AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Concise Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This Revision is directed against the order of the District Munsif Court, Dharmapuri in I.A. 595/97 in O.S. 274/91 dated 15.12.1998 which dismissed an application filed by the plaintiff under Order VI, Rule 17 C.P.C. The plaintiff (the deceased plaintiff in the plaint, Palaniammal) claimed a 5/20th share in certain suit properties as a daughter and legal heir of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder, who had purchased items mentioned in the plaint (Item No. 1 under Sale Deed dated 11.4.1943). The suit sought partition and a permanent injunction restraining certain defendants from interfering with enjoyment of the property; the last demand by the plaintiff was on 3.2.1991 and defendants 4 to 8 were alleged to have refused partition.

Defendant No.1 (D1) filed a written statement admitting relationship but contested material facts, stating among other things that Koolan @ Kandha Gounder died earlier (allegedly about 42 years ago or in/around 1949) and that descriptions/extent of the property in the plaint were incorrect. D1 also alleged an agreement of sale between D4–D8 and D1 dated 8.5.1985 (advance of Rs. 6,000 on a Rs. 8,000 sale consideration) and that D1 had filed a suit for specific performance (O.S.153/88) against D2–D8.

While the partition suit was in trial (part-heard) after P.W.1 had been examined, the plaintiffs filed an application to amend the plaint to change the averment of the year of death of Koolan from "Before 40 years" to "Before 30 years" (i.e., to correct what plaintiffs said was a typographical error). D1 opposed the amendment as a deliberate attempt to delay proceedings and to avoid the consequences of the Hindu Succession Act. The District Munsif dismissed the amendment application on the grounds that the proposed amendment was unsupported by any material particulars, was based on oral evidence of P.W.1 and was belated. The plaintiffs filed this revision against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the District Munsif was justified in dismissing the application for proposed amendment on the finding that it was unsupported by material particulars?
  2. Considering the stage of proceedings when the amendment application was filed, whether the impugned order suffers from any irregularity warranting interference by the revisional court?

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioners / Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The stated year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder ("Before 40 years") was a typographical or innocuous error and should be corrected to "Before 30 years".
  • Allowing the proposed amendment would permit the plaintiffs to correctly set forth their case.

Respondent / Defendant No.1's Arguments

  • The amendment was filed in the part-heard stage primarily to delay trial proceedings and to protract litigation.
  • The proposed amendment has serious consequences because of the operation of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (i.e., the date of death determines whether the plaintiff is entitled to inheritance), and therefore the amendment cannot be allowed.
  • Factual contentions in the written statement: Koolan died about 42 years ago (circa 1949); the extent of the property as pleaded is incorrect; an agreement of sale (8.5.1985) exists between D4–D8 and D1 with an advance payment; D1 had a pending suit for specific performance which bears on the dispute over title and possession.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a fact-focused analysis centered on the materiality of the year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder to the plaintiff's claim:

  1. The court observed that the plaintiff's entitlement (a daughter's share) depends on the operation of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, which came into force on 17.6.1956. The precise year of death of Koolan determines whether the Act applies and hence whether the plaintiff is entitled to a share.
  2. If Koolan had died in or about 1951 (as the plaintiffs' averment "before 40 years" might imply), the plaintiff would be excluded from inheritance; if he died about 1961 ("before 30 years"), the plaintiff would have a share. Thus the date of death is a crucial, determinative fact on which the cause of action depends.
  3. Given this centrality, the court held that the plaintiff could not be unclear or uncertain about that material fact; it is not a mere innocuous typographical error when the fact has such decisive legal consequences.
  4. The court examined the evidentiary support for the proposed amendment and found none: no death certificate or contemporaneous material was produced. The proposed amendment was sought to be supported only by vague and self-serving oral evidence of P.W.1.
  5. The court noted inconsistent and vague testimony from P.W.1: in chief she said her father died "about 50 years ago," while in cross-examination she attempted to fix the death between 1956–1957 by rough arithmetic based on her age, marriage age and approximate dates. The court found these calculations and answers too vague to constitute material particulars supporting the amendment.
  6. The timing and stage of the application were important: the suit had been pending trial for nearly six years; the instant amendment application was made during the part-heard stage in 1997 (after P.W.1 had been examined in 1995 and other proceedings). The court considered the application belated and likely filed to delay the trial, noting that the plaintiffs had filed prior applications and that D1 had obtained a decree in a separate suit for specific performance (allegedly in 1995), which suggested tactical litigation conduct by the plaintiffs.
  7. Summarising these factors, the court concluded the proposed amendment was unsupported by material particulars, belated, and lacking bona fides. For those reasons the District Munsif's refusal to allow the amendment was found to be justified and not irregular or illegal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revisional court confirmed the order of the District Munsif Court dated 15.12.1998 dismissing I.A. 595/97 in O.S. 274/91 and dismissed this Revision Petition. The petition was dismissed with costs in favour of the first respondent/first defendant.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The amendment sought by the plaintiffs to change the alleged year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder from "Before 40 years" to "Before 30 years" is refused; the plaintiff's pleaded position (as it stood) remains in the record and the trial proceeds without that amendment. Costs were awarded to Defendant No.1.
  • Reasoning basis: The refusal was grounded on the materiality of the date of death to the operation of the Hindu Succession Act, lack of documentary or specific supporting material for the amendment, the belated stage at which the amendment was sought, and findings of lack of bona fides.
  • No broader precedent was created by this opinion beyond the application of established principles that a proposed amendment which affects a material fact crucial to the cause of action cannot be allowed without supporting materials and that belated amendments sought in part-heard trials may be disallowed where mala fides or delay are reasonably inferable.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the facts, arguments, reasoning and conclusions contained in the provided opinion text.

