Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (appellant) sued for redemption of an usufructuary mortgage dated 29 August 1959 executed by Kaliaperumal Padayachi in favour of the first defendant. The plaintiff alleged that the first defendant was in enjoyment of the suit property as usufructuary mortgagee and that on 14 July 1960 the plaintiff entered into an oral agreement with Kaliaperumal to purchase the property for Rs. 2,750. The plaintiff paid sums to discharge a bogiam deed and related pronote debts, and later alleged that Kaliaperumal executed a sale deed in his favour on 11 August 1960 directing that the bogiam debt be discharged by the plaintiff. The first defendant allegedly refused to discharge the bogiam deed and evaded receipt of a money order tendered on 7 May 1964. Kaliaperumal died pending suit; defendants 2–5 were impleaded. The plaintiff sought redemption and related reliefs.

The first defendant contended that he obtained a sale of the property from Kaliaperumal on 24 September 1960 for Rs. 2,500, thereby discharging the usufructuary mortgage, and alleged that the plaintiff's sale deed was false or forged and backdated. The first defendant's sale deed was presented for compulsory registration on 16 November 1960 but was initially refused; it was ultimately registered on 10 March 1961 after appeal to the District Registrar.

The trial court, by judgment dated 27 December 1967, decreed the suit against the first defendant for redemption with costs and awarded mesne profits to the plaintiff from the date of notice of deposit of the mortgage amount until delivery of possession. The first defendant appealed to the Sub-Court, Chidambaram (lower appellate court), which reversed the trial court and dismissed the suit. The plaintiff then brought the present second appeal to the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Ex. A-1 (the plaintiff's registered sale deed dated 11 August 1960) was actually executed on 11 August 1960 or was backdated/forged after Ex. B-2 (the first defendant's sale deed dated 24 September 1960) was presented for registration.
  2. Which party bears the legal burden of proof regarding the genuineness and date of execution of a registered sale deed (specifically, whether the plaintiff must prove Ex. A-1's execution date or whether the defendant must rebut the prima facie proof of a registered document).
  3. Whether the lower appellate court committed a substantial procedural error (under S. 100, C.P.C.) by wrongly casting the burden of proof on the plaintiff and by failing to adequately consider or discuss the defendant's evidence.
  4. Whether the matter should be remanded to the lower appellate court for fresh disposal after correctly allocating the burden of proof.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments — presented by the Advocate General

  • The lower appellate court improperly and lightly interfered with the trial court's considered findings of fact; its reversal should be set aside and the trial court's decree restored.
  • The lower appellate court wrongly cast the burden of proof upon the plaintiff; as a registered document Ex. A-1 is prima facie proof of execution on the date it bears, so the burden was on the first defendant to prove that Ex. A-1 was not genuine or not executed on that date.
  • The lower appellate court failed to discuss or properly consider the evidence adduced by the first defendant and thereby committed an error of law/procedure requiring interference in this second appeal.
  • Given these errors, the High Court has power in a second appeal to correct the lower appellate court's procedural error and restore the trial court's judgment (or otherwise remedy the error).

