Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Appeal challenges the Order dated 11.5.2007 of the learned Single Judge who granted an ex parte ad interim injunction to the Plaintiff under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The injunction restrained the Defendants from using the Plaintiff’s trademark "Moon Star" and/or any device of a star in the lap of the moon or any part thereof on the Defendant’s products or business. The Plaintiff claimed proprietary rights over the trademark by use since 1917 and registration since 1943. The Appeal is against this interlocutory injunction order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Single Judge was justified in granting an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining the Defendants from using the Plaintiff’s trademark or any similar device.
  2. Whether the Defendant’s use of the trademark "Super Star" and the pictorial device of a star constitutes fraudulent copying and deception of customers.
  3. The appropriate standard of appellate interference with the discretionary grant of interlocutory injunctions under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff’s complaint regarding the Defendant’s label and packaging, specifically the use of the ® symbol, does not survive as the symbol was impermissibly used and removed without Plaintiff's objection.
  • The Defendant contended that the word "star" is freely used in the market and thus its use should not be restricted.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff asserted proprietary rights over the trademark "Moon Star" since 1917 and registration since 1943.
  • The Defendant’s use of "Super Star" along with a star device amounts to fraudulent copying and deception of the average customer.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Atlas Cycle Industries Ltd. -vs- Hind Cycles Limited, ILR 1973 1 Delhi 393 Trademark protection principles Discussed in the detailed order supporting injunction
Modi Sugar Mills Ltd. -vs- Tata Oil Mills Ltd., AIR 1943 Lahore 196 Trademark infringement and protection Referenced in the order to establish legal principles
James Chadwick & Bros. Ltd. -vs- The National Sewing Thread Co. Ltd., AIR 1951 Bombay 147 Consumer perception of trademarks Quoted to emphasize how an average purchaser reacts to trademarks
Amritdhara Pharmacy -vs- Satya Deo Gupta, AIR 1963 SC 449 Trademark rights and infringement Discussed as part of the legal framework for injunction
Corn Products Refining Co. -vs- Shangrila Food Products Ltd., AIR 1960 SC 142 Trademark protection Referenced in the detailed order
K.R. Chinna Krishna Chettiar -vs- Sri Ambal and Company, AIR 1970 SC 146 : 1969(2) SCC 131 Trademark infringement principles Discussed in the context of trademark rights
De Cordova -vs- Vick Chemical Coy, 68 RPC 103 Trademark law Referenced in the order
Devi Pesticides Pvt. Ltd. -vs- Shiv Agro Chemicals Industries, 2006(32) PTC 434 (Madras) (DB) Trademark infringement and injunctions Discussed in the order
Shaw Wallace & Co. Ltd. -vs- Superior Industries Ltd., 2003(27) PTC 63 (Delhi) Trademark protection Referenced in the detailed order
Vrajlal Manilal & Co. -vs- M/s. N.S. Bidi Co., AIR 1987 Delhi 312 Trademark infringement Discussed in the order
William Grant & Sons Ltd. -vs- Mc Dowell & Co. Ltd., 1997 PTC 17 134 Trademark law principles Referenced in the order
Parle Products P. Ltd. -vs- J.P. & Co., Mysore, (1972) 3 SCR 289 Trademark protection Discussed in the context of injunction
Glaxo Operations UK Ltd. -vs- Samrat Pharmaceuticals, AIR 1984 Delhi 265 Trademark infringement Referenced in the order
Metro Playing Card Co. -vs- Wazir Chand Kapoor, AIR 1972 Delhi 248 Trademark protection Discussed in the detailed order
Hitachi Ltd. -vs- Ajay Kumar Agarwal, 1996 PTC (16) DB (Delhi) Trademark infringement and injunction Referenced in the order
Hardie Trading Ltd. -vs- Addisons Paint and Chemicals Ltd., 2003 (11) SCC 92 Trademark law principles Discussed in the order
State of Mizoram -vs- Biakchhawna, 1999 (1) SCC 156 Legal principles on discretion in injunctions Referenced in the context of appellate discretion
Ramdev Food Products Pvt. Ltd. -vs- Arvindbhai Rambhai Patel, AIR 2006 SC 3304 Appellate interference in interlocutory injunctions Key precedent guiding appellate discretion in this case
Wander Ltd. V. Antox India P. Ltd., (1990) Supp SCC 727 Principles regulating interlocutory injunctions Referred to in Ramdev Food Products decision
Lakshmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah, (2002) 3 SCC 65 Discretion in granting injunctions Referred to in Ramdev Food Products decision
Seema Arshad Zaheer v. MC of Greater Mumbai, (2006) 5 SCALE 263 Appellate discretion in interlocutory orders Referred to in Ramdev Food Products decision

