Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Kattabomman Transport Corporation, Tirunelveli (Appellant)

Factual and Procedural Background

This set of appeals arises from two claim petitions (M.C.O.P No. 15 of 1993 and M.C.O.P No. 382 of 1993) arising out of the same motor-vehicle collision on 14.8.1992. In M.C.O.P No. 15/1993, Srirengam originally claimed Rs. 1,00,000 for grievous injuries; during pendency he died and his legal representatives were substituted as petitioners 2 to 4. In M.C.O.P No. 382/1993, the legal representatives of Duraipandi (who died in the same accident) claimed Rs. 1,50,000. Both petitions were tried together. The claimants led oral evidence (including P.W.1 and P.W.2) and tendered Exhibits P-1 to P-8; the Transport Corporation examined its driver as R.W.1 and placed no documentary evidence.

The Tribunal found that the accident was caused by the negligence of the Corporation bus driver and awarded Rs. 16,500 with 12% interest from the date of petition in M.C.O.P No. 15/1993, and Rs. 1,50,000 with 12% interest from the date of petition in M.C.O.P No. 382/1993, directing the Transport Corporation to pay. The Transport Corporation appealed against these awards.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the materials placed before the Tribunal, the finding of negligence against the bus driver was sufficient to sustain a direction that the Transport Corporation pay compensation.
  2. Whether the fact that three persons were riding the motorcycle (contravening the Motor Vehicles Act) amounted to contributory negligence that would either dismiss or reduce the claim.
  3. Whether the amounts awarded by the Tribunal are excessive and liable to reduction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Kattabomman Transport Corporation)

  • The Tribunal did not make a specific finding that the bus driver alone was responsible; absent such a finding, directing the Corporation to pay compensation cannot be sustained.
  • Three persons were riding on the motorcycle in contravention of the Motor Vehicles Act; therefore the Tribunal should have dismissed the claim or reduced compensation on the ground of contributory negligence.
  • The quantum of the awards is excessive.

Respondents'/Claimants' Arguments

  • The materials placed before the Tribunal justified the finding of negligence against the bus driver and the Tribunal was justified in awarding compensation which is just and reasonable.
  • There is no acceptable evidence to show that travelling of three persons on the motorcycle caused the accident; therefore contributory negligence is not established and no reduction is warranted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Coimbatore Division I) Ltd. v. Abdul Salam, 2003 (1) M.L.J. 489 The Division Bench held that when three persons travelled on a motorcycle meant for two (contrary to the statute), such conduct amounted to contributory negligence and compensation was reduced by 50% (award halved). The court examined that decision and held it should be confined to its facts. It declined to apply that case mechanically here because there was no finding that the presence of the third person caused the accident.
M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (3) L.W. 710 Held that breach of a policy condition (or carrying excess passengers) does not automatically absolve the owner/insurer; the insurer must prove that the presence of additional persons caused the accident before liability can be denied. The court relied on this principle to hold that mere violation (three persons on a motorcycle) is not enough: the appellant/owner/insurer must prove causal link between the breach and the accident. As that proof was absent, liability remained.
Canadian Pacific Railway Co. v. Leonard Lochart, AIR 1943 PC 63 Referred to in M. Anandavalli as part of authorities considered when addressing whether breach of conditions absolves insurer; used to support the approach that breach is not automatically fatal unless causation is shown. Relied upon in M. Anandavalli and, through that decision, indirectly supports the present Court's conclusion that mere non-compliance does not automatically lead to non-liability.
K.R. Sivagami v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi and others, 1981 ACJ 399 Referred to in M. Anandavalli as an earlier authority considered on the question of breach of policy/overloading and insurer's liability. Considered in M. Anandavalli and thereby forms part of the body of authority the present Court relied on in concluding that causation must be proved to deny liability.
B.V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Divisional Officer, Hassan, 1996 (4) SCC 647 Referred to in M. Anandavalli; treated as authority relevant to whether insurer is absolved for breach of policy conditions arising from carrying excess passengers. Referred through M. Anandavalli; used to support the approach that denial of liability requires proof that breach caused the accident.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 (2) SCC 654 Referred to in M. Anandavalli as part of the jurisprudence on policy conditions and insurer liability. Formed part of the authorities underpinning M. Anandavalli's conclusion, which the present Court applied to the facts before it.
Shivraj Vasant Bhagwat v. Shevanta Dattaram Indulkar, AIR 1997 Bom. 242 Referred to in M. Anandavalli as an instance of High Court authority on related questions. Considered in M. Anandavalli and treated as supportive of the proposition that overloading does not automatically extinguish liability absent causation.
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Murugesh, 1998 (1) L.W. 59 Referred to in M. Anandavalli; used as a judicial precedent on questions of excess passengers and insurer liability. Part of the set of authorities which the court in M. Anandavalli relied upon; the present Court accepted that line of reasoning in resolving the contributory-negligence contention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a focused, evidence-based analysis. Its reasoning followed the documentary and oral material tendered before the Tribunal:

