AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the original complainant and brother of the deceased, Babiben, who was the wife of Kanubhai/Mafatlal Patel (respondent No. 1). The death of Babiben is admitted to be unnatural. The petitioner alleges that his sister was murdered by members of her husband's family (the respondents) and submitted a written complaint to Chanasma police station (annexure-A to the Special Criminal Application). The incident occurred at about 9:00 p.m. on 8-8-1987. The written complaint was given on 10-8-1987 but was not recorded as an FIR at that time.

On 11-8-1987 a statement of the complainant was recorded, registered as FIR at CR No. 97 of 1987, and treated as offences punishable under certain sections noted in the record. A charge-sheet was filed on 24-9-1987 for offences punishable under Section 498A and 202 read with Section 114 of the Indian Penal Code. The complainant later wrote to a senior police official (Special Inspector General of Police, CID (Crimes)) on 26-8-1987, expressing dissatisfaction with the local investigation and alleging influence and improper investigation by the police.

The petitioner sought directions that (a) the written complaint annexure-A be registered as an FIR for offences including Section 302 IPC (murder), (b) that the investigation be entrusted to an independent agency such as CID (Crimes), and (c) cancellation of bail granted to the respondent. The High Court considered the competing contentions and evidence relating to the adequacy and direction of the police investigation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court should direct the police to register the petitioner's written complaint (annexure-A) as an FIR for offences including Section 302 IPC (murder).
  2. Whether the investigation by the local police is so improper, casual or directed to a pre-determined conclusion (suicide) that the investigation should be transferred to an independent/senior agency (CID (Crimes)).
  3. Whether the High Court should interfere with the police investigation and the executive function of the police in the present case.
  4. Whether bail granted to the respondent in respect of the charges already framed (Sections 498A and 201/202/114 as reflected in the charge-sheet) should be cancelled in view of the petitioner's allegations.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner / Complainant's Arguments

  • The complainant alleged that his sister was murdered by the respondents and had given written information of an offence under Section 302 IPC which the police did not accept or record as an FIR.
  • He asserted that the police investigation proceeded on a fixed theory of suicide from the beginning, that the investigation was highly improper, casual and deliberately steered to a desired conclusion.
  • He requested that the investigation be conducted by an independent agency (CID (Crimes)) and that the complaint dated 10-8-1987 (annexure-A) be registered as an FIR for murder (Section 302 IPC) and other relevant sections.
  • He also sought cancellation of bail granted to the respondent.

