Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners had previously filed Miscellaneous Criminal Application No. 2412 of 1991, which was withdrawn on 14-8-1991. The present petition does not explicitly state that no other applications have been filed before this Court or the Supreme Court. During the investigation, a bail application was filed and withdrawn. The petitioners' Advocate initially claimed that the chargesheet was not with him at the time of the earlier bail application, but later it was clarified that the chargesheet had indeed been filed and was with the petitioners' Advocate. The earlier bail application withdrawal was treated as a dismissal of that petition. The current bail application was filed without any new grounds for bail.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a subsequent bail application can be entertained after an earlier bail application has been withdrawn, absent any fresh grounds or circumstances.
  2. Whether receipt of the chargesheet by the accused's relatives is a necessary condition for filing or deciding a bail application.
  3. Whether bail should be granted to the petitioners on merits, considering the prima facie case under Section 302 IPC and the potential threat to prosecution witnesses.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The earlier bail application was withdrawn because the Advocate did not have the chargesheet papers, which were with the trial Court’s Advocate.
  • The petitioners' relatives, who had not received the chargesheet earlier, have now obtained it and given instructions to file the present bail application.
  • The Court should consider the present bail application on its merits, regardless of the earlier withdrawal.

Respondent's Arguments

  • This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed that the earlier bail application, having been withdrawn after the chargesheet was already filed and known to the petitioners’ Advocate, effectively amounted to dismissal. The Court held that subsequent bail applications without fresh grounds are not maintainable. The argument that the chargesheet must be received by the petitioners' relatives for the bail application to be valid was rejected as lacking any legal basis. On merits, the Court noted the learned Additional Sessions Judge’s findings of a prima facie case under Section 302 IPC and the risk of witnesses being threatened, which would impair the prosecution. Accordingly, even if the current application were maintainable, bail would not be granted.

Holding and Implications

The application for bail is rejected.

The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the present bail application filed by the petitioners. No new legal precedent was established, and the ruling reinforces the principle that bail applications withdrawn after the chargesheet is filed cannot be renewed without fresh grounds. The Court also clarified that receipt of the chargesheet by relatives is not a legal prerequisite for bail applications.

    Shyamdutt Upadhyay And Ors. v. State Of Gujarat

    Shethna, J.

    1. The petitioners have earlier filed Miscellaneous Criminal Application No. 2412 of 1991, which was withdrawn on 14-8-1991. However, though Mr. Saiyed, learned Advocate himself appeared in the matter also, no such averment is made in this petition. Not even a statement is made in this application that except this application, no other application is filed before this Court or before the Supreme Court.

    2. When I had called upon Mr. Saiyed to explain about the same, he submitted that he has made an averment in para-9 which reads as under:

    During the investigation, one bail application was filed but was withdrawn.

    This statement is absolutely vague. It leads neither here nor there. However, Mr. Ssiyed stated that he wants to explain the same. Therefore, leave to amend is granted.

    3. By way of an amendment, Mr. Saiyed has stated at the end of para-9 in this application as under:

    It is submitted that at the time of Bail Application No. 2412 of 1991 the chargesheet was not with the Advocate, though it was submitted in the Court.

    From the order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge on 26th July, 1991 in Bail Application No. 602 of 1991, it has become more than clear that in fact the chargesheet was with the trial Court Advocate. In fact, on the basis of that only the petitioner's Advocate made a submission before the trial Court that now the chargesheet is filed and the investigation is over and, therefore, there should not any objection in releasing the accused on bail by the Court. If the papers of the chargesheet were with the trial Court's Advocate of the petitioners, then it is very difficult to believe that the papers of the chargesheet were not with the Advocate of the petitioners, who had filed earlier Bail Application being Miscellaneous Criminal Application No. 2412 of 1991 before this Court. At this stage, it is to be noted that in the earlier Bail Application being M.C.A. No. 2412 of 1991 the statement is made in para 8 by Mr. Saiyed himself, learned Advocate for the petitioners, that the chargesheet has already been filed. Thus, the chargesheet was filed and the papers of the said chargesheet were with the petitioners' Advocate even at that time. In my view, once the Bail Application is filed before this Court after the chargesheet, is received by the accused and the same is withdrawn from this Court, it amounts to dismissal of the petition. When a Court is not inclined to grant the bail, it would give some reasons rejecting the application, which might come in the way of the accused during the trial and because of that the Advocate for the accused would prefer to withdraw the application instead of getting the application rejected with reasons. In such an event the subsequent bail application of the same accused cannot be entertained unless and until fresh circumstance or ground is made out by the accused for releasing him on bail. In this case, no new ground is made out by the petitioners for releasing them on bail. Therefore, this application is required to be rejected.

    4. However, Mr. Saiyed urged before me that though the chargesheet was filed before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, the same was with the Advocate appearing for petitioners in the trial Court, and it had not come in the hands of the relatives of the petitioners. Therefore, in the absence of the chargesheet he had withdrawn the earlier petition filed before this Court. But now he has got papers of the chargesheet with him. Therefore, according to him, this Court should consider this Bail Application on its own merits, irrespective of the fact that the earlier Bail Application was withdrawn by him. He has further submitted that the petitioners' relatives are coming from Uttar Pradesh and, therefore, the present application is made after obtaining necessary instructions from the relatives of the petitioners and receiving the papers of the chargesheet. However, this submission made by Mr. Saiyed cannot be accepted for the simple reason that there is no provision of law which provides that the papers of the chargesheet should be received by the relatives. Because the accused are in Jail and when the papers of the chargesheet are received by the relatives then on their instructions when the matter is argued by the petitioners' Advocate the Court should consider the Bail Application and decide the same, such argument is itself devoid of any merit. Therefore, it is rejected.

    5. Even assuming for the sake of argument that this Bail Application can be considered on merits and I have to decide whether bail can be granted to the petitioner-accused in this application or not, in that case also, in my view, the bail could not have been granted to the present petitioners. Because the learned Additional Sessions Judge has observed that in this case the witnesses are not related to the deceased and, therefore, if a threat is given to them then they will not support the prosecution case, which may damage the prosecution case. The learned Additional Sessions Judge has also found prima facie case against the petitioners under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code as number of blows were given on the head of the deceased.

    6. In that view of the matter, no bail can be granted to the petitioners, even if on merits this application was maintainable.

    Accordingly this application fails and is rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shyamdutt Upadhyay And Ors. v. State Of Gujarat
    (Sep 23, 1991)