AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 5794
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 5794
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J. (30 November 2010)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is an Ayurvedic Medical College that had been granted permission annually to admit students for the BAMS course from 2002 through 2009. For the 2010-11 academic year the petitioner applied for permission and its college and attached hospital were inspected by the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) (respondent No.2) and, subsequently, by a team associated with respondent No.1 (Central Government). On 6 August 2010 respondent No.1 issued a show-cause/deficiency notice identifying a shortage of two faculty members. The petitioner replied and was given a hearing.

On 30 August 2010 respondent No.1 conducted another inspection and on 20 September 2010 issued an order refusing permission to admit students for 2010-11, citing, in addition to the initial faculty shortage, several deficiencies observed during the 30 August inspection (e.g., non-functional/locked wards, absence of hospital staff, missing hospital records, doubtful IPD records, absence of case sheets, no nursing staff). The petitioner challenged the 20 September order in WP(C) No. 7424/2010, and the High Court allowed that petition on 1 November 2010 to the extent of treating it as a representation and directing respondent No.1 to pass a fresh order after giving a hearing.

Respondent No.1 then passed a fresh order dated 10 November 2010 again denying permission. The petitioner filed an additional affidavit and respondent filed a counter affidavit. The matter was heard on 15 November 2010 and finally on 30 November 2010 this judgment was delivered dismissing the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 13-A(5) (read with Section 13-C) of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, the Central Government is limited to acting only on the recommendations/report of the CCIM or whether it may itself obtain further particulars (including by conducting its own inspection) before approving or disapproving permission to admit students.
  2. Whether the impugned order of 10 November 2010 (denying permission) was vitiated by procedural defects — in particular, whether the Central Government's own inspection (30 August 2010) was lawful and whether the petitioner had been given a reasonable opportunity of hearing as required by statute.
  3. Whether the Court should interfere with the administrative decision refusing permission to admit students, given the factual findings about deficiencies in the attached hospital, and taking into account the limited scope of judicial review in matters involving expert bodies.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on Section 13-C and Section 13-A(5) of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, arguing that the statutory procedure makes the CCIM the body tasked with inspection and recommendation and that the Central Government should act only on the CCIM report.
  • The petitioner contended the Central Government's inspection of 30 August 2010 (and reliance on its findings) was illegal because only CCIM was empowered to inspect and assess compliance.
  • The petitioner pointed to the CCIM inspection report dated January 2010, which recorded the hospital OPD, IPD and hospital-in-general as "Satisfactory" (and suggested intake capacity could be increased), to show that the CCIM had found the hospital satisfactory.
  • The petitioner relied on the Bombay High Court decision in Hindustani Education Society v. Union of India & Ors (W.P. No. 3512/2008) to support the proposition that the Central Government should not send its own team to reassess and must act on CCIM recommendations.
  • The petitioner further argued that prior yearly permissions were evidence that the petitioner had a functional hospital and wards.

Respondent's Arguments (as reflected in the opinion)

