AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Acts

IN RE: ORDER AMENDING RULES 1206, 1208, 1209, 1210, AND 1211 OF THE PENNSYLVANIA RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE GOVERNING ACTIONS AND PROCEEDINGS BEFORE MAGISTERIAL DISTRICT JUDGES

PER CURIAM

MAGISTERIAL RULES DOCKET

ORDER

PER CURIAM

AND NOW, this 8th day of January, 2025, upon the recommendation of the Minor Court Rules Committee; the proposal having been published for public comment at 49 Pa.B. 1772 (April 13, 2019) and 53 Pa.B. 707 (February 4, 2023):

It is Ordered pursuant to Article V, Section 10 of the Constitution of Pennsylvania that Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure Governing Actions and Proceedings Before Magisterial District Judges 1206, 1208, 1209, 1210, and 1211 are amended in the attached form.

This Order shall be processed in accordance with Pa.R.J.A. 103(b), and shall be effective July 1, 2025.

Rule 1206. Commencement of Proceedings.

[A.](a) Petition.

(1) A proceeding for emergency relief [(1)] from abuse [,] or [(2)] in connection with claims of sexual violence or intimidation shall be commenced by the filing of a petition by the plaintiff with the hearing officer on a form that shall be prescribed by the State Court Administrator.
(2) The petition shall be signed by the plaintiff and shall set forth the names and addresses of the plaintiff and the defendant and the names, addresses , and ages of any person on whose behalf the plaintiff is seeking relief.
(3) The plaintiff shall [also] allege in the petition, in general terms, the cause for seeking emergency relief.
[B.] (b)[Upon issuance of an emergency order, the hearing officer shall provide the plaintiff with instructions regarding the commencement of proceedings in the court of common pleas and regarding the procedures for initiating a contempt charge should the defendant violate the emergency order. The hearing officer shall also advise the plaintiff of the existence of rape crisis centers in the county or in nearby counties in the case of sexual violence, as well as programs for victims of domestic or sexual violence in the county or in nearby counties and inform the plaintiff of the availability of legal assistance without cost if the plaintiff is unable to pay therefor.] Rescinded.
[C.] (c)Costs. The petition shall be filed and service shall be made without prepayment of costs.
[Official Note: Paragraph B is added to assure compliance with the requirement of Section 6110(d) of the Protection From Abuse Act, 23 Pa.C.S. § 6110(d), as well as 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(d). Practice varies among the judicial districts as to what procedures the plaintiff must follow to continue in effect a protection order in the court of common pleas upon the certification of an emergency protection order to the court of common pleas. The hearing officer should provide clear instructions to the plaintiff as to what must be done to continue in effect the protection order in the court of common pleas. See Rule 1210 and Note and Rule 1211 and Note.] Comment: Former subdivision (b), pertaining to instructions that the hearing officer must provide the plaintiff if a petition is granted, was rescinded and relocated to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(3). [Paragraph C] Subdivision (c) is derived from [Section 6106(b) of the Protection From Abuse Act,] 23 Pa.C.S. § 6106(b)[, as well as] and 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A05(b) [, and reflects the practice when a temporary order is issued at the common pleas level]. Compare Pa.R.Civ.P. 1901.3(c) and 1953(c) (petitions for protective relief filed with the court of common pleas).

The filings required by this rule are subject to the Case Records Public Access Policy of the Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania. See [Rule 217] Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 217.

Historical Commentary

The following commentary is historical in nature and represents statements of the Committee at the time of rulemaking:

EXPLANATORY COMMENT--1992

The responsibilities of Hearing Officers to the plaintiff have been increased as a result of the amendments to the Protection from Abuse Act, 23 Pa.C.S.A., Section 6110(d). When issuing an emergency order, Hearing Officers must advise the plaintiff of the existence of programs for victims of domestic violence in the county or in nearby counties and they must inform the plaintiff of the availability of legal assistance without cost if the plaintiff is unable to pay for them. Rule 1206, through the inclusion of Subdivision B, conforms the Rule to this particular statutory provision; and the amendment to the Note simply provides the justification for Subdivision B, i.e., to assure compliance with the Title 23 provisions of the Protection from Abuse Act.

Rule 1208. [Findings and Protection Orders] Protection Orders; Findings; Instructions to Plaintiff; Denial of Petition.

[A.](a) Petition Granted.