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the learned Single Judge’s detailed order which relied on numerous precedents on trademark protection and the principles governing interlocutory injunctions. The Court noted that the Plaintiff has proprietary rights over the trademark "Moon Star" since 1917 and statutory protection through registration since 1943. The Defendant was found to have fraudulently copied an essential part of the trademark by using the word "star" and a star device in its mark "Super Star," creating a likelihood of deception among average purchasers.

The Court emphasized the principle from James Chadwick & Bros. Ltd. that the relevant inquiry is how an average purchaser perceives the trademark and whether there is a likelihood of confusion. The Court rejected the argument that the word "star" is freely used in the market, focusing instead on its use in relation to the Plaintiff’s products, specifically hair dyes, which included the Defendant’s herbal henna product.

Applying the principles from Ramdev Food Products Pvt. Ltd., the Court recognized that appellate interference with interlocutory injunctions is limited to cases where discretion is exercised arbitrarily or illegally. Since the Single Judge’s order was plausible and not perverse, the Court declined to interfere despite any differing opinion.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the Appeal and all pending applications, thereby upholding the ex parte ad interim injunction granted by the learned Single Judge restraining the Defendant from using the trademark "Moon Star" or any similar device.

The parties were directed to bear their own costs. The decision affirms the principle that interlocutory injunctions will not be disturbed on appeal unless there is clear arbitrariness or illegality. No new precedent was established; the ruling reinforces established trademark protection and appellate discretion standards.

    Babu Ram Dharam Prakash v. Izuk Chemical Works

    1. This Appeal assails the Order dated 11.5.2007 of the learned Single Judge granting an ex parte ad interim injunction to the Plaintiff, as prayed for in the Application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). Briefly stated, the Defendants have been restrained from using the Plaintiff‟s Trademark „Moon Star‟ and/or from using the device of a star in the lap of the moon or any part thereof or any of the Defendant‟s products or business.

    2. Indeed, the learned Single Judge has passed a very detailed Order in which various precedents, including Atlas Cycle Industries Ltd. -vs- Hind Cycles Limited, ILR 1973 1 Delhi 393, Modi Sugar Mills Ltd. -vs- Tata Oil Mills Ltd., AIR 1943 Lahore 196, James Chadwick & Bros. Ltd. -vs- The National Sewing Thread Co. Ltd., AIR 1951 Bombay 147, Amritdhara Pharmacy -vs- Satya Deo Gupta, AIR 1963 SC 449, Corn Products Refining Co. -vs- Shangrila Food Products Ltd., AIR 1960 SC 142, K.R. Chinna Krishna Chettiar -vs- Sri Ambal and Company, AIR 1970 SC 146 : 1969(2) SCC 131, De Cordova -vs- Vick Chemical Coy, 68 RPC 103, Devi Pesticides Pvt. Ltd. -vs- Shiv Agro Chemicals Industries, 2006(32) PTC 434 (Madras) (DB), Shaw Wallace & Co. Ltd. -vs- Superior Industries Ltd., 2003(27) PTC 63 (Delhi), Vrajlal Manilal & Co. -vs- M/s. N.S. Bidi Co., AIR 1987 Delhi 312, William Grant & Sons Ltd. -vs- Mc Dowell & Co. Ltd., 1997 PTC 17 134, Parle Products P. Ltd. -vs- J.P. & Co., Mysore, (1972) 3 SCR 289, Glaxo Operations UK Ltd.

