II. T HE COMMISSION DID NOT ERR IN ORDERING EMPLOYER TO
REIMBURSE NARCISO FOR EMPLOYER'S UNPAID PROPORTIONATE
SHARE OF THE LEGAL EXPENSES
¶43 Employer next contends that the Commission erred by affirming the ALJ's order that Employer make what it calls an
"advance of benefits" in the amount of $571,523.29 because these
"benefits" are "not vested" until they have been incurred. Narciso responds that this order was proper because it required "that Employer first reimburse [Narciso] for [its] proportionate share of the costs of the third party settlement before being entitled to offset those settlement proceeds [and] did not require any 'advance' to [him] of future benefits." We agree with Narciso, reject Employer's arguments, and allow the order to stand.
¶44 This issue arose because all legal expenses of the third- party action were already paid by Narciso from the recovery. Once the ALJ determined on remand that Employer's proportionate share of the legal costs was "more than 100%," Employer became responsible for the entirety of those expenses, creating a credit owed to Narciso. See U TAH CODE § 34A-2-106(5)(a)(ii); see also Esquivel v. Lab. Comm'n, 2000 UT 66, ¶¶ 28-29, 7 P.3d 777 (explaining that where the employee's heirs paid all expenses out of the recovery, the insurer owed them a "credit" for its share of the expenses). Applying subsection 34A-2-106(5)(b), the ALJ then took the total amount of past benefits already paid to Narciso ($1,578,095.60) for which Employer was entitled to reimbursement and subtracted the total legal expenses for which it was responsible ($2,149,618.89), leaving $571,523.29 as a credit owed to Narciso for Employer's unpaid proportionate share of fees. Consistent with our direction in Esquivel, the ALJ then ordered Employer to pay Narciso for the credit owed. See Esquivel, 2000 UT 66, ¶ 31. ¶45 Therefore, when Employer was ordered to pay $571,523.29, Employer was not ordered to advance benefits; it was ordered to reimburse Narciso for its proportionate share of legal expenses. And we have explained that while "a third-party recovery must . . . offset for future liability of sums owed, . . . the employer or insurer must first bear [its] proportionate share of the expenses for obtaining the recovery." Id. ¶ 23. The reimbursement order required Employer to do just that. We thus reject all of Employer's arguments based on the flawed premise that the order
13
AUTO OWNERS INSURANCE v. LABOR COMMISSION Opinion of the Court
14
required Employer to advance benefits, and we do not disturb the Commission's decision.9
CONCLUSION
¶46 We hold that where, as here, an employer or insurance carrier seeks both reimbursement and offset under Utah Code subsection 34A-2-106(5), its proportionate share of the legal expenses of the injured employee's third-party action includes consideration of both past and future benefits. We also hold that where, as here, an employee has paid all legal expenses, the employer or insurance carrier must bear its proportionate share of expenses before offsetting future benefits against the tort recovery. Accordingly, we allow the Commission's decisions to stand. __________________________________________________________
14