Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These four appeals were preferred under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 seeking enhancement of compensation payable to the appellants for compulsory acquisition of their property. The land (36 bighas 7 biswas) in Village Khizarabad was notified under Section 4 of the Act on 10.5.1976 for public purpose: construction of a pilot-cut in the reach from Nizamuddin Road Bridge to Okhla Weir. The acquisition invoked Section 17(4) and notifications under Sections 4, 6 and 17(4) were issued simultaneously on 10.5.1976.

The Collector for Land Acquisition made an award on 30.11.1976 fixing compensation at Rs. 700 per bigha. The appellants sought a reference; the Reference Court (on reference) enhanced compensation to Rs. 2,000 per bigha. The appellants continued to be dissatisfied and preferred these appeals, seeking further enhancement — ultimately arguing for compensation of Rs. 50,000 per bigha.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What was the correct market value of the land in Village Khizarabad as on the date of notification, 10.5.1976, for the purpose of fixing compensation?
  2. Whether the earlier decision in Deewan Ram Saroop (fixing market value as on 3.6.1961) could be relied upon as a base and, if so, what escalation rate should be applied from that earlier date to 10.5.1976?
  3. Whether the 28.5.1966 urbanisation notification (listing Khizarabad among urbanised villages) meant the land's potentiality as building site must be taken into account in determining compensation, and whether the appellants produced sufficient evidence of that potentiality.
  4. Whether decisions fixing values of lands in neighbouring villages (e.g., Kilokari, Bahapur, Jasola, Jogabai, Tughlakabad) were applicable to the present land or should be disregarded given the specific facts about the acquired land.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Reliance on previous decisions fixing market values in and around Khizarabad, especially Deewan Ram Saroop v. Union of India, where this Court fixed market value of land in Village Khizarabad at Rs. 12,500 per bigha as on 3.6.1961.
  • Reliance on decisions fixing high market values in nearby revenue estates (Kilokari, Bahapur, Jasola, Jogabai, Tughlakabad) as indicating rising market trends that should inform valuation for Khizarabad; specific cases and figures were cited from Chand Behari, DLF United Limited, Union of India v. DLF Limited, Bhola Nath, Amar Singh, Bijay Singh, Delhi Simla Catholic Archdiocese, and Virender Singh.
  • Reference to a Delhi Administration notification dated 28.5.1966 stating that Khizarabad and several other villages were urbanised; appellants contended that the land's potentiality as a building site should therefore be taken into account.
  • Presentation of a plan showing proximity of Maharani Bagh and Friends Colony to support the contention that Khizarabad's land value had risen substantially, and a claim that compensation should be at least Rs. 50,000 per bigha as on 10.5.1976.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any counter-arguments or submissions advanced on behalf of the Union of India or other respondents in these appeals.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Deewan Ram Saroop v. Union of India (RFA 288/68) — decision dated 23.10.1992 Fixed market value of land situate in Village Khizarabad at Rs. 12,500 per bigha as on 3.6.1961 (acquisition in 1961 for similar purpose). The Court relied upon this earlier award as the appropriate base value for Khizarabad (given similar acquisition purpose and locality) and used it to compute market value as on 10.5.1976 by applying escalation.
Chand Behari v. Union of India (RFA 381/70) — decided 8.3.1984 Determined market value of land in Village Kilokari as on 13.11.1959 at Rs. 26,000 per bigha. Cited by appellants to indicate trend in adjacent areas; the Court declined to rely upon this (and similar) decisions for Khizarabad because of lack of direct evidence and distinct physical features of the acquired land (inside the Yamuna).
DLF United Limited v. Union of India Fixed market value for Village Bahapur as on 13.11.1959 at Rs. 19,000 per bigha. Cited as indicative of regional values; the Court did not rely upon it for Khizarabad valuation for reasons stated in its analysis (insufficient evidence and differing land characteristics).
Union of India v. DLF Limited For an acquisition by notification on 13.11.1972, fixed market value of Village Bahapur at Rs. 65,000 per bigha. Referred to show subsequent higher valuations in adjacent localities; the Court did not adopt it as the base for Khizarabad due to evidentiary and locational distinctions.
Bhola Nath & Ors. v. Union of India — 1998 VI A.D.(Delhi) 159 For acquisition by notification on 30.6.1978, fixed market value for Village Bahapur at Rs. 2,000 per sq. yard (i.e., Rs. 20 lacs per bigha). Cited by appellants to show escalation in neighbouring areas; the Court did not rely on this decision for valuation of the subject land.
Amar Singh v. Union of India — 26(1994) DLT 367 For acquisition of land in Village Jasola by notification on 24.10.1961, fixed market value at Rs. 10,000 per bigha. Used by appellants to argue regional value levels; Court declined to rely on these adjacent-village decisions for the subject land.
Bijay Singh v. Union of India For subsequent acquisition of Jasola (notification 31.12.1976), fixed market value at Rs. 55,000 per bigha. Cited to show later higher valuations in neighboring areas; the Court did not adopt this figure for Khizarabad.
Delhi Simla Catholic Archdiocese v. Union of India For land in Jogabai acquired under Section 4 dated 13.11.1959, market value fixed at Rs. 15,000 per bigha. Mentioned as part of regional comparators; the Court declined to use this decision for Khizarabad's valuation.
Virender Singh & Ors. v. Union of India (RFA 299/84) — decided 23.4.1991 For lands in Tughlakabad acquired under Section 4 dated 5.7.1973, market value fixed at Rs. 68,000 per bigha. Cited by appellants to support higher valuations nearby; the Court did not rely upon it for the subject land owing to factual distinctions.
P.N. Singh v. Union of India (RFA 359/98) — decided 6.11.1996 Principle: where entire land has been urbanised well before acquisition, the potentiality as building site must be considered, but this depends on other circumstances and special features apparent on record. The Court accepted the proposition but held that whether potentiality applies depends on facts; in the present case, because of absence of specific evidence and particular features, the Court could not treat Khizarabad simply as building site without further proof.
Prakash Chand Kashyap v. Union of India — AIR 1983 Delhi 316 Considered escalation of 12% per annum reasonable (instead of past practice of fixed Rs.1,000 per bigha escalation). The Court relied on this decision to justify applying 12% p.a. escalation to the base value from Deewan Ram Saroop to reach value as on 10.5.1976.
Rameshwar Solanki & Another v. Union of India & Another Division Bench decision endorsing departure from Rs.1,000 per bigha escalation practice and approving 12% p.a. escalation in line with statutory amendments. The Court relied on this authority to support adoption of 12% p.a. escalation when adjusting the 1961 base value to 1976.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first acknowledged that the Delhi Administration notification dated 28.5.1966 had urbanised Village Khizarabad and several other villages; it accepted the legal proposition (from P.N. Singh) that where land has been urbanised well prior to acquisition, its potentiality as a building site must be considered. However, the Court emphasized that whether such potentiality is to be taken into account depends on additional factual circumstances and special features of the acquired land.