Respondents / Accused's Arguments

  • The respondents maintained that the death was an unfortunate suicide and that they were absolutely innocent.
  • They relied on the fact that after investigation the police had filed a charge-sheet for offences under Sections 498A and 201 (read with Section 114), and submitted that the trial process should proceed without judicial interference in the executive function of police investigation.
  • They argued that remedies are available under the Code if the FIR was not recorded (for example, approaching the Superintendent of Police under Section 154(3), filing a private complaint directly in Court, or seeking further investigation under Section 173(8)), and that the High Court should not ordinarily intervene in the field of investigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of West Bengal v. Sampat Lal (Supreme Court) The judiciary should not decide at interlocutory stage whether a death is suicide or murder; appointment of a special officer for investigation is permissible only if statutory channel of investigation is found not to have functioned properly, and authorities must be given opportunity to show how they discharged their statutory obligations. The court relied on this principle to emphasize that judicial intervention in investigation is exceptional; nevertheless, it used the standard that a special investigation may be ordered if the statutory investigative machinery has failed, which framed the assessment of the present investigation.
King Emperor v. Khwaja Nasim Ahmed (AIR 1945 PC 18; 1945-46 Cri LJ 413) The functions of the judiciary and the police are complementary, not overlapping; ordinarily each should exercise its own function and courts intervene only in appropriate cases (e.g., under Section 491 CrPC for habeas corpus). Applied as authority for the proposition that police have primary responsibility for investigation and courts should not create a new channel of inquiry unless necessary; supported limited scope of judicial interference.
State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanna Followed the Privy Council view that the power of the police to investigate a cognizable offence is ordinarily not to be interfered with by the judiciary. Used to reinforce the limited nature of judicial interference in police investigations.
Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, Delhi (1983 Cri LJ 1981) In cases like bride burning/dowry deaths, ordinary police investigation may be inadequate; investigation may be transferred (e.g., to CBI) where police investigation is casual, lacks incisiveness and is dilatory; investigators must not proceed from a tentative conclusion (such as suicide) and must look for prima facie motive/evidence. The court treated this precedent as directly apposite: where police investigation is casual and directed to a conclusion, transfer to a higher/independent agency is warranted. The opinion applied these considerations in finding the present investigation unsatisfactory and directed transfer to CID (Crimes).
State Of West Bengal v. S.N. Basak Statutory power of the police to investigate cannot be interfered with by exercise of powers under Section 439 or under inherent power of the Court under Section 561A. Cited by the respondents to argue against judicial interference; the court acknowledged this authority while also noting the exceptions identified in other precedents.
S. N. Sharma v. Bipen Kumar Tiwari Police power to investigate cognizable offences is uncontrolled by the Magistrate except where the police decide not to investigate; in such cases a Magistrate may intervene. An aggrieved person may seek remedy in the High Court under constitutional provisions (opinion references Article 228). Referred to for the limited circumstances in which judicial intervention is permissible; helped frame the balance between police primacy and remedies for aggrieved persons.
Kanaksinh H. Jadeja v. Balbhadrasinh N. Jhala (1987 (2) Guj LR 1219; 1988 Cri LJ 578) Investigation is the exclusive field of the executive; the High Court should not, by exercise of inherent powers (Section 482 CrPC), ordinarily prevent the police from investigating except in exceptional cases where non-interference would result in miscarriage of justice. Relied upon to support the principle of non-interference in investigations, while acknowledging that the present case could be an exceptional one justifying intervention.
Eastern Spinning Mills v. Rajiv Poddar Save in exceptional cases where non-interference would result in miscarriage of justice, the Court and judicial process should not interfere at any stage of investigation of offences. Cited to underline that judicial interference in investigation is exceptional; the court balanced this presumption against the facts indicating unsatisfactory investigation in the present case.
Joint Women's Programme v. State of Rajasthan Supreme Court interim direction: investigation into certain unnatural deaths to be conducted by an officer not below the rank of Superintendent of Police and States to create special dowry cells / specialised investigating units including involvement of social women workers. The court referenced this decision to support the need for specialised investigative machinery (dowry cells) and directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Home Secretary for broader administrative action in the State.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out the general legal principle from the precedents: ordinarily investigation of cognizable offences is the exclusive domain of the police and judicial intervention is restrained. However, the court noted a clear and established exception — where the police investigation is "casual, unsatisfactory or directed towards a particular conclusion right from the beginning," the court may interfere and even transfer the investigation to another agency.

Applying those principles to the present facts, the court examined the conduct of the police investigation and made the following findings (described in the opinion and relied upon for its decision):

  • From the first interrogation of the complainant, the police attempted to recast his suspicion of murder into a theory of suicide, effectively steering the investigative hypothesis to suicide rather than neutrally examining all possibilities.
  • The written complaint dated 10-8-1987 (annexure-A) containing allegations sufficient to justify investigation for murder (Section 302 IPC) was not registered as an FIR at the time it was given.
  • The police recorded statements and case diary entries in a casual and non-incisive manner. Specifically, statements of treating medical practitioners were taken without asking obvious and necessary questions about history, symptoms, whether they suspected poisoning, or why they did not report an unnatural death to police or ensure post-mortem examination.
  • The deceased was not taken to a public hospital, no post-mortem was done, and those facts were not adequately probed by the investigating officers.
  • There were circumstances pointed out by the complainant that merited investigation (e.g., false intimation to family that deceased suffered from cholera, restriction on who could see the deceased, delay or failure to take deceased to public hospital and failure to conduct post-mortem) and those circumstances were not properly explored by the police.

On this factual matrix the court concluded that the investigation was "highly improper and unsatisfactory." The court emphasized that this conclusion does not mean that ultimately the death will be treated as murder or that any conviction will necessarily follow; rather, the issue at this stage was whether the original investigating agency had so failed in its statutory duty that transfer of investigation was required to safeguard the investigation's integrity.

Balancing the principle of non-interference with the demonstrated deficiencies in the investigation, the court determined that direction for registration of the written complaint as FIR for Section 302 IPC and transfer of the investigation to CID (Crimes) to be conducted by a senior officer was warranted.

The court declined to order cancellation of bail since the only formal charge at that time (as per the charge-sheet) related to Sections 498A and 201, in respect of which bail had already been granted. Regarding the offence under Section 302 IPC, no FIR had been registered earlier and no arrest/bail issue had yet arisen for that charge; those matters were left for the investigating agency and appropriate court to deal with at the appropriate time.

