Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 20 ANDHRA PRADESH BUILDINGS LEASE RENT AND EVICTION CONTROL ACT 1960
  • Act 19 of 1972. Likewise, in the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act,
  • Section 87 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act,
  • Secs. 4 and 5 of the A.P (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act.
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act, 1330
  • Section 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act
  • sec. 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act
  • S. 6(c) of the Essential Commodities Act
  • A.P Civil Courts Act (Act, 19 of 1972)
  • Area) Small Causes Courts Act
  • Area) Civil Courts Act, 1954
  • Rent Control Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 20 ANDHRA PRADESH BUILDINGS LEASE RENT AND EVICTION CONTROL ACT 1960
  • Act 19 of 1972. Likewise, in the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act,
  • Section 87 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act,
  • Secs. 4 and 5 of the A.P (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act.
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act, 1330
  • Section 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act
  • sec. 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act
  • S. 6(c) of the Essential Commodities Act
  • A.P Civil Courts Act (Act, 19 of 1972)
  • Area) Small Causes Courts Act
  • Area) Civil Courts Act, 1954
  • Rent Control Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Jayachandra Reddy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arose from eviction proceedings under the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960 ("the Act"). In one described factual pattern, an eviction petition filed before the Rent Controller under Section 10 of the Act was dismissed; the landlord appealed under Section 20 to the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, Hyderabad. The Chief Judge transferred a batch of such appeals to the Additional Chief Judge exercising administrative power. The validity of those transfer orders was challenged by way of Civil Revision Petitions.

Separately, the High Court, by proceeding ROC No. 843.E1/86 dated 12-3-1986, exercising administrative power, transferred 185 rent appeals to the Additional Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court. The validity of that order was challenged by writ petitions (Writs of Mandamus) seeking declaration that the High Court's order was illegal.

The matters were referred to a Bench because the question raised was of general importance: whether the "appellate authority" named in Section 20 of the Act is intended to act as a persona designata or as a Court, and whether the High Court under Article 227 can transfer appeals from the file of that appellate authority to another Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the "appellate authority" named in Section 20 of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960 — described as the "Chief Judge, Small Causes Court" — is intended to act as a persona designata (i.e., an individual singled out) or to act as a Court (i.e., in the capacity of the office he holds).
  2. Whether the High Court, exercising its power under Article 227 of the Constitution, can transfer appeals from the Court of the "appellate authority" (the Chief Judge) to another Court (for example, to an Additional Chief Judge).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Under Section 20 of the Act the "appellate authority" is the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, who is contended to be a persona designata; hence only he alone is competent to hear the appeals provided by Section 20.
  • By reason of that persona designata contention, the Additional Chief Judge (to whom appeals were administratively transferred) has no jurisdiction to hear those appeals.
  • Consequently, the High Court, exercising power under Article 227, cannot transfer the appeals from the Chief Judge to the Additional Chief Judge, because the Additional Chief Judge would lack jurisdiction for the same persona designata reason.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of counter-arguments made by the respondents in the text of the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Abdul Wahid Sahib v. Dewanjee Abdul Khader Sahib, AIR 1947 Mad 400 Earlier Madras decisions held that the "appellate authority" under a Rent Control Act acted as a persona designata. The Court noted these cases reached the view that the appellate authority acted as persona designata but observed that those decisions did not deeply examine the scope and extent of the appellate authority vis-à-vis the Chief Judge of the Small Causes Court; thus they were not treated as dispositive for the present context.
Chinnaiah Thevar v. F.N. Badsha, AIR 1948 Mad 439 Also decided that the appellate authority under the Rent Control enactment acted as a persona designata. Referenced as part of a cluster of earlier decisions reaching the persona designata conclusion; the Court distinguished these on the basis that they lacked extended discussion of the interplay with Small Causes Court structures.
S. Rajam Ayyar v. Pavanambal, AIR 1949 Mad 787 Another Madras decision treating the appellate authority under rent law as persona designata. Noted among earlier authorities that found persona designata; again the Court observed limits to their applicability to the present statutory structure.
Bathula Krishnabrahmam & Ors. v. Daram Chenchireddy & Ors., AIR 1959 Andh Pra 129 Section 87 (Hindu Religious & Charitable Endowments Act) context: presiding officer (Magistrate) is not to be treated as acting as persona designata but as a Court. The Division Bench's conclusion that the presiding Officer was not a persona designata was cited to show judicial precedent favoring office-capacity treatment, and to show inconsistency across authorities.
Public Prosecutor v. Lacisetty Ramayya, (1975) 1 Andh WR 133 (Full Bench) Full Bench analysis of whether the appellate authority (District and Sessions Judge under S.6(c) of the Essential Commodities Act) acts as persona designata or as a Court; emphasized that intention depends on nature of the act and surrounding circumstances. The Court relied on the Full Bench's ratio as directly applicable: identifying authority (persona designata or court) depends on the nature of the functions and context; applied that principle to hold that the Chief Judge under S.20 is not persona designata and can assign appeals to Additional Judges.
Chatur Mohan v. Ram Behari, AIR 1964 All 562 (Full Bench) Observation that the distinction between “a Munsif” and “a Court of Munsif” is not absolute; being named by office does not necessarily make the officer a persona designata. Quoted to support the proposition that references to an office-holder in a statute do not automatically import persona designata status; used to reinforce a functional inquiry into legislative intent.
Ramachandra Rao v. State of Madras, AIR 1962 Andh Pra 58 (referring to Satyanarayan Laxminarayan v. Mallikarajun Bhavanappa, AIR 1960 SC 137) Explains "persona designata" as a person pointed out by name or personal description, contrasted with identity by office; intention to single out depends on words used, nature of functions and object of the statute. The Court reproduced the quoted principle to show that a judicial officer intended to act in a judicial capacity ordinarily should not be treated as persona designata; used to support holding that the statutory reference is to the office/court rather than an individual in a personal capacity.
Central Talkies Ltd., Kanpur v. Dwarka Prasad, AIR 1961 SC 606 Accepted the dictionary definition of persona designata (from OSBORN) as a person pointed out by name or personal description contrasted with an office-holder. Used to bolster the definitional foundation for the Court's analysis of whether the Chief Judge is persona designata; reinforced the statutory-context inquiry.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise, text-focused manner:

  1. Statutory reading: The Court began with a plain reading of Section 20 of the Act, which prescribes appeals from orders of the Rent Controller to the "Chief Judge, Small Causes Court" in Hyderabad and Secunderabad, and to Principal/Subordinate Judges elsewhere.
  2. Statutory context — Small Causes Courts Act: The Court examined the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act (secs. 3, 4 and 5). Those provisions define a "Court of Small Causes", permit appointment of Judges and Additional Judges, and provide that an Additional Judge discharges functions assigned by the Judge and exercises the same powers in discharge of those functions; the Judge may transfer cases from an Additional Judge to himself and, when the Judge is absent, an Additional Judge may exercise all powers of the Judge (subject to pecuniary limits).
  3. Terminology and identification: The Court observed that the expression "Chief Judge" does not literally appear in the Small Causes Act; the Act uses "Judge" and "Additional Judge". The Court explained that the label "Chief Judge" is used for convenience/description and that "Judge" in the Small Causes Act corresponds to what Section 20 describes as "Chief Judge".
  4. Meaning of "persona designata": The Court reviewed lexical definitions (Ramanatha Aiyar; OSBORN) and numerous judicial decisions to explain that whether an officer is a persona designata depends on context, the nature of the functions to be performed, the words used, and the surrounding circumstances.
  5. Precedential analysis: The Court surveyed prior decisions — some reaching persona designata conclusions in rent-control contexts, others reaching the opposite conclusion in different statutory settings (including Full Bench Andhra Pradesh and other High Courts). Importantly, the Full Bench in Public Prosecutor v. Lacisetty Ramayya was relied upon for the principle that one must look at the nature of the act and surrounding circumstances to determine whether an officer is meant to act in personal capacity or as the Court.
  6. Application to Section 20: Applying the above, the Court concluded that the reference in Section 20 to the "Chief Judge, Small Causes Court" is an identification of the office/court (the Judge of the Small Causes Court) and not a singling out of an individual as persona designata. Consequently, under Section 5 of the Small Causes Act, the Judge (Chief Judge) may assign or transfer appeals to Additional Chief Judges (Additional Judges of the same grade) for disposal.
  7. Power of the High Court: Because the appellate authority is not persona designata, the High Court, exercising its Article 227 powers, can transfer appeals from the Chief Judge's file to the Additional Chief Judge(s). Thus, the High Court's administrative transfer (ROC No. 843.E1/86 dated 12-3-1986) of 185 rent appeals was valid.
  8. Mufussil/principal-subordinate-judge area: The Court extended the same reasoning to the "mufussil" (non-city) context: the Principal Subordinate Judge under Section 20 likewise is not a persona designata and may assign appeals to Additional Subordinate Judges.
  9. Ancillary observation: The Court noted the persistent use, in practice, of labels like "Chief Judge" and "Addl. Chief Judge" though the statutory language uses "Judge" and "Additional Judge", and suggested it would be desirable to amend the Small Causes Act to avoid such complications.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Petitions dismissed.

