An Unconditional ACOD Can Satisfy Favorable Termination for a Section 1983 Malicious Prosecution Claim
Case: Brill v. Ulster County, No. 25-2432, United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, decided November 10, 2026.
Opinion: District Judge Lewis J. Liman, sitting by designation, joined by Circuit Judges Calabresi and Merriam.
1. Introduction
Brill v. Ulster County revises an important threshold requirement for federal malicious prosecution claims. Applying the Supreme Court’s decision in Thompson v. Clark, 596 U.S. 36 (2022), the Second Circuit recognizes that its longstanding rule categorically excluding New York adjournments in contemplation of dismissal from “favorable termination” is no longer valid. An unconditional adjournment in contemplation of dismissal, or ACOD, that results in dismissal without a conviction can satisfy that requirement.
The plaintiff, Cristina Brill, operated a licensed animal rescue after previously working for the Ulster County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. She alleged that SPCA peace officers Christopher West and Adam Saunders, together with competing rescue operator Eleni Calomiris, disseminated false accusations that she mistreated animals. According to the complaint, those accusations supported warrants leading to a search of her home, her arrest, and misdemeanor animal-welfare charges. Deputy Damon Alberts and Detective Emmett Vedder also participated in the enforcement activity.
After the prosecution ended through an ACOD, Brill sued these defendants, Ulster County, and unidentified officers. Her claims principally challenged the search, arrest, prosecution, alleged conspiracy, and resulting interference with her animal rescue business.
The appeal involved two distinct questions: whether Brill’s existing allegations stated constitutional claims, and whether she should receive another opportunity to plead them. The court answered the first question negatively but the second, for several claims, affirmatively. Its central doctrinal ruling therefore expands access to federal malicious prosecution litigation without finding that Brill had yet pleaded a viable claim.
2. Summary of the Opinion
The district court dismissed the entire action with prejudice, although the moving defendants had challenged only selected claims. The Second Circuit identified errors in that approach and in several aspects of the district court’s reasoning. Nevertheless, reviewing the complaint independently, it concluded that every federal claim was deficient as pleaded.
| Claim or issue |
Appellate conclusion |
Practical result |
| Unlawful search |
General accusations of false warrant information did not plausibly undermine probable cause. |
Dismissal sustained; leave to amend required. |
| Federal false arrest |
Confinement was adequately alleged, but the complaint did not plausibly overcome the warrant-based justification for arrest. |
Dismissal sustained; leave to amend required. |
| Federal malicious prosecution |
The unconditional ACOD constituted favorable termination, but no post-arraignment liberty restraint was alleged. |
Dismissal sustained on an alternative ground; leave to amend required. |
| Section 1983 conspiracy |
No underlying constitutional violation was adequately pleaded. |
Dismissal sustained; leave to amend required. |
| First Amendment, Fourteenth Amendment, and Section 1985(3) |
The allegations did not establish the necessary protected rights, personal involvement, or discriminatory class-based animus. |
Dismissal and denial of leave to amend affirmed. |
| State-law defamation |
Declining supplemental jurisdiction was permissible, but dismissal should not have been with prejudice. |
Judgment modified to dismissal without prejudice. |
| State-law false arrest |
Brill had consented to dismissal as untimely. |
No comparable reinstatement or amendment ruling. |
The court therefore affirmed the judgment in part as modified, vacated the denial of amendment in part, and remanded. It did not reinstate any federal claim as sufficiently pleaded.
3. Analysis: The New Favorable-Termination Rule
3.1. The statutory character of an ACOD
New York Criminal Procedure Law § 170.55 permits a criminal proceeding to be adjourned with a view toward eventual dismissal in furtherance of justice. The defendant, prosecutor, and court must consent. As described in the opinion, charges ordinarily remain suspended for six months and are then dismissed absent an intervening event warranting restoration.
The court relied on Hollender v. Trump Village Co-op., Inc., 448 N.E.2d 432 (N.Y. 1983), to explain this unusual disposition. An ACOD resolves relatively minor charges without adjudicating their merits. It is neither a conviction nor an admission of guilt, and a completed dismissal generally treats the charge as though it had never been brought. Importantly, its neutrality concerning guilt once defeated federal malicious prosecution claims; after the Supreme Court’s intervention, that neutrality no longer does so.