Holding and Implications

Holding: These applications are allowed. The court gave the following specific directions:

  • Direct the police and State authorities to register the complainant's application dated (record reflects both 10-8-1987 in the facts and a direction recording "10-10-1987" in the operative paragraph) as an FIR for offence punishable under Section 302 and other relevant sections of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Direct the transfer of the investigation to CID (Crimes) of the State of Gujarat to be conducted by an officer of senior and high level.
  • Order that after completing the investigation, appropriate further steps in accordance with law be taken by the investigating agency and competent courts.
  • Stay the proceedings consequent upon filing of the charge-sheet under Section 498A until the transferred investigation is completed.
  • Send a copy of the judgment to the Home Secretary, Gandhinagar, drawing attention to the observations regarding specialised investigative arrangements (paragraph 15).
  • Rule made absolute in both matters (the two applications by the same petitioner seeking substantially similar relief).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the previously unregistered written complaint is to be recorded as an FIR for murder (Section 302 IPC) and the investigation will be taken over by CID (Crimes) under a senior officer. The immediate effect is a re-opening and re-direction of investigatory efforts under a more senior/independent agency.
  • Bail already granted on the offences for which charge-sheet had been filed (Sections 498A and 201/202/114 as recorded) was not disturbed; the court expressly declined to cancel such bail at this stage.
  • Administrative implication: the court called attention to the need for specialised investigative machinery (dowry cells/special investigative units) and directed transmission of the judgment to the Home Secretary for any general action the State may consider necessary.
  • On precedent and law: the decision applies established principles about limited judicial interference in police investigations but recognizes and applies the exception where the investigation is shown to be casual, unsatisfactory or directed to a particular conclusion. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new legal precedent beyond applying those existing principles to the facts of this case.

Order: The applications were allowed; the Rule was made absolute in both matters and further directions given as summarized above.

    Patel Lilabhai Ambalal v. Patel Kanubhai Mafatlal & Ors. Opponents.

    1. Both these applications are by the same petitioner for substantially same relief. The petitioner is the original complainant and brother of deceased Babiben, wife of one Kanubhai/Mafatlal Patel, respondent No. 1 in Cr. Misc. Application No. 2095/87. The other respondents are the family members of the husband and in-laws of the deceased It is not in dispute that this is a case of unnatural death of Babiben. The complainant petitioner suspects that his sister has been murdered by the respondents accused He gave written complaint to Chanasma police station which is annexure-A to the Special Criminal Application. The incident had taken place at about 9-00 p.m. on 8-8-1987. The written complaint was given on 10-8-1987. However, that was not recorded as FIR. Therein it was stated that the in-laws had done his sister to death.

    (matter in vernacular omitted - Ed.) However, on the next day i.e. on 11-8-1987, a statement of the complainant was recorded which has been registered as FIR at CR No. 97 of 1987 and it is treated as offences punishable under sections 496a, 204 b and 201 of ipc. In this statement, a clarification is taken from the complainant that even though it is stated in the application that these persons have intentionally murdered his sister, it was not the purpose or intention of his say, but his intention was to state that his sister had committed a suicide or had died a suspicious death and therefore he had made that application because the in-laws have not informed the police; had not taken the deceased to Government hospital and had also not got the post-mortem done and that he was given false intimation that his sister was suffering from cholera However, when he went to see his sister, she was already dead and he was not allowed to see her dead body. Thereafter on 26th Aug. 1987, the complainant has addressed a letter to Special Inspector General of Police, CID (Crimes) as he felt that the police was not properly making investigation and some influential persons were bringing pressure in the case. In respect of this FIR of 11-8-1987, a charge-sheet is filed on 24-9-1987 for offences punishable under Section 498A and 202 read with Section 114 of I.P.C.

    2. The grievance of the complainant is that he has given written information of an offence under Section 302 of IPC and the police has not recorded the complaint for offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and the police has right from the beginning started with a case of suicide and made investigation to that end only and this investigation is highly improper casual and deliberately towards the desired end and therefore the prayer is that the investigation be directed to be made by other independent agency like CID (Crimes) and to register the FIR for offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC. There is also a prayer for cancellation of bail which has been granted to the respondent by the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class.