The Court explicitly held:

  • The "appellate authority" under Section 20 of the Act (described there as the "Chief Judge, Small Causes Court") is not intended to act as a persona designata; the reference is to the Judge of the Small Causes Court in his official/court capacity.
  • Under Section 5 of the Small Causes Courts Act the Judge (Chief Judge) may assign or transfer appeals to Additional Judges (Additional Chief Judges) who can dispose of them.
  • The High Court, exercising its powers under Article 227 of the Constitution, can transfer appeals from the file of the Chief Judge to the Additional Chief Judge for disposal. Accordingly, the High Court's transfer proceedings (ROC No. 843.E1/86 dated 12-3-1986) are valid.
  • The same principle applies to the non-city (mufussil) context: the Principal Subordinate Judge is not persona designata and may assign appeals to Additional Subordinate Judges.

Direct consequences for the parties and procedure:

  • The writ petitions challenging the High Court's transfer order were dismissed.
  • The Civil Revision Petitions that questioned the Chief Judge's administrative transfers must be heard on their merits and were ordered to be posted before the regular court hearing civil revision petitions for disposal on merits.
  • No costs were awarded.
  • The Court suggested that an amendment to the Small Causes Courts Act to clarify usage (e.g., "Judge"/"First Judge" terminology) would be desirable to avoid such disputes in future.

The opinion primarily adjudicated the procedural and jurisdictional questions described above; it did not purport to lay down novel broader legal doctrines beyond applying established principles about persona designata versus office capacity and the consequences for administrative transfers.

Petitions dismissed.

    S. Srinivas Rao v. High Court Of A.P And Other

    Jayachandra Reddy, J.:— A question of general importance, viz. whether “appellate authority” named in S. 20 of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960 (Act No. XV of 1960) (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) is intended to act as a persona designata or as a Court and whether the High Court exercising its power under Art. 227 of the Constitution of India, can transfer the appeals from the Court of the “appellate authority” to any other Court, has arisen in these cases.

    2. The facts that give rise to these questions may be stated.

    3. In most of these cases the petitioners are either tenants or landlords. An eviction petition was filed in the Court of the Rent Controller under Sec. 10 of the Act, in one case and it was dismissed and the landlord filed an appeal in the Court of the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, Hyderabad, under S. 20 of the Act. The Chief Judge, however, transferred the batch of such appeals to the Court of the Addl. Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, exercising his administrative power. The validity of the said order is questioned in these Civil Revision Petitions. The High Court by its proceedings ROC No. 843.E1/86 dated 12-3-1986 exercising its administrative power transferred 185 Rent Appeals to the Court of the Addl. Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court. The validity of this order also is questioned by way of Writs of Mandamus to declare that the order passed by the High Court is illegal.

    When the matters came up before our learned brother Syed Shah Mohd. Quadri, J. he felt that the question is of general importance and should be decided by a Bench. Thus these matters came up before us.