  • Respondent No.1 accepted that the College had a full complement of required faculty but denied permission on substantial hospital-related deficiencies discovered on 30 August 2010 (locked and dusty wards, lack of bed linen, absence of nursing and other hospital staff, missing hospital support rooms, unreliable IPD records, absence of case sheets).
  • Respondent No.1 relied on Section 13-A(5)'s language that the Central Government may "after obtaining, where necessary, such other particulars as may be considered necessary" take a decision — and submitted that this permits the Central Government to obtain particulars by its own inspection rather than being bound to the CCIM report.
  • Respondent No.1 relied on the inspection findings and provided evidentiary material (including a file containing a CD of photographs taken during the 30 August 2010 inspection) to support the deficiencies recorded in the impugned order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Hindustani Education Society v. Union of India & Ors (Bombay High Court, judgment dated 9 Jan 2009) Held that Central Government should act on CCIM report and not send its own team to assess compliance; procedure requires reliance on CCIM assessment. The petitioner relied on this decision. The Court expressly disagreed with the Bombay High Court judgment, holding that Section 13-A(5) permits the Central Government to obtain other particulars (including its own inspection). The Court noted an SLP against that decision had been issued.
Dr. Ashok K. Mittal v. University of Delhi (ILR (1996) 2 Del 489) Where a governing/appointing body is the final deciding authority, the court will not fault its decision taken on the basis of a committee report; the decision-making authority may take final decisions regarding appointments/process. Used to support the general proposition that a recommending/technical body is not the final authority and that the appointing/decision-making authority may exercise its discretion.
M.P. Rural Agriculture Extension Officers Association v. State of M.P (2004) 4 SCC 646 Even expert/recommending bodies (like a Pay Commission) are not binding on the State; the State may accept or reject recommendations. Cited to support that the Central Government is not bound by CCIM recommendations and may accept or reject them.
Union of India v. Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (74 (1998) DLT 282) Recommendations of a regulatory authority cannot be held to be binding on the Government if that would effectively place the Government under the control of the regulatory body. Invoked to underscore that binding the Government to the recommendations of a recommendatory body would be improper; supports the view that the Government may carry out its own inquiries.
MTNL v. TRAI (84 (2000) DLT 70) Affirmed that recommendations of TRAI are not binding on final decision-making authorities. Referenced to reinforce that recommendatory bodies do not bind the Government.
Dr. H. Mukherjee v. Union of India (AIR 1994 SC 495) Government as appointing authority has absolute power to approve or disapprove lists of recommendations and may take into account developments subsequent to the recommendations. Used to support the proposition that the appointing authority (Government) may consider subsequent developments and is not bound by prior recommendations.
Sethi Auto Service Station v. DDA (129 (2006) DLT 139) If a recommendatory body is not the final authority, favourable recommendations do not bind the higher authority. Applied to illustrate that CCIM's favourable recommendations would not prevent the Central Government from arriving at a contrary decision on proper consideration.
Lakhwinder Singh v. Union of India (2008) 7 SCC 648 Assessment of selection/assessment boards is recommendatory; appointing authority may accept or vary recommendations. Cited to support the non-binding character of recommendations and the implied power of the appointing authority to differ.
State of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt) (1986) 4 SCC 632 Even recommendations of the High Court for appointments (District Judges) are not strictly binding on the State, although circumstances where State may differ were recognized. Referred to demonstrate that even highly-regarded recommendatory recommendations are not invariably binding on the appointing authority.
Dental Council of India v. Subharti K.K.B. Charitable Trust (2001) 5 SCC 486 Court's jurisdiction to interfere with exercise of discretion by expert bodies is limited; establishing institutions and granting approval is within executive/expert domain. Relied upon to emphasize the limited role of courts in reviewing technical/expert administrative decisions and to justify deference to respondent No.1's technical findings.
Dental Council of India v. Integrated Education Development Organization (2000) 56 DRJ 283 Whether a technical college should be granted permission is for the designated authority; High Court should not interfere unless decision is mala fide, arbitrary, unjust, unfair or unreasonable. Used to hold that absent mala fides or arbitrariness, the High Court ought not to substitute its view for that of the expert authority.
Dr. Basavaiah v. Dr. H.L. Ramesh (2010 (7) SCALE 529) Court's role is limited where no malafide is alleged against experts; courts should not sit in appeal over the decision of experts. Relied upon to reinforce the principle that courts should generally defer to expert administrative decisions in the absence of malafide or arbitrariness.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based only on the material in the opinion:

