ORDERS that Plaintiff file by noon on Friday, July 18, 2025, both: (1) an appearance from new counsel; and (2) proof of filings dismissing the wrongful death claims in the New York and Pennsylvania cases. If Plaintiff fails to file either of these documents, the Court will dismiss this case for want of prosecution."); accord ECF 43 (in the order conditionally granting the First Amended Complaint, recalling that, prior to the amendment, failure to file proof of dismissal of the wrongful death claims in the New York Case and the Pennsylvania Case would result in sanctions, including potentially dismissal). Outside of explicit warnings, Powers was also repeatedly informed by the Court that she would not be permitted to pursue a wrongful death claim in multiple lawsuits across different states, and then later repeatedly informed that she "[would] not be permitted to pursue a wrongful death case against [CCF], directly or indirectly" because she would not be permitted to continue equivocating or otherwise changing where she wanted to
20
pursue a wrongful death claim. Minutes of Proceedings, Powers v. Cleveland Clinic Found., No. 1:22-cv-00198 (N.D. Ohio Jan. 12, 2026).
Finally, the fourth factor asks whether the Court considered lesser sanctions. Indeed, the Court previously imposed lesser sanctions against Powers for her conduct. ECF 43, at 10; ECF 49. Powers' continued misconduct leaves the Court with "no alternative sanction [to] protect the integrity of the pretrial process." Schafer, 529 F.3d at 738 (cleaned up) (quoting Wu, 420 F.3d at
644).
III. CONCLUSION
The Court is mindful that Powers lost her husband, and that is why the Court has bent over backwards for nearly six years to allow Powers to pursue her claim against CCF. However, Powers' actions over the course of the litigation, and especially over the last year, have demonstrated a "clear record of contumacious conduct." Wu, 420 F.3d at 643; see also Webster's Third New International Dictionary 497 (1986) (defining "contumacious" as "perverse in resisting authority" and "stubbornly disobedient"). All four of the equitable factors weigh in favor of dismissal.
Accordingly, the Court hereby GRANTS CCF's Motion under Rule 41(b). Powers' First Amended Complaint is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Date: April 1, 2026 /s/ Dan Aaron Polster Dan Aaron Polster
United States District Judge