    4. The main contention in all these matters is that under S. 20 of the Act, the appellate authority, the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court is the persona designata, that he alone is competent to hear these appeals and that the Additional Chief Judge, to whom the appeals are transferred has no jurisdiction to hear these appeals. Similarly the other contention is that the High Court exercising its powers under Art. 227 of the Constitution, cannot transfer these matters from the file of the Chief Judge, to the file of the Addl. Chief Judge, since the Addl. Chief Judge cannot hear such appeals for the same reason, viz., that it is the Chief Judge who, as the persona designata, can alone hear the appeals.

    5. We shall now refer to Sec. 20 of the Act which is in the following terms:

    “Sec. 20:— Appeal — (1) Any person aggrieved by an order passed by the Controller may, within thirty days from the date of such order, prefer an appeal in writing to the Chief Judge, Small Causes Court in the Cities of Hyderabad and Secunderabad and elsewhere to the Subordinate Judge, or if there are more than one Subordinate Judge to the Prl. Subordinate Judge having original jurisdiction over the area aforesaid.”

    6. A plain reading of the section makes it clear that as against the order of the Rent Controller an appeal is provided, in the cities of Hyderabad and Secunderabad, to the Chief Judge, Small Causes Court and elsewhere to the Subordinate Judge, or if there are more than one Subordinate Judge, to the Principal Subordinate Judge having original jurisdiction over the area. Though in Sec. 20 the expression “Chief Judge, Small Causes Court” is used, we do not find any such designation in the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act, 1330 Fasli. In the said Act, Sec. 3 defines the “Court of Small Causes “as to mean “a court established under this Act” and Sec. 4 deals with the establishment and composition of Court of Small Causes, and lays down that the Government may establish a Court of Small Causes at any place in the area to which this Act extends and define the local limits of its jurisdiction and appoint Judge or the Court of Small Causes and if necessary, appoint Additional Judge or Judges. Section 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act reads thus:—

    “4. Establishment and Composition of Court of Small Causes:— The Government may—

    (1) establish a Court of Small Causes at any place in the area to which this Act extends and define the local limits of its jurisdiction;

    (2) appoint a Judge for the Court of Small Causes and if necessary, appoint Additional Judge or Judges;

    (3) appoint the place or places at which the Court of such Judge or Additional Judge or Judges shall be held;

    Provided that no person shall be appointed as Judge unless he is in the opinion of Government qualified for appointment as a District Judge and no person shall be appointed as an Addl. Judge unless he is in the opinion of Government qualified either to be appointed as an Additional District Judge or as a Subordinate Judge.

    (4) When a person is appointed as an Additional Judge on the ground that in the opinion of Government, he is qualified for appointment as a District Judge, his pecuniary jurisdiction shall be the same as that of a Judge, Small Causes Court, and where a person is appointed as an Additional Judge on the ground that he is qualified for appointment as a Subordinate Judge, his pecuniary jurisdiction shall extend to Rs. 1000/- and in either case at the time of his appointment or as soon as possible thereafter, the extent of pecuniary jurisdiction of the Additional Judge concerned shall be notified in the Official Gazette.”

    (Emphasis supplied).

    7. Section 5 deals with the powers of Judge and Additional Judge and it reads as follows:—

    “5. Powers of Judge and Additional Judge:—

    (1) An Additional Judge of a Court of Small Causes shall discharge such functions as may be assigned to him by the Judge of that Court and in the discharge of those functions, shall exercise the same powers as the Judge.

    (2) The Judge of a Court of Small Causes may transfer to himself any case or proceedings pending before an Additional Judge.

    (3) When the Judge is absent an Additional Judge may exercise all the powers of the Judge.

    (4) Nothing contained in this Section shall be deemed to authorise an Additional Judge to exercise powers in excess of his pecuniary jurisdiction.”