Matter of Edwin L., 671 N.E.2d 1247 (N.Y. 1996), establishes that an ACOD is available before a guilty plea or the commencement of trial, rather than after factfinding. Hennessy v. Gorman, 450 N.Y.S.2d 638 (4th Dep’t 1982), reversed on other grounds, supports the proposition that the court need not state reasons for granting it. Together, these authorities show why an ACOD commonly produces no affirmative declaration of innocence.
Sections 170.55(8) and 160.50 reinforce that understanding: an ACOD is not an admission of guilt, and consummated dismissal carries restorative and record-sealing consequences. Those statutory effects support treating Brill’s completed disposition as a termination without conviction, rather than as an implicit finding against her.
3.2. The displaced precedents: affirmative innocence is no longer required
In Singleton v. City of New York, 632 F.2d 185 (2d Cir. 1980), the Second Circuit held that an ACOD was not a favorable termination because it left guilt unresolved. Drawing on the Restatement (Second) of Torts, that decision required a disposition indicating that the accused was not guilty.
The earlier decision also invoked practical concerns. Relying on Kenul v. Hollander, 382 N.Y.S.2d 650 (Dist. Ct. Nassau County 1976), it characterized an ACOD as a special break resembling probation and feared that potential civil liability would discourage prosecutors from consenting to it. In the present opinion, those concerns cannot preserve a categorical rule inconsistent with controlling Supreme Court law.
Lanning v. City of Glens Falls, 908 F.3d 19 (2d Cir. 2018), subsequently applied the affirmative-innocence approach. An allegation that charges had merely been dismissed was insufficient because procedural or jurisdictional dismissals might say nothing about innocence. The present decision explains that this reasoning rested on the same premise the Supreme Court later rejected.
The doctrinal correction is therefore precise: a plaintiff need not establish that the criminal disposition affirmatively demonstrated innocence. The court recognizes the earlier ACOD exclusion as overruled, rather than merely creating an exception to it.
3.3. The controlling Supreme Court decision
Thompson v. Clark, 596 U.S. 36 (2022), supplies the decisive rule: favorable termination requires that the prosecution have ended without a conviction. Its method is also important. Because Section 1983 was enacted in 1871, the Supreme Court examined American malicious prosecution law at that time, rather than treating a twentieth-century Restatement as controlling historical evidence.
Under that historical understanding, a prosecutor’s abandonment of a case or an unexplained judicial dismissal could satisfy favorable termination. Requiring an affirmative indication of innocence would improperly deny a federal remedy based on the absence of an explanation that the criminal court was not obliged to provide.
Chiaverini v. City of Napoleon, 602 U.S. 556 (2024), reinforces that historical methodology. It holds that a valid criminal charge does not automatically defeat a malicious prosecution claim concerning a separate invalid charge. Although it does not decide the ACOD question, it confirms the Supreme Court’s reliance on the common-law principles governing malicious prosecution when Section 1983 was enacted.
Ordinarily, one Second Circuit panel cannot overrule another. Lotes Co. v. Hon Hai Precision Indus. Co., 753 F.3d 395 (2d Cir. 2014), provides the applicable exception: an intervening Supreme Court decision casting doubt on circuit precedent permits a panel to revisit that precedent. Here, the conflict between an affirmative-innocence requirement and a termination-without-conviction standard justified that step.
The opinion also notes that district courts had already recognized this development in Perez v. City of New York, No. 20-cv-1359, 2022 WL 4236338 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 14, 2022), and Douglas v. Walmart, No. 24-cv-3030, 2026 WL 2922281 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 29, 2026). Those decisions are corroborative applications, not the source of the circuit’s authority to depart from its earlier rule.
3.4. Why plea bargains and diversionary compromises remain different
The court carefully reconciles its holding with Carruthers v. Colton, 153 F.4th 169 (2d Cir. 2025). That decision holds that dismissal of charges as part of a negotiated guilty plea does not satisfy favorable termination. Such dismissal purchases a conviction on another charge; it is not simply prosecutorial abandonment.
Chapdelaine v. Desjardin, 180 F.4th 454 (2d Cir. 2026), likewise rejected favorable termination on the particular facts of a Connecticut diversionary disposition. The defendant obtained a court-ordered compromise requiring participation in a supervised program, and the prosecutor had opposed her admission. The prosecution therefore had not abandoned its case.