    -vs- Samrat Pharmaceuticals, AIR 1984 Delhi 265, Metro Playing Card Co. -vs- Wazir Chand Kapoor, AIR 1972 Delhi 248, Hitachi Ltd. -vs- Ajay Kumar Agarwal, 1996 PTC (16) DB (Delhi), Hardie Trading Ltd. -vs- Addisons Paint and Chemicals Ltd., 2003 (11) SCC 92 and State of Mizoram -vs- Biakchhawna, 1999 (1) SCC 156 have been discussed. The extract from James Chadwick enunciates that the

    real question is as to how a purchaser who must be looked upon as an average man of ordinary intelligence, would react to a particular trademark, what association he would form by looking at the trademark, and in what respect he would connect the trademark with the goods which he would be purchasing.

    3. The learned Single Judge has concluded that the Defendant has fraudulently copied an essential part of the trademark of the Plaintiff in using "star as well as the device of a star" as part of its trademark. It has been noted that the Plaintiff has proprietary rights over the same by user of the trademark since 1917 and registration of its trademark since 1943. The learned Single Judge has also highlighted that the legal rights of the Plaintiff are based on its registered trademark and, therefore, is entitled statutorily to protection.

    4. As has been mentioned above, the Appeal is against an interlocutory Order granting the Prayers contained in an Application under order xxxix rules 1 and 2 of the cpc. The approach which must be adhered to by the Appellate Court in such matters is perspicuously enunciated in the decision of the Supreme Court in Ramdev Food Products Pvt. Ltd. -vs- Arvindbhai Rambhai Patel, AIR 2006 SC 3304, paragraphs 128 and 129 of which are topical:-

    128.The grant of an interlocutory injunction is in exercise of discretionary power and hence, the appellate courts will usually not interfere with it. However, appellate courts will substitute their discretion if they find that discretion has been exercised arbitrarily, capriciously, perversely, or where the court has ignored settled principles of law regulating the grant or refusal of interlocutory injunctions. This principle has been stated by this court time and time again. (See for example Wander Ltd. V. Antox India P. Ltd., ( 1990) Supp SCC 727, Lakshmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah, ( 2002) 3 SCC 65 and Seema Arshad Zaheer v. MC of Greater Mumbai, (2006) 5 SCALE 263).
    129.The appellate court may not reassess the material and seek to reach a conclusion different from the one reached by the court below if the one reached by that court was reasonably possible on the material. The appellate court would normally not be justified in interfering with the exercise of discretion under appeal solely on the ground that it had considered the matter at the trial stage it would have come to a contrary conclusion.

    5. Learned counsel for the Appellant had laid great emphasis on the fact that even prior to the grant of the injunction the submission of learned counsel for the Plaintiff had been noted to the effect that the complaint of the Plaintiff against the label and packaging of the Defendant does not survive. That, however, was in respect of the use of the alphabet „R‟ in a circle ® which is impermissible by the statute. It had to be removed even without the Plaintiff‟s objection. The challenge and complaint to the plagiarisation of the Plaintiff‟s trademark „Moon Star‟ by the Defendant‟s adoption of the trademark „Super Star‟ together with a star along with the alphabet remained alive.

    6. We are of the view that the Plaintiff had made out a prima facie case for the grant of an injunction against the Defendant for the use of the trademark „Super Star‟. It has been contended that the word „star‟ has been freely used in the market. The precise inquiry would have to be whether the use of the word „star‟ has been adopted in respect of the products manufactured and marketed by the Plaintiff, that is, Hair Dye. It is of no relevance or advantage to the Defendant that the product in question is Herbal Heena. This product is widely used as a Hair Dye, although it may also have ameliorative effect on hair. The use of the pictorial device of a „star‟ compounds and demonstrates the intention of the Defendant to deceive a customer into buying its product, believing it to be that of the Plaintiff. The views and findings expressed by us herein should not affect or influence the passing of the final judgment of the case. However, based on Ramdev, even if we were of a different opinion, we would be loath to interfere in this Appeal since the view taken by the learned Single Judge is a plausible one and is not perverse or illegal.

    7. Appeal as well as pending applications stand dismissed. Parties to bear their respective costs.

    VIKRAMAJIT SEN, J.

    S.L.BHAYANA, J.

    SEPTEMBER 17, 2008

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babu Ram Dharam Prakash v. Izuk Chemical Works
    (Sep 17, 2008)