  1. Statutory construction of Section 13-A(5) (read with Section 13-C): The Court examined the language of Section 13-A(5) which permits the Central Government, after considering the CCIM's recommendations and "after obtaining, where necessary, such other particulars as may be considered necessary by it," to approve or disapprove a Scheme. The Court held that the words "such other particulars as may be considered necessary" include the power to obtain particulars by means other than written submissions from the college — including by carrying out its own inspection. Thus, the Central Government is not mechanically bound to accept CCIM recommendations and may make its own inquiry.
  2. On the petitioner's contention that the Central Government's inspection was illegal because only CCIM can inspect: The Court noted that the petitioner had earlier challenged the 20 September 2010 order and, during that earlier proceeding, did not contend that the Central Government's inspection was illegal. The earlier petition was disposed of on 1 November 2010 with a direction to treat that writ as a representation and to give the petitioner a hearing; in that process the petitioner availed the hearing. Having accepted the hearing in the first round, the Court held the petitioner could not in the second round repudiate the lawfulness of the Central Government's inspection (i.e., the petitioner had not reserved a right to challenge the inspection's legality at the earlier stage).
  3. The Court reviewed the substance of the impugned order's factual findings regarding hospital deficiencies (locked wards, lack of staff, missing records, doubtful IPD entries, no case sheets, etc.). The Court accepted that respondent No.1 had conceded the College had required faculty but nevertheless denied permission because the hospital — an essential appendage to a medical college — did not meet essential standards for training students.
  4. Evidentiary support: The Court examined the photographic evidence provided by respondent No.1 (a CD of photographs from the 30 August 2010 inspection) and found that the photographs did not demonstrate that the impugned order's findings were without basis. While the petitioner contended respondent No.1 misconstrued its records, the Court emphasized the limited scope of judicial review: the High Court in writ jurisdiction is not to substitute its own view over that of the expert administrative authority or to conduct the extensive factual inquiry the petitioner sought.
  5. Reliance on authority: The Court canvassed numerous precedents to support two related propositions: (a) recommendatory bodies like CCIM are not final decision-makers and their recommendations are not binding on the Government, and (b) courts have limited scope to interfere with expert administrative decisions, intervening only where there is mala fides, arbitrariness, or unreasonableness.
  6. Application to facts: Given the serious lacunae found by respondent No.1 in the hospital functioning and records, and the absence of any allegation or material of mala fide or arbitrariness against respondent No.1's decision-makers, the Court concluded there was no legal basis to interfere with the decision to deny permission for admissions for the year 2010-11.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The Court upheld the Central Government's power to obtain additional particulars (including by its own inspection) and found no ground to interfere with the impugned order refusing permission to admit students for the 2010-11 academic year.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The petitioner's challenge to the 10 November 2010 order was rejected and the refusal of permission to admit students for 2010-11 stands as upheld by this judgment.
  • The Court emphasized that CCIM's recommendations are recommendatory and not binding; the Central Government may conduct its own inquiries before deciding under Section 13-A(5).
  • The Court reaffirmed the limited role of judicial review in technical/expert administrative decisions — interference is appropriate only in cases of mala fides, arbitrariness or unreasonableness, none of which were shown here.
  • The judgment expressly disagreed with the Bombay High Court decision relied upon by the petitioner (Hindustani Education Society), and the opinion records that a notice had been issued in the SLP filed against that Bombay High Court decision.
  • No order as to costs was made by the Court.

Judge: Rajiv Sahai Endlaw — Date: 30 November 2010

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Acharya Gyan Ayurved College Petitioner v. Department Of Ayush & Ors. S

    RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.

    1. The petitioner, an Ayurvedic Medical College, claims to have been granted permission in the year 2002 for imparting education in Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery (BAMS) Course. The permissions in favour of the petitioner to admit students were granted from year to year till the year 2009. The petitioner, as required applied for permission to admit students in the current academic year 2010-11 also and the College and attached Hospital of the petitioner was inspected by the respondent No. 2 Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) constituted under the provisions of The Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970. Pursuant to the said inspection, a deficiency/show cause notice dated 6th August, 2010 was given by the respondent No. 1 to the petitioner. The only deficiency pointed out in the said notice was of shortage of two faculty members. The petitioner submitted a reply to the said show cause notice and was also given a hearing. After the hearing, the respondent No. 1 conducted inspection on 30 August, 2010 of the petitioner's College and attached Hospital and thereafter made an order dated 20 September, 2010 refusing permission to the petitioner to admit students in the current academic year. In the order dated 20 September, 2010, besides the ground of shortage of faculty, several other grounds on the basis of inspection on 30 August, 2010 were also stated for denying the permission.