Brill’s disposition differed in material respects. No conviction resulted, the prosecution consented, and she was not required to surrender liberty through a comparable program in exchange for dismissal. Moreover, she alleged that the prosecutor acknowledged an inability to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. That allegation supported the conclusion that the government had effectively abandoned the prosecution.
The holding is expressly limited. Section 170.55 permits some ACODs to be conditioned on community service or dispute-resolution participation. The court leaves open whether those arrangements might constitute bargained-for compromises rather than favorable terminations. It also addresses a prosecution that had actually ended, not merely charges still awaiting dismissal during an adjournment period.
3.5. Policy concerns and continuing defenses
The favorable-termination requirement avoids parallel criminal and civil proceedings, inconsistent judgments, and civil attacks on outstanding convictions. A completed ACOD dismissal without a guilt determination does not create those problems.
The court nevertheless acknowledges the criminal system’s reliance on negotiated resolutions, invoking Santobello v. New York, 404 U.S. 257 (1971), through the discussion of plea-bargaining incentives. Its answer is not that civil exposure is irrelevant, but that other substantive safeguards remain.
Cornelio v. Connecticut, 32 F.4th 160 (2d Cir. 2022), establishes that probable cause is a complete defense to malicious prosecution. District of Columbia v. Wesby, 583 U.S. 48 (2018), emphasizes that probable cause is not a high threshold. A prosecutor’s inability to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt therefore does not itself establish that probable cause was absent.
Qualified immunity supplies an additional protection for officers where its requirements are met. The court cites Rohman v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth., 215 F.3d 208 (2d Cir. 2000), Bonide Prods., Inc. v. Cahill, 223 F.3d 141 (2d Cir. 2000), Droz v. McCadden, 580 F.3d 106 (2d Cir. 2009), and Dettelis v. Sharbaugh, 919 F.3d 161 (2d Cir. 2019), as examples of its role in resolving malicious prosecution litigation. The court does not itself decide qualified immunity here.
4. Analysis: Pleading Requirements and the Remaining Claims
4.1. The governing pleading framework
Dieujuste v. Sin, 125 F.4th 397 (2d Cir. 2025), and Mazzei v. The Money Store, 62 F.4th 88 (2d Cir. 2023), require courts reviewing dismissal to accept factual allegations as true and draw reasonable inferences for the plaintiff. That protection does not extend to unsupported legal conclusions.
Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009), and Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007), require enough nonconclusory factual content to make liability plausible. Discovery cannot substitute for the initial obligation to plead such facts.
Yak v. Bank Brussels Lambert, 252 F.3d 127 (2d Cir. 2001), permits consideration of complaint exhibits and materials incorporated by reference. Conversely, Wright v. Ernst & Young LLP, 152 F.3d 169 (2d Cir. 1998), warns that a represented plaintiff cannot amend a complaint through motion papers. These rules matter because Brill submitted warrant materials and a police report with her opposition papers; the opinion expressly questions whether the report was properly considered.
Because Brill represented herself on appeal, Wright v. Comm'r of Int. Rev., 381 F.3d 41 (2d Cir. 2004), required liberal construction of her appellate submissions. That did not eliminate the substantive deficiencies in the complaint, which had been filed through counsel.
4.2. Search warrants: particular falsehoods and materiality must be pleaded
Alexander v. City of Syracuse, 132 F.4th 129 (2d Cir. 2025), supplies the Fourth Amendment foundation: protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. A judicially issued warrant, however, carries a presumption of reasonableness.
Under Ganek v. Leibowitz, 874 F.3d 73 (2d Cir. 2017), drawing on Velardi v. Walsh, 40 F.3d 569 (2d Cir. 1994), a plaintiff challenging the truthfulness of a warrant application must identify knowingly or recklessly false statements or material omissions necessary to probable cause. The court evaluates materiality through a hypothetical corrected affidavit: would probable cause remain after the relevant falsehoods were removed?
Brill alleged that false information produced the search warrant but did not identify particular false statements or facts demonstrating their falsity. That prevented a meaningful assessment of whether any alleged fabrication mattered to probable cause.
Calderon v. City of New York, 138 F. Supp. 3d 593 (S.D.N.Y. 2015), supports rejecting conclusory allegations of warrant falsehoods. Evans v. Chalmers, 703 F.3d 636 (4th Cir. 2012), provides persuasive support that blanket assertions that every material fact was fabricated are insufficient. These authorities explain why merely demanding discovery could not save the existing pleading.
