Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the defendant in O.S. No.125 of 2007 on the file of the Principal District Munsif Court, Bhavani. The respondent filed a suit for recovery of Rs.98,600/- based on a promissory note alleged to have been executed by the petitioner on 10.07.2005. In his written statement the petitioner contended that he had acted as guarantor for one Rangasamy, who borrowed Rs.5,000/- from the finance company run by the plaintiff, and that the petitioner had put his signature and left thumb impression on a blank promissory note which originally showed numerals "Rs.5,000/-". The petitioner alleged that Rangasamy discharged the loan but the plaintiff did not return the blank pro-note; instead, the pro-note was allegedly forged and materially altered to show an amount of Rs.85,000/-, thereby increasing the claimed liability.

The petitioner filed an application under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act and Section 151 CPC seeking a referral of the suit pro-note to a handwriting expert to compare the age, thickness and clarity of the ink used to insert an "8" in front of "Rs.5,000/-" and to compare the writing of the amount in words with other entries in the document. The respondent filed a counter-affidavit denying the alleged alteration and characterising the petition as belated and intended to delay proceedings. The Principal District Munsif dismissed the application, holding that a handwriting expert referral would only delay the proceedings, there was no apparent mischief on the face of the pro-note, and the issue should be decided at trial by examination of witnesses and other evidence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in refusing to refer the disputed promissory note to a handwriting expert under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act and Section 151 CPC when the defendant specifically disputed alterations and the age of the ink.
  2. Whether an expert opinion on the age/thickness/clarity of ink (and related handwriting comparison) is an appropriate and necessary mode of enabling a defendant to rebut statutory presumptions (notably the presumption under Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act) in a civil recovery suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that he had signed a blank promissory note limited to the numericals "Rs.5,000/-" as guarantor for Rangasamy; Rangasamy had repaid the loan.
  • The petitioner alleged that the plaintiff retained the blank pro-note and that the pro-note before the court had been forged and materially altered to show "Rs.85,000/-".
  • The petitioner sought referral to a handwriting expert under Section 45 Indian Evidence Act and Section 151 CPC to compare ink thickness, clarity and the apparent insertion of the digit "8" and to determine the age of the writing.
  • Counsel for the petitioner relied on Supreme Court and High Court authorities (including T. Nagappa v. Y.R. Muralidhar and Kalyani Baskar v. M.S. Sampoornam) to the effect that where the contents of a negotiable instrument are disputed, the document should be referred to an expert to afford the party an opportunity to rebut presumptions.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent denied that any alteration was made and alleged that the petition was belated and designed to delay proceedings.
  • Counsel for the respondent relied on this Court's decisions (Sundaramoorthy v. R. Palanisamy and S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran) arguing that determining the age of ink is unreliable, would not resolve controversy and might create confusion, and that no useful purpose would be served by sending the document for such examination.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T. Nagappa v. Y.R. Muralidhar, 2008 (5) SCC 633 When the person who delivered a cheque (or negotiable instrument) disputes its contents, the Court may direct comparison of the age of writing by an expert; accused/defendant must be given opportunity to adduce rebuttal evidence despite statutory presumptions. The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision as directly supporting the proposition that the pro-note should be sent for expert examination to enable the petitioner to rebut presumptions.
Kalyani Baskar v. M.S. Sampoornam, 2007 (2) SCC 258 A magistrate's refusal to send a disputed document for expert examination may deprive the accused of an opportunity to rebut the prosecution's case and result in denial of a fair trial. Referenced to demonstrate the Supreme Court's consistent view that expert opinion may be essential to afford a fair opportunity to rebut documentary evidence relied upon by the opposite party.
Uppu Jhansi Lakshmi Bai v. J. Venkateswara Rao, AIR 1994 Andhra Pradesh 90 The opinion of a handwriting expert is not wholly irrelevant; expert opinion can be sought to determine the age of disputed handwriting, subject to limitations discussed in authorities. Used to support the proposition that expert opinion (including chemical examination where appropriate) can assist in determining whether a document is genuine or its age, thereby bolstering the petitioner's request.
Shashi Kumar Banerjee v. Subodh Kumar Banerjee, AIR 1964 SC 529 Discusses limitations of expert handwriting/chemical tests for determining age, and cautions about overreliance where positive attesting evidence exists. Referred to within the Andhra Pradesh authority discussed above; the Court considered these limitations but nonetheless accepted that expert opinion could assist where specific disputes as to age/alteration are raised.
Sundaramoorthy v. R. Palanisamy, 2009 (2) MLJ 358 (this Court) Expresses the view that age of ink cannot reliably be determined and that an expert's opinion as to age of ink may not resolve the controversy and could create confusion. Relied on by the respondent; the Court considered this line of authority but distinguished it from the instant case on the ground that Supreme Court precedents require that a party disputing contents be given opportunity to rebut by expert opinion.
S. Gopal v. D. Balachandran, 2008 (1) MLJ (Crl.) 769 (this Court) Expresses skepticism about determining age of ink and effectiveness of expert opinion for that purpose. Referenced by respondent's counsel; the Court acknowledged the view but held that it did not preclude referring the document for expert examination where specific and pleaded disputes exist and where Supreme Court guidance favours such referral to protect the right to rebut.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by reviewing higher judicial pronouncements (notably the Supreme Court decisions in T. Nagappa and Kalyani Baskar) which establish that where a person delivering a negotiable instrument disputes its contents, the Court should grant an opportunity to adduce rebuttal evidence and may direct expert examination of the instrument to determine matters such as the age of writing. The Court emphasised that a refusal to obtain expert opinion in such circumstances may amount to depriving the disputant of an opportunity to rebut the presumption arising under statutory provisions applicable to negotiable instruments.