Respondent's (First Defendant's) Arguments

  • The lower appellate court correctly placed the burden on the plaintiff to prove the genuineness and actual execution date of Ex. A-1; the plaintiff had to prove Ex. A-1 was executed on 11 August 1960.
  • The first defendant maintained that he obtained the sale from Kaliaperumal on 24 September 1960 and that the plaintiff's sale deed was false or forged and possibly created after the first defendant sought compulsory registration of his deed.
  • The lower appellate court, after considering evidence, correctly concluded that Ex. A-1 could not have come into existence prior to Ex. B-2.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sarju Prasad v. Raja Jwaleswari Pratab Narain Singh, 1950 S.C.R. 781 The principle that an appellate court should not lightly interfere with a trial judge's findings of fact based on credibility of witnesses unless special features or clear improbability exist. Cited by the Advocate General to support the proposition that the lower appellate court should not have lightly reversed the trial court's factual findings; used to justify High Court intervention in a second appeal where such interference has occurred.
Radha Prasad Singh v. Gajadhar Singh & Others, A.I.R. 1963 S.C. 115 Authority supporting the proposition that no second appeal lies except on grounds specified in S. 100, C.P.C.; limits on second appeal jurisdiction. Referred to by both sides as part of the jurisprudential framework limiting second appeals to S.100 grounds; relied upon in discussion of when the High Court may intervene.
Ramachandra v. Ramalinga, A.I.R. 1963 S.C. 302 Support for the proposition that second appeals are limited by S.100 and cannot be entertained merely for erroneous findings of fact unless procedural/substantial error exists. Cited in support of the general rule on scope of second appeals; the opinion treats this and related authorities as setting the background to determine whether a procedural/substantial error exists in the lower appellate court's approach.
Chunilal Vithaldas v. Mohanlal, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 226 Another authority on limits of second appeal jurisdiction under S.100 and related appellate principles. Referred to along with other Supreme Court decisions to outline the constraints on second appeal interference with findings of fact.
Ramachandra Iyer v. Ramalinga Chettiar, 1963 S.C.R. 605 Explains that S.100(1) refers to substantial errors or defects in procedure (not mere errors in appreciation of evidence), and gives examples of procedural defects that may justify interference (e.g., wrong casting of burden, discarding admissible evidence, failing to consider an issue). The court relied upon this decision to conclude that the lower appellate court had committed a substantial procedural error by wrongly casting the burden of proof on the plaintiff, thereby justifying remand of the matter to the lower appellate court for fresh disposal after properly allocating the burden.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the central factual dispute concerning two registered sale deeds relating to the same property: Ex. A-1 (plaintiff's sale deed dated 11 August 1960, registered 21 November 1960) and Ex. B-2 (first defendant's sale deed dated 24 September 1960, presented for registration 16 November 1960, ultimately registered 10 March 1961). The crucial question was whether Ex. A-1 was truly executed on 11 August 1960 or was later fabricated/backdated after Ex. B-2 was presented for registration.

The court set out the governing evidentiary principle that a registered document is prima facie proof of its execution on the date it bears. Accordingly, Ex. A-1, being registered, established a prima facie case that it was executed on 11 August 1960. That prima facie proof places the burden on the party who challenges the document's genuineness (here, the first defendant) to rebut that proof.

Applying the Supreme Court's guidance in Ramachandra Iyer v. Ramalinga Chettiar (and related authorities on S.100), the court examined whether the lower appellate court committed a procedural error of a nature that S.100 permits the High Court to correct in a second appeal. The court concluded that the lower appellate court had wrongly cast the burden of proof on the plaintiff to establish the execution date of Ex. A-1. This misallocation of burden was treated as a substantial procedural error because it materially affected the appellate court's approach to the evidence and to decision-making.

Because the lower appellate court's conclusion flowed substantially from this wrong approach to burden, the High Court determined that the proper remedy was to allow the second appeal and remand the matter to the lower appellate court for fresh disposal. On remand the lower appellate court was directed to proceed after properly placing the onus upon the first defendant to rebut the prima facie proof of Ex. A-1's execution on 11 August 1960 and to consider the evidence already on record with arguments from the parties.

The court also ordered ancillary measures based on the state of the appeal: refund of the court fee paid on the memorandum of grounds of second appeal, no order as to costs in the second appeal, and a direction that the lower appellate court dispose of the remanded matter within three months.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The second appeal is allowed and the matter is remanded to the lower appellate court for fresh disposal after the lower appellate court properly casts the burden of proof on the first defendant to prove that Ex. A-1 was not executed by Kaliaperumal on 11 August 1960. The court ordered refund of the court fee paid on the memorandum of grounds of second appeal, made no order as to costs, and directed the lower appellate court to dispose of the matter within three months.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the judgment of the lower appellate court is set aside to the extent necessary to allow fresh consideration; the lower appellate court must now re-hear and decide the appeal correctly allocating the burden of proof and considering the evidence already on record.
  • Administrative directions: refund of the second appeal court fee to the appellant; no costs awarded in the second appeal; and an express three-month timetable for the lower appellate court to conclude the remand.
  • The opinion remands for proper application of existing precedent rather than purporting to establish a new legal principle; the decision addresses procedural error in the lower appellate court's approach under the framework of S.100, C.P.C.