Brill also alleged that the search warrant had expired under state law. United States v. Singletary, 798 F.3d 55 (2d Cir. 2015), establishes that constitutional reasonableness does not necessarily require compliance with state procedural rules. United States v. Gerber, 994 F.2d 1556 (11th Cir. 1993), supports the conclusion that execution shortly after expiration need not violate the Constitution where probable cause continues. United States v. Nyah, 928 F.3d 694 (8th Cir. 2019), adds that the Fourth Amendment does not itself require warrant expiration dates.
The resulting rule is limited: the brief expiration alleged here, standing alone and without additional nonconclusory allegations of unreasonableness, did not establish a federal violation. The opinion does not authorize every search under an expired warrant.
4.3. False arrest: confinement was alleged, but lack of justification was not
Guan v. City of New York, 37 F.4th 797 (2d Cir. 2022), directs courts to consult the law of the state where the arrest occurred. Carruthers v. Colton identifies New York’s elements: intentional confinement, awareness, lack of consent, and absence of privilege. Probable cause makes the confinement privileged.
Under Escalera v. Lunn, 361 F.3d 737 (2d Cir. 2004), probable cause exists when reasonably trustworthy information would justify a person of reasonable caution in believing that an offense occurred.
The district court wrongly concluded that Brill had not alleged confinement. Her allegation that officers “arrested” her reasonably conveyed that she was confined. The police report, even assuming it could be considered, also described custody, transport, and processing before release. Kaupp v. Texas, 538 U.S. 626 (2003), confirms that involuntary transport to a police station can constitute a Fourth Amendment seizure.
Nevertheless, the claim remained deficient because Brill did not plausibly undermine the arrest warrant. Fabrikant v. French, 691 F.3d 193 (2d Cir. 2012), requires knowingly or recklessly false warrant statements material to probable cause. Her general fabrication allegations did not satisfy that standard.
That precedent also supplies institutional context: New York law permits municipalities to delegate broad animal-control powers to organizations such as the SPCA. The opinion therefore does not treat the SPCA officers’ private organizational employment as automatically removing their enforcement conduct from constitutional scrutiny.
4.4. Malicious prosecution still requires a post-arraignment seizure
Under Carruthers v. Colton, a federal malicious prosecution claim requires commencement or continuation of criminal proceedings, favorable termination, lack of probable cause, malice, and a sufficient post-arraignment liberty restraint implicating the Fourth Amendment.
Brill satisfied the disputed favorable-termination requirement but failed to allege the final element. Her complaint identified her arrest and arraignment, not any subsequent restraint.
Singer v. Fulton County Sheriff, 63 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 1995), grounds the federal claim in an injury consistent with a Fourth Amendment seizure. Drawing on Gerstein v. Pugh, 420 U.S. 103 (1975), it distinguishes such an injury from an impermissible general review of the decision to prosecute.
Murphy v. Lynn, 118 F.3d 938 (2d Cir. 1997), recognizes physical detention as a paradigmatic restraint. But incarceration is not indispensable. Swartz v. Insogna, 704 F.3d 105 (2d Cir. 2013), recognizes required post-arraignment court attendance as a qualifying restraint, while Rohman v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth. illustrates the principle through repeated mandatory court appearances.
These authorities identify a potentially curable omission, not a finding that Brill actually experienced such restrictions. On remand, she must allege any qualifying restraint factually and truthfully.
4.5. First Amendment: animal rescue was not pleaded as protected association
Brill characterized rescuing animals, arranging adoptions, and associating with others as protected activity. Jacoby & Meyers, LLP v. Presiding Justices of the First, Second, Third, and Fourth Dep'ts, 852 F.3d 178 (2d Cir. 2017), applying Roberts v. U.S. Jaycees, 468 U.S. 609 (1984), distinguishes intimate association from association undertaken for protected expressive, religious, or petitioning activity.
Her allegations fit neither category. The court does not hold that animal-welfare advocacy can never receive First Amendment protection; it holds that operating the rescue and arranging adoptions, as pleaded, did not establish a protected associational activity.
The factual background also references Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966), to explain the warnings associated with custodial interrogation. The opinion does not develop those allegations into an independent damages holding.