  1. Primary documentary evidence: Ex.P-1 (certified copy of the First Information Report) contained a statement by Srirengam (the injured pillion rider) stating the Kattabomman bus was driven rashly and negligently and dashed against the motorcycle. The Tribunal had also relied on the same contents in the claim petition.
  2. Criminal proceedings: Following the complaint in Ex.P-1, a charge sheet (Ex.P-2) was filed against the bus driver for offences under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304-A IPC; this corroborated the attribution of fault to the bus driver.
  3. Technical and medical material: Ex.P-3 (Motor Vehicle Inspector's report) showed there was no mechanical defect in the bus; Ex.P-4 (wound certificate) established Srirengam sustained injuries; Ex.P-7 (post-mortem) showed Duraipandi died in the accident.
  4. Scene sketch: Ex.P-8 (rough sketch prepared by police) depicted the place and manner of occurrence. The court and Tribunal observed that the sketch showed the motorcycle proceeding on the proper (left) side of the road and that the bus moved onto the wrong side and struck the motorcycle, then moved to the western side. From this it inferred that the bus was on the wrong side when it hit the motorcycle.
  5. On the basis of the earliest documentary record (Ex.P-1), the rough sketch (Ex.P-8), and the fact that a charge sheet had been filed against the driver (Ex.P-2), the court concluded that the accident was caused solely by the rash and negligent driving of the bus driver and rejected the appellant's argument to the contrary.
  6. Regarding the contention of contributory negligence because three persons travelled on the motorcycle: the court noted this objection was not seriously pressed before the Tribunal; the bus driver did not lodge any complaint blaming the motorcycle rider or the presence of three persons; and there was no evidence linking the presence of the third person to the cause of the accident. The court examined precedent relied upon by the appellant (the Abdul Salam decision) but found that decision lacked specific evidence that the extra passenger caused the accident and therefore confined its application to its own facts.
  7. The court relied on the principle articulated in M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital (and the authorities cited there) that a breach of statutory provisions or policy conditions (such as carrying extra passengers) does not automatically absolve the owner/insurer of liability unless the owner/insurer proves that the accident occurred because of that breach. Applying that principle, the court held that the appellant had not proved the causal link between the presence of a third person on the motorcycle and the accident.
  8. On quantum, although the appellant asserted the awards were on the higher side, it provided no acceptable material to substantiate a case for reduction. After review of the oral and documentary evidence, the court found the Tribunal's awards to be just and acceptable and thus not liable to interference.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeals are dismissed.

Implications / Consequences:

  • The Tribunal's awards stand: the award in M.C.O.P No. 15/1993 of Rs. 16,500 with interest at 12% from the date of petition, and the award in M.C.O.P No. 382/1993 of Rs. 1,50,000 with interest at 12% from the date of petition, are upheld against the appellant-Transport Corporation.
  • No costs were awarded.
  • The court clarified its approach to contributory negligence claims based on statutory or policy violations: (a) a mere violation (such as carrying more persons than permitted) does not automatically establish contributory negligence or absolve the other vehicle owner/insurer; (b) the owner/insurer must demonstrate that the breach was causally responsible for the accident. The court confined the Abdul Salam decision to its own facts and endorsed the principle in M. Anandavalli that causation must be proved before denying or reducing liability.
  • On the record before this court, the Transport Corporation failed to prove that the presence of three persons on the motorcycle caused the accident, so no reduction was made. The decision therefore affirms the Tribunal's fact-findings and award without creating any wider departure from the precedent law cited; it applies established principles regarding causation and contributory negligence.

