Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 17 of the Registration Act.
  • Registration Act or the provisions of s. 17
  • s. 17 of the Registration Act:
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 17 of the Registration Act.
  • Registration Act or the provisions of s. 17
  • s. 17 of the Registration Act:
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit filed by plaintiffs (respondents Nos. 1, 2, and 3) seeking possession of survey No. 92 of mouza Kopadi. The undisputed facts are that Ramji, the grandfather of plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2 and husband of plaintiff No. 3, owned the suit property and died in 1941, survived by his widow Bainabai (plaintiff No. 3) and two sons, Deorao and Bhaurao (defendants Nos. 2 and 3). A partition of the joint family estate occurred on December 31, 1951, dividing properties between Deorao and Bhaurao, with the suit field allotted to Bhaurao. Bhaurao sold the suit field to defendant No. 1 (appellant) on January 5, 1952. Subsequently, on March 26, 1952, there was a partition between Deorao and his two sons (plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2), with Bainabai acting as guardian for her minor grandsons. The plaintiffs filed the suit in 1956 claiming (1) the 1951 partition was not binding on them as no share was allotted to Bainabai, (2) the sale by Bhaurao to defendant No. 1 was invalid, and (3) sought possession of the property.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the partition dated December 31, 1951, between Deorao and Bhaurao was binding on the plaintiffs and Bainabai, particularly considering that no share was allotted to Bainabai.
  2. Whether Bainabai had validly relinquished her interest in the joint family properties orally or if such relinquishment required a registered deed.
  3. Whether the sale of the suit field by Bhaurao to defendant No. 1 was valid and binding on the plaintiffs.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant No. 1's Arguments

  • The partition on December 31, 1951, between Deorao and Bhaurao was valid.
  • Bainabai had orally relinquished her interest in the joint family properties in favor of her two sons after Ramji's death, which justified no share being allotted to her in the partition.
  • The sale of the suit field by Bhaurao to defendant No. 1 was valid and binding on the plaintiffs.

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The partition dated December 31, 1951, was not binding as Bainabai was entitled to a share which was not allotted.
  • The alienation of the suit field by Bhaurao was invalid and not binding on the plaintiffs.
  • They sought possession of the suit field based on these contentions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dattatraya Govind v. Narayan Gangaram [1936] A.I.R Nag. 186 Title once vested can be divested only by a recognized conveyance or means allowed by law; disclaimer or relinquishment requires a deed when law demands it. The Court interpreted this precedent to clarify that relinquishment is valid only if law requires a deed; it does not prohibit oral relinquishment per se.
Imperial Bank of India v. Bengal National Bank, Limited 1930 I.L.R 58 Cal. 136 Partition, release and surrender are forms of transfer and under the Transfer of Property Act, may be effected orally without restrictions. The Court relied on this to hold that oral relinquishment of a right to immoveable property is valid and does not require a written instrument.
Gauri Bai v. Gaya Bai [1927] A.I.R Nag. 44 Relinquishment or abandonment of interest in joint family property can be effected without a written instrument, though if executed, registration is required. The Court applied this precedent to support the validity of Bainabai’s oral relinquishment of interest in the joint family properties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed whether Bainabai’s oral relinquishment of her interest in the joint family properties was legally valid. It noted that the Transfer of Property Act generally allows oral transfers unless a writing or registration is expressly required. The Court examined statutory provisions (Sections 9, 54, 59, 107, 118, 123, 130 of the Transfer of Property Act) and found that while certain transfers of immoveable property require a registered instrument, mere relinquishment or abandonment of interest does not necessarily fall under these requirements.

The Court distinguished the precedent in Dattatraya Govind by clarifying that it does not prohibit oral relinquishment unless a statute mandates a deed. It also relied on Imperial Bank of India to affirm that partition, release, and surrender can be oral transfers without restrictions under the Transfer of Property Act. The Court further held that the Registration Act’s Section 17 does not require every transaction to be in writing, only that written transactions be registered.

Consequently, the Court concluded that Bainabai’s oral relinquishment of her interest was valid and effective, and she ceased to have any interest in the joint family properties from that time. Therefore, the partition between the brothers was valid and binding, and the sale by Bhaurao to defendant No. 1 was also valid.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The Court set aside the decree of the Additional District Judge that had declared Bainabai entitled to a one-third share in the suit field and entitled to recover possession from defendant No. 1. The suit is dismissed with costs.