    8. Before we proceed further, we want to make it clear at this stage that we are not, for the purpose of this case, concerned with “Additional Judge” who is of the rank of a Subordinate Judge, because under sec. 20 the Appellate authority is the Chief Judge in the City. We are concerned only with Addl. Judges who are of the rank of the District Judge. However, it can be seen that the words “Chief Judge” as such are not used in these sections. But we can take it that under sec. 4 of the A.P (T.A) Small Causes Courts Act “the Judge” appointed may for convenience sake has been called Chief Judge as distinguished from Additional Judges of the same grade or other Additional Judge. As per the language of Sec. 20 of the Act we take it that the Chief Judge, Small Causes Court is the “appellate authority”.

    9. The next important question is, whether he is intended to act as a persona designata. The meaning to be given to the word “persona designata” depends upon the context in which the expression is used. In Ramanatha Aiyar's Law Lexicon the meaning of “Persona Designata” is given as follows:—

    “Persona Designata:

    Where a person is indicated in a statute or legal instrument not by name, but either by an official designation or as one of a class, a question sometimes arises whether he ceases to be the person so indicated on losing his official designation or his character as one of the class, or whether the intention was to single him out as a persona designata, that is, as an individual, the designation being merely a further description of him. Designatio personae then, in general, means simply the singling out by description of a party to a deed or contract: or a person taking thereunder such party or person being in turn called persona designata. (Ency. of the Laws of England). When difficulty is found in ascertaining whether a person takes as persona designata, the maxim “Designatio unius est exclusio alterius et expressum facit cessare tecitum” is applicable; in other words, if one person is specified, another is excluded on the principle that what is expressed makes what is only understood to give way.”

    10. According to OSBORN Concise Law Dictionary, “persona designata” means, a person pointed out or described as an individual, as opposed to a person ascertained as a member of a class, or as filling a particular character.”

    11. In several enactments while conferring powers on “appellate authority” the Legislature makes its intention clear implying whether the authority is intended to act as the “persona designata” or not.

    12. In the decisions reported in M. Abdul Wahid Sahib v. Dewanjee Abdul Khader Sahib (1947) 1 Mad LJ 207 : (AIR 1947 Mad 400), Chinnaiah Thevar v. F.N Badsha, (1948) 1 Mad LJ 314 : (AIR 1948 Mad 439) and S. Rajam Ayyar v. Pavanambal (1949) 1 Mad LJ 419 : (AIR 1949 Mad 787) a question directly arose whether the “appellate authority” under the Rent Control Act acts as a “persona designata” and the courts decided that he acts only as “persona designata”. But these are all cases where there is no much of discussion about the scope and extent of the power to be exercised by the “appellate authority” vis a vis, as the Chief Judge of the Small Causes Court. In this context it is necessary to bear in mind that it is the Chief Judge, Small Causes Court that can hear the appeals. If there are more than one such Judge, then the other Judges of the same grade are called as the Addl. Chief Judges. Is it necessary, therefore, to restrict the scope of the meaning of the “appellate authority” used in Sec. 20 of the Act to such an extent as to mean that the Addl. Chief Judge of a Small Causes Court who has the powers of a Chief Judge of the Small Causes Court, cannot hear an appeal even though the same is transferred as per the Rules and procedure? In our view it is not necessary to lay such embargo.

    13. We shall now proceed to consider some of the decisions which throw some light in understanding the context in which the Legislature has prescribed such authorities.

    14. In Bathula Krishnabrahmam & Others… v. Daram Chenchireddy & Others…, (1959) 1 Andh WR 265 : (AIR 1959 Andh Pra 129) a Division Bench of this Court while examining a case which arose under Section 87 of the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, reviewed the earlier authorities and having regard to the context in which the Magistrate is empowered to act under Sec. 87 of the Act concluded that the Presiding Officer viz, the Magistrate was selected to act in a particular matter in his private or individual capacity does not act as a “persona designata” and there is no warrant for treating the Magistrate performing the functions allotted to him by S. 87 as one acting as the “persona designata” and not as a court. The Division Bench also examined some earlier decisions and their Lordships however, observed that the judicial precedents are not uniform.