This summary is strictly confined to the materials and reasoning presented in the provided opinion and does not add facts or conclusions beyond those expressly found in the judgment text.

    Kattabomman Transport Corpn. Ltd. v. Vellai Duraichi

    P. Sathasivam, J.

    1. Kattabomman Transport Corporation, Tirunelveli is the appellant in the above appeals. In respect of grievous injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident on 14.8.1992, one Srirengam filed M.C.O.P No. 15 of 1993 praying for a compensation of Rs. 1,00,000. During the pendency of the said petition, the said Srirengam died and his legal representatives were brought on record as petitioners 2 to 4. In respect of death of one Duraipandi in the very same accident, his wife, children and mother filed M.C.O.P No. 382 of 93 praying for a compensation of Rs. 1,50,000. Both the claim petitions were tried together. 2nd claimant in the former petition (M.C.O.P No. 15/1993) was examined as P.W.1 and first petitioner in the latter petition (M.C.O.P No. 382/1993) as P.W.2, besides marking of Exs. P-1 to P-8 in support of their claim. On the side of the Transport Corporation, their driver was examined as R.W.1 and no document was marked. The Tribunal, on appreciation of evidence, both oral and documentary, after holding that the accident was caused due to the negligence of the driver of the Corporation bus, passed an award for Rs. 16,500 with interest at 12 per cent from the date of petition in respect of the former M.C.O.P; and for Rs. 1,50,000 with interest at 12 per cent from the date of petition in the latter M.C.O.P, and directed the Transport Corporation to pay the same. Questioning the said awards, the Transport Corporation has preferred the above appeals.

    2. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant as well as the respondents/claimants.

    3. Mrs. Kala Ramesh, learned counsel for the appellant-Transport Corporation, would contend that in the absence of specific finding regarding negligence that the driver of the Corporation bus alone was responsible for the accident, the ultimate direction to the Transport Corporation for payment of compensation cannot be sustained. She also contended that since three persons were riding on the motor cycle at the time of the accident which is contravention of the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, the Tribunal ought to have dismissed the claim petition or, in any event, ought to have reduced the compensation towards contributory negligence. She further contended that the award amount is on the higher side. On the other hand, Mr. J. Pothiraj, learned counsel appearing for the respondents/claimants, by pointing out the entire materials placed before the Tribunal, would contend that the Tribunal is fully justified in rendering the finding against the bus driver and passing an award which is just and reasonable. He also contends that in the absence of any acceptable evidence that since three persons travelled in the motor cycle which alone has resulted in the accident, there cannot be any contributory negligence on the part of those persons travelled in the motor cycle and consequently there will be no reduction in the compensation.

    4. We have carefully considered the rival submissions.

    5. Though the injured Srirengam (pillion rider) was not available for evidence at the time of trial, the said Srirengam, after the occurrence had given a statement to the police with regard to the accident wherein he has specifically mentioned that the Kattabomman bus was driven in a rash and negligently manner and it dashed against the motor cycle, resulted in the accident, as seen from Ex.P-1, certified copy of First Information Report. As rightly observed by the Tribunal, even in his claim petition in M.C.O.P No. 15/93, he had mentioned all the above statements as found in Ex. P-1. It is also seen that based on the complaint-Ex.P-1, after investigation, a criminal case has been filed against the driver of the Kattabomman bus for offences under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304-A, I.P.C and that subsequently a charge sheet was also filed against him. Ex. P-2 is the certified copy of the charge sheet. Motor Vehicle Inspector's report is Ex.P-3 which shows that the accident was not due to any mechanical defect. Ex.P-4-wound certificate shows that the said Srirengem sustained injuries in the said accident. Subsequently Srirengem died on 10.5.94 and his death is not due to the injuries. Ex. P-7, certified copy of the post-mortem certificate, shows that another person by name Duraipandi died in the said accident. It is further seen that the motor cycle was coming to Kovilpatti from Pasuvanthanai, on the Kovilpatti to Pasuvanthanai road and the bus was going from the opposite direction. The police had prepared rough sketch regarding the manner of the accident which has been marked as Ex.P-8. The perusal of Ex.P-8 shows that the accident had taken place on the eastern end of the road. As rightly observed by the Tribunal, the motor cycle was coming along the left side of the road and after the occurrence, the bus went to the western side. Therefore, it is clear that at the relevant time, the bus came on the wrong side of the road and hit against the motor cycle and caused the accident. In the light of the said conclusion and the stand taken by the appellant/Transport Corporation, we also verified the rough sketch-Ex.P-8 which shows that the bus came on the wrong side of the road and hit the motor cycle coming on the left side, which is the proper side, and caused the accident. From the contents of the earliest document-First Information Report-Ex.P-1, Rough sketch-Ex.P-8, which shows the place of occurrence, and of the fact that after investigation, the driver of the Corporation bus was charge sheeted as seen from Ex.P-2, we hold that the accident was caused solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the Corporation bus and reject the argument of the learned counsel for the appellant.

