Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a Private Limited Company engaged in manufacturing flexible packaging material, filed a reference under section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) on 13.8.1999, alleging it had become a sick industrial company due to erosion of net worth. The Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) dismissed the reference as non-maintainable due to undue delay of nearly two years in filing. The petitioner appealed to the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (AAIFR), which allowed the appeal on 14.7.2000, remanding the matter for fresh consideration. On reconsideration, BIFR again rejected the reference on 22.11.2001 for delay based on the audited accounts for 1996-97, which showed sickness earlier. The petitioner appealed again, and AAIFR dismissed the appeal on 7.2.2002, reasons given on 15.2.2002. The petitioner sought a writ of certiorari to quash AAIFR’s order dismissing the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of nearly two years in filing the reference under section 15(1) of the SICA renders the reference non-maintainable.
  2. Whether the 60-day limitation period under section 15(1) of the Act is mandatory and from which date it begins to run.
  3. Whether the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to proceedings before BIFR and AAIFR, or whether delay can be condoned.
  4. Whether the Board of Directors can file a reference after the finalisation of duly audited accounts or based on an earlier formed opinion of sickness.
  5. The scope of inquiry by BIFR on remand regarding delay in filing the reference and the effect of prior appellate orders on such inquiry.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The reference was filed within 60 days from the date of adoption of audited accounts for 1997-98 as defined under section 3(1)(da) of the Act.
  • The delay in preparation of accounts was due to possession of the units by financial institutions and was not intended to thwart recovery efforts.
  • The AAIFR’s order dated 14.7.2000 held that delay in preparation of accounts cannot be a ground to dismiss the reference.
  • The object of the Act is timely detection and rehabilitation of sick companies, and a technical approach to limitation defeats this object.
  • Once it is established that the company is sick, public interest requires the Board to take remedial measures regardless of delay.

Respondents’ Arguments (U.P Financial Corporation and Others)

  • The limitation period under section 15(1) is mandatory and must be strictly construed to prevent misuse of the Act’s provisions.
  • The Limitation Act does not apply to BIFR or AAIFR as they are not courts, and they have no power to condone delay.
  • The delay frustrates the object of the Act by allowing promoters to avoid recovery efforts by financial institutions.
  • The company showed no genuine interest in revival and delayed filing to thwart creditors’ recovery.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.R.F Limited v. Garware Plastics and Polysters Limited, 1995 3 SCC 4651 Legislative intent of SICA for timely detection and expeditious rehabilitation of sick companies; limitation and condonation of delay only within reasonable time. The Court emphasized the mandatory nature of timely detection and held that proceedings should not be used as dilatory tactics; delay beyond reasonable time cannot be condoned.
M/s. Tools International Limited (AAIFR Judgment, August 1996) Interpretation of delay in filing reference and applicability of the Act’s provisions regarding sickness and filing timelines. The Court noted that this judgment was available at the time of finalisation of accounts for 1996-97 and the petitioner could not rely on ignorance of law or delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory provisions of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, focusing on section 15(1) which mandates that the Board of Directors must file a reference within sixty days from the date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts for the financial year at the end of which the company became sick. The Court emphasized that the word "shall" in section 15(1) carries a mandatory character in light of the Act’s object to ensure timely detection and rehabilitation of sick companies.

The Court rejected the petitioner’s contention that delay could be condoned or that the limitation period started from the adoption of later accounts (1997-98). Instead, the Court held that the limitation period commenced from the finalisation of the audited accounts for 1996-97, when the company first became sick. The petitioner’s failure to file the reference within sixty days from that date rendered the reference non-maintainable.

The Court further clarified that the Limitation Act, 1963 does not apply to BIFR or AAIFR proceedings, as these are quasi-judicial bodies and not courts, and therefore have no power to condone delay under that Act. The Court held that the object and purpose of the Act would be defeated if the Board of Directors could delay filing references at will, potentially using the protective provisions of the Act to frustrate creditors’ recovery efforts.

