clauses ‘c’ and T of the Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act. As such if the suit was pending on the date when Family Court was established, Sub Court, Irinjalakuda would not have jurisdiction to try and dispose of the suit and the same would have stood statutorily transferred to the Family Court under Section 8 of the Act. But in this case since the suit was decreed ex parte prior to the establishment of the Family Court, there was no question of statutory transfer of the suit as such to the Family Court. However, the relevant question to be considered is whether the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda was having jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of an application filed after the establishment of the Family Court for the purpose of setting aside the ex parte decree passed in a suit prior to the establishment of the Family Court or not?

    6. Section 8 excludes the jurisdiction of all Civil Courts within the local jurisdiction of Family Court to deal with the categories of suits and proceeding enumerated in the Explanation to Section 7. All pending suits and proceedings of the categories mentioned in the Explanation get statutorily transferred to the Family Court on its establishment. Thus the scheme of the Act is to exclude with reference to the date of establishment of Family Court all the Civil Courts from I exercising all the jurisdictions they were having hither to in respect of the categories of suits and proceedings mentioned in the Explanation and to confer all such jurisdictions on the Family Court on its establishment in relation to the particular area for which the Family Court is established. The above legislative scheme will be evident from the provisions in Section 7(1)(a) and (b) of the Act which is as under:

    “Jurisdiction. — (1) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, a Family Court shall—

    (a) have and exercise all the jurisdiction exercisable by any district court or any subordinate civil court under any law for the time being in force in respect of suits and proceedings of the nature referred to in the Explanation; and

    (b) be deemed, for the purpose of exercising such jurisdiction, under such law, to be a district court or, as the case may be, such subordinate civil court for the area to which the jurisdiction of the Family Court extends.”

    It is significant to note that the jurisdiction conferred is the entirety of the jurisdiction exercised by all the civil Courts in respect of the categories of the suits and proceedings mentioned in the Explanation to Section 7 and that while exercising such jurisdiction there is a statutory deeming that Family Court shall be deemed to be civil Courts of different categories for the areas to which the jurisdiction of such Family Court extends. In the light of the above provision in Section 7, we would hold that all the jurisdiction which the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda had in respect of the suit and the ex parte decree passed therein have stood vested or conferred statutorily on the Family Court, Ernakulam as per Section 7(1) of the Act and on the establishment of the Family Court, that Court alone has got exclusive right to exercise all such jurisdictions. On the passing of the ex parte decree in the suit, defendants had a statutory right to approach that Court and to file an application to set aside the ex parte decree under Order IX, Rule 13, C.P.C with a petition to condone the delay under the Limitation Act for condoning the delay, if any, occurred in the matter of filing such an application, Sub Court would have certainly had jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of such application under Order IX, Rule 13 and Section 5 of the Limitation Act as the Court which had jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of the suit but for the provisions in Sections 7 and 8 of the Act. As such, such jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of applications like those filed by the appellant would in this case stand vested in the Family Court, Ernakulam on its establishment. There is nothing in the Act to show that civil Courts would continue to have power to exercise all jurisdicitons they had with reference to the suits and proceedings of the category mentioned in the Explanation which were already disposed of by them prior to the establishment of the Family Court. On the other hand the wording, of the provisions in Section 7 of the Act would clearly show that all the jurisdiction exercised by the Civil Courts in respect of the suits and proceedings of the category mentioned in the Explanation to Section 7 whether disposed of, pending or to be filed would vest in the Family Court to the exclusion of all the civil Courts in the area to which the jurisdiction of the Family Court extends. On and after the establishment of the Family Court it cannot also be that parties affected by the ex parte decrees passed in suits prior to the decree be deprived of their valuable right to file application under Order IX, Rule 13 and Section 5 of the Limitation Act if there occurs delay. It is significant to note in this connection that there is no provision in the Act saving of the jurisdiction of the Civil Courts in respect of suits and proceedings covered by the Explanation and disposed of already by the Civil Courts prior to the establishment of the Family Court. In the circumstances, it has to be held generally that the entire jurisdiction exercisable by the Civil Courts in respect of suits and proceedings of the categories covered by the Explanation and already disposed of by them prior to the establishment of the Family Court would stand statutorily excluded and vested in the Family Court established for the areas within their jurisdiction and only such Family Court would have thereafter jurisdiction to entertain any application or petition in such disposed of matters and to dispose of them in accordance with law.

    7. If support is needed for the above view which we have taken in the matter, we find that Madras and Rajasthan High Courts have taken a similar view in more or less similar factual situations in the decisions reported in P.N Kalathi v. Ellammal. AIR 1964 Mad 463 and Union of India v. Anandi Lal, (1995) 1 Current Civil Cases 559 (Raj).