    6. Coming to the other contention that travelling of three persons in a motor cycle, which is prohibited, has contributed for the accident, it is to be noted that this objection was not seriously raised before the Tribunal. Further, admittedly, the bus driver did not lodge any complaint finding fault with the rider of the motor cycle as well as the carrying of 3 persons therein. Admittedly, only the injured Srirengam (since deceased) gave a statement with regard to the accident, which was registered as First Information Report-Ex.P-1 and based on it, the police investigated the matter, prepared a rough sketch-Ex.P-8 and charge sheeted the driver of the Corporation bus for offences under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304-A, I.P.C In the discussion relating to the earlier issue, we have said that Ex.P-8 sketch clearly shows that the accident occurred on the left side of the road which is the proper side for the motor cycle and it is also clear that the Corporation bus had gone to the wrong side and after hitting the motor cycle, came to the west. The position of the motor cycle, the bus and the other damaged articles give the following inferences: (1) The motor cycle was proceeding on the proper side i.e, left side of the road; (2) Though 3 persons travelled in the motor cycle, the same was in no way connected with the accident. As discussed earlier, the materials placed would clearly show that it was the bus driver who had gone to the other side of the road and hit the motor cycle, thereby caused the accident. There is no iota of evidence to show that the fatal accident had occurred because of the mere travelling of the three persons in the motor cycle. In this regard, learned counsel for the appellant pressed into service a Division Bench decision of this Court in Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Coimbatore Division I) Limited, Coimbatore v. Abdul Salam, 2003 (1) M.L.J 489. In that case, there was a collision between three persons riding in a motor cycle and a bus coming in an opposite direction resulting in accident, thereby one of the pillion rider died for which the legal representatives of the deceased claimed compensation. The Tribunal therein awarded a sum of Rs. 2,20,000. Aggrieved by the said award, the owner of the vehicle-Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation, Coimbatore Division I preferred an appeal before this Court. The Division Bench, after holding that when three persons travelled in a motor cycle which is meant for two persons, after depricating the conduct of the persons who travelled, held that they are liable for contributory negligence, and reduced the compensation to 50 per cent, namely, Rs. 1,10,000 with interest at 9 per cent per annum. In para 13, the Division Bench has observed thus:

    “13. When three persons travelled in a motor cycle which is meant for two persons, this Court is of the view, the conduct of the persons who travelled in such a manner are liable for contributory negligence; especially when their action is contrary to the statute.”

    A perusal of the said decision does not show that except the fact that 3 persons travelled in the motor cycle, there is no evidence to show that the accident took place only because of such act (taking one more passenger). The Division Bench went on saying that since 3 persons travelled in a motor cycle which is meant for two persons, they are liable for contributory negligence. By saying so, the Division Bench fixed their liability to the extent of 50 per cent.