The Court also addressed the scope of inquiry by BIFR on remand, holding that the Board was entitled to consider delay based on the audited accounts for 1996-97 despite earlier appellate findings relating to delay in preparation of later accounts. The Court rejected the petitioner’s plea of estoppel or res judicata against the Board’s inquiry since statutory provisions cannot be barred by such doctrines.

In sum, the Court found no ground to interfere with the impugned orders dismissing the appeal and held that the delay in filing the reference was fatal to its maintainability.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the mandatory nature of the sixty-day limitation period under section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, from the date of finalisation of the audited accounts for the financial year in which the company first became sick. The decision confirms that delay beyond this period renders a reference non-maintainable and that BIFR and AAIFR have no power to condone such delay under the Limitation Act. This ruling reinforces the statutory scheme’s emphasis on timely detection and rehabilitation of sick companies and prevents misuse of the Act’s provisions to delay recovery efforts by creditors. No new precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties was set by this decision.

    M/S. Ess Bee Packagers Pvt. Ltd. v. Appellate Authority For Industrial And Financial Reconstruction, New Delhi And Others

    Sunil Ambwani, J.:— Petitioner, a Private Limited Company, has sought for a writ of certiorari to quash order dated 15.2.2002 passed by Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, New Delhi by which it has dismissed the appeal on 7.2.2002 for which reasons were given on 15.2.2002, against the order of Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction dated 22.11.2001 holding the reference filed by the company under section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 on 13.8.1999 to be non-maintainable on account of undue delay of nearly two years.

    2. I have heard Sri Ravi Kant, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri Saurabh Srivastava for petitioner company. Sri H.R Misra for U.P Financial Corporation and Additional Standing Counsel for respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3. The other respondents have not appeared in spite of notices issued to them on 17.4.2002, upon which the service is deemed to be sufficient.

    3. Since the matter does not involve any disputed questions of fact, with the consent of parties, the writ petition is being decided at the admission stage.

    4. The admitted facts are stated as below:

    5. Petitioner has two industrial Units; one situated at Rania, Kanpur Dehat in U.P and the other at Bilaspur, Himanchal Pradesh. It is engaged in manufacture and sale of flexible packaging material. It has been taking financial assistance from U.P Financial Corporation, Himachal Pradesh Financial Corporation and Bank of Baroda. The company suffered losses for reasons, which are not the matter of concern in this writ petition. The accounts of the company for financial year 1997-98 were finalised by adopting auditor's report in annual general meeting convened in the month of July, 1999. It was found that net worth of the company has been eroded due to huge losses, and that the company had become sick industrial company within the meaning of section 3(o) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’). A reference was made to the Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (hereinafter called as ‘BIFR’) on 11.8.1999 It was registered as Case No. 273 of 1999. On 8.11.1999, secured creditors raised objections with regard to delay in filing Reference. It was noted that the company's net worth was fully eroded as on 31.3.1997 whereas Reference was filed on 11.8.1999 The Board found that Company's two plants had been taken over by HPFC and UPFC on 30.10.1996 and 20.8.1996 respectively. 50% of the net worth had been eroded by 31.3.1996 The Reference was filed after a delay of two years and four months. In its explanation, it was said by the company, that the two Units were taken over in 1996 and that it was under impression that a Reference did not lie. However, based on judgment of Appellate Authority of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (hereinafter called as ‘AAIFR’) in the case of Tools International Limited, the Reference was filed. It was found that the aforesaid judgment was delivered in August, 1996. The company while negotiating with financial institutions and banks had not disclosed about the filing of Reference with BIFR. It could not give a satisfactory explanation as to why accounts for the year 1997-98 were finalised on 31.5.1999 Bank of Baroda had initiated legal action against which petitioner company with Debt Recovery Tribunal on 3.8.1999 The Board thus in its order dated 1.3.2000 concluded that the plants are lying closed for over three years. The company/promoters have not shown any interest in reviving the company and that Reference has been filed only to thwart the efforts of secured creditors in their recovery. It was further found that the Reference was not filed even after immediately finalising the 31.3.1999 accounts on 31.5.1999, as there was a delay of three days beyond 60 days after the date of finalisation of accounts. It was observed that the intention of promoters was not honourable and that no public interest will be served in accepting the Reference. It was, as such, rejected as non-maintainable.