The Court acknowledged contrary decisions (including this Court's own earlier observations) that express caution about the reliability of determining the precise age of ink and that an expert opinion might sometimes create confusion. However, the Court distinguished those decisions from the present case and reasoned as follows:

  • When the contents of a suit promissory note are specifically and expressly disputed in the written statement (here the allegation of alteration from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.85,000/-), the Court need not decline a request for expert examination.
  • The petitioner must be afforded an ample and meaningful opportunity to rebut the presumption under Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act; expert opinion can materially assist in such rebuttal.
  • There is no absolute legal impediment to obtaining an opinion from a handwriting expert; such an opinion may assist the Court in ascertaining the truth and in reaching a just decision, including by means of chemical examination where appropriate.
  • Given the Supreme Court's consistent stance that the accused/defendant must be given an opportunity to rebut documentary evidence and that expert opinion can constitute admissible and material evidence for that purpose, the trial court's failure to refer the document warranted judicial intervention.

On this basis, the Court concluded that the Principal District Munsif's refusal to refer the pro-note to an expert was unsustainable and that the petitioner's application for expert examination should have been granted. Consequently, the Court set aside the order of the trial court and directed that the pro-note be sent to a handwriting expert following the relevant procedure.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Revision Petition was allowed and the order of the Principal District Munsif dismissing the petition to refer the promissory note to a handwriting expert was set aside. The Court directed that the trial court refer the suit pro-note to a handwriting expert and obtain the expert's opinion; no costs were awarded and the connected miscellaneous petition was closed.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The petitioner (defendant) will receive the expert examination he sought; the expert's opinion is to be obtained pursuant to the trial court following the prescribed procedure.
  • The trial in O.S. No.125 of 2007 will proceed after the expert opinion is received and the parties will have the opportunity to rely upon or challenge that opinion at trial.

Broader implications: The opinion relies on existing Supreme Court authorities to reinforce that a party disputing the contents of a negotiable instrument is entitled to an opportunity to rebut statutory presumptions by seeking expert examination. The opinion itself does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts before the Court.


Decision delivered by S. Palanivelu, J. on 15.04.2009. Civil Revision Petition allowed; trial court directed to refer the suit pro-note to a handwriting expert.