    7. It is also useful to refer another Division Bench decision of this Court in the case of M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (3) L.W 710. Among other questions, the Division Bench considered the question when the vehicle carrying more persons than what is allowed/prescribed in the policy, whether insurance company is absolved of the liability on that ground. The relevant question that was decided by the Division Bench is, whether, in view of the fact that a medical squad consisting of 16 persons were taken in the ill-fated van and which is contrary to one of the conditions that is found in the conditions of the policy, the Insurance Company is absolved from liability. After referring to a decision of the Privy Council in Canadian Pacific Railway Co. v. Leonard Lochart, AIR 1943 PC 63, an earlier Division Bench decision of this Court in the case reported in K.R Sivagami v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi and others, 1981 ACJ 399, a judgment of the Supreme Court reported in B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan., 1996 (4) SCC 647, and a decision of the Supreme Court reported in Skandia Insurance Company Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 (2) SCC 654, a Division Bench decision of the Bombay High Court reported in Shivraj Vasant Bhagwat v. Shevanta Dattaram Indulkar, AIR 1997 Bom. 242 and a decision of a learned Single Judge of this Court reported in Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Murugesh, 1998 (1) L.W 59, concluded that, (para 19)

    “19. Coming to the case on hand, as many as 10 persons were taken in the ill-fated van, when the terms and conditions of the policy prescribe or restrict the maximum number as 14. From the cases cited supra and other rulings, it could be seen that in most of the cases, the driver took additional passengers without the knowledge of the owner that is insured and in the rest, it is not clear as to whether the owner had knowledge. As far as the present case is concerned, the insured is none else than the Arvind Eye Institute. It cannot be said, in this case, that the Driver took two extra persons without the knowledge of the insured or to benefit him in any manner. Then the question is, whether it would make any difference. We may straight away say, the answer is in the negative. Merely by lifting a person or two, it cannot be said to be such a fundamental breach that the owner should, in all events, be denied indemnification. The breach of the condition of the policy was somewhat irregular, though, but not so fundamental in nature, so as to put an end to the contract, unless some factors existed, which, by themselves, had gone to contribute to the causing of the accident. If the Insurance Company is able to prove that it is because of the presence of the additional persons who were allowed to occupy the vehicle, the accident occurred, the position would be different. Consequently, we hold that even in cases where more passengers are taken with or without the knowledge or implied consent or even consent of the owner, unless the Insurance Company is able to prove that the accident took place only because of such act (taking more passengers) the Insurance Company will be liable to make good the loss/compensation….”

    8. In the light of the said conclusion, we have carefully verified the factual details and the ultimate decision arrived at in the first Division Bench decision, namely, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation, Coimbatore Division v. Abdul Salam (cites supra). As observed earlier, except stating that 3 persons travelled in a motor vehicle, which is prohibited, no specific finding was given to the effect that travelling of three persons in a motor cycle was responsible for the accident; hence we are of the view that the conclusion in 2003 (1) M.L.J 489 is to be confined to that case. In other words, merely because there is violation of the provisions of the Act or Rules or the policy conditions, it is not automatic that in every case the principle of contributory negligence is to be applied mechanically. As rightly observed in the other Division Bench decision, namely, M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (3) L.W 710, unless there is evidence to prove that the accident took place only because of such act that is taking/travelling more persons in a motor cycle which resulted in an accident, the owner of the other vehicle and its insurer will be liable to pay compensation. To put it clear, if the appellant-Transport Corporation is able to prove that it is because of the addition of one more (third person in the motor cycle instead of two), the accident occurred, the position would be different. In other words, unless the owner of the vehicle or the Insurance Company is able to prove that the accident took place only because of such act that is taking more persons than the prescribed number, the owner/Insurance Company will be liable to make good the loss/compensation. In the case on hand the materials placed before the Tribunal show that it was the bus driver who had gone to the other side of the road, hit the motor cycle thereby caused the accident. There is no evidence to show that the accident occurred because of travelling of three persons in the motor cycle. In the light of the above said conclusion, we reject the contra argument made by the learned counsel for the appellant.

    9. Though it is stated that the amount awarded by the Tribunal is on the higher side, except mere statement, the same was not substantiated by placing acceptable materials. On the other hand, after perusing the oral and documentary evidence let in before the Tribunal, we are of the view that the amount awarded in both the cases is just and acceptable, and no ground for interference.

    10. In the light of what is stated above, we do not find any merit in both the Appeals; accordingly the same are dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kattabomman Transport Corpn. Ltd. v. Vellai Duraichi
    (Jan 30, 2004)