    6. The company preferred an appeal No. 82 of 2000 before AAIFR on the grounds that accounts for 1997-98 were approved by the Board of Directors on 31.5.1999, and at the Annual General Meeting on 30.6.1999, after which the Board of Directors met again and evolved to make a Reference. According to section 3(1)(da) of the Act, which defines “date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts” means the date on which the audited accounts of the company are adopted at the annual general meeting of the company, the Reference was filed on 11.8.1999, within 60 days. It cannot, therefore, be said that the Reference was to thwart the efforts of recovery by secured creditors. Bank of Baroda had filed a suit after finalisation of accounts. The efforts for revival with financial institutions did not meet any success. The delay in preparation of accounts was sought to be explained on the ground that industrial Units of the company were in possession of HPFC and UPFC. AAIFR upon hearing found as under:

    (a) that the reference was made within 60 days from the date of finalisation of duly audited accounts, as defined in section 3(1)(da) of the Act;

    (b) that HPFC and UPFC had sufficient time at their disposal for recovery of their dues from 30.10.1996 and 20.8.1996 when the Units were taken over, until the filing of reference on 11.8.1999 and thus it could not be said that the purpose of filing reference was to thwart recovery proceedings. It was not the case of HPFC and UPFC that the bids for sale were accepted or that the Units were to be sold away to the accepted bidder but for the reference to the BIFR. Bank of Baroda had filed a suit before Debt Recovery Tribunal on 3.8.1999 after finalisation of accounts which cannot be said to be initiation of any recovery effort;

    (c) AAIFR did not take any view with regard to the fact that the company had become a sick industrial unit and on the observations of the BIFR that the company/promoters had no interest in reviving the company. If the company was a sick industrial company and promoters were not interested in its revival, BIFR could take recourse to other measures for revival of the company; and

    (d) that the delay in finalisation of accounts cannot be a reason to dismiss the reference under section 15(1) of the Act.

    Clause (d) of the conclusions of AAIFR is relevant and is quoted below:

    “It is true that there was lapse on the part of the appellant company in not reporting to BIFR under section 23 of SICA on the basis of its accounts for the financial year ended on 31.3.96 It is also true that there was lapse in not filing a reference on the basis of accounts for the financial year ended on 31.3.97 Moreover there was a considerable delay in the finalisation of the accounts for the financial year 1997-98. However, such delay cannot be the reason for the dismissal of a reference under section 15(1) of SICA. Delay in preparation of accounts are matters that may be raised by aggrieved persons with the appropriate authorities competent to take cognizance thereof under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956. However, considering that there have been considerable delays on the part of the appellant company/promoters in these matters, we grant consent to BOB to continue legal proceedings in application filed with DRT, Jabalpur subject to the condition that the execution of recovery certificate/decree that may be obtained from the DRT can only be executed with the prior consent of BIFR.”

    7. The appeal was allowed on 14.7.2000 by AAIFR and after setting aside the order of BIFR, the case was remanded for fresh consideration of the reference under section 15(1) of the Act.

