Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Case Summary — Appeal arising from Title Appeal No. 66 of 1975 / Title Suit No. 160/71

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the judgment and decree of the Assistant District Judge, Goalpara, Dhubri in Title Appeal No. 66 of 1975, which dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment and decree passed by the learned Munsiff, Goalpara in Title Suit No. 160/71 dismissing the suit. The suit sought declaration of title and delivery of khas possession on partition of the suit land.

Facts as stated in the plaint and the written statement: Gende Bibi (the original owner of the suit property, described as about 7 bighas of land) died leaving three plaintiffs and four defendants, who are her brothers and sisters (i.e., her legal heirs). The plaintiffs alleged that following Gende Bibi's death the heirs made an amicable partition and each possessed their respective shares, but defendant No. 3, Serajuddin, allegedly obtained the entire land recorded in his name in the revenue records and attempted to dispossess the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs sought partition and separate possession of 1/7th share each.

The defendants jointly denied these allegations; they admitted the heirship and the ownership by Gende Bibi but pleaded that prior to her death Gende Bibi had gifted the entire suit property in favour of the 3rd defendant in accordance with Mahomedan Law, after which the 3rd defendant had the land mutated in his name and was possessing it.

On the pleadings the trial court framed the following issues for decision: (1) cause of action; (2) whether the plaintiffs have right, title and interest in the suit land as inheritors and entitlement to share; (3) whether plaintiffs were entitled to decree for partition; and (4) what reliefs the parties are entitled to. The learned Munsiff held that a valid gift had been made by Gende Bibi in favour of the 3rd defendant, including delivery of possession; on appeal the appellate court affirmed the trial court's findings and decree. This second appeal challenges that conclusion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the alleged gift made by Gende Bibi in favour of defendant No. 3 (Serajuddin) was a valid gift.
  2. As framed by the trial court: (1) Is there any cause of action for the suit? (2) Whether the plaintiffs have right, title and interest in the suit land as inheritors and each entitled to a share? (3) Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree for partition as prayed for? (4) To what relief(s) are the parties entitled?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Plaintiffs)

  • Ext. A(2), the alleged deed of gift, was not registered and therefore falls within the mischief of Section 17 of the Registration Act; it is said to be a document that created the gift and thus was compulsorily registerable.
  • Because Ext. A(2) was not registered, it could not create any right, title or interest in favour of the 3rd defendant with respect to the suit property; consequently the property must be partitioned among the heirs according to the applicable law.
  • Counsel also referred to the essentials of a valid Mahomedan gift (declaration/ijab, acceptance/qabul, and delivery of possession/qabda) and contended that when the written instrument is the sole basis of the gift it must be registered; but implicitly argued that Ext. A(2) sought to play that role and was unregistered.

Respondent's / Defence Position (as pleaded)

  • The defendants admitted the heirship and ownership by Gende Bibi but pleaded that Gende Bibi had, during her lifetime, gifted the entire suit property in favour of defendant No. 3 in accordance with Mahomedan Law.
  • It was pleaded that the 3rd defendant got the land mutated in his name in the revenue records and has been possessing the suit land on his own account, indicating acceptance and possession by the donee.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jubeda Khatoon v. Moksed Ali, AIR 1973 Gau 105 The principle that under Mahomedan Law three essentials are necessary for creation of a gift: (i) declaration by the donor, (ii) acceptance by the donee (express or implied), and (iii) delivery of possession of the subject of the gift. The deed of gift is immaterial for creation of gift under Mahomedan Law; even a registered deed does not substitute for proof of delivery of possession. The court relied on this authority to treat Ext. A(2) as at best a declaration of gift by the donor rather than a formal instrument that by itself creates a disposition. The court held that independent proof (here, mutation and continuous possession) supported acceptance and delivery of possession, making the gift valid under Mahomedan Law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in several steps, limited to the materials and arguments in the record:

