Florida Case Commentaries

Abrogation of Legislative and Governmental Immunity under Florida's Firearms Preemption Statute

Date: Jan 20, 2023

Abrogation of Legislative and Governmental Immunity under Florida's Firearms Preemption Statute Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida's landmark decision in Nicole “Nikki” Fried, etc.,...

Supreme Court of Florida Clarifies Formation of Binding Settlement Agreements under section 768.79

Date: Oct 21, 2022

Supreme Court of Florida Clarifies Formation of Binding Settlement Agreements under section 768.79 Introduction The case of Suarez Trucking FL Corp., et al. v. Adam J. Souders, et al. (350 So. 3d 38)...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Harmless Error Standard for Erroneous Denial of Judicial Disqualification Motions

Date: Sep 9, 2022

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Harmless Error Standard for Erroneous Denial of Judicial Disqualification Motions Introduction The case of Joshua Davis v. State of Florida, decided by the Supreme...

Defining "Purchase" in Florida's Drug Trafficking Law: Supreme Court of Florida Sets New Precedent

Date: Aug 26, 2022

Defining "Purchase" in Florida's Drug Trafficking Law: Supreme Court of Florida Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of Michael Anthony Conage v. United States of America (346 So. 3d 594)...

Prudence in Utility Cost Recovery: Insights from Duke Energy Florida v. Clark

Date: Jul 8, 2022

Prudence in Utility Cost Recovery: Insights from Duke Energy Florida v. Clark Introduction The case of Duke Energy Florida, LLC v. Gary F. Clark, et al., decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on...

Double Jeopardy Violation in DUI Offenses: Velazco v. State Establishes Degree-Variant Exception

Date: Jul 1, 2022

Double Jeopardy Violation in DUI Offenses: Velazco v. State Establishes Degree-Variant Exception Introduction Robert Velazco v. State of Florida is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Florida...

Reaffirming the Prejudice Standard for Midtrial Amendments: Thach v. State

Date: Jul 1, 2022

Reaffirming the Prejudice Standard for Midtrial Amendments: Thach v. State Introduction In the landmark case of Ngoc C. Thach v. State of Florida, the Supreme Court of Florida addressed a pivotal...

Exclusive Jurisdiction under Florida Workers' Compensation Law: LabCorp v. Davis

Date: May 27, 2022

Exclusive Jurisdiction under Florida Workers' Compensation Law: LabCorp v. Davis Introduction The case of Laboratory Corporation of America, et al. v. Patty Davis, et al. (339 So. 3d 318) adjudicated...

Affirmation of Standards for Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases: VALENTINE v. STATE

Date: Apr 8, 2022

Affirmation of Standards for Postconviction Relief in Capital Cases: VALENTINE v. STATE Introduction Terance VALENTINE v. STATE of Florida is a significant case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Discretionary Pretrial Detention Standards for Capital Offenses

Date: Mar 18, 2022

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Discretionary Pretrial Detention Standards for Capital Offenses Introduction The case of Brandon Thourtman v. Daniel Junior, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Supreme Court of Florida Reaffirms Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Postconviction Relief

Date: Mar 11, 2022

Supreme Court of Florida Reaffirms Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Postconviction Relief Introduction In the case of Billy Jim Sheppard, Jr. v. State of Florida, the Supreme Court...

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Mandatory County Oversight on Sheriff's Budget Transfers

Date: Jan 28, 2022

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Mandatory County Oversight on Sheriff's Budget Transfers Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida delivered a pivotal decision in Alachua County, Florida, etc.,...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Fundamental Error Standard for Unpreserved Ineffective Assistance Claims in Direct Appeals

Date: Nov 11, 2021

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Fundamental Error Standard for Unpreserved Ineffective Assistance Claims in Direct Appeals Introduction The case of Henry Martin Steiger v. State of Florida (328 So....

No Fundamental Error Exception to Appellate Preservation Requirements for Involuntary Pleas: Florida Supreme Court Rules in State of Florida v. Dortch

Date: May 21, 2021

No Fundamental Error Exception to Appellate Preservation Requirements for Involuntary Pleas: Florida Supreme Court Rules in State of Florida v. Dortch Introduction In the landmark case of State of...

Affirmation of Summary Denial in Boyd v. State Establishes Rigorous Standards for Postconviction Relief Claims of Juror Misconduct

Date: May 14, 2021

Affirmation of Summary Denial in Boyd v. State Establishes Rigorous Standards for Postconviction Relief Claims of Juror Misconduct Introduction The case of Lucious Boyd v. State of Florida (324 So....

Florida's Adoption of Federal Summary Judgment Standards: Comprehensive Commentary

Date: Apr 30, 2021

Florida's Adoption of Federal Summary Judgment Standards: Comprehensive Commentary Introduction On April 29, 2021, the Supreme Court of Florida issued a landmark decision in In re Amendments to...

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Lowest Permissible Sentence as Individual Minimum in Multiple Convictions Sentencing

Date: Apr 9, 2021

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Lowest Permissible Sentence as Individual Minimum in Multiple Convictions Sentencing Introduction The case of State of Florida v. Ridge Gabriel (314 So. 3d 1243)...

Florida Adopts Federal Summary Judgment Standard: Insights from Wilsonart, LLC v. Lopez

Date: Jan 1, 2021

Florida Adopts Federal Summary Judgment Standard: Insights from Wilsonart, LLC v. Lopez Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida's decision in Wilsonart, LLC, et al. v. Miguel Lopez, etc., 308 So....

Reciprocal Attorney's Fees in Account Stated Actions under Florida Statute 57.105(7)

Date: Jan 1, 2021

Reciprocal Attorney's Fees in Account Stated Actions under Florida Statute 57.105(7) Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida's decision in Eugene Ham III, Petitioner, v. Portfolio Recovery...

Florida Aligns Summary Judgment Standard with Federal Law

Date: Jan 1, 2021

Florida Aligns Summary Judgment Standard with Federal Law Introduction In the landmark decision In Re: Amendments to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.510 (309 So. 3d 192, 2020), the Supreme Court of...