    8. The BIFR while considering the matter, on remand, once again went into the delay in filing of reference. It was found that the reference was based on the audited balance sheet as on 31.3.1998 whereas the audited balance sheet as on 31.3.1997 also indicated that company's net worth of Rs. 123.76 lacs consisting of paid up share capital of Rs. 116.95 lacs and free reserve of Rs. 6.81 lacs had been completely eroded by accumulated losses which, on that date, stood at Rs. 161.52 lacs. The audited balance sheet for 1996-97 was finalised in Annual General Meeting held on 30.9.1997, and the company was, therefore, required to explain as to why it had not filed reference within 60 days beginning from 30.9.1997, and the delay of about two years. The company had not provided for depreciation in its balance-sheets during 1996-97 and 1997-98 and if that was done, the accumulated losses could have been much higher. The company relied upon the order of AAIFR dated 14.7.2000 with reference to para 8(c) and submitted that the question of delay in filing of reference is no longer in issue. The statutory auditor of the company had not held it to be a sick industrial company as on 31.3.1997 on account of the fact that both the Units were taken over by Financial Institutions. Subsequently, in view of AAIFR's judgment in M/s. Tools International Limited, the issue was settled and the auditors qualified the company to be sick in terms of the Act. UPFC submitted that company had removed major parts of machinery from its Kanpur Unit in 1996-97 on account of which reports were made to police. The company and its promoters were not interested in revival at all. HPFC submitted that it had granted loan of Rs. 1.4 crores to the company which stood at Rs. 4.19 crores and that the charged assets were deteriorating on account of the delay caused by the company and thus they should be allowed to sell the assets. BIFR thereafter proceeded to conclude that the judgment of AAIFR dated 14.7.2000 related to the delay in preparation of accounts for 1997-98. There was, however, no delay at all in finalisation of audited balance sheet for 1996-97 on 30.9.1997, in which it was found that the company's net worth was fully eroded. The reference, therefore, should have been filed by 30.11.1997 The company cannot interpret the order of AAIFR that it had condoned the delay in filing company's reference, with reference to financial year 1996-97, since this question had not arisen in appeal at all. In para 8(d) of the order, AAIFR had considered the delay in finalisation of accounts with reference to 1997-98, which were finalised with some delay. The judgment in M/s. Tools International Limited was available at the time of finalisation of accounts for 1996-97. The fact that the assets of the company had been taken over by financial institutions does not result into ceasure of the company to be an industrial company. M/s. Tools International Limited's judgment of AAIFR was based on a judgment of the Supreme Court of India rendered in the year 1993. The BIFR as such again held the reference to be non-maintainable on account of undue delay of nearly two years in filing the same. Section 15(1) reference which could have been made, based on audited balance-sheet for 1996-97 which came to be finalised on 30.9.1997 and thus the reference should have been filed by 30.11.1997 latest i.e within 60 days from the date its net worth was fully eroded in that year itself.

    9. The company again appealed against the aforesaid order of BIFR dated 22.11.2001 It was dismissed after hearing arguments on 6.2.2002 The reasons followed in the order dated 15.2.2002

    10. Since the question was of some importance, although the Chairman and two other members agreed in dismissing the appeal, they gave their separate reasons for reaching to the same conclusion. Justice J.B Goel, Chairman of the Appellate Authority, held that the cause of action for making the reference is not the finalisation of the duly audited accounts of company on the basis of which the reference is made but the annual accounts at the end of which the company had become sick in terms of section 3(1)(5) of the Act for the first time. The period of 60 days under section 15(1) of the Act is mandatory and starts from the finalisation of the annual audited accounts at the end of which it becomes sick and if the Board of Directors of the company formed an opinion of sickness earlier, in that case, sixty days starts when such opinion is formed. The Limitation Act, 1963 applies only to proceedings in Courts and not in applications before Bodies other than Courts, such as, quasi-judicial Tribunals or executive authorities, not withstanding the fact that such bodies or authorities may be vested with certain specified powers conferred on Courts in the Codes of Civil and Criminal Procedures. BIFR is not a Court and thus Limitation Act, 1963 or its section 5 provides for condonation of delay is not a proceeding provided under the Act and, as such, BIFR had no power to condone the delay. Undisputedly, the company had become a sick industrial company at the end of its annual accounts on 31.3.1997 The reference was not made on the basis of those accounts and, as such, the reference was not maintainable and had been rightly rejected by BIFR. In respect of the contention based on section 16(1)(b) of the Act, which authorises the Board to make such inquiry as it may deem fit for determining whether any industrial company has become a sick industrial company, upon information received with respect to such company or upon its own knowledge as to the financial condition of the company. The learned Chairman held that the information contemplated in section 16(1)(b) of the Act should be available to the BIFR within a reasonable time and at the earliest. If any delay is caused, the losses will further increase, making the revival of the company impossible or at least a remote possibility.