  1. Characterisation of Ext. A(2): The document described as Ext. A(2) was an unstamped sheet of ordinary paper dated 15-7-65 B.S., reciting that Gende Bibi made a gift of the land (7 bighas 1 katha 19 lechas under khatian No. 49, Mouza Bhatipara) in favour of her son Serajuddin, stating that Serajuddin maintained her and that she lived with him. The paper bore three attesting witnesses and the donor's thumb impression.
  2. Registration argument: The appellants contended that Ext. A(2) was the basic instrument creating the gift and so should have been registered under Section 17 of the Registration Act (and related provisions). The court noted statutory provisions governing gift of immovable property (Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act which mandates registered instrument for gift of immovable property) and that Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act excludes the rule of Mahomedan Law from Chapter VII of the T.P. Act (which includes Section 123). The court therefore examined whether the writing necessarily required registration in the facts of this case.
  3. Mahomedan law essentials and role of writing: The court reiterated the three essentials for a valid Mahomedan gift—declaration by donor (ijab), acceptance by donee (qabul), and delivery of possession (qabda)—and emphasised that a deed is immaterial for creation of a gift under Mahomedan Law. It relied on Jubeda Khatoon v. Moksed Ali for the proposition that even a registered deed will not validate a gift without delivery of possession.
  4. Application to the facts: Given that Ext. A(2) was on plain paper and not a formal or stamped instrument, the court held it should be treated as a declaration of the donor rather than a formal instrument that, by itself, creates a disposition requiring registration. The court considered the surrounding circumstances (the donor being a mother who lived with and was maintained by defendant No. 3 while other children neglected her) as indicative of real intention and motive (love and affection) for making the gift.
  5. Proof of acceptance and possession: The court observed that the 3rd defendant had his name mutated in the revenue records and had been possessing the land. The court inferred acceptance by the donee and delivery of possession (or at least constructive possession) from the mutation and continuous possession; it noted that absent possession the mutation would not have taken place.
  6. Conclusion on validity: On these bases, and by applying the principles from Jubeda Khatoon, the court concluded that the requirements of a valid Mahomedan gift were satisfied (declaration, acceptance, and possession), and that Ext. A(2) need not operate as a formal registerable instrument to sustain the gift in the present factual matrix.
  7. Deference to concurrent findings: The court also noted that there were concurrent findings of fact by the trial and appellate courts on declaration, acceptance, and delivery of possession, and the present court found no reason to interfere with those concurrent findings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's final decision was to dismiss the appeal. The core ruling is:

DISMISSED — The appeal is dismissed; the judgment and decree of the courts below are upheld.

Implications:

  • The trial court's and the appellate court's findings that a valid gift was made by Gende Bibi in favour of defendant No. 3 (Serajuddin) and that delivery of possession occurred were affirmed; consequently the plaintiffs' suit for declaration of title and partition was dismissed as the gift was held valid in the given facts.
  • No order as to costs was made by the court.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal precedent; it applies established Mahomedan law principles (as discussed in Jubeda Khatoon) to the specific facts and emphasizes that whether a writing requires registration depends on the factual context and whether the writing is a formal instrument creating the disposition or merely a declaration of an already effected or effected-by-possession gift.
Appeal dismissed.

    Md. Hesabuddin And Others v. Md. Hesaruddin And Others

    1. This appeal arises from the judgment and decree passed by the learned Assistant District Judge, Goalpara, Dhubri in Title Appeal No. 66 of 1975 dismissing the appeal and affirming the judgment and decree passed by learned Munsiff, Goalpara in Title Suit No. 160/71 dismissing the suit. The suit is for declaration of title and delivery of khas possession on partition of the suit land.