    15. The next important decision is that of a Full Bench reported in The Public Prosecutor v. Lacisetty Ramayya (1975) 1 Andh WR 133. There the scope of S. 6(c) of the Essential Commodities Act came up for consideration under which provision confiscation proceedings could be taken and he “appellate authority” mentioned in S. 6(c) is the District and Sessions Judge and he has to deal with those appeals filed under Sec. 6(c) in the Sessions Court. A question arose, whether he acts as a “persona designata” and not as a Court. The Full Bench reviewed almost all the cases decided by several High Courts including our own High Court. In the evidence Act, the Court is defined as including all Judges and Magistrates and all persons except arbitrators, legally authorised to take evidence. The words “Court” and “judge” are many times used as interchangeable terms. In Chatur Mohan v. Ram Behari, AIR 1964 All 562 (FB) the Allahabad High Court observed (at p. 564)—

    “I am not enamoured of the distinction made between ‘a Munsif’ and ‘A Court of Munsif’ and of the argument based upon it to the effect that ‘a Munsif’ acts as a persona designata whereas ‘a Court of Munsif's acts as a Court constituted under the Act. ‘A Court of Munsif’ it certainly means a Court and not a persona designata but the converse is not always true.”

    16. At this stage we may refer to the ratio laid down by the Full Bench in identifying the “authority” viz. who acts as a persona designata or as a court. The Full Bench observed—

    “When a reference is made to the presiding Officer of a Court whether it meant to refer to the Court or to him personally and refer to the fact of his presiding over a Court simply to describe or identify him depends upon the intention to be gathered from the nature of the act he has to perform and other I surrounding circumstances.

    Therefore, from the mere fact that in the notification of the Government for the appointment of the appellate authority the expression “the District and Sessions Judge of each district” is used instead of the Court over which such officer presides, it does not necessarily follow that the District and Sessions Judge is mentioned as persona designata and not in his capacity of presiding over the District and Sessions Courts.”

    17. In the instant case much stress has been laid on the words “Chief Judge”, “Small Causes Court” in support of the argument that he acts only as a “persona designata”. We have already noted that the words “Chief Judge” do not find place in the A.P (Telangana) Small Causes Courts Act. Section 4 of the said Act makes it clear. It is only for convenience sake and for facilitating procedural aspects the word is used. There is no such designation as “Chief Judge” in the Small Causes Courts Act. Therefore, just as we find a District and Sessions Judge and Addl. District Judges in a District, as already noted, S. 5 confers power on the Judges and Addl. Judges of Small Causes Court. But, what all S. 5 lays down is that an Additional Judge of a Court of Small Causes shall discharge such functions as may be assigned to him by the Judge of that Court. In this context, the expression “Judge” means the “Chief Judge”. It is only in that context the expression “Chief Judge” is used in S. 20 of the Act. Therefore, it cannot be said that the “appellate authority” under S. 20 of the Act. viz. the Chief Judge is referred, as to mean that he should act as a “persona designata”. In other words, when a reference is made in S. 20 of the Act to the “appellate authority” as the “Chief Judge” it only means the Judge of the Small Causes Court and is not mentioned as “persona designata.” We may once again mention that the expression “Chief Judge” in Sec. 20 of the Act is only to describe or identify and this becomes clear when we examine Sec. 20 of the Act in the light of Secs. 4 and 5 of the A.P (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act. Therefore, under S. 5 the Judge who could otherwise also be called the Chief Judge of the Small Causes Court can assign or transfer the appeals on his file to the Addl. Chief Judges for disposal. Sec. 20 of the Act even if interpreted strictly can only mean that all those appeals have to be filed before the Chief Judge i.e, the judge of the Small Causes Court and the Chief Judge can exercise powers under Sec. 5 and transfer them to the Addl. Chief Judges, of the Small Causes Courts, who for identity and distinction sake are being called as the “Addl. Chief Judges.”

    18. In this contex it is also useful to note that the words “Court” and “judge” are frequently used in the statutes as synonymous and in the instant case we have no hesitation in holding that the appellate authority under Sec. 20 viz. the Chief Judge or otherwise called the Judge of the Small Causes Court is not appointed as the “persona designata” for any particular case.

