Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The defendant, Quiana Mathews, pleaded guilty to one count of Conspiracy to Defraud the Government With Respect to Claims under 18 U.S.C. § 286, related to operating a tax preparation business that filed false tax refund claims with the IRS. In October 2020, the Court sentenced her to 72 months imprisonment followed by 3 years of supervised release. She is currently incarcerated at the Federal Correctional Institution (FCI) in Victorville, California.

The defendant filed a motion for compassionate release pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A)(i), as amended by the First Step Act of 2018, arguing for release due to the death of the primary caregiver of her minor children. The Court addressed both procedural exhaustion of administrative remedies and the substantive merits of the motion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant exhausted the administrative remedies required under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A) before filing for compassionate release.
  2. Whether the death of the primary caregiver of the defendant’s minor children constitutes an “extraordinary and compelling” reason justifying compassionate release under the First Step Act and applicable Sentencing Guidelines.
  3. Whether the defendant’s motion for compassionate release is consistent with the sentencing factors under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a).
  4. Whether the defendant’s prior compassionate release motion based on conditions at FCI Aliceville remains viable or is moot following her transfer to FCI Victorville.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contends that compassionate release is warranted due to the death of her mother, who was the primary caregiver for her four minor children during her incarceration.
  • She asserts there is no suitable alternative caregiver for her children and fears that without her release, Children Services might take custody of them.
  • Previously, the defendant also sought compassionate release based on alleged sexual misconduct by staff, intimidation by an inmate, and deficient medical care related to COVID-19 complications while at FCI Aliceville.

Government's Position

  • The Court’s findings reflect that the defendant initially failed to show exhaustion of administrative remedies but later demonstrated compliance by submitting compassionate release requests to the wardens at FCI Aliceville and then FCI Victorville.
  • The Court, relying on verified information from the Probation Office and local child services, found that the defendant’s children are currently living with their father, who is a suitable caregiver, and that Children Services has closed its case without taking custody.
  • The government implicitly contends that because an appropriate caregiver is available, the defendant has not met the burden to establish an extraordinary and compelling reason for release.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
United States v. Jones, 980 F.3d 1098 (6th Cir. 2020) Exhaustion requirement under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A); discretion in defining "extraordinary and compelling" reasons. Used to confirm the procedural exhaustion requirement and the court’s discretion in defining grounds for compassionate release post-First Step Act.
United States v. McCall, 56 F.4th 1048 (6th Cir. 2022) Outlined the three-step inquiry for compassionate release motions: extraordinary and compelling reasons, consistency with Sentencing Commission policy, and § 3553(a) factors. Guided the Court’s substantive analysis framework for the defendant’s motion.
United States v. Jenkins, 50 F.4th 1185 (D.C. Cir. 2022) Explained the lack of a current policy statement from the Sentencing Commission due to quorum issues. Supported the Court’s reliance on prior policy statements and judicial discretion.
U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13, Application Note 1(C)(i) Identifies death or incapacitation of a caregiver of a defendant’s minor children as a potential extraordinary and compelling reason. Provided the baseline policy statement for evaluating the defendant’s family circumstances.
United States v. Cole, No. 18-20237, 2021 WL 194194 (E.D. Mich. Jan. 20, 2021) Recognition that death/incapacitation of a caregiver may justify compassionate release. Used as persuasive authority supporting the possible extraordinary and compelling nature of the defendant’s circumstances.
United States v. Dick, No. 2:95-CR-00010, 2021 WL 5850187 (M.D. Tenn. Dec. 9, 2021) Requirement for defendant to prove lack of alternative suitable caregivers for minor children. Supported the Court’s burden analysis regarding availability of other caregivers.
United States v. Lemon, No. 4:16-cr-0239, 2021 WL 1060142 (N.D. Ohio Mar. 18, 2021) Similar focus on availability of alternative caregivers in compassionate release motions. Further supported the Court’s evaluation of caregiver availability.
United States v. Simmons, No. CR 15-0025 (PLF), 2021 WL 5074741 (D.D.C. Nov. 2, 2021) Emphasized the need for defendant to establish that other caregivers are incapacitated or unavailable. Reinforced the Court’s standard for evaluating family circumstances.
United States v. Delgado, No. 3:15-CR-246, 2023 WL 4552890 (M.D. Pa. July 14, 2023) Noted that defendants typically must show all other caregivers are incapacitated to establish extraordinary and compelling reasons. Used to frame the burden of proof on the defendant regarding alternative caregivers.
United States v. Lou, No. 05 CR 514, 2023 WL 2499878 (N.D. Ill. Mar. 14, 2023) Recognized an extraordinary and compelling reason for compassionate release despite availability of grandparents due to trauma on the child. Distinguished as contrary but factually different from the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first examined whether the defendant satisfied the procedural exhaustion requirements under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A). Although initially unexhausted, the defendant later submitted compassionate release requests to the wardens at both FCI Aliceville and FCI Victorville. Thirty days passed without a response from the latter, satisfying the statutory exhaustion prerequisite.