(1) Order Issued.
(i) Emergency Protection from Abuse. If the hearing officer, upon good cause shown, finds it necessary to protect the plaintiff or minor children from abuse , the hearing officer may grant relief in accordance with [Section 6110(a) of the Protection From Abuse Act,] 23 Pa.C.S. § 6110(a)[, and make] . The hearing officer shall issue any protection orders necessary to effectuate that relief. Immediate and present danger of abuse to the plaintiff or minor children shall constitute good cause.
[(2)] (ii)Emergency Protection from Sexual Violence or Intimidation. If the hearing officer, upon good cause shown, finds it necessary to protect the plaintiff or another individual in connection with claims of sexual violence or intimidation, the hearing officer may grant relief in accordance with 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(a)[, and make] . The hearing officer shall issue any protection orders necessary to effectuate that relief. Immediate and present danger posed by the defendant to the plaintiff or another individual shall constitute good cause.
[B] (2) Findings. The hearing officer shall enter on the petition form the findings and any protection order issued or other action taken.
(3) Instructions. The hearing officer shall instruct the plaintiff regarding:
(i) commencing proceedings in the court of common pleas;
(ii) initiating a contempt charge if the defendant violates the emergency order;
(iii) programs for victims of domestic or sexual violence in the county or in nearby counties, as well as the existence of rape crisis centers in the county or nearby counties in the case of sexual violence; and
(iv) the availability of legal assistance without cost if the plaintiff is without resources to pay.
[B.](b) Petition Denied.
(1) If the hearing officer does not find good cause pursuant to subdivision (a)(1)(i) or (a)(1)(ii), the hearing officer shall deny the petition.
(2) A denied petition shall not be available to the public.
(3) The hearing officer shall:
(i) not issue a written denial order;
(ii) orally inform the plaintiff that the petition is denied;
(iii) confirm that no identifying information relating to the
denied petition, such as the name of the plaintiff or defendant, is made public or retained in court files;
(iv) enter on the docket non-identifying information relating to the petition, including the date of filing, the municipality and zip code of the plaintiff's residence, and the relief sought by the plaintiff; and
(v) destroy the denied petition.

[The hearing officer shall enter on the petition form the findings and any protection orders made or other action taken.]

[Official Note: Subparagraph A(1) of this rule] Comment: Subdivision (a)(1)(i) permits the hearing officer to grant limited relief [in accordance with] pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S. § 6108(a)(1), (2), and (6), or (1) and (6), which includes directing the defendant to refrain from abusing the plaintiff or minor children, possession of the residence, and prohibiting contact by the defendant. [Subparagraph A(2) of this rule] Subdivision (a)(1)(ii) permits the hearing officer to grant limited relief [to plaintiffs in accordance with] pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A07(b) , which includes prohibiting contact by the defendant and any other appropriate relief.

Subdivision (a)(3) is derived from former Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1206(b). Practice varies among the judicial districts regarding procedures to maintain a protection order in the court of common pleas upon the certification of an emergency protection order to that court. See Pa.R.Civ.P. 1210, cmt. and Pa.R.Civ.P. 1211, cmt.

Subdivision (b) provides for denial of a petition for emergency relief. Subdivision (b)(3) is intended to protect the plaintiff's personal safety and the defendant's reputational interest following the denial of a petition for emergency relief.

Historical Commentary

The following commentary is historical in nature and represents statements of the Committee at the time of rulemaking:

EXPLANATORY COMMENT--1992

Hearing Officers' authority to grant relief under the Act has been enlarged under 23 Pa.C.S.A., Section 6108. In accordance with the provisions of the Act, the court may grant any protection order or approve any consent agreement to bring about a cessation of abuse of the plaintiff or minor children. The order or agreement may include the following:

(a)(1) Directing the defendant to refrain from abusing the plaintiff or minor children.
(a)(2) Granting possession to the plaintiff of the residence or household to the exclusion of the defendant by evicting the defendant or restoring possession to the plaintiff when the residence or household is jointly owned or leased by the parties, is owned or leased by the entireties or is owned or leased solely by the plaintiff.
(a)(3) When the defendant has a duty to support the plaintiff or minor children living in the residence or household and the defendant is the sole owner or lessee, granting possession to the plaintiff of the residence or household to the exclusion of the defendant by evicting the defendant or restoring possession to the plaintiff or, by consent agreement, allowing the defendant to provide suitable alternate housing.

Therefore, Rule 1208 incorporates the additional relief remedies available to the Hearing Officer.

Rule 1209. Service and Execution of Emergency Protection Orders. [A.](a) Emergency Protection from Abuse.