    V.P Sankaran Petitioner v. R. Uthirakumar

    The petitioner is the defendant in O.S.No.125 of 2007 on the file of the Principal District Munsif Court, Bhavani. The respondent filed the sit for recovery of Rs.98,600/- from this petitioner on the strength of a promissory note executed by him on 10.07.2005. This petitioner filed the written statement, contending inter alia, that as he stood as guarantor for his friend by name Rangasamy, who borrowed a sum of Rs.5,000/- from the Finance Company run by the plaintiff and this petitioner put his signature and his left thumb impression on a blank pro-note, in which, only numericals of Rs.5,000/- written at the top, and that the said Rangasamy discharged the loan. However, the plaintiff did not return the above said blank pro-note to the defendant and that the said document has been forged and fabricated, with material alteration as if, the defendant owes Rs.85,000/- to the plaintiff.

    2. The petitioner filed the petition under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act and Section 151 CPC, praying the Court to refer the suit pro-note to handwriting expert to compare the difference available in the thickness, clarity of ink used to place 8 in front of Rs.5,000/- and writing of the amount in words with the other words used to fill up the pro-note relating to the address of parties and to give his opinion. In the affidavit, he has stated that originally, numericals "Rs.5,000/-" alone was entered in the pro-note, but the suit pro-note shows as if, it is for Rs.85,000/- and words in Tamil as "Rs.85,000/-" have been written subsequently and hence, age, thickness and clarity of the ink have to be compared by the handwriting expert.

    3. The above said petition resisted by the respondent by filing counter affidavit, stating that it is false to state that the alteration has been affected in the suit pro-note from numericals 8 to 85; that the petitioner is belated one; and that only in order to drag on the proceedings, the petitioner has been filed.

    4. Learned Principal District Munsif, Bhavani, dismissed the said application, by observing that referring to the pro-note to the handwritting expert would only drag on the proceedings, as there is no apparent mischief could be observed in the pro-note and the said question has to be decided at the time of trial by examination of witnesses and other evidence.

    5. Learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr.V.Manoharan, would draw the attention of this Court to the decision of the Supreme Court in T. Nagappa v. Y.R Muralidhar. reported in 2008 (5) SCC 633, wherein, Their Lordships have dealt with an identical circumstance and held that the age of writing can be directed to be compared by an expert and that when the person, who delivered a cheque disputes the contents of the document, it is incumbent upon the Court to refer the same to the handwriting expert. The operative portion of the judgment is extracted hereunder:

    "7. When a contention has been raised that the complainant has misused the cheque, even in the case where a presumption can be raised under Section 118(a) or 139 of the said Act, an opportunity must be granted to the accused for adducing evidence in rebuttal thereof. As the law places the burden on the accused, he must be given an opportunity to discharge it."

    6. In the above said decision, an earlier decision of the Supreme Court in Kalyani Baskar v. M.S.Sampoornam reported in 2007 (2) SCC 258, is also referred to, in which, it is observed thus,

    "The appellant is entitled to rebut the case of the respondent and if the document, viz., the cheque on which the respondent has relied upon for initiating criminal proceedings against the appellant would furnish good material for rebutting that case, the Magistrate having declined to send the document for the examination and opinion of the handwriting expert has deprived the appellant of an opportunity of rebutting it. The appellant cannot be convicted without an opportunity being given to her to present her evidence and if it is denied to her, there is no fair trial."

    7. The Supreme Court has taken a consistent view that when the opinion of the expert brings out good material in favour of the person, delivering the cheque to rebut the case, it has to be obtained by the Court and refusal on the part of the Court would amount to deprivation of opportunity of rebutting it.

    8. Learned counsel for the petitioner would draw attention of this Court to a decision of the Andra Pradesh High Court in Uppu Jhansi Lakshmi bai v. J.Venkateswara Rao reported in AIR 1994 Andra Pradesh 90, in which, it is held that the opinion of the handwriting expert is not totally irrelevant factor for adjudication of the dispute and his opinion can be sought for determining the age of disputed handwriting. In the said decision, a judgment of the Apex Court in Shashi Kumar Banerjee v. Subodh Kumar Banerjee reported in AIR 1964 SC 529, has been referred and relied upon. The extraction of portion of the judgment is as follows:

    "Finally we may point out that the expert admitted in his evidence that it was only by a chemical test that it could be definitely stated whether a particular writing was of a particular year or period. He also admitted that he applied no chemical tests in this case. So his opinion cannot on his own showing have that value which it might have had if he had applied a chemical test. Besides we may add that Osborn on "Questioned Documents" at page 464 says even with respect to chemical tests that "the chemical tests to determine the age also, as a rule are a mere excuse to make a guess and furnish no reliable date upon which a definite opinion can be based. In these circumstances, the mere opinion of the expert cannot override the positive evidence of the attesting witnesses in a case like this where there are no suspicious circumstances."