    2. Gende Bibi died leaving the three plaintiffs and four defendants in the suit, own brothers and sisters as her legal heirs with respect to the suit property consisting in 7 and odd bighas of land as described in the plaint schedule. It is the case of the plaintiffs that on the death of their mother Gende Bibi the plaintiffs and defendants made an amicable partition of the suit property and each started possessing his/her share of the property but defendant No. 3 Serajuddin surreptitiously got the entire land recorded in his name in the revenue records and has been trying to dispossess the plaintiffs from their portions of the suit land. Hence the suit for declaration of title to the suit land and partition of it in 1/7th share thereof for each of the legal heirs and for separate possession of each. The 4 defendants filed a joint written statement denying all these allegations. It is admitted that all the plaintiffs and the defendants are legal heirs of late Gende Bibi and that the suit property belonged to Gende Bibi. It is the defence case that prior to her death Gende Bibi gifted away the entire suit property in favour of the 3rd defendant alone in accordance with the provisions of the Mahomedan Law in that behalf. Thereafter, the third defendant got the land mutated in his own name and he has been possessing the suit land on his own account. On the pleadings of the parties learned trial Court struck the following issues for decision:

    (1) Is there any cause of action for the suit?

    (2) Whether the plaintiffs have right, title and interest in the suit land as inheritors and each of the plaintiffs is entitled to the share of the suit land?

    (3) Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree for partition as prayed for?

    (4) To what relief or reliefs are the parties entitled?

    The learned Munsiff came to the finding that the suit land was validly gifted by Gende Bibi during her lifetime in favour of 3rd defendant who accepted the gift and also that the delivery of possession of the gifted land was effected in favour of the third defendant. On appeal by the plaintiffs the learned appellate Court affirmed the findings and decree passed by the learned trial Court.

    3. In this appeal the short question for decision is whether the alleged gift made by Gende Bibi was a valid one. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that Ext. A(2) being the deed of gift was not registered and hence it comes under the mischief of Section 17 of the Registration Act. His argument is that this document is not a memorandum of gift but rather it is a basic document which created the gift. This being the position, according to him, the document was compulsorily registerable under the provisions of Section 17 of the Registration Act. He further pointed out that as the deed was not registered it created no right, title and interest in favour of the 3rd defendant with respect to the suit property. Admittedly the plaintiffs and the defendants are the legal heirs of Gende Bibi and after her death they un-disputedly inherited the property. Therefore, according to him, the property has to be partitioned according to the law applicable to the parties.

    4. Now it is to be seen whether Ext. A(2) deed itself created any right, title and interest in favour of the 3rd defendant-respondent. Ext. A(2) was written in an unstamped sheet of ordinary paper. It is dated 15-7-65 B.S The recitals are that by this deed executant Gende Bibi makes a gift of the land measuring 7 bighas 1 katha 19 lechas under khatian No. 49 of Mouza Bhatipara in favour of her son Serajuddin Sheikh and that her son Serajuddin was maintaining her and that no other son or daughter of hers was taking care of her and that she was living with Serajuddin. Three persons, namely, Abdul Hamid, Jayanuddin, and Ali Hussain attested the document as witnesses. Gende Bibi executed the deed by putting her thumb impression on the deed.

    5. Learned counsel Mr. Ali appearing for the appellants referred to the provisions with regard to gift of immovable property under the Mahomedan Law and submitted that if the instrument of gift be the sole basis effecting the gift it must be registered. In the present case, according to him, the gift was made through Ext. A(2) document. He further submitted that it does not merely recite the fact of a prior gift in which case no registration would have been required. But when the document itself becomes the basis of the right, title and interest to be created in favour of the donee, it is compulsorily registrable under the provisions of Section 17 of the Registration Act. But it should be pointed out that such an instrument must be a formal instrument of gift creating the gift itself. In the instant case, the alleged paper has been written in an ordinary sheet of paper and not in a stamped paper and as such it cannot be said that it is a formal instrument of gift. It is the admitted position of the law of Mahomedan gift that three essentials are required to make a gift valid which are: (1) declaration of the gift by the donor (Ijab), (2) acceptance of the gift by the donee (Qabul) and (3) delivery of possession (Qabda). It is therefore found that the manifestation of the wish of the donor to make the gift, the acceptance of the donee either impliedly or expressly and the taking possession of the subject-matter of the gift by the donee either actually or constructively are the essential requisites to make a gift valid under the Mahomedan Law. It may be noted that no written document is required in such a case. It is also to be noted that where there is no real intention to make a gift, the gift fails. There may be sham, colourable or benami transactions. These things should be distinguished from a real gift so far as the Mahomedan Law is concerned.