    Nataraja Deekshidar v. Aiyathurai Padayachi

    1. Plaintiff is the appellant. The suit was for redemption of an usufructury mortgage dated 29th August 1959 executed by one Kaliaperumal Padayachi in favour of the first defendant, on the allegation that the first defendant has been in enjoyment of the suit property as usufructuary mortgagee and that on 14th July 1960 the plaintiff entered into an oral agreement with Kaliaperumal Padayachi for purchase of the suit property for Rs. 2,750. In accordance with the said agreement, Kaliaperumal Padayachi received Rs. 700 from the plaintiff in discharge of the bogiam deed executed by Kaliaperumal Padayachi's daughter Chinapillai, (4th defendant) in favour of one Pakkirisami Padayachi and for the discharge of a pronote debt due by Chinnapillai to the same Pakkirisami Padayachi. It was the further case of the plaintiff that Kaliaperumal Padayachi received on several occasions for his needs amount to the tune of Rs. 150. Later on, on 11th August 1970 Kaliaperumal executed the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 2,750, under which he directed the suit bogiam debt to be discharged by the plaintiff. In spite of repeated demands, the first defendant did not receive the bogiam amont and give discharge to the document. Hence, the plaintiff sent Rs. 600 by money order to the first defendant and informed the same also by notice dated 7th May 1964. The defendant evaded receipt of the same. Hence, the money order as well as the notice was returned to the sender. Since under the bogium deed the principal has to be paid after a period of three years in Chitrai Kalavathi, the plaintiff tendered the amount by money order on 7th May 1964. Kailaperumal Padayachi died pending suit. Defendants 2 to 5 were impleaded as parties to the suit as the first defendant contended that the suit as framed was bad without impleading Kaliaperumal Padayachi. On these pleadings, the plaintiff prayed for the above reliefs.

    2. It was the case of the first defendant that he obtained the sale of the suit property from Kaliaperumal on 24th September 1960 for Rs. 2,500 and by that the suit usufructuary mortgage was discharged. According to the first defendant, the sale in favour of the plaintiff was false and was learnt to be a forgery. It was contended that the plaintiff after coming to know the presentation of the sale deed by the first defendant for compulsory registration, created the sale deed on old stamp papers as if it had come into being on 11th August 1960. The agreement alleged to have been made on 14th July 1960 by Kaliaperumal with the plaintiff was also denied. The first defendant also denied the recitals of consideration made in the plaintiff's sale deed as false. After sending three notices for compulsory registration proceedings, the Sub Registrar refused registration on 19th December 1960, as the executant (Sic) Thereupon the first defendant filed appeal in A.P 28 of 1960 before the District Registrar, Chidambaram, and as per order dated 2nd March 1961, the sale deed was registered on 10th March 1961. With these contentions, the first defendant prayed for the dismissal of the suit.

    3. All the other defendants supported the claim of the first defendant. The trial court, by judgment dated 27th December 1967, decreed the suit against the first defendant for redemption with costs with a direction that the plaintiff will be entitled to mesne profits of the first defendant from the date of his notice of the deposit of the mortgage amount into court till delivery of possession of the suit property.

    4. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree of the trial court, the first defendant preferred an appeal to the Sub-Court, Chidambaram. The Sub Court reversed the judgment and decree of the trial court, and dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree of the lower appellate court, the plaintiff has preferred the above second appeal.

    5. Sri Parasaran, the learned Advocate General appearing for the appellant, took me through the judgment of the lower appellate court and stated that the lower appellate court has lightly interfered with the judgment and decree of the trial court and as such the decision of the lower appellate court has to be set aside. According to the Advocate General, there was absolutely no material or point made out for the lower appellate court to disagree with the considered judgment of the trial court. If that be so, the High Court has ample power to interfere in second appeal and restore the judgment and decree of the trial court. The learned Advocate General further submitted that the lower appellate court has wrongly cast the burden upon the plaintiff and as such there is error of law committed by the lower appellate court which requires interference by this court. It has also been argued that the lower appellate court has not discussed the evidence adduced by the first defendant in the case and as such the judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are vitiated, the precedure adopted by it being erroneous in law.