Substantively, the Court applied the three-step inquiry mandated by the First Step Act and relevant case law: (1) whether extraordinary and compelling reasons exist; (2) whether the reduction aligns with Sentencing Commission policy statements; and (3) whether the § 3553(a) factors support release.

The defendant’s claimed extraordinary and compelling reason was the death of her mother—the primary caregiver for her four minor children. The Court verified the death and the ages of the children through the Probation Office and local authorities. However, the Court found that the children currently reside with their father, who is deemed a suitable caregiver, and that Children Services has closed its case without taking custody.

Given the presence of an available and suitable caregiver, the Court concluded that the defendant failed to meet her burden to show an extraordinary and compelling reason for compassionate release. The Court acknowledged contrary authority but distinguished it on factual grounds. The Court also found the defendant’s prior compassionate release motion based on conditions at FCI Aliceville moot due to her transfer.

Holding and Implications

The Court DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE the defendant’s motion for compassionate release based on the death of her minor children’s caregiver. The motion for compassionate release related to conditions at FCI Aliceville was denied as moot. The Court granted the defendant’s motions for leave to file supplemental briefs and terminated miscellaneous motions to expedite as moot.

The direct effect of this decision is that the defendant remains incarcerated at FCI Victorville. The Court did not establish new precedent but applied existing legal standards to the facts, emphasizing the necessity for defendants to demonstrate that no suitable alternative caregivers are available to justify compassionate release on family-care grounds.

United States of America v. Quiana Mathews

JAMES L. GRAHAM, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

OPINION AND ORDER

JAMES L. GRAHAM, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Defendant pleaded guilty to one count of Conspiracy to Defraud the Government With Respect to Claims, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 286, for operating a tax preparation business through which she filed false claims for tax refunds with the Internal Revenue Service. In October 2020, the Court sentenced defendant to a period of 72 months imprisonment and 3 years supervised release. Defendant is presently incarcerated at the Federal Correctional Institution in Victorville, California.

This matter is before the Court on defendant's motion for compassionate release pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A)(i), as amended by the First Step Act of 2018. Defendant argues that she should be considered for compassionate release because of the death of the primary caregiver of her minor children.

I. Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies

Under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A), an imprisoned person may file a motion for compassionate release after (1) exhausting the Bureau of Prison's administrative process, or (2) thirty days after the warden received the compassionate release request, whichever is earlier. See United States v. Jones, 980 F.3d 1098, 1105 (6th Cir. 2020).

Defendant initially filed her motion on May 3, 2023, alleging that the caregiver of her minor children had passed away on April 26, 2023. See Doc. 76. Defendant did not allege that she had exhausted the BOP's administrative process or made a compassionate release request with the warden.

Defendant filed a notice with the Court on May 15 that she had submitted a compassionate release request with the warden where she was then incarcerated, FCI Aliceville in Alabama. See Doc. 77. On June 27, 2023, the Court instructed defendant to provide an update on the status of her request. See Doc. 80. On July 7, defendant filed a response in which she stated that she had been transferred to FCI Victorville in June and filed a new request there for compassionate release.

On August 2, defendant submitted a notice to the Court that thirty days had lapsed since she filed her request for compassionate release with the warden at FCI Victorville and that she had not received a response.

The Court finds that defendant has demonstrated that she has satisfied the procedural requirements of § 3582(c)(1)(A).

II. Substantive Standard for Compassionate Release Motions

The First Step Act directs courts to follow a “three-step inquiry” in addressing defendant-filed motions for compassionate release. United States v. McCall, 56 F.4th 1048, 1054 (6th Cir. 2022). First, a defendant must show that “extraordinary and compelling” reasons warrant the reduction. Id. (quoting 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A)(i)). Second, and related to the first, a court should confirm that a reduction in sentence “is consistent with applicable policy statements issued by the Sentencing Commission.” Id. (quoting § 3582(c)(1)(A)). Third, the court considers the sentencing factors set forth in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a), to the extent that they are applicable. See id. (citing § 3582(c)(1)(A)).

Since the passage of the First Step Act, district courts have had full discretion to define what constitutes an “extraordinary and compelling” reason. See Jones, 980 F.3d at 1111. That is in part because the United States Sentencing Commission lacked a quorum to promulgate a policy statement regarding the appropriate use of § 3582(c). See United States v. Jenkins, 50 F.4th 1185, 1193 (D.C. Cir. 2022).

In the absence of a new policy statement, courts generally have referred to the Commission's policy statement which applied to BOP-filed motions. See U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13. Under that statement, the defendant's medical conditions, age, and family circumstances may provide “extraordinary and compelling” reasons for compassionate release. See id., Application Note 1.

The Commission reached a quorum in August 2022 and promulgated proposed amendments to the Sentencing Guidelines on April 27, 2023. The amendments will take effect on November 1, 2023 if Congress does not act to disapprove of them. The Court will discuss below the amendment relevant to this case.

III. Extraordinary and Compelling Reasons

According to the motion and related filings submitted by defendant, her mother Barbara Huffman was found dead in defendant's home on April 26, 2023 in Dallas, Georgia. Huffman had lived there since defendant's incarceration in order to care for defendant's four minor children. Defendant states that a neighbor has been looking after her children, but that this is not a long-term solution. Defendant identifies herself as the only suitable caregiver for her children, and she expresses her fear that Children Services officials will take her children into custody.