(1) Plaintiff. [The] If the hearing officer grants the petition in whole or in part, then the hearing officer shall [provide to] give the plaintiff a copy of [a] the protection order [made under Rule 1208] issued pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(1)(i).
(2) Defendant.
(i) The hearing officer or, when necessary, the plaintiff shall immediately deliver a service copy of [any] the protection order [made under Rule 1208] issued pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(1)(i) to a police officer, police department, sheriff , or certified constable for service upon the defendant and execution.
(ii) After making reasonable effort, if the executing officer is unable to serve the protection order upon the defendant in a timely fashion, the executing officer shall leave a service copy of the petition [form] containing the order with the police department with jurisdiction over the area in which the plaintiff resides for service upon the defendant, and shall advise such police department that the order could not be served.

[B. When a protection order is issued under Rule 1208 in accordance with 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(a), the hearing officer shall:

(1) within two business days, serve the order upon the police department, sheriff and district attorney in the jurisdiction where the order was entered, and
(2) in the case of a minor victim of sexual violence, serve a copy of the petition and order upon the county agency (as defined by 23 Pa.C.S. § 6303) and the Department of Human Services.]

(b) Emergency Protection in Connection with Claims of Sexual Violence or Intimidation.

(1) Plaintiff. If the hearing officer grants the petition in whole or in part, then the hearing officer shall give the plaintiff the protection order issued pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(1)(ii).
(2) Defendant.
(i) The hearing officer or, when necessary, the plaintiff shall immediately deliver a service copy of the protection order issued pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(1)(ii) to a police officer, police department, sheriff, or certified constable for service upon the defendant and execution.
(ii) After making reasonable effort, if the executing officer is unable to serve the protection order upon the defendant in a timely fashion, the executing officer shall leave a service copy of the petition containing the order with the police department with jurisdiction over the area in which the plaintiff resides for service upon the defendant, and shall advise such police department that the order could not be served.
(3) Law Enforcement. Within two business days after the protection order is issued, the hearing officer shall serve the order upon the police department, sheriff, and district attorney in the jurisdiction where the order was entered.
(4) Minor Victims. In the case of a minor victim of sexual violence, the hearing officer shall serve a copy of the petition and order upon the county agency, as defined by 23 Pa.C.S. § 6303, and the Department of Human Services.

[Official Note] Comment: The hearing officer [should] shall provide the plaintiff with at least one copy of [a] the protection order, but more than one copy may be needed. For example, the plaintiff may wish to serve the order upon multiple police departments [when] if the plaintiff lives and works in different police jurisdictions[, etc]. If it is necessary for the plaintiff to deliver the protection order to the executing officer, the hearing officer should make sure that the plaintiff fully understands the process and what must be done to have the order served upon the defendant. [The hearing officer should make every effort to have the protection order served by a law enforcement officer in a timely fashion. The Rule requires that if the executing officer is unable to serve the protection order in a timely fashion, the executing officer shall leave a service

copy of the order with the police department with jurisdiction over the area in which the plaintiff resides. This was thought advisable so that]

Service of protection orders upon the defendant at the time of execution may not be possible under some circumstances. The intention of subdivisions (a)(2)(ii) and (b)(2)(ii) is for the local police [would] to have a service copy [in case] if they [would be] are called to the plaintiff's residence should the defendant return there.

The hearing officer should make every effort to have the protection order served by a law enforcement officer in a timely fashion. [Due to the emergency nature of these] For emergency protection orders [and the fact that] to be meaningful, they must be served and executed at night or on a weekend[,]. Therefore, the hearing officer should have the authority to use police officers [as well as], sheriffs, and certified constables to serve and execute [these] protection orders.

Protection orders issued [under Rule 1208] pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(1)(ii) in accordance with [42 Pa. C.S. § 62A09] 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09, [(]providing for protection of victims of sexual violence or intimidation[)], are subject to additional service requirements. [See Section 6109(a) of the Protection From Abuse Act,] Compare 23 Pa.C.S. § 6109(a)[, and] with 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A05(d).

Service shall be made without prepayment of costs. See [Rule 1206(C)] Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1206(c).

[Service of protection orders upon the defendant at the time of execution may not be possible under some circumstances.]

Rule 1210. Duration of Emergency Protection Orders.

Protection orders issued [under Rule 1208] pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a) shall expire at the end of the next business day the court deems itself available.