Implications: The direct effect of this decision is that Bainabai’s oral relinquishment of her interest in joint family immoveable property is recognized as valid, affirming the validity of the partition between the brothers and the subsequent sale. No new legal precedent beyond the facts of this case is established, but it clarifies the application of existing law regarding oral relinquishment of interest in joint family property.

    Ramdas Chimna v. Pralhad Deorao

    Kantawala, J.:— This appeal arises from the suit filed by the plaintiffs, who are respondents Nos. 1, 2 and 3 before me, for possession of survey No. 92 of mouza Kopadi. The following facts are no more in dispute. One Ramji, the grandfather of plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2 and the husband of plaintiff No. 3, was at the relevant time the owner of this survey number. He died in the year 1941 leaving him surviving his widow Bainabai, plaintiff No. 3, and two sons Deorao and Bhaurao, who are defendants Nos. 2 and 3 respectively, in the suit. Plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2, Pralhad and Dnyaneshwar, are the sons of Deorao. There was a partition of the joint family estate on December 31, 1951, whereunder the joint family properties were partitioned between Deorao and Bhaurao. As a result of this partition, the suit field along with other properties came to the share of Bhaurao. On January 5, 1952, Bhaurao sold away the suit field to defendant No. 1, who is the appellant before me, for the sum of Rs. 2,500. Subsequent to this sale-deed, on March 26, 1952, there was a partition between Deorao, defendant No. 2, and his two sons, Pralhad and Dnyaneshwar, plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2, whereunder the properties, which came to the share of Deorao under the partition dated December 31, 1951, were divided by metes and bounds between Deorao and his two sons. In this partition, as plaintiffs Nos. 1 and 2 were then minors, Bainabai acted as their guardian. The present suit was filed in the year 1956 by the two sons of Deorao and Bainabai, the mother of Deorao. The reliefs asked for in the suit are that the partition dated December 31, 1951, between Deorao and Bhaurao is not binding on the plaintiffs, as under the said partition no share was allotted to the mother Bainabai, Secondly, the alienation made by Bhaurao of the suit field in favour of defendant No. 1 was not valid and binding on the plaintiffs, and lastly there was a prayer for possession.

    2. The case of defendant No. 1 was that the partition effected on December 31, 1951, between Deorao and Bhaurao was a valid partition. In fact, Bainabai plaintiff No. 3, had orally relinquished her interest in the joint family properties in favour of her two sons, Deorao and Bhaurao, after the death of Ramji, and that is why no share was allotted to Bainabai when the joint family properties were divided between the two sons, defendants Nos. 2 and 3, and the sale effected by Bhaurao in favour of defendant No. 1 was binding on the plaintiffs. The trial Court accepted the contentions of defendant No. 1 and dismissed the plaintiffs' suit. It held that after the death of Ramji, Bainabai had orally relinquished her interest in the joint family properties and the partition effected between defendants Nos. 2 and 3 on December 31, 1951, was valid and binding.

    3. The plaintiffs came in appeal from this decision of the trial Court dismissing the suit. The appellate Court has modified the decree that has been passed by the learned trial Judge. It held that the partition dated December 31, 1951, was a valid partition. However, it took the view that it was not established that Bainabai had orally relinquished her interest in the joint family properties after the death of Ramji and that was the reason why no share was allotted to her when the joint family properties were partitioned between, the two brothers Deorao and Bhaurao. It further held that relinquishment of interest in the joint family properties, which consist of immoveable properties, can only be made by a registered deed if the interest to be relinquished is worth more than Rs. 100. Such relinquishment cannot be made orally and, as in the present case, there was no registered deed, Bainabai had not legally relinquished her interest in the joint family properties to which she was entitled. The appellate Court, therefore, modified the decree in view of the said finding as stated above. It is from this decision of the learned Additional District Judge that defendant No. 1 has come in appeal to this Court.

    4. Mr. Gandhe, the learned counsel who appears on behalf of the appellant, has contended before me that there is a patent error in the decision arrived at by the learned Additional District Judge, that he has come to the conclusion that Bainabai did not relinquish her interest in the joint family properties without appreciating the proper provision of law and the admitted facts on record, and secondly the learned Additional District Judge was in error in proceeding on the assumption that there can be no oral relinquishment. In my opinion, each one of these contentions must be upheld…

    5. The question then arises whether it is open to the mother to relinquish her interest in the joint family properties orally when the joint family properties consist of immoveable properties like the suit fields and the value of her share therein is more than Rs. 100. Mr. Deshpande drew my attention to the case reported in Dattatraya Govind v. Narayan Gangaram . [1936] A.I.R Nag. 186., It was held by Vivian Bose J. in that case that

    “Except in the case of partition among the members of a joint Hindu family, where the unities of possession, interest, title and time are complete and except in the case of entrance to a religious order involving complete renunciation of the world, no person can divest himself of interests which have once vested in him by a mere disclaimer. A title once vested can be divested only by a recognized conveyance or one of the other means allowed by law. It cannot pass by admission, relinquishment, or disclaimer when the law requires a deed.”