    3. On behalf of the respondents/accused, it has been submitted that this is an unfortunate case of suicide and all the accused are absolutely innocent. It is submitted that after due investigation, the police have filed a charge-sheet for offences punishable under sections 498a, 201 read with section 114 of ipc and that the trial will take place in accordance with law and there is no case for interference with the executive function of police of investigation and statutory duty and right of the police to investigate into cognizable offence and the trial of such offence by the competent court.

    4. The Supreme Court, in the case of State of West Bengal v. Sampat Lal , has observed as under (para 13):

    It is certainly not for this Court at the present stage to examine and come to a conclusion as to whether this was a case of suicide or murder. If as a result of investigation, evidence is gathered and a trial takes place, the Sessions Judge will decide that controversy and it may be that in due course such controversy may be canvassed before this Court in some form or the other. It would, therefore, be wholly inappropriate at this stage to enter into such a question.

    In that case, two young boys were found missing since 2-3-1983 and their dead bodies had been thrown on a railway track on 5-4-1983 and they had been disposed of by the local police without taking any steps for their identification. It seems that it was taken as a case of suicide. However, there was great public uproar and the High Court came to be moved by some public spirited citizens and the High Court had directed investigation by special officer i.e. Dy. Inspector General of Police, CBI to inquire into the matter. However, no hearing was afforded to the State Government or its officers when direction to appoint the Special Officer was made and the Supreme Court observed that there could be no scope for appointing a special officer unless the statutory channel of investigation was found not to have functioned properly. In that case, the authorities were not given an opportunity to show how they were discharging their statutory obligation to carry out investigation. The Supreme Court observed as under (para 15):

    The appointment of a Special Officer with a direction to inquire into the commission of an offence can only be on the basis that there has not been a proper investigation. There is a well defined hierarchical administrative set up of the police in the State of West Bengal as in all other States and to have created a new channel of inquiry or investigation is likely to create an impression that everything is not well with the statutory agency and it is likely to cast a stigma on the regular police hierarchy.

    The Supreme Court also referred to King Emperor v. Khwaja Nasim Ahmed AIR 1945 PC 18 : 1945-46 Cri LJ 413, where the Privy Council observed as under:

    The functions of the judiciary and the police are complementary, not overlapping, and the combination of individual liberty with a due observance of law and order is only to be obtained by leaving each to exercise its own function, always, of course subject to the right of the Court to intervene in an appropriate case when moved under Section 491 of the Criminal Procedure Code to give directions in the nature of habeas corpus.

    The case of State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanna was also referred where also the above Privy Council judgment was followed, and the following observations were made (para 26):

    This view of t he Judicial Committee clearly demarcates the functions of the executive and the judiciary in the field of detection of crime and its subsequent trial and it would appear that the power of the police to investigate into a cognizable offence is ordinarily not to be interfered with by the judiciary.

    More apposite case and facts were of Bhagwant Singh v. Commr. of Police, Delhi which was also a case of bride burning. The investigation had come to an end and a conclusion of the case being one of suicide was reached. At that time, the Government had taken a decision to entrust the investigation to C.B.I. In that ease, after dealing with the material placed before it, the Court came to the conclusion that the investigation by the police was suffering from casualness, lack of incisiveness and unreasonable dilatoriness. The entries in the police case diary were also unsatisfactory. The investigation of the case was transferred from police administration to CBI by the Government and therefore nothing further was required to be done by the Court. The Supreme Court also noted that the Court has to be alive to the fact that the scheme of law is that the investigation has been entrusted to the police and it is ordinarily not subject to the normal supervisory power of the Court. The Supreme Court therefore came to the conclusion that the appointment of special officer was not called for at that stage in that ease. In para 29 the Supreme Court emphasized that it is necessary that the investigating agency must disabuse its mind of the tentative conclusion that death was suicidal; adding that it does not mean that after a proper investigation, they may not reach the same conclusion and it was emphasized that the conclusion should not have been the basis upon which the investigation should have proceeded The Supreme Court observed that normally one would not commit suicide unless there are strong and compelling reasons for it and ordinarily there has to be a very pressing motive behind every case of suicide and sufficient material to prima facie establish the existence of such a motive has to be brought on record of investigation.