    8. Ellammal's case (supra) was a case where a petition was filed by the husband of Ellammal under Section 5 of the Madras Hindu (Bigamy Prevention and Divorce) Act, 1949 for dissolution of his manage with her before the Chittoor Sub Court. An ex parte decree was passed in the petition. Subsequent to the passing of the ex parte decree, Sholinghur, the place where the parties were residing and which was within the jurisdiction of the District Court, Chittoor came within the jurisdiction of the North Arcot District. After such territorial adjustment, Ellammal filed an application under Section 150 and Order IX of Rule 13 to set aside the ex parte order of dissolution of marriage before the Vellore Sub Court which was subordinate to the District Court, North Arcot. Maintainability of the application was challenged, Vellore Sub Court upheld the objection and held that the application is not maintainable. On appeal, the decision was reversed. The High Court of Madras upheld the view taken by the appellate Court in the above decision while dismissing the revision petition filed by the husband Of Ellammal. While taking the view that Vellore Sub Court alone had jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of the application for setting aside the decree, the High Court has relied upon the provisions in Section 150, C.P.C regarding transfer of business from one Court to the other and the earlier decisions rendered by the Court in Srinivasa v. Hanumantha, AIR 1922 Mad 10; M. Guruswamy Naicker v. Sheikh Muhammadhu Rowther, AIR 1923 Madras 92 and Narasimha Raju v. Brundavanasahu, AIR 1943 Madras 617. It was held that when a territorial adjustment takes place there will be a transfer of business from one Court to the other if certain areas are removed from the territorial jurisdiction of one Court and added to the jurisdiction of another Court.

    9. Anandi Lal's case (1995 (1) Cur Civ Cas 559) (Raj) (supra) was a case where a decree for recovery of arrears of pay and allowance of a Government employee was passed by the Civil Court prior to the commencement of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 with effect from 1-11-1985. In 1986 the decree holder filed an application for executing the decree before the Civil Court which passed the decree. On behalf of the Union of India it was contended that E.P filed before the Civil Court was not maintainable in the light of the provisions in Section 37 of the C.P.C read along with Sections 14 and 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 excluding the jurisdiction of all the Civil Courts and High Courts and conferring jurisdiction on the Tribunal regarding service matters. Rajasthan High Court has held that on and after the commencement of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 the Court which passed the decree ceases to have jurisdiction to entertain the E.P and the Tribunal alone had exclusive jurisdiction to enetertain and dispose of the E.P The legal effect of Sections 28 and 29 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 is more or less similar to the legal effect of Sections 7 and 8 of the Act.

    10. In view of principles followed by the Courts while deciding the above two cases and the cases referred to therein are applicable to the case on hand also, if not on all four at least analogically. We have already indicated that the provisions contained in Section 7 itself would provide sufficient reasons to take the above view in this case and we need not rely upon any other general principle analogically or otherwise in support of the above view.

    11. We would, in the circumstances, hold that entertainment and disposal of the applications, I.As 1960 and 1961 of 1996 is without jurisdiction and as such liable to be set aside on that ground also.

    12. In the light of our finding that the Sub Court, Irinjalakuda had no jurisdiction to entertain and dispose of the applications, the proper procedure which that court ought to have followed was to receive the applications and on receipt of the applications forward the same to the Family Court concerned even before entertaining them with appropriate endorsement and with notice to the petitioner/petitioners; for entertainment and disposal in accordance with law. We are indicating the above procedure as the proper one because such a procedure would avoid the necessity of returning the applications for presentation to the Family Court, its presentation before the Family Court and the forwarding of the records by the Civil Court to the Family Court in response to the request of the Family Court for records, etc. which would necessarily cause considerably long delay and protraction of the proceedings. We would further indicate that as far as suits and proceedings disposed of by the Civil Courts prior to the establishment of the Family Court and coming within the ambit of the Explanation to Section 7 of the Act are concerned, it will be legal and proper for the Family Court to entertain and dispose of such applications/petitions after calling for the records of the disposal of suits or proceedings from the concerned Civil Courts on the request of the parties.

    Appeal is thus allowed. There will be a direction to the Court below to forward the application numbered as I.As 1960 and 1961 of 1996 to the Family Court, Ernakulam with appropriate endorsements for entertainment and disposal afresh in accordance with law by the Family Court, Ernakulam. The entire records in O.S 163 of 1991 should also be forwarded to the Family Court along with the applications. Parties will bear their respective costs.

    Order on C.M.P No. 4207 of 1997 in C.M.A No. 184 of 1997 dismissed.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devaki v. Chandrika And Another
    (Sep 9, 1997)