On examining the record, the Court found no separate evidence as to the exact location or specific potentiality of the appellants' land. The Collector's award contained observations that the subject land was "inside the Jamuna" and "not very good for cultivation." The Collector had also discarded sale deeds from 1971-72 relating to other plots in Khizarabad on the ground that they were at a considerable distance and described as levelled plots with good soil — unlike the acquired land. The acquisition purpose here was limited to construction of a pilot-cut in the Yamuna reach and not for general building-site development.

Given the appellants' failure to lead sufficient evidence on potentiality or precise locality, the Court declined to accept the appellants' invitation to adopt market values fixed in other cases concerning adjacent villages (Kilokari, Bahapur, Jasola, Jogabai, Tughlakabad). Instead, the Court determined that the earlier decision in Deewan Ram Saroop (which fixed Khizarabad's value at Rs. 12,500 per bigha as on 3.6.1961) was the most appropriate base because that acquisition was for a similar purpose and related to the same locality.

Recognising that market value had increased between 1961 and 1976, and in absence of other material evidence as to rate of increase, the Court considered an escalation rate of 12% per annum reasonable. That rate was supported by precedents: Prakash Chand Kashyap (AIR 1983 Delhi 316) and Rameshwar Solanki (which endorsed abandoning the old Rs.1,000 per bigha per annum escalation practice in favour of 12% p.a.). Applying 12% p.a. escalation to the Rs. 12,500 per bigha base, the Court arrived at a market value of Rs. 35,000 per bigha as on 10.5.1976.

The Court also noted that, because the land was situated in the Yamuna region and not comparable to levelled plots elsewhere, the past practice of allowing Rs. 1,000 per bigha per annum escalation would be unreasonable in this case.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed in part: the appellants are held entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs. 35,000 per bigha as on 10.5.1976.

Consequences and orders flowing from the holding:

  • The appellants are entitled to compensation at Rs. 35,000 per bigha.
  • In addition to the principal amount of compensation, the appellants are entitled to solatium at 15% of the compensation amount.
  • The appellants are entitled to interest at 6% per annum from the date the Collector took over possession until the date of payment.
  • The appeal was allowed with proportionate costs in favour of the appellants.

The opinion does not articulate any broader legal principle intended to create a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities (notably Deewan Ram Saroop for base value and Prakash Chand Kashyap / Rameshwar Solanki for applying 12% p.a. escalation). The decision's direct effect is the monetary enhancement for these appellants; the Court explicitly relied on prior precedents rather than establishing a new rule.