    9. Learned judge of the Andra Pradesh High Court further had taken pains to go through the authority of 'Albert S.Osborn' and extracted the view of the author, which is more appropriate to furnish here:

    "There are those also who pretend to say how old a writing is by merely examining it with a hand magnifier or a microscope. This always is an exhibition either of ignorance or of dishonest presumption. The chemical tests to determine age also, as a rule, are a mere execuse to make a guess and furnish no reliable date upon which a definite opinion can be based as can easily be demonstrated by fair tests on documents of known age."

    The learned author also expressed the view that:

    ".........By recording the color as first seen, any observer with good eyesight can on second view answer the question whether an ink is still undergoing a change in color. This kind of an ink examination often furnishes conclusive evidence that a document is not as old as it purports to be.

    .............................

    It is important to know that the color of the ink on a suspected document, if it is promptly examined, may thus be the means of showing that the document is not genuine. If a writing of this kind purports to have been written long before and it can be shown that the ink has not yet reached its final depth of color, and it actually goes through those changes that are characteristic of ink during the first months or year of its history, it is only necessary to prove this fact to invalidate the document."

    The relevant authorities on this subject also lend support to the contention of the petitioner.

    10. Learned counsel for the respondent, Mr.T.Murugamanikkam, would place reliance on a decision of this Court in Sundaramoorthy v. R.Palanisamy reported in 2009 (2) MLJ 358, where, the learned Judge referred to another decision of this Court in S.Gopal v. D.Balachandran reported in 2008 (1) MLJ (Crl.) 769, wherein, it was observed as under:

    "the age of the ink cannot be determined, on the basis of the writing the ink in dispute was manufactured five years prior to the date of execution of the document and used effectively on a particular dated for the first time and an experts opinion as age of ink will not resolve any controversy, but it will help to create only confusion."

    11. In the above prorated judgment, this Court has taken a view that the defendant need not take any steps to disprove the case of the plaintiff and no useful purpose would be served by sending the pro-note to ascertain the age of the ink.

    12. Following the principles and guidelines laid down in the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court mentioned supra, it is held that referring the suit pro-note to the wisdom of handwriting expert is inevitable for the reasons that the petitioner had to be afforded with ample opportunities to rebut the presumption under Section 118 of the negotiable Instruments Act. When the contents in the suit pro-note are specifically disputed, the Court need not decline to refer the matter to the handwriting expert. As for the Criminal case under Section 138 of the negotiable Instruments Act, it has become the responsibility of the accused to discharge the burden. In so far as the civil cases are concerned, the position of affording ample opportunities to the defendant, when necessary defence is specifically available in the written statement, has to be considered.

    13. There is no legal embargo for getting opinion from the handwriting expert, which would effectively assist the Court in reaching a just decision. By no stretch of imagination, it could be stated that the opinion of the expert, is not relevant factor for adjudication of the dispute and in order to unearth the truth, the Court can very well refer the matter for comparison and necessary chemical examination.

    14. In the light of the above said observations and following the principles of the Apex Court, it is observed that it is necessary to get the opinion of the handwriting expert as per the prayer contained in the affidavit. Hence, the order passed by the Court below calls for intervention and the same is liable to be set aside, which is accordingly set aside and the Civil Revision petition deserves to be allowed. The trial Court shall follow the relevant procedure for referring the suit pro-note to the handwriting expert and to get the opinion and proceed with the case further.

    15. In fine, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed. No costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.

    15.04.2009 Index: Yes Internet: Yes skm To The Principal District Munsif Court, Bhavani.

    S.PALANIVELU, J.

    skm C.R.P.(PD)No.3962 of 2008 15.04.2009

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V.P Sankaran Petitioner v. R. Uthirakumar
    (Apr 15, 2009)