    19. In Ramachandra Rao v. State of Madras, AIR 1962 Andh Pra 58 the learned Judge referred to the Judgment of the Supreme Court reported in Satyanarayan Laxminarayan v. Mallikarajun Bhavanappa, AIR 1960 SC 137 and observed—

    “The expression “persona designata” connotes a person pointed out by name or other personal description in contradistinction to one whose identity is to be ascertained by the office which he holds. So then, where a person is indicated in a Statute not by name but by an official designation, a question will arise whether the intention was to single him out as a persona designata that is, as an individual, the designation being merely a further description of him or it was that he would cease to be the person so indicated on losing his official designation. Surely if he be a judicial officer as in this case and is intended by the statute to act not otherwise than in a judicial capacity or court of civil jurisdiction, he cannot come within the expression “persona designata” so that he may, irrespective of his continuance in office, perform the duty. Whether the intention is one or the other has to be gathered from the words used, nature of the functions to be performed and object and purpose of the statute.”

    20. In Central Talkies Ltd., Kanpur v. Dwarka Prasad, AIR 1961 SC 606 the definition given for “persona designata” in OSBORN'S Concise Law Dictionary was accepted as correct and it is observed that a persona designata as the phrase implies is a person pointed out by name or other personal description in contradistinction to one whose identity is to be ascertained by the office which he holds.

    21. After giving our careful consideration, we think that this complication, viz., whether a “Chief Judge” of Small Causes Court referred to as “appellate authority” in S. 20 of the Act acts as a “persona designata” has mainly arisen due to the fact that the words ‘Chief Judge” are used. We have made it clear at more than one place that it is before the Judge of the Small Causes Court the appeals against the order of the Rent Controller have to be filed and for description and identity sake he is described as “Chief Judge” and the Addl. Judge of the same grade is described as “Additional Chief Judge.”

    22. The words “Chief Judge” as such do not occur in the Small Causes Courts Act. Similarly in A.P (Telangana Area) Civil Courts Act, 1954 also under Sec. 12 it is mentioned that the First Judge of the City Civil Courts may from time to time make such arrangement for distribution of the business of the Courts among various Judges thereof and the Second Judge of the City Civil Courts shall, subject to the general or special orders of the High Court, discharge all or any of the functions of the First Judge, which the First Judge may assign to him. But, over the years, we have been using the words “Chief Judge” instead of “First Judge”, till the Act was substituted by Act 19 of 1972. Likewise, in the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act, though originally the words used were “Judge” and “Additional Judges”, the words “Chief Judge” and “Addl. Chief Judge” are being used in practice. Therefore, the mere use of the words “Chief Judge” in Sec. 20 of the Act does not make him as a “persona designata”. The A.P (Telangana Area) Small Causes Courts Act also could have been amended on the same lines as A.P Civil Courts Act (Act, 19 of 1972) to avoid all these complications. It is desirable that such an amendment should be made as early as possible.

    23. The general principle laid down by the Full Bench in Public Prosecutor's Case, (1975) 1 Andh WR 133 : (1975 Cri LJ 144) Supra, applies on all fours to the facts of this case. Accordingly we hold that the appeals against the judgments of the Rent Controller have to be filed before the Chief judge, Small Causes Court and he has got power under S. 5 to assign them to the Addl. Chief Judges who can dispose them of Since we have held that the Chief Judge under Sec. 20 of the Act is not the persona designata, the High Court exercising its power under Art. 227 of the Constitution can transfer the appeals to the Addl. Chief Judge, for disposal. Therefore the proceedings of the High Court in ROC. No. 843.E1/86, dated 12-3-1986 are perfectly valid.

    24. We may also point out at this stage that he same principle applies to the mufussil area and the Principal Subordinate Judge is not persona designata under Sec. 20 of the Act. As discussed above, appeals under the Act have to be filed before the Principal Subordinate Judge and he has power to assign them to the Additional Subordinate Judges who can dispose them of.

    25. In the result, the writ petitions are dismissed. Now the Civil Revision Petitions have to be heard on merits and accordingly they may be posted before the regular court hearing Civil Revision Petitions for being disposed of on merits. No costs.

    Petitions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Srinivas Rao v. High Court Of A.P And Other
    (Aug 19, 1988)