    Pachammal And 3 Others Petitioners v. Rathinasamy And 7 Others S

    1. This Revision is directed against the order of District Munsif Court, Dharmapuri in I.A 595/97 in O.S 274/91 dated 15.12.1998 dismissing the Application filed by the Revision Petitioner/Plaintiff under Order VI, Rule 17 C.P.C

    2. Parties are related. Plaintiff and Defendants 4 to 8 are related as under:

    3. The case of the deceased plaintiff Palaniammal is that her father Koolan @ Kandha Gounder purchased the item No. 1 under Sale Deed dated 11.4.1943 Suit Item No. 2 was purchased by Koolan and out of joint exertion or Ganapathy. Koolan @ Kandha Gounder died about 40 years ago leaving plaintiff Palaniammal and Ganapathy as his legal heirs. Plaintiff is entitled to 5/20th share in the suit property as daughter of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder. Suit is also filed for permanent injunction restraining D1 and D3 from interfering with the enjoyment of the suit property by the plaintiff. Despite demand by the plaintiff, and the last demand on 3.2.1991, Defendants 4 to 8 have refused effecting partition. D1 claims right in Item No. 1 on the basis of certain documents from D5 to D8 which is not binding upon the plaintiff. Since Defendants 4 to 8 are prejudicially acting against the interest of Plaintiff, plaintiff has filed the suit for partition claiming her 5/20th share in the suit property.

    4. Admitting the relationship of parties, main contesting Defendant/D1 filed Written Statement contending that Koolan @ Kandha Gounder died about 42 years ago and in or about 1949. Extent of Item No. 1 stated in the plaint schedule is incorrect. Actual extent of Item No. 1 in Survey No. 538/2A is O. 49.5 Hectares. Further case of D1 is that agreeing to sell Item No. 1 to him, D4 to D8 entered into an Agreement of sale with D1 for Rs. 8,000. D4 to D8 have received an advance of Rs. 6,000 and executed an Agreement of Sale on 8.5.85 In the Agreement of Sale, extent of Item No. 1 is mistakenly referred as One Acre. Though D.1 was already ready and willing to take the Sale Deed in his favour on payment of balance Sale Consideraion, D4 to D8 have been evading execution of Sale Deed. Hence, for Specific Performance of Contract, D1 had filed O.S 153/88 on the file of District Munsif Court, Dharmapuri against Defendants 2 to 8. Second Defendant contested the said suit raising false defence. While the suit is pending, with a view to cause inconvenience and harassment to D.1, D4 to D8 have instigated the plaintiffs to file this suit for Partition, which is unsustainable.

    5. The suit was taken up for trial. While P.W.1 was examined and when the suit was in the part heard stage, an amendment Application was filed to amend the year of death of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder (i.e) to amend “Before 40 years” as “Before 30 years”. According to the Revision Petitioners/Plaintiffs, the year of death of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder was mistakenly typed as “Before 40 years” instead of “Before 30 years”.

    6. Amendment Application was seriously opposed by D1 on the ground that the Application is filed only with a view to delay the trial proceedings. The counter statement refers to various dates on which the case was adjourned for examination of plaintiffs. According to D.1 “Before 40 years” is sought to be corrected as “Before 30 years” only with a view to get over the effect of Hindu Succession Act and disentitlement of the plaintiffs to get any share in the suit property.

    7. Upon consideration of submissions by both sides, learned District Munsif has dismissed the application finding that the year of death of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder is unsupported by any materials. Finding that the Amendment on the basis of oral evidence of P.W.1, cannot be allowed, the Amendment Application was dismissed. Learned District Munsif was also of the view that the Application was filed belatedly.

    8. Aggrieved over the dismissal of the Application, Revision Petitioners/Plaintiffs have preferred this Revision Petition.

    9. Learned counsel appearing for the Revision Petitioners/Plaintiffs submitted that the year of death of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder is mistakenly stated as “Before 40 years” which is only a typhographical error or innocuous, crept in by mistake and that by allowing the proposed Amendment opportunity is to be given to the Revision petitioners/Plaintiffs to set forth her case.