    6. Sri Habibullah Badsha, the learned counsel appearing for the first defendant submitted that the burden of proof has been rightly cast upon the plaintiff to prove the genuineness of Ex. A-1, sale deed in his favour, and that the lower appellate court, after elaborately discussing the evidence on record, has correctly come to the conclusion that the sale deed Ex. A-1, could not have come into existence prior to Ex. B.2

    7. The facts in this case are simple. Ex. A-1 is the registered sale deed executed by Kaliaperumal Padayachi in favour of the plaintiff Ex. A-1 is dated 11th August 1960. Ex. B-2 is a registered sale deed executed by Kaliaperumal Padayachi in favoer of the 1st defendant and the same is dated 24th September 1960. But these sale deeds are in respect of the very same property that belonged to Kaliaperumal Padayachi. Ex. A.1 was registered on 21st November 1960, though the execution was on 11th August 1960. Ex. B.2 was presented for compulsory registration on 16th November 1960, but the Sub Registrar refused to register the same since Kaliaperumal Padyachi was not present. Subsequently it was registered only on 10th March 1961. It is the case of the 1st defendant that subsequent to his presenting Ex. B-2 for compulsory registration on 16th November 1960, the plaintiff brought about Ex. A.1, on old stamp papers as if it was written on 11th August 1960 and got it registered on 21st November 1960. Thus, according to the first defendant, Ex. A.1, could not have come into existence prior to Ex. B.2 Hence the main question that was agitated upon before the courts below was as to whether Ex. A.1 which was dated 11th August 1960 and registered on 21st November 1960, was actually executed on 11th August 1960 or not.

    8. The lower appellate court has stated that in view of the nature of the pleadings of the case of the parties, it is no doubt true that the plaintiff who has come to court must establish that Ex. A-1 was executed by Kaliaperumal Padayachi on 11th August 1960. This wrong casting of burden on the plaintiff according to the learned Advocate General has vitiated the whole judgment of the lower appellate court and as such the judgment and decree of the trial court have to be restored. According to the learned Advocate General the registration of a document prima facie proves the genuineness of the same. Hence the burden is upon the first defendant to prove that the sale under Ex. A.1 was not genuine and that Ex. A.1 was not executed on the date which it bears

    9. To substantiate his contention, the learned Advocate General first cited Sarju Prasad v. Raja Jwaleswari Pratab Narain Singh . 1950 S.C.R 781, for the proposition that the first appellate court cannot lightly interfere with the finding of fact arrived at by the trial court and if such interference has been made, it is for the High Court to correct the same in second appeal. The principle laid down in the above decision is as follows—

    “When there is conflict of oral evidence of the parties on any matter in issue and the decision hinges upon the credibility of the witnesses, then unless there is some special features about the evidence of a particular witness, which has escaped the trial judge's notice or there is a sufficient balance of improbability to displace his opinion as to where the credibility lies; the appellate court should not interfere with the finding of the trial judge on a question of fact. It would not detract from the value to be attached to a trial Judge's finding of fact if the judge does not expressly base his conclusion upon the impressions he gathers from the demeanour of witnesses, the rule is, however, only a rule of practice and does not mean that the court of first instance can be treated as infallible in determining which side is telling the truth or is refraining from exaggeration.”

    10. After citing the above decision, the learned Advocate General accepted the proposition that no second appeal will lie except on the grounds specified in S. 100, C.P.C and that the second appellate court has no jurisdiction to entertain a second appeal on the ground of an erroneous finding of tact, however gross or inexcusable the error may seem to be. The said proposition has been succinctly stated, as rightly contended by Sri Habibullah Badsha, the learned counsel appearing for the first appellant, in Radha Prasad Singh v. Gajadhar Singh & Others . A.I.R 1963 S.C 115., Ramachandra v. Ramalinga . A.I.R 1963 S.C 302. and Chunilal Vithaldas v. Mohanlal . A.I.R 1967 S.C 226. But in Ramachandra Iyer v. Ramalinga Chettiar . 1963 S.C.R 605. 613. the Supreme Court has observed:

    “It is necessary to remember that S. 100(1)(case) refers to a subsiantial error or defect in the procedure. The defect or error must be substantial that is one fact to remember; and the substantial error or defect should be such as may possibly have produced error or defect in the decision of the case upon the merits — that is another fact to be borne in mind. The error or defect in the procedure to which the clause refers is, as the clause clearly and unambiguosly indicates, an error or defect connected with or relating to, the procedure; it is not an error or defect in the appreciation of evidence adduced by the parties on the merits. That is why even if the appreciation of evidence made by the lower appellate court is patently erroneous and the finding of fact recorded in consequence is grossly erroneous, that cannot be said to introduce a substantial error or defect in the procedure. On the other hand, if in dealing with a question of fact, the lower appellate court had placed the onus on a wrong party and its finding of fact is the result, substantially, of this wrong approach., that may be regarded as a defect in procedure; if in dealing with questions of fact, the tower appellate court discards evidence on the ground that it is inadmissible and the High Court is satisfied that the evidence was admissible, that may introduce an error or defect in procedure. If the lower appellate court fails to consider an issue which had been tried and found upon by the trial court and proceeded to revere the trial court's decision without the consideration of such an issue, that may be regarded as an error or defect in procedure; if the lower appellate court allows a new point of fact to be raised for the first time, before it, or permits a party to adopt a new plea of fact, of makes out a new case for a party, that may, in some cases, be said to amount to a defect or error in procedure”.

    In the same judgment, the Supreme Court has further observed:

    “But the High Court cannot interfere with the conclusions of fact recorded by the lower appellate court however erroneous the said conclusions may appear to be to the High Court, because, as the Privy Council observed, however gross or inexcusable the error may seem to be, there is no jurisdiction under S. 100 to correct error.

    11. According to the learned Advocate General, the lower appellate Court has definitely cast on the plaintiff the burden of proving that Ex. A.1 was executed by Kaliaperumal on 11th August 1960 while the document, Ex. A.1, as it stands is a prima facie proof of its execution as on the date it bears. It is for the person who wants to refute a registered sale to prove that the document was not executed on the date it bears. This approach of the lower appellate court, according to the learned Advocate General, amounts to a defect or error in procedure and as such the decision rendered by the lower appellate court is vitiated. It was also submitted by the learned Advocate General that the lower appellate court having doubted the execution of Exs. B.5, and B.6, is wrong in coming to the conclusion that Ex. A.1 was written subsequent to the execution of Ex. B.2

    12. According to the learned Advocate General, it is also clear from the judgment of the lower appellate court, that there is no proper discussion of the evidence let in by the first defendant and the same was due to the fact that it has committed an error in casting the burden of proof upon the plaintiff.

    13. I am of the view, that Ex. A.1, which is a registered document, proves that the same has been executed on list August 1960. It is for the first defendant to rebut this prima facie proof established by the plaintiff. It was, thus, necessary for the lower appellate court, to discuss the evidence on record casting the burden upon the first defendant to rebut the proof of the execution of Ex. A.1 on the date it bears. Following the decision in Ramachandra Iyer v. Ramalinga Chettiar. I am of the view that there is a substantial error in the procedure adopted by the lower appellate court in giving its decision with regard to the dispute between the parties. It is but fair that the matter is remanded to the file of the lower appellate court for the purpose of disposal after properly casting the burden on the first defendant to prove that Ex. A.1 was not executed by Kaliaperumal on 11th August 1960.

    14. In these circumstances, the second appeal is allowed. The matter is remanded to the file of the lower appellate court for disposal afresh bearing in mind the observations made by this court in the foregoing paragraphs. It is open to the parties to put forth their arguments before the lower appellate court, with the evidence already on record. The court fee paid on the memorndum of grounds of second appeal will be refunded to the appellant. There will be no order as to costs in second appeal. No leave. The lower appellate court is directed to dispose of the matter on remand within three months from today.

    VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nataraja Deekshidar v. Aiyathurai Padayachi
    (Oct 29, 1976)