Florida Case Commentaries

Reciprocity of Attorney's Fee Provisions in Foreclosure Actions: Insights from TERRI P. PAGE v. DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS

Date: Jan 1, 2021

Reciprocity of Attorney's Fee Provisions in Foreclosure Actions: Insights from TERRI P. PAGE v. DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS Introduction TERRI P. PAGE, Petitioner, v. DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST...

Florida Supreme Court Restricts Comparative Proportionality Review in Death Penalty Cases

Date: Oct 30, 2020

Florida Supreme Court Restricts Comparative Proportionality Review in Death Penalty Cases Introduction The case of Jonathan Huey LAWRENCE v. STATE of Florida (308 So. 3d 544) represents a pivotal...

Establishing Foundations for Business Records: Insights from Jackson v. Household Finance Corp III

Date: Jul 3, 2020

Establishing Foundations for Business Records: Insights from Jackson v. Household Finance Corp III Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the case of Cynthia L. Jackson, et al. v. Household...

Dismissal of Wheeler's Appeal Due to Lack of Jurisdiction: Establishing Standards for Reviewing Unelaborated Court Orders

Date: Jun 12, 2020

Dismissal of Wheeler's Appeal Due to Lack of Jurisdiction: Establishing Standards for Reviewing Unelaborated Court Orders Introduction In the landmark case of Jimmy Lee Wheeler v. State of Florida,...

Florida Supreme Court Abandons Special Appellate Standard for Circumstantial Evidence in Death Penalty Cases

Date: May 15, 2020

Florida Supreme Court Abandons Special Appellate Standard for Circumstantial Evidence in Death Penalty Cases Introduction In the landmark case of Sean Alonzo Bush v. State of Florida, the Supreme...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Benjamin Davis Smiley, Jr. v. State of Florida

Date: May 15, 2020

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Benjamin Davis Smiley, Jr. v. State of Florida Introduction In the case of Benjamin Davis Smiley, Jr., Appellant, v. State of Florida, Appellee (295 So. 3d 156), the...

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Eighth Amendment Application in Juvenile Sentencing: Pedroza v. State of Florida

Date: Mar 13, 2020

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Eighth Amendment Application in Juvenile Sentencing: Pedroza v. State of Florida Introduction Linda Pedroza v. State of Florida, 291 So. 3d 541 (Fla. 2020), represents...

Partial Reversal of Hurst v. State: Upholding Jury Unanimity for Aggravating Factors in Death Penalty Sentencing

Date: Jan 24, 2020

Partial Reversal of Hurst v. State: Upholding Jury Unanimity for Aggravating Factors in Death Penalty Sentencing Introduction The case of State of Florida v. Mark Anthony Poole (297 So. 3d 487)...

Clarifying Appealability of Nonfinal Orders Denying Sovereign Immunity Under Florida Rule 9.130

Date: Jan 24, 2020

Clarifying Appealability of Nonfinal Orders Denying Sovereign Immunity Under Florida Rule 9.130 Introduction The case of Florida Highway Patrol v. Lashonta Renea Jackson, decided by the Supreme Court...

Interpretation of "All Terms of Sentence" in Florida's Voting Restoration Amendment 4: Inclusion of Legal Financial Obligations

Date: Jan 17, 2020

Interpretation of "All Terms of Sentence" in Florida's Voting Restoration Amendment 4: Inclusion of Legal Financial Obligations Introduction In the landmark advisory opinion issued on January 16,...

Preclusion of Subsequent Requests for Investigative Costs: Florida Supreme Court in Richards v. State

Date: Jan 17, 2020

Preclusion of Subsequent Requests for Investigative Costs: Florida Supreme Court in Richards v. State Introduction In the landmark case of Ronald J. Richards v. State of Florida, decided by the...

Knight v. State: Florida Supreme Court Recedes from Jury Pardon Doctrine in Fundamental Error Analysis

Date: Dec 20, 2019

Knight v. State: Florida Supreme Court Recedes from Jury Pardon Doctrine in Fundamental Error Analysis Introduction Knight v. State, 286 So. 3d 147 (Fla. 2019), represents a pivotal moment in Florida...

DAILEY v. STATE of Florida: Reinforcement of Standards for Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases

Date: Nov 13, 2019

DAILEY v. STATE of Florida: Reinforcement of Standards for Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases Introduction In James Milton DAILEY v. STATE of Florida, decided on November 12, 2019, by the Supreme...

Supreme Court Clarifies Non-Applicability of Email Service Requirements for Settlement Proposals Under Florida Statutes

Date: Jan 5, 2019

Settlement Proposals Not Subject to Email Service Requirements of FL Rule 2.516: Supreme Court Establishes Clear Distinction Introduction The case of Sandra Kent Wheaton v. Mardella Wheaton, decided...

Deductible Application in PIP Claims: Progressive Select Ins. Co. v. Florida Hospital Medical Center

Date: Dec 29, 2018

Deductible Application in PIP Claims: Progressive Select Insurance Company v. Florida Hospital Medical Center Introduction The case of Progressive Select Insurance Company v. Florida Hospital Medical...

Franklin v. State: Upholding Juvenile Life Sentences with Parole Eligibility under the Eighth Amendment

Date: Nov 9, 2018

Franklin v. State: Upholding Juvenile Life Sentences with Parole Eligibility under the Eighth Amendment Introduction Franklin v. State, 258 So. 3d 1239 (Fla. 2018), is a landmark decision by the...

Florida Supreme Court Upholds No Cap on Noneconomic Damages for Independent Adult Children in Wrongful Death Cases

Date: Sep 21, 2018

Florida Supreme Court Upholds No Cap on Noneconomic Damages for Independent Adult Children in Wrongful Death Cases Introduction In the landmark case of Gwendolyn E. Odom, etc., Petitioner, v. R.J....

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Insights from Gonzalez v. State

Date: Sep 14, 2018

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Insights from Gonzalez v. State Introduction Gonzalez v. State, 253 So.3d 526 (Fla. 2018) is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida that delves...

De Novo Review for Presuit Expert Qualifications in Florida Medical Malpractice: Morris v. Muniz

Date: Sep 7, 2018

De Novo Review for Presuit Expert Qualifications in Florida Medical Malpractice: Morris v. Muniz Introduction The case of Tuyuana L. Morris v. Orlando S. Muniz, M.D., et al., adjudicated by the...

Enhanced Suspension Imposed for Professional Misconduct in Florida Bar v. Madsen Marcellus, Jr.

Date: Jul 20, 2018

Enhanced Suspension Imposed for Professional Misconduct in Florida Bar v. Madsen Marcellus, Jr. Introduction In the landmark case of Florida Bar v. Madsen Marcellus, Jr., the Supreme Court of Florida...