    6. Section 123 of the T.P Act mandates that the gift of immovable property must be effected by a registered instrument signed by or on behalf of the donor and attested by at least two witnesses. Section 129 of the T.P Act however excludes the rule of Mahomedan Law from the purview of Chapter 7, T.P Act, which includes Section 123 of the T.P Act.

    7. But it cannot be taken as sine qua non in all cases that wherever there is a writing about a Mahomedan gift of immovable property, there must be registration thereof. The facts and circumstances of each case have to be taken into consideration before finding whether the writing requires registration or not. The essential requirements, as said before, to make a Mahomedan gift valid are declaration by the donor, acceptance by the donee and delivery of possession to the donee. It was held in Jubeda Khatoon v. Moksed Ali, AIR 1973 Gau 105 (at p. 106)—

    “Under the Mahomedan Law three things are necessary for creation of a gift. They are (i) declaration of gift by the donor, (ii) acceptance of the gift express or implied by or on behalf of the donee and (iii) delivery of possession of the subject of the gift by the donor to the donee. The deed of gift is immaterial for creation of gift under the Mahomedan Law. A gift under the Mahomedan Law is not valid if the above mentioned essentials are not fulfilled, even if there be a deed of gift or even a registered deed of gift. In other words even if there be a declaration of acceptance of the gift, there will be no valid gift under the Mahomedan Law if there be no delivery of possession, even though there may be registered deed of gift.” In that case there was a deed of gift which was not produced during trial. Still it was found in that case that had the defendants produced the deed of gift, at best it would have proved a declaration of the gift by the donor and acceptance thereof by the donee. It was further held that despite this the defendants would have to lead independent oral evidence to prove delivery of possession in order to prove a valid gift. Therefore it was found in that case that deed of gift under the Mahomedan Law does not create a disposition of property. Relying on this it cannot be said that whenever there is a writing with regard to a gift executed by the donor, it must be proved as a basic instrument of gift before deciding the gift to be valid. In the instant case a mere writing in the plain paper as aforesaid containing the declaration of gift cannot tantamount to a formal instrument of gift. Ext. A(2) has in the circumstances of the present case to be taken as a form of declaration of the donor. In every case the intention of the donor, the background of the alleged gift and the relation of the donor and the donee as well as the purpose or motive of the gift all have to be taken into consideration. In the present case, case, it is recited in the said writings that the 3rd defendant has been maintaining and looking after the donor and that the other children of the donor were neglecting her. The gift was from a mother to a son and it was based on love and affection for the son in whose favour the gift was made. Therefore, it cannot be held that because a declaration is contained in the paper Ext. A(2) the latter must have been registered in order to render the gift valid. Admittedly, the 3rd defendant has been possessing the land and got his name mutated in the revenue records with respect to the land. It is therefore implied that there was acceptance on behalf of the donee and also that the possession of the property was delivered to the donee by the donor. It should be remembered that unless there was possession on behalf of the 3rd defendant, no mutation would have taken place with regard to the property. It may be repeated that Ext. A(2) has to be taken in the present case as a mere declaration of the donor in presence of the witnesses who are said to have attested the writing.

    8. No other point was agitated on behalf of the appellants.

    9. In view of the discussion made above, I hold that there is no merit in the appeal so as to interfere with the findings of the Court below. There have been concurrent findings of facts by the two Courts below with regard to declaration of the gift, acceptance thereof and delivery of possession. I therefore find no reason to come to a different findings and reverse the findings of the learned Courts below.

    10. In the result, the appeal is dismissed. The judgment and decree passed by the learned Courts below are upheld. No order as to costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Hesabuddin And Others v. Md. Hesaruddin And Others
    (May 12, 1983)