    10. Learned counsel appearing for the Respondent/D.1 has submitted that Amendment Application was filed in the part-heard stage, mainly with the intention to delay the trial proceedings. It is submitted that the proposed Amendment has serious consequences in view of the intervention of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 between 1940-1950 and that the proposed Amendment cannot be allowed.

    11. Upon consideration of the submissions by both counsel, impugned order and the other available materials, in my considered view, the following points arise for determination in this Revision:

    i. Whether the District Munsif was not justified in dismissing the Application for proposed Amendment finding that it is not supported by any material particulars ?

    ii. Considering the stage in which the Application was filed can it be said that the impugned order suffers from any irregularity warranting interference ?

    12. Plaintiff being the daughter of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder claims 5/20 th share. Plaintiff being the daughter, her share could only be by virtue of the provisions of Hindu Succession Act which came into force on 17.6.1956 The suit was filed in the year 1991. Plaintiff has vaguely alleged that her father Koolan alias Kandha Gounder died about 40 years ago implying that the must have died in or about 1951. If Koolan alias Kandha Gounder died in 1951, plaintiff is definitely excluded from inheritance. If death of Koolan alias Kandha Gounder is 30 years prior to the suit, the death must have been in 1961 implying that the plaintiff has share in the suit property. Hence, the date of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder is crucial forming the very basis of the suit. Now on this material particular and the basis of the claim, plaintiff cannot be unclear or uncertain.

    13. Year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder is material fact on which plaintiff's cause of action depends. On the year of death of Koolan plaintiff must fail or succeed in her suit. While so, on that factual basis, on which plaintiff's cause of action has arisen, there cannot be any uncertainty or mistake even a typographical error.

    14. It is not as if submitted by the counsel appearing for the Revision petitioner/plaintiff that the proposed Amendment is so simple and innocuous and a typographical error. Year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder has far reaching effect on plaintiff's case. It is very much essential that even at the time of filing the suit, plaintiff ought to have produced material showing the year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder. Now the plaintiff seeks to amend the plaint by the proposed amendment after six years. Even that proposed Amendment amending the year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder ‘died 30 years ago’ is unsupported by any material particulars. The proposed Amendment is sought to be made only on the bais sof vague oral evidence of P.W.1 In fact, in her chief examination plaintiff/P.W.1 has stated that her father died about 50 years ago. But in her cross examination she has tried to fix the year of death of Koolan betweeb 1956-1957 on certain vague answers as under:

    Approximate age of P.W.1/Plaintiff at the time of trial in 1997 60 Therefore, probable year of birth of P.W.1/Plaintiff 1937 Marriage at the age of 15 15 Approximate year of Marriage of P.W.1 1952 Koolan died 5 years thereafter (Add 5 years) 5 1957

    Approximate year of death of Koolan : 1957

    On the above basis of rough arithmetical calculation and vague answers of P.W.1, the proposed Amendment is sought to be introduced. Absolutely it is not supported by any material particulars. No death Certificate is produced showing the year of death of Koolan @ Kandha Gounder. On the basis of self serving statement of P.W.1/Plaintiff, no amendment could be ordered.

    15. The stage in which the Amendment Application was filed is also to be noted. Suit was pending trial for nearly six years. After overcoming all the hurdles, the matter came up for trial in 1995. P.W.1 was examined on 2.11.1995 At that time, an Amendment Application is said to have been filed which was allowed. (Details of which are not known from the available materials).Thereafter when the suit was again posted for examination of other witnesses in 1997. At that time, the present Amendment Application I.A 595/97 was filed seeking to amend the plaint. In the proposed Amendment seeking to amend the very basis/material particular on which the plaintiff's suit revolves. The learned District Munsif was right in finding that the application is belatedly filed with a view to delay the trial proceedings. Proposed Amendment Application lacks in bona fide.

    16. In the counter statement it is stated that the suit for Specific Performance in O.S 193/98 was filed by D.1 against D.4 to D.8 was already decreed in faovur of D.1 on 31.10.1995 According to D.1, only with a view to grab the suit property − Item No. 1, Revision petitioner/Plaintiff filed Application after Application to protract the trial. The averments in the counter statement filed by the first respondent/D.1 cannot be brushed aside as without any substance.

    17. The proposed Amendment Application cannot be allowed for the reasons:

    i. that it is unsupported by any material particulars;

    ii. belatedly filed;

    iii. lacks in bona fide.

    Learned District Munsif has rightly declined to allow the Amendment Application. The order does not suffer from any material irregularity or illegality warranting interference. This Revision has no merits and is bound to fail.

    18. Therefore, order of District Munsif, Dharmapuri in I.A 595/97 in O.S 274/91 (dt. 15.12.1998) is confirmed and this Revision Petition is dismissed with the cost of the first Respondent/First Defendant.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pachammal And 3 Others Petitioners v. Rathinasamy And 7 Others S
    (Oct 21, 2003)