    5. In the case of Bhagwant Singh (1983 Cri LJ 1981) (supra), the Supreme Court observed that in cases of dowry deaths, ordinary police investigation is inadequate and perpetrators of such crime not infrequently escape from the nemesis of the law because of inadequate police investigation and the Supreme Court suggested that high priority be given to the expeditious investigation of such cases by a special magisterial machinery created for the purpose and efficient investigative techniques and procedures be adopted taking into account the peculiar features of such cases. The Supreme Court also suggested that a female police officer of sufficient rank and status in the police force should be associated with the investigation from its very inception. After referring to several features of investigation, the Supreme Court held that the investigation by police did not inspire confidence.

    6. The learned Counsel for the accused has also relied on the case of State Of West Bengal v. S.N Basak. wherein it has been held that the statutory power of the police to investigate cannot be interfered with by the exercise of power under Section 439 or under the inherent power of the Court under Section 561 A.

    7. In the ease of S. N. Sharma v, Bipen Kumar Tiwari , the Supreme Court observed that power of the police to investigate into the cognizable offence is uncontrolled by the Magistrate and it is only in the cases in which the police decide not to investigate the case that the Magistrate can intervene and either direct an investigation, or in the alternative, himself proceed or depute a Magistrate subordinate to him to proceed to enquire into the case. It was further observed that though the Code gives to the police unfettered power to investigate all cases where they suspect that a cognizable offence had been committed, in appropriate cases an aggrieved person can always seek a remedy by invoking the power of the High Court under Article 228 of the Constitution of India.

    8. In the case of Kanaksinh H. Jadeja v. Balbhadrasinh N. Jhala 1987 (2) 28 Guj LR 1219 : 1988 Cri LJ 578, it is held that the investigation being the exclusive field of the executive, it is not desirable to prevent the police from investigating in the offence by the High Court in exercise of the inherent powers under section 482 of the code. Reliance was placed on the case of Eastern Spinning Mills v. Rajiv Poddar wherein the Supreme Court observed that save in exceptional cases where non interference would result in miscarriage of justice, the Court and the judicial process should not interfere at any stage of investigation of the offences.

    9. Relying on these cases, it was submitted by the learned Counsel for the respondents-accused that in the matter of investigation, there is no scope for the High Court to interfere and there are remedies provided under the Code itself to an aggrieved person. It is suggested that if the FIR was not recorded by Police Station Officer, the remedy was to approach the Superintendent of Police under Section 154(3) of the Code. The second remedy was to file a private complaint directly in the Court. The third remedy was to apply to the Court where the charge-sheet is filed to direct further investigation under Section 173(8). However, it is to be noted that in a case like this, unless there is a proper investigation by a proper independent agency, no useful purpose will be served by filing a private complaint or the Magistrate directing further investigation by police. The highest officer of the State was also approached and nothing happened. Therefore, these remedies cannot be said to be of any effective purpose in the present case.

    10. From the above judgments of the Supreme Court, it is clear that investigation in cognizable offences in the field reserved for the executive and the police authorities have statutory right to investigate into the cognizable offence and to file a charge-sheet and the scope for judicial interference in this investigative process is restricted. However, as laid down in the aforesaid Supreme Court judgments, where the investigation is casual, unsatisfactory or directed towards a particular conclusion right from the beginning, such investigation can be interfered with and even can be transferred from ordinary police agency to other agencies.

    11. In the present case, right from the first interrogation of the complainant himself, the police has tried to change the suspicion of murder to suicide, as if the police wanted the complainant himself to commit to the theory of suicide even though he had strong reasons to suspect murder. It is true that he had no personal knowledge about the incident. But he had his own reasons to suspect which ultimately may or may not prove to be good and sufficient. The registration of the complaint under Section 302 of IPC was necessary when such complaint was made in writing, The circumstances pointed out by the complainant were sufficient to justify investigation into the suspicion of murder. In fact, at the investigation stage, it is elementary for the police to suspect everything and everyone and thereafter by process of elimination and inclusion come to the conclusion. However, that conclusion has to be the last thing on the completion of investigation and not the first thing at the beginning of the investigation. The complainant had pointed out the following circumstances.

    1. Even though his sister had died unnatural death, he was sent an intimation at his village that his sister was ill and suffering from Cholera.

    2. That his sister is not given any medical treatment until she became unconscious,

    3. The statements of two doctors who are said to have given treatment are taken in a very very casual manner without putting the obvious and necessary questions to them.