    11. In S.R.F Limited v. Garware Plastics and Polysters Limited . 1995 3 SCC 4651., the Supreme Court considered the legislative intent of the Act for timely detection of sick or Potentially sick industry and for taking up proceedings for revival and rehabilitation expeditiously to be completed within a time frame and if unavoidable, it should be condoned within a reasonable time thereafter, or say six months. The proceedings are not to be allowed to be used as dilatory tactics to prevent rehabilitation of sick company or potentially sick company, in particular by rival companies. The Board and appellate authority and the High Court should give effect to the provisions, comply with procedural format and should finalise the proceedings expeditiously within the time frame so that not only the starving workmen, who are kept in agonising wait for revival of sick company without wages, be rescued, but also needless accumulation of losses by the company and the loss of revenue to the State is avoided. The information contemplated under section 16(1)(b) of the Act should have been furnished or made available to the BIFR, if not within 60 days, then within a reasonable time when the company had become sick. It was not done and thus the Appellate Authority held that it cannot consider the plea after five years.

    12. Dr. J.K Bagchi and Shri M.S Dayal principally agreed with the Chairman in dismissing the appeal whereas Dr. Bagchi relied upon the provisions of section 32(1) of the Act to repel the Limitation Act, he held that even Limitation Act talks about reasonable period and that section 16(1)(b) of the Act cannot be resorted, as it would be a round about approach and it will be virtually impossible to implement limitation issues.

    13. Shri S.M Dayal found that accounts for financial year 1997-98 were approved at the Annual General Meeting on 30.9.1997 The period of 60 days expired on 29.11.1997 and since 29.11.1997 and 30.11.1997 were holidays, being Saturday and Sunday, the reference should have been made by 1.12.1997 The question of delay with reference to erosion of net worth in financial year 1996-97 was neither raised nor considered in AAIFR's order dated 14.7.2002 As the case was remanded to BIFR, it was open to BIFR to consider this issue. He held that a reference under section 15(1) of the Act must be made when the company became sick for the first time in terms of section 3(1)(o) of the Act. The Appellant's plea of ignorance of law was not tenable and was rejected.

    14. Shri Ravi Kant, Senior Advocate, submits that the matter with regard to delay in filing of reference under section 16(1) of the Act was considered and decided by AAIFR in its order dated 14.7.2000 in para 8(d) and it was held that such delay cannot be reason for dismissing the reference inasmuch as delays in preparation of accounts are matters that may be raised by aggrieved persons before appropriate authorities under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956. The appellate order was not challenged and became final and, as such, it was not open to BIFR to make a further inquiry with regard to the delay in filing of reference. He further submits that the object of the Act is to timely detect the sick and potentially sick companies. BIFR was constituted and, vested with powers for speedy determination of preventive ameliorative, remedial and other measures. With this object in mind, the period for making reference under section 15(1) of the Act by the company cannot be held to be mandatory and that once it was established before the Board that the company had become a sick industrial unit, it was in public interest, keeping in view the object of the Act, to take such measures, as provided under the Act, for its rehabilitation. The provisions of sections 15 and 16 of the Act provide for timely detection of sick and potentially sick industrial companies. A technical approach in rejecting the reference on the ground of delay will be ultra vires to the object and other provisions of the Act. In a case under section 16(1)(b), once the Board receives information that an industrial company has become sick or is potentially sick, the provisions of Chapter III must be brought into action to take all and such remedial measures for its rehabilitation failing which the opinion under section 20(1) of the Act can be formed to wind up the sick industrial company. According to him, the Appellate Authority has given an arbitrary approach in rejecting the reference and has avoided its statutory liability.