[Official Note] Comment: This rule is derived from [Section 6110(b) of the Protection From Abuse Act,] 23 Pa.C.S. § 6110(b)[, as well as] and 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(b). Practice varies among the judicial districts as to what procedures the plaintiff must follow to [continue in effect] maintain a protection order in the court of common pleas upon the certification of an emergency protection order to the court of common pleas. The hearing officer should [provide clear instructions to] instruct the plaintiff [as to] what must be done to [continue in effect] maintain the protection order in the court of common pleas. See [Rule 1206 and Note, and Rule 1211 and Note] Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(3)(i), cmt. and Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1211, cmt.

Historical Commentary

The following commentary is historical in nature and represents statements of the Committee at the time of rulemaking:

EXPLANATORY COMMENT--1992

Initially, the Protection from Abuse Act provided that emergency orders issued by Hearing Officers were to expire at the resumption of business of the court at the beginning of the week or within 72 hours, whichever occurs sooner. This language has been simplified under 23 Pa.C.S.A., Section 6110(b) to provide that said orders expire as of the resumption of business of the court at the beginning of the next business day. Rule 1210 incorporates this simplification.

Rule 1211. Certification to Court of Common Pleas.

[A.] (a) [Any] A protection order issued [under Rule 1208] pursuant to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a), together with any documentation in support thereof, shall immediately be certified to the court of common pleas by the hearing officer.
[B.] (b) Certification [under subdivision A of this Rule] pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be accomplished by sending to the prothonotary of the court by first class mail or messenger a certified copy of the petition form containing the order, with any supporting documentation attached.
[Official Note] Comment: Certification [under subdivision A of this rule] pursuant to subdivision (a) is required by [Section 6110(c) of the Protection From Abuse Act,] 23 Pa.C.S. § 6110(c)[, as well as] and 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(c). This rule is [also] consistent with [Pa.R.C.P. Nos. 1901.3(b) and 1953(b)] Pa.R.Civ.P. 1901.3(b) and 1953(b), which permit commencement of an action by filing with the prothonotary a certified copy of an emergency protection order. However, practice varies among the judicial districts as to how [the] a protection order is [continued in effect] maintained after [it is certified] certification to the court of common pleas. For example, some judicial districts may require that the plaintiff appear in person to continue the action in the court of common pleas. Others may automatically commence an action in the court of common pleas upon receipt of a certified copy of the emergency order from the hearing officer. See [Rule 1206 and Note, and Rule 1210 and Note] Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(3)(i), cmt. and Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1210, cmt.

Depending on local practice, the plaintiff or the plaintiff's representative may act as a messenger under [subdivision B of this rule] subdivision (b).

MINOR COURT PROCEDURAL RULES COMMITTEE ADOPTION REPORT

Amendment of Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1206, 1208, 1209, 1210, and 1211

On January 8, 2025, the Supreme Court amended Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure Governing Actions and Proceedings Before Magisterial District Judges 1206, 1208, 1209, 1210, and 1211. These rule changes relate to orders denying petitions for emergency protective relief. The Minor Court Procedural Rules Committee ("Committee") has prepared this Adoption Report describing the rulemaking process as it relates to these Rules. An Adoption Report should not be confused with Comments to the rules. See Pa.R.J.A. 103, cmt. The statements contained herein are those of the Committee, not the Court.

Background

The Committee received an inquiry from a magisterial district court questioning if a copy of an order denying a petition for emergency protection from abuse should be served on the defendant. The inquirer expressed concern that sending the denial order to the defendant could aggravate tensions between the parties and endanger the plaintiff. The Committee identified no legal authority addressing the issue. This void resulted in divergent local practices in magisterial district courts for processing a denial order-some courts send it to the defendant, others place it in the court's file, while others forward it to the court of common pleas without sending a copy to the defendant. The Committee believed it would be preferable to have a standardized statewide practice for these cases.

After reviewing relevant statutes and rules, as well as the Case Records Public Access Policy of the Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania ("Policy"), the Committee considered the fairness of withholding a denial order from a defendant in an adversarial, albeit ex parte, proceeding when the denial order and underlying petition could be accessed by the public. The Committee further considered the concern raised in the initial inquiry-the potential harm to a plaintiff if the defendant is notified of the denial order. Notifying the defendant of the court's denial order would inform him or her of the plaintiff's attempt to seek emergency protective relief from the court, while leaving the plaintiff without any court-ordered protection. The Committee aimed to balance the safety of plaintiffs seeking emergency protection with the due process rights of defendants.

