Montana Case Commentaries

Gravamen Over Label: Statute of Limitations Determination in Tin Cup County Water v. Garden City

Date: Dec 17, 2008

Gravamen Over Label: Statute of Limitations Determination in Tin Cup County Water v. Garden City Introduction The case of Tin Cup County Water and/or Sewer District v. Garden City Plumbing Heating,...

Reformation of Warranty Deed via Mutual Mistake: Thibodeau and Gillies v. Bechtolds

Date: Dec 10, 2008

Reformation of Warranty Deed via Mutual Mistake: Thibodeau and Gillies v. Bechtolds Introduction The case of Thibodeau and Gillies v. Bechtolds addresses critical issues surrounding the reformation...

Montana v. Cotterell: Upholding Evidence from Aerial Surveillance and Public Communication Channels

Date: Dec 10, 2008

Montana v. Cotterell: Upholding Evidence from Aerial Surveillance and Public Communication Channels Introduction State of Montana v. Sam Cotterell is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Contributory Negligence in Nondelegable Duty Context: Olson v. Shumaker Trucking

Date: Nov 19, 2008

Montana Supreme Court Upholds Contributory Negligence in Nondelegable Duty Context: Olson v. Shumaker Trucking Introduction In the landmark case of Cody J. Olson v. Shumaker Trucking and Excavating...

Limits on Prosecutorial Commentary and Application of Rape Shield Law in State v. Lindberg

Date: Nov 19, 2008

Limits on Prosecutorial Commentary and Application of Rape Shield Law in State v. Lindberg Introduction State of Montana v. Lawrence Rolan Lindberg is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Interlocutory Orders and Appealability: Insights from Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. v. Bodell

Date: Oct 30, 2008

Interlocutory Orders and Their Appealability: An Analysis of Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. v. Bodell Introduction The case of Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Company v. Brian L. Bodell,...

Due Process and Unnecessary Delay in Probation Revocation: Insights from West v. Montana

Date: Oct 10, 2008

Due Process and Unnecessary Delay in Probation Revocation: Insights from West v. Montana Introduction In the landmark case of STATE OF MONTANA v. Dennis Eugene West, the Supreme Court of Montana...

Montana Supreme Court Rules on Contract Ambiguity in Aircraft Sale Dispute

Date: Aug 13, 2008

Montana Supreme Court Rules on Contract Ambiguity in Aircraft Sale Dispute Introduction The dispute between Corporate Air and Edwards Jet Center, Inc. reached the Supreme Court of Montana after a...

State v. Hayden: Upholding Jury Integrity Against Prosecutorial Misconduct

Date: Aug 6, 2008

State v. Hayden: Upholding Jury Integrity Against Prosecutorial Misconduct Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Clyde William Hayden, Sr. (345 Mont. 252) dealt with significant issues...

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Admissibility of Prior Dealings in Insurance Contract and UTPA Claims: Lorang v. Fortis

Date: Jul 18, 2008

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Admissibility of Prior Dealings in Insurance Contract and UTPA Claims: Lorang v. Fortis Introduction The case of John and Bonnie Lorang v. Fortis Insurance Company,...

Montana Supreme Court Revises Understanding of Statutory Time Bars in Post-Conviction Relief – Davis v. Montana

Date: Jun 25, 2008

Montana Supreme Court Revises Understanding of Statutory Time Bars in Post-Conviction Relief – Davis v. Montana Introduction The case of George H. Davis v. State of Montana (344 Mont. 300),...

Interpretation of "Political Actions" under § 87-1-204, MCA: Montana Supreme Court Upholds Narrow Construction

Date: Jun 4, 2008

Interpretation of "Political Actions" under § 87-1-204, MCA: Montana Supreme Court Upholds Narrow Construction Introduction In the landmark case of Montana Sports Shooting Association, Inc., and Gary...

Strickland Standard Reaffirmed in Montana: Whitlow v. State of Montana

Date: Apr 23, 2008

Strickland Standard Reaffirmed in Montana: Whitlow v. State of Montana Introduction Whitlow v. State of Montana, 343 Mont. 90 (2008), is a pivotal case in Montana's appellate jurisprudence concerning...

Clarification of Motion to Dismiss Standards and Parole-Eligibility Restrictions in Montana's State v. Rosling

Date: Feb 27, 2008

Clarification of Motion to Dismiss Standards and Parole-Eligibility Restrictions in Montana's State v. Rosling Introduction State of Montana v. Jared Lee Rosling is a significant judicial decision...

State of Montana v. Dunn: Limits on Reasonable Expectation of Privacy in Warrantless Property Searches

Date: Nov 14, 2007

State of Montana v. Dunn: Limits on Reasonable Expectation of Privacy in Warrantless Property Searches Introduction In State of Montana v. Charles Robert Dunn, the Supreme Court of Montana addressed...

Exigent Circumstances and Warrantless Entry in Arson Investigations: Analysis of State v. Robert L. Lewis

Date: Nov 9, 2007

Exigent Circumstances and Warrantless Entry in Arson Investigations: Analysis of State of Montana v. Robert L. Lewis Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Robert L. Lewis, 340 Mont. 10 (2007),...

Affirmation of Consent Search and Rule 404(b) Evidence Admissibility in Negligent Homicide Cases

Date: Oct 20, 2007

Affirmation of Consent Search and Rule 404(b) Evidence Admissibility in Negligent Homicide Cases Introduction The case State of Montana v. Sabine Halvorson Bieber (2007) represents a significant...

Southwick v. State of Montana: Exception to Res Judicata in Criminal Sentencing

Date: Oct 10, 2007

Southwick v. State of Montana: Exception to Res Judicata in Criminal Sentencing Introduction State of Montana v. Paul Jay Southwick is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of Montana on...

Affirmation of Drug Possession Conviction: Montana Supreme Court Reiterates Standards for Ineffective Assistance and Cumulative Error

Date: Sep 26, 2007

Affirmation of Drug Possession Conviction: Montana Supreme Court Reiterates Standards for Ineffective Assistance and Cumulative Error Introduction The case of State of Montana v. Paul Laszlo Racz...

Montana Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Compliance with §41-3-609 in Terminating Parental Rights

Date: Sep 26, 2007

Montana Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Compliance with §41-3-609 in Terminating Parental Rights Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana, in the case of In the Matter of D.B. and D.B., Youths In...