    15. Sri H.R Misra appearing for UPFC while supporting the order of the Appellate Authority submits that the object of the Act is timely detection of the sick and potentially sick companies. Section 22 of the Act gives special protection to the companies after the registration of the references and looking to the object of the Act and to avoid misuse of the provisions of section 22, the period prescribed for making a reference under section 15(1) must be strictly construed and should be held to be mandatory, failing which the Board of Directors will make reference according to their convenience, frustrating the object of the Act. He submits that section 33 of the Act provides for penalty for violating provisions of the Act and that the provisions of the Limitation Act are not applicable to the Board and Appellate Authority. The Act has special purpose to achieve, for which it has been given overriding effect over the provisions of all other Acts except the Acts prescribed under section 32.

    16. Section 15 of the Act is relevant and is quoted below:

    “15. Reference to Board.—(1) Where an industrial company has become a sick industrial company, the Board of Directors of the company, shall, within sixty days from the date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the company for the financial year as at the end of which the company has become a sick industrial company, make a reference to the Board for determination of the measures which shall be adopted with respect to the company.

    17. Provided that if the Board of Directors had sufficient reasons even before such finalisation to form the opinion that the company had become a sick industrial company, the Board of Directors shall, within sixty days after it has formed such opinion, make a reference to the Board for the determination of the measures which shall be adopted with respect to the company:

    (2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section (1), the Central Government or the Reserve Bank or a State Government or a public financial institution or a State Level institution or a scheduled bank may, if it has sufficient reasons to believe that any industrial company has become, for the purposes of this Act, a sick industrial company, make a reference in respect of such company to the Board for determination of the measures which may be adopted with respect to such company:

    Provided that a reference shall not be made under this sub-section in respect of any industrial company by —

    (a) the Government of any State unless all or any of the industrial undertakings belonging to such company are situated in such State;

    (b) a public financial institution or a State level institution or a scheduled bank unless it has, by reason of any financial assistance or obligation rendered by it, or undertaken by it, with respect to such company, an interest in such Company.”

    18. The words “sick industrial company” and “finalisation of the duly audited accounts” of the company have been defined under sections 3(o) and 3(da) of the Act. They are quoted below:

    “3(o) “sick industrial company” means an industrial company (being a company registered for not less than five years) which has at the end of any financial year accumulated losses equal to or exceeding its entire net worth.”

    “3(da) “date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts” means the date on which the audited accounts of the company are adopted at the annual general meeting of the company.”