    Tindey And Ors. v. Union Of India (Uoi) And Anr.

    1. These four appeals have been preferred under Section 54 of Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act") seeking further enhancement in the mount of compensation payable to the appellants for acquisition of their property.

    2. The property of the appellants situate in Village Khizarabad was notified under Section 4 of the Act on 10.5.1976 for being acquired for public purpose, namely construction of pilot-cut m the Reach from Nizamuddin Road Bridge to Okhla Weir. In all 36 bighas 7 biswas of land was notified for the said purpose. It was an acquisition, which was made by invoking Section 17(4) of the Act and all notifications under Sections 4, 6 and 17(4)of the Act were issued simultaneously on 10.5.1976. Proceedings for determination of the amount of compensation were held separately and the Collector Land Acquisition on 30.11.1976 made his award No.18776-77 holding the appellants to be entitled to compensation @ Rs.700/- per bigha. Feeling dissatisfied with the amount of compensation offered to them, the appellants sought reference. The Reference Court through the impugned awards enhanced the amount of compensation holding that the appellants entitled compensation @ Rs. 2,000/- per bigha. Still dissatisfied, these appeals have been preferred for further enhancement in the amount of compensation. The extent of enhancement sought in the appeals is now @ Rs. 50,000/-

    per bigha.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellants has contended that this Court in RFA 288/68 (Deewan Ram Saroop v. Union of India & Ors.) decided on 23.10.1992, fixed market value of land situate in Village Khizarabad @ Rs. 12,500/- per bigha as on 3.6.1961. In Deewan Rant Saroop's case (supra), land situate in Village Khizarabad was acquired for public purpose through notification dated 3.6.1961. Col lector in that case had made his award dated 27.2.1962 dividing the land in two blocks and fixing the market value at Rs. 4,000/- and Rs. 2,500/- per bigha for blocks 'A' and 'B' respectively. On reference, Additional District Judge held market value to be @Rs. 5.000/- per bigha, but this Court in appeal held the market value of land as on 3.6.1961 to be Rs. 12,500/- per bigha. In the said case topography of Village Khizarabad was noticed that it was surrounded by Villages Bahapur, Jogabai and the lands where Maharani Bagh and New Friends Colony (Village Kilokari) had come up.

    Holy Family Hospital situated in Village Jogabai, which was on the main road, i.e. Mathura Road to Okhla and Bharat Nagar Colony were found to be located nearby at a distance of about 200 yards. It was also found to be contiguous to Village Bahapur abouting the main Mathura Road where Ishwar Nagar Cooperative Society houses had come up. Placing reliance upon the market value of the lands in Villages Bahapur, Jogabai and Kilokari, the market value of land situated in Village Khizarabad as on 3.6.1961 was held to be at Rs. 12,500/- per bigha.

    4. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that in RFA 381/70 (Chand Behari v. Union of India) decided on 8.3.1984, market value of land situate in Village Kilokari as on 13.11.1959 determined at Rs.26,000/- per bigha. For Village Bahapur in DLF United Limited v. Union of India, , market value as on 13.11.1959 was held to be at Rs. 19,000/- per bigha. For subsequent acquisition, which took place by notification issued under Section 4 of the Act on 13.11.1972, this Court in Union of India v. DLF Limited, held the market value of land situated at Village Bahapur to be at Rs. 65,000/- per bigha. For yet another acquisition, with respect to lands situate in Village Bahapur through notification issued under Section 4 of the Act on 30.6.1978 this Court in Bhola Nath & Ors. v. Union of India, ,1998 VI A.D.(Delhi) 159 fixed market value at Rs. 2,000/- per sq.yards, i.e., Rs.20 lacs per bigha. Learned counsel for the appellants also placed reliance upon determination of the market value of lands situate in Villages Jasola. Jogabai and Tughlakabad on the ground that the said revenue estates are within close proximity of Village Khizarabad. For acquisition of land situate at Village Jasola, which took place by virtue of notification issued under Section 4 of the Act on 24.10.1961, this Court in Amar Singh v. Union of India, 26(1994) DLT 367 held the market value to be at Rs. 10,000/- per bigha. For subsequent acquisition of land of Village Jasola, which took place by notification issued under Section 4 of the Act on 31.12.1976, market value was determined at Rs. 55.000/- per bigha in Bijay Singh v. Union of India, . For land situate at Jogabai acquired through notification under Section 4 dated 13.11.1959, market value was determined at Rs. 15,000/- per bigha in Delhi Simla Catholic Archdiocese v. Union of India, . For land situate in Village Tughlakabad acquired through notification under Section 4 dated 5.7.1973, market value was determined at Rs.68,000/- per bigha in Virender Singh & Ors. Vs. Union of India (RFA 299/84) decided on 23.4.1991.