    2. The petitioner filed WP(C) No. 7424/2010 in this Court challenging the order dated 20 September, 2010. Finding that no show cause notice/deficiency notice with respect to the deficiencies noticed in the inspection on 30 August, 2010 had been given and the petitioner had had no opportunity of hearing with respect thereto, the said writ petition was allowed vide order dated 1st November, 2010 and the writ petition was directed to be considered as a representation of the petitioner to the respondent No. 1 and the respondent No. 1 was directed to pass a fresh order after giving a hearing to the petitioner.

    3. The respondent No. 1 thereafter passed order dated 10 November, 2010 (impugned in this writ petition) again denying permission to admit students in the current academic year to the petitioner.

    4. The respondent No. 1 in the order dated 10 November, 2010 has concluded that the College has a full complement of required faculties. However, the permission has been denied to the petitioner on the grounds:

    (i) That in the surprise inspection on 30 August, 2010, it was found that there were no medicines or any signs of regular use of wards; most of the wards were locked; some of the wards were opened in front of the visiting team; all the wards had lot of dust on the floor, no bed sheets on mattresses, no blanket etc. clearly suggesting that the wards were not in use since long.

    (ii) There was no hospital staff namely nursing staff, Panchakarma attendant, ward boy etc. in the Panchakarma section.

    (iii) There was no record room, hospital superintendent room, matron room, medicine store, hospital office, hospital canteen, laundry etc.

    (iv) That the petitioner has been unable to substantiate its claim during the hearing of having a genuinely fully functional Ayurvedic Hospital.

    (v) That the records of IPD patients produced by the petitioner were doubtful and could not be backed by records of X-ray, Pathological and Clinical investigation done in the Hospital.

    (vi) Serious inconsistencies were found in the IPD registers produced by the petitioner and it was not found to indicate when the individual patient was admitted and when he was discharged and whether he was referred to any other Hospital or not.

    (vii) The petitioner could not produce any document related to the case sheet of the IPD patients and which case sheet is supposed to be the basic document required to be prepared by the Hospital.

    (viii) There was not a single nursing staff in the Hospital.

    The respondent No. 1 thus concluded that the petitioner did not meet the minimum eligibility conditions stipulated in Regulation 5(1)(d) of the Indian Medicine Central Council (Permission to Existing Medical Colleges) Regulations, 2006.

    5. The petition came up before this Court on 15 November, 2010 when this Court was of the opinion that the petitioner had not placed before this Court any material to show that the reasons given in the impugned order were incorrect. The petitioner sought time to file an additional affidavit. However, considering that the admissions for the current year were underway, by way of abundant caution, notice was also issued and the respondent directed to file counter affidavit, both to the petition as well as the additional affidavit to be filed by the petitioner. The petitioner has since filed an additional affidavit and the respondent has filed a counter affidavit. Since it was told that today is the last date for admission as per the prescribed schedule, arguments have been heard.

    6. The counsel for the petitioner at the outset has drawn attention to Section 13-C of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 which makes the procedure laid down in Section 13-A applicable for permission to admit students by Medical Colleges established before the commencement of the Indian Medicine Central Council (Amendment) Act, 2003. Thereafter attention is invited to Section 13-A(5) of the Act which is as under:-

    “(5) The Central Government may, after considering the Scheme and recommendations of the Central Council under sub-section (4) and after obtaining, where necessary, such other particulars as may be considered necessary by it from the person or medical college concerned and having regard to the factors referred to in sub-section (8), either approve the Scheme with such conditions, if any, as it may consider necessary or disapprove the Scheme and any such approval shall constitute as a permission under sub-section (1):

    Provided that no Scheme shall be disapproved by the Central government except after giving the person or medical college concerned a reasonable opportunity of being heard.”

