FOURTH DIVISION
MERCIER, C. J.,
DILLARD, P. J., and LAND, J. NOTICE: Motions for reconsideration must be physically received in our clerk's office within ten days of the date of decision to be deemed timely filed. https://www.gaappeals.us/rules
June 17, 2025
In the Court of Appeals of Georgia A25A0607. BLUE 42 ORGANICS, LLC v. GEORGIA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY.
DILLARD, Presiding Judge. Blue 42 Organics, LLC filed a lawsuit against the Department of Public Safety,1 alleging it suffered compensable damage to its property as a result of a DPS drug- interdiction operation. DPS moved to dismiss, arguing the alleged property damage occurred during the exercise of its police powers, and so the doctrine of sovereign immunity barred Blue 42's claim. The trial court agreed and granted DPS's motion. On appeal, Blue 42 contends the trial court erred in dismissing its complaint, arguing
1
DPS's actions did not constitute a valid exercise of police power, and therefore, its claim was not barred by sovereign immunity. For the following reasons, we affirm. A motion to dismiss asserting sovereign immunity is based on the trial court's
"lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, rather than the merits of the plaintiff's claim."2 Put another way, sovereign immunity is not "an affirmative defense, going to the merits of the case, but raises the issue of the trial court's subject matter jurisdiction to try the case."3Significantly, a waiver of sovereign immunity "must be established by the party seeking to benefit from that waiver; thus, the plaintiffs have the burden
2 Alred v. Ga. Public Defender Council, 362 Ga. App. 465, 465-66 (869 SE2d 99) (2022) (punctuation omitted); accord Dep't of Pub. Safety v. Justice, 320 Ga. 149, 153 (907 SE2d 817) (2024); State v. Fed. Def. Program, Inc., 315 Ga. 319, 343 (882 SE2d
2
of establishing waiver of sovereign immunity."4And so, when reviewing a trial court's ruling on a motion to dismiss on this basis, we do so "de novo while sustaining factual findings if they are supported by any evidence."5
Bearing this legal backdrop in mind, the record shows that Blue 42 is a licensed hemp grower in Georgia and operates a licensed hemp farm in Dahlonega that is properly registered with both the Georgia Department of Agriculture and the United States Department of Agriculture. On July 21, 2021, DPS—acting through the Governor's Drug Suppression Task Force—conducted a drug-suppression operation in the Dahlonega area. During this operation, three helicopters and one single engine fixed wing aircraft flew over Blue 42's farm at an altitude so low that they destroyed two rows of legally registered hemp crops valued at approximately $37,000. Blue 42 filed suit against DPS, alleging claims of inverse condemnation and private nuisance based on the damage to its hemp crops. DPS answered and moved
3
to dismiss, arguing the doctrine of sovereign immunity barred both of Blue 42's claims. Blue 42 then amended its complaint, alleging only a claim for inverse condemnation. DPS renewed its motion to dismiss, again arguing that sovereign immunity barred the inverse-condemnation claim, and Blue 42 filed a response. Ultimately, the trial court granted DPS's motion to dismiss, finding that sovereign immunity barred the claim for inverse condemnation because the alleged damages stemmed from the state's exercise of its police power. This appeal follows. Blue 42 claims the trial court erred in dismissing its complaint, arguing DPS's actions were not a valid exercise of police power, and so its inverse-condemnation claim was not barred by sovereign immunity. We disagree.
Inverse-condemnation claims "draw their meaning and remedies from the eminent domain provisions in the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution and Article I, Section III, Paragraph I of the Georgia Constitution, each of which protects against uncompensated 'takings.'"6More precisely, inverse condemnation
4
is an action "brought by a private landowner under the [eminent-domain provisions] alleging the taking or damaging of the private property for public purposes without the initiation of eminent domain proceedings."7And significantly, the Supreme Court of Georgia has held that "sovereign immunity is waived when a private property owner asserts a claim for inverse condemnation[.]"8
That said, our cases have articulated a distinction "between eminent domain and the police power; the two powers serve a different set of purposes and are subject to different limitations."9The police power of a governing authority is "properly used
5
to regulate property to prevent its use in a manner detrimental to the public interest, while the exercise of eminent domain involves the taking of property because it is needed for public use."10But the constitutional provision prohibiting "the taking of private property for a public purpose without compensation has no relevance to the exercise of the police power by the state or its political subdivisions."11And the police power is that power "by which the Government may destroy or regulate the use of property in order to promote the health, morals[,] and safety of the community, and
6
the police power may be exercised without making compensation for the impairment of the use of property or any decrease in the value of property."12 Here, Blue 42 alleged in its complaint that DPS—acting through the Governor's Drug Suppression Task Force—conducted a drug-suppression operation, during which low-flying aircraft destroyed part of its hemp crop. This allegation indicates that Blue 42's property was damaged by an exercise of police power. Even so, Blue 42 counters that because it was operating a legal hemp farm, DPS's conduct was an invalid exercise of police power. But this argument essentially seeks to impose a requirement that police power must be flawlessly executed for sovereign immunity to apply. That is not the law. To the contrary, in describing the police power, we have explained that "[t]he safeguarding of society by the prosecution of crimes against it is a sovereign attribute inherent in all governments, and for mistakes in exercising this sovereign right there can be no liability against the government without its consent."13 Given these circumstances, Blue 42's amended complaint alleges no evidence that
7
would allow it to avoid sovereign immunity and obtain relief from DPS.14The trial court did not err, then, in granting DPS's motion to dismiss.15 Judgment affirmed. Mercier, C.J., and Land, J., concur.
8