    5. By making reference to a plan produced during the course of arguments, learned counsel for the appellants contended that Maharani Bagh and Friends Colony are closest to Villages Khizarabad, Jogabai and Bahapur are also in close proximity. Therefore, various decisions relied upon by him would give an indication about the rising trend of market values of land in and around the locality and on that basis, it was contended (hat the appellants would be entitled for compensation for acquisition of their properly not less than Rs. 50,000/- per bigha as on 10.5.1976.

    6. Reliance was also placed by learned counsel for the appellants on notification issued on 28.5.1966 by the Delhi Administration, Delhi (No.F.2(49)/65-LSG) contending that by virtue of this notification, Villages Kilokari, Khizarabad, Jogabai, Okhla, Bahapur, Tughlakabad and Jasola amongst others were urbanised.

    7. The effect of urbanisation would be that the potentiality of the lands situate in Village Khizarabad as on the date of notification issued under Section 4 was to be taken as a building site.

    8. We have considered the submissions made at the Bar. There is no doubt that as on 28.5.1966, Village Khizarabad, which hitherto formed part of the rural area, ceased to be as such and they stood urbanised. There is also no dispute with the proposition laid down by this Court in P.N.Singh v. Union of India (RFA 359/98) decided on 6.11.1996 that when entirety of land has been urbanised by notification, much prior at any point of time to acquisition, the land could have been used as a building site and its potentiality had to be taken into account with that in mind, but this will depend upon other circumstances apparent on record, particularly special features, if any, with respect to the acquired land.

    9. We have perused the record. There is no separate evidence recorded as regards exact location of the land. Except for the observations made by the Collector Land Acquisition in his award about location of the land, no other or separate evidence was led. The Collector Land Acquisition while determining the amount of compensation payable to the claimants even discarded the sale deeds for the year 1971-72 of the same Village Khizarabad on the ground that the same pertained to land situate at a considerable distance from the land under acquisition. The land subject matter of sale deeds was level with good soil whereas the land under acquisition was "inside the Jamuna and was not very good for cultivation". It is noteworthy that the land has been acquired for the purpose of construction of pilot-cut in the reach from Nizamuddin Bridge to Okhla Weir. It was not an acquisition for any other construction activity such as a building site as is usual in case of other acquisitions in Delhi where irrespective of classification of land, acquisition has been for construction of building sites. It was incumbent and also necessary for the appellants to have led sufficient evidence on record as regards potentiality of the land. In the absence of such evidence, there is no other option except to place reliance upon what has been observed by the Collector Land Acquisition in his award that the land under acquisition was within Jamuna River and for that reason the Collector Land Acquisition discarded even the sale instances of levelled plots situate in Village Khizarabad. For similar reasons, it will not be permissible for us to rely upon the other decisions referred to by learned counsel for the appellants of the adjacent villages. We will have to place reliance upon decision in Deewan Ram Swoop's case (supra) wherein in 1961 also acquisition had taken place for similar purpose as in the instant, case and compensation was fixed at Rs. 12,500/- per bigha. It is a fact that there has been increase in market value of the land. In the absence of any other material, we presume that in this locality increase must have taken place from 1961 to 1976 at a normal pace. It will not be unreasonable to allow an increase @ 12% p.a. in order to arrive at market value. In Prakash Chand Kashyap v. Union of India, AIR 1983 Delhi 316, an escalation of 12% p.a. was considered as reasonable instead of past practice of Court in allowing escalation @ Rs. 1,000/- per bigha. In Rameshwar Solanki's & Another v. Union of India & Another, , also placing reliance on the decision in Prakash Chand Kashyap's case (supra), Divisions Bench observed that it would be appropriate to discard the past practice of this Court to give escalation @ Rs. 1,000/- per bigha and to allow escalation @ 12% p.a., which has been given following statutory provisions made by the amendments in the Act. In the absence of any other material in the instant case also, we are of the view that the market value as on 10.5.1976 can be worked out by placing reliance upon the earlier award of the Court in Deewan Ram Saroop's case (supra) and by allowing 12% p.a. escalation thereon. Otherwise also as the land was situate in Yamuna, we are of the view that the past practice of allowing escalation @ Rs. 1,000/-per bigha p.a. will not be reasonable. As such, we are of the view that the market value as on 10.5.1976 would be Rs. 35,000/- per bigha.

    10. Consequently, we allow the appeal with proportionate costs, holding the appellants to be entitled to compensation @ RS. 35,000/- per bigha. Over and above the amount of compensation, the appellants are also held entitled to solatium @ 15% and interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of Collector taking over possession till date of making payment.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tindey And Ors. v. Union Of India (Uoi) And Anr.
    (Dec 21, 1999)