    4. She is not taken to any public hospital.

    5. No post-mortem examination is done.

    12. Dr. Babubhai Purshottam whose statement is recorded on 14-8-1987 states that at about 10-15 in the night on 8-8-1987, Babiben was brought to his residence in a jeep and she was unconscious and there was vomitting and he felt that the patient had drunk poison and therefore he had given three injections. However, as the patient had not become conscious, he directed the patient to be taken to public hospital at Mehsana and therefore they had gone to Mehsana. This Doctor has not been put any questions as to what was t he history given to him at that time, what were the symptoms, what was the poison and why did he not report the case of attempted suicide or murder to any police authority. Even thereafter she was not taken to any public hospital, but she was taken to a private Doctor (Dr. N. T. Patel) who is said to have directed the relatives of the patient to go to the civil hospital and get the postmortem done. However, it was not done. Even this Doctor has not been put any questions as to the history given by the relatives, symptoms and as to why he did not report the matter to the police and to see that the post-mortem is done in case of unnatural death. There is total lack of incisiveness in the interrogation and investigation.

    13. It would thus appear that not only the deceased was not allowed to speak any word and not allowed to see anyone till she became unconscious, none else is allowed to speak anything about the incident. The police do not seem to have posed obvious questions to the medical persons; to the relatives as to what history they had given and why deceased was not taken to any public hospital or institution and why no information was given to police and why no post-mortem was carried out. It would appear that the police have recorded statements only from one angle to establish suicide and not tried to search for the evidence and did not interrogate witnesses. This investigation is thoroughly and highly unsatisfactory. However, this observation is not to be taken to mean that after proper and thorough investigation, same conclusion may not be reached It may be reached, it may not be reached. The trial of offence under Section 302 of IPC may take place, may not take place. Even if it takes place, there may be conviction there may not be any conviction. At this stage, it is impossible to jump to any conclusion. The discussion of some of the circumstances in this judgment is only with a view to ascertain whether the investigation was proper and satisfactory and whether the police had performed the duty properly.

    14. Having come to the conclusion that the investigation by the police is highly improper and unsatisfactory, there is no alternative but to see that proper investigation is carried out by proper investigating agency. Nor that, I will first direct the police to register the written complaint dt. 10-10-1987 annexure-A as FIR for offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and other sections and thereafter the investigation shall be taken over by CID(Crimes)and shall be conducted by an officer of higher and senior level. At this stage, there is no question of cancelling bail to the respondent-accused against whom the only charge recorded was under sections 498a and 201 of ipc and in respect of these offences, the bail had been granted So far as the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC is concerned it is so far neither registered nor has been the subject matter of any arrest or bail. It would be for the investigating agency to consider and take appropriate steps at appropriate time before appropriate court and there is no necessity of making any observation at this stage by this Court.

    15. Before parting with this matter, a reference to the recent Supreme Court case of dowry death would be proper. It is the case of Joint Women's Programme v. State of Rajasthan . In that case, the Supreme Court had by an interim order directed investigation into unnatural deaths of two women by an officer not below the rank of Superintendent of Police. The Supreme Court gave a further direction to the States of Rajasthan and State of Haryana by way of an interim order to create a special dowry cell at the State level to investigate into dowry death through specialised investigating units and one or two leading social women workers to be named by the Ministry dealing with the Social Welfare and Women's problems to be associated with such dowry cells. Although the Supreme Court direction was for the States of Rajasthan and Haryana, such special investigative cell seems to be the necessity of the day having regard to frequency of such occurrences in this State also. I was told by the learned Public Prosecutor Mr. M. D. Pandya that there is some special arrangement in Gujarat State also. However, he was not very specific about the same. 1 would only direct that a copy of this judgment be sent to the Secretary, Home Department, to take such general action as may be deemed necessary for investigation of suspected cases of dowry death & bride burning in the light of observations made by the Supreme Court.

    16. In the result, these applications are allowed by directing the police and State authorities to register the application of the complainant dt. 10-10-1987 as FIR for offence punishable under section 302 and other sections of ipc and to transfer the investigation to CID (Crimes) of State of Gujarat to be conducted by an officer of senior and high level and after completing the investigation, to take such further steps in accordance with law as may be necessary and the proceedings consequent upon the filing of the charge- , sheet under Section 498A shall remain stayed till then.

    Copy of the judgment to be sent to Home Secretary, Gandhinagar, drawing attention to paragraph 15 above.

    Rule made absolute accordingly, in both the matters.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Patel Lilabhai Ambalal v. Patel Kanubhai Mafatlal & Ors. Opponents.
    (Feb 22, 1988)