    6. This case does not lay down that relinquishment cannot be made orally. All that it says is that the title once vested can be divested only by a recognized conveyance or by one of the other means allowed by law. It further says that the title once vested cannot pass by relinquishment when the law requires a deed. What has to be seen is whether the law requires that relinquishment can only be made by a deed or by an instrument. The Transfer of Property Act clearly recognizes oral transfers. Section 9 of the Act provides that “a transfer of property may be made without writing in every case in which a writing is not expressly required by law.” It follows, therefore, that an oral transfer of property is the rule unless there is a law which expressly requires that it should be made in writing. The Transfer of Property Act makes writing necessary in case of various transfers. Under s. 54, a sale of tangible immoveable property of the value of Rs. 100 or upwards, or of a reversion or other intangible thing is required to be made only by a registered instrument. Under s. 59, a writing is necessary in the case of a simple mortgage or in the case of all other mortgages except a mortgage by deposit of title-deeds where the principal sum secured is Rs. 100 or upwards. Under s. 107, a lease of immoveable property from year to year, or for any term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent, is required to be made in writing. Under s. 123, a gift of immoveable property can only be made by a writing. Under s. 130, all transfers of actionable claims have to be made by writing and, under s. 118, all exchanges are subject to the same rules as are applicable to sales. Thus, when the law requires that there should be an instrument in writing and that instrument must be registered, the transfer can only be effected in that manner. But where no writing is required by the Transfer of Property Act or any other law, the transfer may be made orally. Mr. Deshpande is unable to point out any statute which requires that the relinquishment by the mother of her interest in the joint family property, when the property consists of immoveable property and the value of the share therein exceeds Rs. 100, can only be made in writing or by an instrument registered.

    7. In Imperial Bank of India v. Bengal National Bank, Limited . 1930 I.L.R 58 Cal. 136., Rankin, C.J said that partition, release and surrender are all forms of transfer but that so far as the Transfer of Property Act is concerned, they come under no restrictions. A right to recover a share of immoveable property may be relinquished orally and without an instrument in writing.

    8. Mr. Deshpande, however, drew my attention to the provisions of s. 17 of the Registration Act. There is nothing in the Registration Act or the provisions of s. 17 thereof, which requires any particular transaction to be recorded in writing. That Act requires only that when certain transactions are so recorded, the writing shall be registered. There is nothing in the Transfer of Property Act or any other law that I am so far aware which requires that a mere extinguishment of an interest in the immoveable property shall be in writing. The relinquishment by Bainabai of her interest in the joint family property was merely abandonment of her interest in the joint family property in favour of her two sons. Such a relinquishment or abandonment of interest in the joint family property, even though it consists of immoveable properties and is of the value of Rs. 100 and upwards, can be effected without a written instrument, though if one is executed, it would undoubtedly require registration under s. 17 of the Registration Act: Gauri Bai v. Gaya Bai . [1927] A.I.R Nag. 44..

    9. Thus, the oral relinquishment by Bainabai of her interest in the joint family properties in favour of her two sons after the death of Ramji was valid and effective in law. Since the time of that relinquishment she ceased to have any interest in the joint family properties. The learned Additional District Judge was in error in taking the view that an oral relinquishment, even if proved, would not divest Bainabai of her interest in the joint family properties.

    10. In the result, the partition, dated December 31, 1951, between Deorao and Bhaurao was a valid and effective partition whereunder each one of the two brothers became entitled to the properties that were respectively allotted to them. It is not in dispute that the suit field was allotted to Bhaurao under the said partition and Bhaurao has sold it to the present defendant No. 1 in, the year 1952. In the result Bainabai is not entitled to any interest in the suit field. The appeal is allowed. The decree passed by the learned Additional District Judge declaring that Bainabai had ⅓rd share in the suit field and that she was entitled to recover possession of that share from defendant No. 1 is set aside and the suit is dismissed with costs throughout.

    11. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramdas Chimna v. Pralhad Deorao
    (Mar 13, 1964)