Courts have found that the death or incapacitation of the caregiver of a defendant's minor child or minor children may provide an extraordinary and compelling reason for compassionate release. See, e.g., United States v. Cole, No. 18-20237, 2021 WL 194194, at *2 (E.D. Mich. Jan. 20, 2021). In recognizing such a basis for compassionate release, courts have cited the Sentencing Commission's policy statement (applicable to BOP-filed motions) which stated that the “death or incapacitation of the caregiver of the defendant's minor child or minor children” may constitute an extraordinary and compelling reason for a sentence reduction. U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13, Application Note 1(C)(i).

The proposed amendments to the Sentencing Guidelines would only slightly alter the language of the existing policy statement. The relevant amendment provides that extraordinary and compelling reasons may exist upon the “death or incapacitation of the caregiver of the defendant's minor child or defendant's child who is 18 years of age or older and incapable of self-care because of a mental or physical disability or a medical condition.” Proposed April 27, 2023 Amendments to the Sentencing Guidelines, § 1B1.13(b)(3)(A).

The Court requested the Unites States Probation Office for the Southern District of Ohio to verify the statements made by Mathews in her filings. The Probation Office contacted state and local officials in Georgia and confirmed that Barbara Huffman did in fact die in Paulding County, Georgia on April 26, 2023. In addition, they have verified that defendant has four minor children who are approximately 9, 10, 14, and 16 years old.

The Court also asked the Probation Office to determine the current living situation of the minor children. After contacting the Paulding County Division of Family and Children Services, the Probation Office reported that the children are living with their father. Satisfied with that arrangement, Children Services closed its case on the matter. Children Services stated that the children have not been in state custody.

When addressing motions for compassionate release under similar circumstances, courts have looked to whether there are other available caregivers for the minor child. See United States v. Dick, No. 2:95-CR-00010, 2021 WL 5850187, at *5 (M.D. Tenn. Dec. 9, 2021); United State v. Lemon, No. 4:16-cr-0239, 2021 WL 1060142, at *2 (N.D. Ohio Mar. 18, 2021); Cole, 2021 WL 194194, at *2; United States v. Simmons, No. CR 15-0025 (PLF), 2021 WL 5074741, at *5 (D.D.C. Nov. 2, 2021) (citing cases). As one court observed, “a defendant typically must establish that all other potential caregivers for their minor child are incapacitated.” United States v. Delgado, No. 3:15-CR-246, 2023 WL 4552890, at *2 (M.D. Pa. July 14, 2023) (internal quotation marks omitted). Courts have placed the burden on the defendant to prove that other potential caregivers are not available or suitable. See Dick, 2021 WL 5850187, at *5; Lemon, 2021 WL 1060142, at *2; United States v. Cruz-Rivera, No. 11-43, 2020 WL 5993352, at *7 (E.D. Pa. Oct. 9, 2020).

The Court notes the contrary, but factually distinguishable, authority of United States v. Lou, No. 05 CR 514, 2023 WL 2499878, at *2 (N.D. Ill. Mar. 14, 2023). In Lou the court held that the defendant had shown an extraordinary and compelling reason even if there were grandparents available to care for the child at issue. The court found that the trauma on the child of first losing his father to incarceration and then losing his mother to suicide was an extraordinary and compelling reason for reducing the sentence of the father.

In a recent filing, dated August 13, 2023, defendant continues to assert that “there is no caregiver available to take my children.” Doc. 87. Her assertion is fully contradicted by the information provided by the Paulding County Division of Family and Children Services. Defendant has not submitted any evidence from which the Court could find that the children's father is not suitable to be a caregiver.

Accordingly, the Court finds that defendant has not demonstrated that an extraordinary and compelling reason exists for compassionate release, and thus denies her motion without prejudice.

IV. Prior Motion for Compassionate Release

Before filing a motion for compassionate release based on the death of her minor children's caregiver, defendant had filed a motion for compassionate release based on alleged circumstances at FCI Aliceville. The grounds related primarily to an incident in which a female staff member allegedly touched defendant in a sexual manner. Defendant later supplemented her motion with allegations that she had been intimidated by inmate. Defendant also reported in supplemental filings that she had contracted COVID-19 and alleged that her post-recovery care (relating to complications with asthma and anemia) was deficient because of staff shortages at FCI Aliceville.

The Court finds that defendant's grounds for compassionate release are moot now that defendant has been transferred to FCI Victorville.

V. Conclusion

Accordingly, defendant's motion for compassionate release based on the death of her minor children's caregiver (docs. 76, 77) is denied without prejudice. Defendant's motion for compassionate release based on circumstances at FCI Aliceville (docs. 57, 64, 65) is denied as moot. Defendant's motions for leave to file supplemental briefs (docs. 73, 75) are granted. The Clerk of Court shall terminate defendant's miscellaneous motions to expedite (docs. 61, 74, 88) as moot.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

United States v. Mathews
(Sep 12, 2023)