4.6. Fourteenth Amendment: entitlement and personal responsibility were missing
Bryant v. N.Y. State Educ. Dep't supplies the procedural due process framework: a protected property or liberty interest and deprivation without constitutionally adequate process.
Spinelli v. City of New York, 579 F.3d 160 (2d Cir. 2009), drawing on Barry v. Barchi, 443 U.S. 55 (1979), recognizes a protected interest where a license may be suspended only upon a satisfactory showing of misconduct. By contrast, Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales, 545 U.S. 748 (2005), explains that a benefit subject to official discretion is not necessarily a protected entitlement.
Brill did not describe the licensing scheme sufficiently to establish a protected entitlement. Independently, she did not allege that any defendant participated in the license revocation or licensing process. Wiggins v. Griffin, 86 F.4th 987 (2d Cir. 2023), requires each defendant’s personal involvement in the constitutional violation.
The distinction is consequential: involvement in events that trigger separate licensing proceedings is not automatically involvement in denying the process owed during those proceedings.
The court also considered a possible “stigma plus” theory. Salladah v. City of Utica, 383 F.3d 34 (2d Cir. 2004), recognizes limited constitutional relief for government defamation accompanied by a material state-imposed burden or status change. That theory failed because Brill had not connected these defendants to the requisite additional state-imposed deprivation.
4.7. Conspiracy does not replace the missing substantive elements
Under Singer v. Fulton County Sheriff, a Section 1983 conspiracy must produce an actual constitutional violation. Because none was adequately pleaded, Brill’s conspiracy theory also failed.
Ciambriello v. County of Nassau, 292 F.3d 307 (2d Cir. 2002), explains why conspiracy mattered particularly to Calomiris: joint action with government officials can supply the state-action connection needed to bring a private participant within Section 1983.
Section 1985(3) has a different requirement. N.Y. State Nat. Org. for Women v. Terry, 886 F.2d 1339 (2d Cir. 1989), recognizes its application to certain private conspiracies, while Dolan v. Connolly, 794 F.3d 290 (2d Cir. 2015), requires racial or otherwise qualifying class-based, invidiously discriminatory animus. Brill alleged no qualifying class membership or such motivation.
The appellate court expressly declined to decide whether the complaint otherwise adequately alleged an agreement among defendants. Its ruling therefore should not be read as endorsing the district court’s conspiracy-agreement analysis.
5. Procedural Fairness, Amendment, and State-Law Claims
5.1. Unrequested dismissal ordinarily requires notice
The district court’s dismissal of claims no defendant had moved to dismiss raised a separate fairness problem. Catzin v. Thank You & Good Luck Corp., 899 F.3d 77 (2d Cir. 2018), cautions against dismissal without an opportunity to be heard, reserving exceptional treatment for unmistakably clear defects. Fitzgerald v. First East Seventh Street Tenants Corp., 221 F.3d 362 (2d Cir. 2000), recognizes authority to dismiss frivolous claims sua sponte.
Brill’s search and false arrest claims were not frivolous. She should therefore have received notice and an opportunity to address their deficiencies before dismissal.
Nevertheless, J.C. v. Reg'l Sch. Dist. 10, 278 F.3d 119 (2d Cir. 2002), supported appellate consideration of a purely legal issue addressed in the parties’ briefs. Konikoff v. Prudential Ins. Co. of Am., 234 F.3d 92 (2d Cir. 2000), permits affirmance on any ground supported by the record. Jennings v. Stephens, 574 U.S. 271 (2015), reinforces that appellate courts review judgments, not merely the reasoning in lower-court opinions.
Accordingly, the court could sustain dismissal of the existing complaint while correcting the unfair denial of an opportunity to amend.
5.2. Why amendment was required for some claims but not others
Absolute Activist Value Master Fund Ltd. v. Ficeto, 677 F.3d 60 (2d Cir. 2012), applies Rule 15’s direction to give leave freely when justice requires. Perez v. Ortiz, 849 F.2d 793 (2d Cir. 1988), explains that sua sponte dismissal can prejudice plaintiffs by depriving them of an opportunity to cure pleading defects.
Brill had not been alerted to the search and false arrest deficiencies before judgment. Nor had defendants raised below the post-arraignment-restraint ground on which the appellate court sustained dismissal of malicious prosecution. Fairness therefore required an opportunity to amend those claims. Because successful amendment could supply an underlying constitutional violation and further allegations of agreement, amendment of the Section 1983 conspiracy claim was also permitted.