    19. The objects and Reasons as given in the Bill originally proposed were serious concern of the Government and society at large to the ill effects of sickness in industrial companies, such as, loss of production, loss of employment, loss of revenue to the Central and State Governments and locking up of investible funds of banks and financial institutions, the alarming increase of the sickness in industrial companies and to fully utilise the productive industrial assets, to give protection of employment and to optimize the use of the funds of banks and financial institutions impelled the enactment, to revive and rehabilitate the potentially viable sick industrial companies as quickly as possible. It was found that the existing institutional arrangements and procedures for revival and rehabilitation of potentially viable sick industrial companies are both inadequate and time consuming. Multiplicity of laws and agencies made the adoption of a coordinated approach for dealing with sick industrial companies difficult. It was, as such, felt that for dealing with sick industrial companies, a legislation was necessary to provide for timely detection of sickness in industrial companies and for expeditious determination by a body of experts of the preventive, ameliorative, remedial and other measures that would need to be adopted with respect to such companies and for enforcement of such measures considered appropriate with utmost practicable despatch. The timely detection, expeditious determination and practicable despatch of all measures to be enforced were thus the impelling motive to enact the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985. In order to timely detect the sickness, the Act provides the Board of Directors of the company to make a reference to the Board. It can be made by the Board of Directors if they have sufficient reasons, before the finalisation of duly audited accounts to form an opinion, and to make a reference within sixty days of forming such an opinion under the proviso to section 15(1) of the Act. In other cases, the sickness must be reported by the Board of Directors within sixty days of the date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the company for the financial year, at the end of which the company will become a sick industrial company. Without prejudice to the aforesaid, the Central Government or the Reserve Bank or the State Government or a public financial institution or a State level institution or a Scheduled Bank may, if it has reasons to believe, that an industrial company has become sick, make a reference for which no limitation is prescribed under sub-section (2) of section 15 of the Act. Section 16(1)(b) of the Act mandates the Board to make such inquiry as it may deem fit for determination whether any industrial company has become sick industrial company, either upon receipt of reference under section 15 or upon information received with respect to such company or upon its own knowledge as to the financial condition of the company. These three sources have been provided in the Act for the Board to initiate proceedings of determination to sickness and thereafter to take measures under sections 16, 17 and 18 of the Act. The purpose of the provisions is the timely detection. Since the Board of Directors are primarily responsible for preparing the account of the company, they are the one who first acquire the knowledge of the sickness of the industrial company. They can either before the finalisation of the accounts form an opinion or after finalisation of the accounts inform the Board with regard to sickness. Whereas no limitation is provided for formation of an opinion before finalisation of duly audited accounts, the period of sixty days from the date of such finalisation in respect of the financial year has been provided.

    20. Section 210 of the Companies Act, 1956 provides for placing of annual accounts before annual general meeting by the Board of Directors of the company. There has to be at least one annual general meeting under section 166 of the Companies Act in the course of one year in relation to the financial year. It is thus not open to the company to submit accounts for more than one year for consideration at the annual general meeting. A profit and loss account for the period along with auditor's report, as provided under sections 216/218 and other specified documents to be attached/annexed to the annual accounts, and its circulation under section 219 to the members before it is laid before the annual general meeting. It is only after the balance-sheet and profit and loss account have been placed before and considered by the general body of the share holders of the company, that they are finally accepted and thereafter under section 220, these have to be filed with the Registrar within 30 days from the date on which the balance-sheet and the profit and loss account are so laid at the annual general meeting where the annual general meeting of the company for any year has not been held, section 220 provides that these shall be filed with the Registrar within 30 days from the latest day on or before which that meeting should have been held in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Sub-section (2) of section 220 provides that if the annual general meeting of the company before which a balance-sheet is laid does not adopt the balance-sheet, or is adjourned without adopting the balance-sheet, or, if the annual general meeting of the company for any year has not been held, a statement of that fact and the reasons therefor shall be annexed to the balance-sheet and to the copies thereof required to be filed with the Registrar. In default, every officer of the company is liable to punishment, as provided under section 162 of the Act.

    21. Upon receipt of the profit and loss account and the balance-sheet by the Board of Directors at the Annual General Meeting of the company, held in pursuance of section 166, in the case of any subsequent annual general meeting of the company under sub-section (3)(b) of section 210, to the period beginning with the day immediately after the period for which the account was last submitted, and ending with a day which shall not precede the day of the meeting by more than six months, or, in any case, where an extension of time has been granted for holding the meeting under the second proviso to sub-section (1) of section 166, by more than six months and the extension so granted. Sub-section (4) of section 210 provides that the period of which the account aforesaid relates is referred to in this Act as a “financial year” and it may be less or more than a calendar year, but it shall not exceed fifteen months provided that it may extend to eighteen months where special permission has been granted in that behalf by the Registrar. Failure to comply with the aforesaid provisions is punishable with imprisonment. The balance-sheet under section 211 is to provide true and fair view of the State of affairs of the company at the end of the financial year as every profit and loss account under sub-section (2) is required to give a true and fair view of the profit and loss of the company for the financial year and must comply with the accounting standards. The Board of Directors, therefore, have the first opportunity to find out the net worth of the company with reference to the balance-sheet which is, subsequently, audited and is thereafter placed before the Annual General Meeting after its circulation. It is on account of this fact that the proviso to section 15(1) provides that if the Board of Directors had sufficient reasons even before the finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the company for the financial year, that is, on its adoption at the annual general meeting, to form an opinion that the company had become a sick industrial company, the deeming provision under section 3(da) has been provided, taking into account the provisions of the Companies Act and by way of giving sufficient opportunity to the company to form an opiion and to refer the matter to the Board under section 15(1) of the Act. After such finalisation of accounts, two months' period has been provided to make a reference.