The Committee published for public comment proposed amendments to rules governing emergency protective actions. See 49 Pa.B. 1772 (April 13, 2019). Proposed amendments to Rule 1209 would have required the hearing officer to send the denial order to the defendant by first class mail no sooner than 48 hours after issuance of the denial order. The 48-hour delay in the mailing of the denial order to the defendant was intended to provide the plaintiff with time to implement a safety plan or seek a temporary protection order from a court of common pleas. Public comment to the proposal was largely negative and expressed concern for the safety of plaintiffs. The Committee revisited the proposal and proceeded to develop an alternative approach.

The Committee next considered that there may be no optimal period to serve the denial order on the defendant such that the plaintiff's safety is not compromised. A defendant receiving a denial order 10, 30, or 60 days after its issuance may be as provoked as a defendant receiving the order 48 hours later. The Committee had no way of knowing if delayed service on the defendant could put the petitioner at risk despite being temporally removed from the incident that precipitated the petition filing. The Committee, therefore, recommended that the denial order not be served on the defendant and that the denial order be deemed a non-public record pursuant to the Policy. However, because a plaintiff would have access to a denial order as a named party, there was a possibility that the order could be used by the plaintiff in a subsequent proceeding without the defendant having even been aware of it. Thus, this approach did not reliably protect the defendant's due process interests. Thereafter, the Committee considered developing a procedure similar to Pa.R.Crim.P. 212(B), pertaining to unexecuted search warrants, whereby the emergency protective petition and denial order are expunged, sealed, or never entered on the docket in the first instance. The Committee considered the impact of proposed revisions on the defendant's rights, the safety of the plaintiff, and the public's interest in access to judicial records.

Discussion

The Committee began its review by weighing the important and competing interests of the plaintiff, the defendant, and the public. The amount of process that is due in any circumstance must be determined by application of the three-part balancing test first established in Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319 (1976). See In re Fortieth Statewide Investigating Grand Jury, 197 A.3d 712, 717 (Pa. 2018). This balancing test considers three factors: (1) the private interest affected by the governmental action; (2) the risk of an erroneous deprivation together with the value of additional or substitute safeguards; and (3) the state interest involved, including the administrative burden the additional or substitute procedural requirements would impose on the state. Id.

The Committee identified competing interests of the parties relating to a denied petition. The plaintiff has a personal safety interest, which could be threatened if the defendant learns of the petition but the plaintiff is not covered by a protective order. The object of the Protection from Abuse Act is self-evident - to protect plaintiffs from abuse. Commonwealth v. Stevenson, 283 A.3d 196, 205 (Pa. 2022). A similar statutory scheme exists for victims of sexual violence and intimidation. See 42 Pa.C.S. §§ 62A01 - 62A20. If a plaintiff seeks an emergency protective order, then the hearing officer conducts ex parte proceedings and may enter an order protecting the plaintiff from immediate and present danger of abuse. 23 Pa.C.S. § 6110(a); 42 Pa.C.S. § 62A09(a).

Superficially, a plaintiff's interest would seem to end when an order denying emergency relief is entered. However, the basis for a denial may not be indicative of the absence of danger of abuse. A plaintiff may not be entitled to relief for other reasons, e.g., a lack of immediacy. A denial does not mean the plaintiff is safe and without the potential of threat. In the view of the Committee, the risk of retaliation for seeking protective relief gives the plaintiff a significant interest in the denial process.

The defendant has a reputational interest that could be adversely impacted if the existence of a petition and denial order is made public. The Court has acknowledged a defendant's right to protect his or her reputation as it relates to expungement of protective orders. See Carlacci v. Mazaleski, 798 A.2d 186 (Pa. 2002). The Court noted that "there exists a right to petition for expungement of a protection from abuse record where the petitioner seeks to protect his reputation. This right is an adjunct of due process and Article I, Section 1 of the Pennsylvania Constitution and is not dependent upon express statutory authority." Id. at 190 (relying on P.E.S. v. K.L., 720 A.2d 487 (Pa. Super. 1998)). In P.E.S. v. K.L., the Superior Court recognized that a dismissed protection from abuse petition could have a negative impact on a defendant: "Although [defendant's] record here is not an arrest record, it, nonetheless, carries with it the potential stigmas associated with such a record. The negative social connotations that attach to the protection from abuse are too great to allow the [defendant's] record to remain intact." 720 A.2d at 492. While case law is silent regarding the expungement of emergency protective orders, the Committee observes there may be an opportunity for reputational harm if the public can access an emergency petition for protective relief that the defendant may not know was filed against him or her. Relatedly, a defendant cannot avail himself or herself of these remedies without notice of the petition or denial order. For these reasons, the Committee believes the defendant has a substantial interest.