Tocker v. Philip Morris Cos., 470 F.3d 481 (2d Cir. 2006), permits denial where amendment would be futile. Brill had already received notice of the First and Fourteenth Amendment deficiencies and proposed no substantive cure. Nothing suggested that she could supply the protected-class allegations missing from her Section 1985(3) claim. Denial of amendment for those claims was therefore affirmed.
5.3. State-law defamation was not decided on its merits
Travelers Ins. Co. v. Keeling, 996 F.2d 1485 (2d Cir. 1993), quoting Carnegie-Mellon Univ. v. Cohill, 484 U.S. 343 (1988), recognizes that dismissal of all federal claims before trial ordinarily favors declining supplemental jurisdiction over remaining state claims.
That principle justified declining jurisdiction over defamation. But Jusino v. Fed'n of Cath. Tchrs., Inc., 54 F.4th 95 (2d Cir. 2022), required dismissal without prejudice rather than a merits-preclusive dismissal. The judgment was modified accordingly.
The opinion further recognizes that if Brill successfully amends a federal claim, the district court could again become an appropriate forum for related state claims under 28 U.S.C. § 1367.
6. Potential Impact
-
Removal of a categorical federal barrier: Plaintiffs whose prosecutions ended through unconditional ACOD dismissals can no longer be rejected solely because those dispositions did not affirmatively establish innocence.
-
Closer examination of disposition terms: Courts must distinguish completed, unconditional dismissals from guilty-plea exchanges and potentially bargained-for diversionary arrangements. The label attached to a disposition may not answer the entire favorable-termination inquiry.
-
Greater importance of other elements: Probable cause, malice, defendants’ involvement, qualifying liberty restraints, and applicable immunity defenses remain substantial obstacles. Favorable termination establishes neither fabrication nor wrongful prosecution.
-
More particularized warrant pleading: Plaintiffs alleging fabricated warrant applications must identify material falsehoods and supporting facts, rather than rely on generalized accusations of dishonesty.
-
Protection against procedural surprise: Dismissal on unbriefed grounds may be sustainable after appellate review, but withholding a meaningful opportunity to amend can still constitute an abuse of discretion.
-
Limited reach beyond federal claims: The holding concerns favorable termination for Section 1983 malicious prosecution. It does not purport to rewrite every requirement of New York’s state-law tort.
Important matters remain unresolved: conditional ACODs, the adequacy of any amended allegations, individual defendants’ ultimate liability, municipal liability, and any eventual qualified-immunity defenses.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Section 1983
- A federal vehicle for seeking relief when someone acting under state authority violates a federal right. It does not make every wrongful act a constitutional violation.
- ACOD
- A pause in a criminal case intended to lead to dismissal. It is not a guilty plea or an acquittal. The completed, unconditional dismissal in this case qualified as favorable termination.
- Favorable termination
- The requirement that the criminal proceeding end in a manner permitting a later malicious prosecution claim. Here, an affirmative declaration of innocence was unnecessary.
- Probable cause
- A reasonable factual basis to believe an offense occurred. It is substantially less demanding than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Post-arraignment liberty restraint
- A qualifying restriction after the formal charging appearance, such as detention or required court attendance. An earlier arrest alone does not satisfy this element.
- Corrected affidavit analysis
- A test asking whether the warrant would still have probable cause after correcting material falsehoods or omissions.
- Qualified immunity
- A protection potentially available to officials sued for damages when their conduct did not violate clearly established law. The court discussed, but did not decide, that defense here.
- Sua sponte dismissal
- Dismissal initiated by the court rather than requested by a party. Nonfrivolous claims ordinarily should not be dismissed this way without notice.
- Without prejudice
- A dismissal that does not itself prevent refiling in an appropriate court, subject to applicable procedural requirements and defenses.
8. Conclusion
Brill v. Ulster County brings the Second Circuit’s ACOD doctrine into line with the Supreme Court’s termination-without-conviction standard. Brill’s unconditional dismissal satisfied favorable termination even though it did not establish innocence.
That doctrinal success did not establish a viable malicious prosecution claim: the complaint still lacked a post-arraignment liberty restraint. The decision’s broader significance lies in combining a less restrictive termination rule with continued enforcement of substantive pleading requirements—and a meaningful opportunity to correct deficiencies first identified without adequate notice.