    7. On the basis of the aforesaid, it is argued that the inspection dated 30 August, 2010 conducted by the respondent No. 1 itself and on the basis of which the impugned order is based was illegal and the only Body empowered to inspect and submit a report is the respondent No. 2 CCIM and the respondent No. 1 is to thereafter only act on the basis of report of the respondent No. 2 CCIM. It is contended that the report of the respondent No. 2 CCIM does not contain the deficiencies as found by the respondent no. 1 in the inspection on 30 August, 2010. The respondent No. 2 CCIM in the report of its inspections on 27/28 January, 2010 had against the Columns “Hospital OPD” and “Hospital IPD” recorded “Satisfactory. Intake capacity should be increased” Similarly against the Column “Hospital in General” it was written “Satisfactory”

    8. The counsel for the petitioner relies on the judgment dated 9 January, 2009 of a Division Bench of the High Court of Bombay in W.P(C) No. 3512/2008 titled Hindustani Education Society v. Union of India & Ors. laying down that the Central Government (respondent No. 1 herein) after considering the report of the CCIM can either approve a Scheme or disapprove it and that the Central Government is not expected to send its own team to assess for itself whether the Institution/College complies with the requirements. It was held that that task is to be performed by the CCIM and the Central Government can only approve or disapprove the Scheme and the question of sending their own team for assessing whether a particular Institution/College has the infrastructure as required under Section 13-A of the Act does not arise. It was thus held that the procedure adopted by the Central Government of sending its own team was not in consonance with the provisions of the Act.

    9. In the present case the inspection by the Central Government was prior to the first order dated 20 September, 2010 of refusal which was challenged in the earlier writ petition aforesaid. The petitioner at the time of disposal of the earlier writ petition did not contend that the findings on the basis of the inspection by the Central Government were not to be considered or that the said inspection was illegal. The petitioner was rather satisfied that an opportunity of being heard was given with respect to the findings based on the inspection by the Central Government's team. In my view, the petitioner in this second round of litigation, after availing of the hearing with respect to the said inspection is not entitled to contend that the said inspection itself was illegal. No such right was reserved by the petitioner to itself at the time of disposal of the earlier writ petition. Besides the aforesaid, as per the Act and the Regulations, the decision to grant the permission or to not grant the permission is to be of the Central Government. Section 13-A(5) (supra) does not require the Central Government to take a decision only by considering the recommendations of the CCIM; the same expressly permits the Central Government to take the decision “after obtaining, where necessary, such other particulars as may be considered necessary by it from the person or Medical College concerned and having regard to the factors referred to in Sub-section (8)” In my opinion, obtaining of “particulars as may be considered necessary” would include obtaining such particulars by carrying out its own inspection. The said words cannot be given a narrow interpretation so as to confine the scope thereof to obtaining information only in writing from the College. Moreover, by reference to Sub-section (8) which lays down the parameters to which the CCIM is to have regard, the Central Government has been empowered to consider the matter qua each and every parameter. The Central Government cannot be said to be a slave to the inspection by the CCIM. CCIM under the Act is merely a recommendatory body and a recommendatory body can never be deemed to deprive the authority vested with the power to take decision from exercising such power to the hilt. There is nothing whatsoever in the Act to show that the Central Government in which the power to take the decision is vested is deprived from making any enquiry or investigation as it may deem necessary for the purpose of taking the said decision.

    10. The Division Bench of this Court in Dr. Dr. Ashok K. Mittal…Petitioner v. University Of Delhi & Ors.…S ILR (1996) 2 Del 489 held that where the Governing Body of the college was the appointing and the deciding authority, no error could be found in its decision while considering the report of the Selection Committee, to re-advertise the post. The Supreme Court in M.P Rural Agriculture Extension Officers Association v. State of M.P (2004) 4 SCC 646 also held that the Pay Commission even though an expert body, it was still open to the State to accept or not to accept its recommendations. A Single Judge of this Court in Union Of India v. Telecom Regulatory Authority Of India. 74 (1998) DLT 282 in relation to the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 held that to hold the recommendations of the Regulatory Authority to be binding on the licensing authority i.e the Government would amount to changing the basic structure of the Telegraph Act and to putting the Government under the control of the Regulatory Authority thereby curtailing, restricting and circumscribing the power of the Government. The Division Bench in other petitions relating to TRAI, in MTNL v. TRAI 84(2000) DLT 70 did not differ therefrom. In relation to UPSC also, in Dr. H. Mukherjee v. UOI AIR 1994 SC 495, it was held that Government as appointing authority has absolute power to approve or disapprove list of recommendations. It was further held that the Government can take into consideration the developments subsequent to the selection made by the UPSC and to hold otherwise would not be in public interest and may lead to serious complications if the Government is enjoined to act notwithstanding serious matters having come to its notice subsequent to the recommendation made by the UPSC. Another Division Bench of this Court in Sethi Auto Service Station v. DDA 129 (2006) DLT 139 also held that if the recommendatory body is not the final authority to take the decision, merely because some favourable recommendations are made at some level of decision making process, that will not bind the superior or higher authority. Recently in Lakhwinder Singh v. UOI (2008) 7 SCC 648 also, assessment of the Selection Board was held to be purely recommendatory in character and the power of the appointing authority to accept or vary the recommendation of the Selection Board was held to be implicit. Even the recommendations of the High Court for appointment of District Judges were in State Of Kerala v. A. Lakshmikutty (Smt) (1986) 4 SCC 632 held to be not binding though the circumstances in which the State could differ were laid down.