In considering alternative procedures or safeguards to accommodate both parties' interests, the Committee considered Pa.R.Crim.P. 212 (Dissemination of Search Warrant Information) as a potential model for the handling of denied protective orders. That rule provides in part: "Unexecuted warrants and the associated affidavits of probable cause are not public records and upon return to the issuing authority the unexecuted warrants and affidavit(s) shall be destroyed by the issuing authority." Pa.R.Crim.P. 212(B). The Committee considered whether Pa.R.Crim.P. 212 would provide a workable framework for denied emergency protective relief. To prevent recording the defendant's identifiable information, a denied petition for emergency protective relief would not be entered on the docket. Likewise, a denial order would not be issued to the plaintiff and the underlying petition destroyed. In this manner, both the plaintiff's safety interest and the defendant's reputational due process interests are secured.

The Committee acknowledges this approach may have ramifications involving other interests, including the public right of access, secondary uses, and data collection. First, the petition and order are part of the record of the case and relied upon by the court in rendering a decision, thereby rendering those documents as a public judicial record. See Commonwealth v. Fenstermaker, 530 A.2d 414, 419 (Pa. 1987). Second, an emergency PFA proceeding is not closed to the public or required to be held in camera even though the public is rarely, if ever, present during these proceedings. Third, the documents are currently publicly available pursuant to the Policy. The contemplated approach would limit the transparency of denied petitions for emergency relief. There would no longer be a record of a denied petition or the order denying relief, which impacts the public's interest.

The parties have a contingent or secondary interest if the record of a denied petition and order are destroyed. Those documents, including any verified statements, may have evidentiary weight in subsequent or future court proceedings, e.g., custody. See also Pa.R.E. 803.1(3) (Recorded Recollection of Declarant-Witness); see also 23 Pa.C.S. § 6117(b) (Remedies for Bad Faith). Moreover, the documents may be relevant to the prosecution or defense of any criminal proceedings as a consequence of, or related to, an allegation of abuse.

Concerning data collection, this approach would impact the data retained in the Magisterial District Justice System ("MDJS") relating to emergency protective relief. To the extent this data may be used in the decennial reestablishment of the magisterial district courts, omitting denied emergency petitions from the MDJS will result in a lower reported case load, thus creating an inaccurate picture of court workloads. See 42 Pa.C.S. § 1503 (pertaining to decennial reestablishment of magisterial district courts). Further, it may be in the public interest to know how many emergency petitions are denied to identify outliers in deciding such petitions. The Committee also believes that funding for domestic violence programs may be tied, in part, to case numbers.

The Committee attempted to address this issue by adding a new requirement that the hearing officer enter on the MDJS docket certain non-identifying information relating to the petition, including the date of filing, the municipality and zip code of the plaintiff, and the relief sought by the plaintiff using a "Jane Doe" docket. See Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(b)(3)(iii). This is a new concept intended to address data integrity concerns that represents an administrative burden in the due process analysis.

Rule Changes

The Committee published a revised proposal at 53 Pa.B. 707 (February 4, 2023). Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208 was amended to address the denial of a petition for emergency protective relief. The amendment is modeled after Pa.R.Crim.P. 212(B) and provides: (1) a denied petition for emergency relief is not available to the public; (2) the hearing officer shall orally inform the plaintiff that the petition is denied; (3) no identifying information relating to the case is retained in court files; (4) non-identifying information is entered on the docket, i.e., "Jane Doe" docket entries; and (5) the petition is destroyed. See Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(b)(3). For the reasons previously discussed, the Committee believes these proposed changes are consistent with protecting the parties' interest.

The Committee also identified other salutary changes to the rules that are being made at this time. First, Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1206B, pertaining to commencement of proceedings, included provisions and instructions following the issuance of the order that appeared misplaced within the rules. Therefore, that subdivision was rescinded and its provisions were relocated to Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1208(a)(3). Amendments to

Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1209 are intended to clarify service and execution procedures when a petition has been granted in whole or in part. Additional stylistic, organizational, and grammatical changes were made throughout proposed Pa.R.Civ.P.M.D.J. 1206 and 1208 - 1211.

These changes are effective July 1, 2025.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

In re Order Amending Rules 1206, 1208, 1209, 1210, & 1211 of the Pa. Rules of Civil Procedure Governing Actions
(Jan 8, 2025)