    22. The purpose of citing the aforesaid provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 is to find out the object of the definition of the ‘date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts’, and the time period provided under section 15(1) of the Act. Even if the audited accounts are not adopted at the annual general meeting of the company, they shall have the same effect inasmuch as these have to be filed with the Registrar of Companies. The Act, however, starts the period of limitation of sixty days from the date they are adopted at the annual general meeting of the company.

    23. The object and purpose of the Act has to be seen before interpreting any of its provisions. The word ‘shall’ occurring in section 15(1) has to be interpreted, therefore, in the context in which it has been used and the object and purposes of the Act. The Preamble of the Act shows that SICA was enacted as a special provision with a view to secure timely detection of sick and potentially sick industrial companies owning industrial undertakings, the speedy determination by a Board of experts of the preventive, ameliorative, remedial and other protective measures. The words “timely detection of sick and potentially sick industrial companies” are relevant and thus the word “shall” has to be given mandatory character. The Board of Directors, therefore, have a mandate under the Act to make a reference to the BIFR within sixty days from the date of finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the company for the financial year at the end of which the company has become a sick industrial company.

    24. There is no dispute, in the present case, that the company had become a sick industrial company at the end of the finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the financial year 1996-97, and thus it was mandatory for the Board of Directors to have made a reference to the Board. There was a clear delay close to two years in this case. The Board of Directors have given reasons for condonation of delay. These reasons were considered and were found to be inadequate inasmuch as the judgment in TIL's case was dated 5.8.1996 and was already available at the time of finalisation of the company's accounts for the year 1996-97. That judgment was in respect of an appeal against BIFR's order dated 17.2.1995 and it had also referred to the earlier judgments of the Supreme Court.

    25. Coming to the submission of the scope of inquiry by the Board after the matter was remanded by the Appellate Authority, I find that firstly the Appellate Authority in its order dated 14.7.2000 had not considered the delay on the basis of finalisation of the audited accounts of the company for the financial year ended on 31.3.1999 The finding that there was considerable delay in the finalisation of the accounts for the financial year 1997-98 was arrived at without taking into account the provisions of the Companies Act under which the permission of the Registrar was required to be taken and there was no pleading that such permission was applied for or obtained by the company. The observation of the Appellate Authority under para 8(d) of its order dated 14.7.2000, that such delay cannot be the reason for the dismissal of a reference under section 15(1) of the SICA, was against the mandatory provisions of the Act. Res-judicata or estoppel cannot be pleaded against the Statute. The Board, therefore, did not err in law in proceeding to consider the delay firstly on the basis of finalisation of the duly audited accounts of the company for the financial year ended on 31.3.1996 and, thereafter, the delay on account of finalisation of the accounts for the financial year ended on 31.3.1997 The submissions against the jurisdiction of the BIFR to consider the matter after remand are as such not tenable.

    26. There is another reason for coming to the same conclusion, namely, that the object and purpose of the Act will be defeated in case the Board of Directors are allowed to make a reference at their will. In such a case, the reference may be used as a tool against the recoveries initiated against the company, by virtue of the umbrella of protection given under section 22 of the Act. The Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction and Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction are not Courts to which section 5 of the Limitation Act is applicable.

    27. For the aforesaid reasons, I do not find any ground to interfere with the impugned orders. The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Ess Bee Package... v. Appellate Authority ...
    (Oct 31, 2002)