    11. I am therefore, with respect, unable to agree with the judgment (supra) of the Bombay High Court. The counsel for the respondent no. 1 also informs that notice in the SLP preferred thereagainst has been issued.

    12. The next question which arises is whether else there is any other error capable of interference with the order impugned. The lacunas attributed to the petitioner are serious. In the face thereof, the petitioner cannot be said to be equipped to train future doctors. A hospital is a necessary appendage to a Medical College and without a Hospital with the sufficient number of patients, no expertise can be gained by the students of the Medical College. I had during the hearing enquired form the counsel for the respondent No. 1 whether any photographs of the inspection on 30 August, 2010 were taken. The counsel under instructions has handed over the file of the respondent No. 1 relating to the petitioner and which contains the CD of the photographs of inspection. From a perusal of the said photographs, it cannot be said that the findings in the impugned order are without any basis whatsoever. The counsel for the petitioner of course from the documents filed with the additional affidavit has sought to argue that the respondent No. 1 has misconstrued the records of the petitioner. However, this Court in writ jurisdiction cannot launch into an enquiry as the petitioner would want this Court to undertake. This Court is not to sit in appeal over the decision of the Government. Moreover, this Court would not substitute its opinion over that of the experts in the respondent no. 1 who have taken the decision.

    13. The Supreme Court in The Dental Council of India v. Subharti K.K.B Charitable Trust (2001) 5 SCC 486 held that it is the function of the Central Government under section 10a of the dentists act, 1948 to accord approval for establishing Dental College and the jurisdiction of the Court to interfere with discretion exercised by expert bodies is limited. The Division Bench of this Court in Dental Council of India v. Integrated Education Development Organization (2000) 56 DRJ 283 also held that the question whether or not a technical College should be granted permission to admit students and to start classes has to be left to the concerned authority constituted for such purpose and the High Court sitting in extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution normally ought not to interfere as such a matter does not lie in the province of the Court; the power to interfere exists only when the decision suffers from mala fide and arbitrariness and is unjust, unfair or unreasonable. No such case is made out in the present case. Reliance in this regard can also be placed on the recent judgment in Dr. Basavaiah v. Dr. HL Ramesh 2010 (7) SCALE 529 reiterating that the Courts have a very limited role particularly when no malafide has been alleged against the experts and that it would normally be prudent, wholesome and safe for the Courts to leave the decisions to the experts. It was further held that as a matter of principle the Courts should never make an endeavour to sit in appeal over the decision of the experts.

    14. The counsel for the petitioner in the hearing on 15 November, 2010 had also contended that the very fact that the petitioner had been granted permission for the last so many years showed that the petitioner had a functional hospital and ward and the finding of the respondent no. 1 of petitioner not having functional hospital is obviously erroneous. No merit was found in the said argument also. The legislature having provided for yearly permission, the enquiry for each year is independent and no fault can be found with such enquiry on the basis of permission in earlier years.

    15. No case for interference is made out. The petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW

    (JUDGE)

    30 November, 2010

    ‘gsr’..

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Acharya Gyan Ayurved College Petitioner v. Department Of Ayush & Ors. S
    (Nov 30, 2010)