AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges

COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION, Plaintiff, v. TERRY MICHAEL SVEJDA, and CENTURION CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, INC., Defendants.

Michael D. Nelson United States Magistrate Judge

ORDER

Michael D. Nelson United States Magistrate Judge

This matter comes before the Court following a telephone conference held with counsel for the parties on August 1, 2022. In accordance with the discussion held on the record, IT IS ORDERED:

1. Counsel have until August 8, 2022, to notify the undersigned magistrate judge whether any discovery disputes remain outstanding.

2. Regarding Plaintiff's RFP 1 seeking all communications between Defendants and Doug Hays:

a. On or before August 8, 2022, Defendants may suggest to Plaintiff search terms to limit the number of responsive documents. If counsel agree to search terms, Defendants shall produce responsive documents on or before September 2, 2022.
b. If counsel cannot agree on search terms, Defendants shall produce all nonprivileged communications responsive to RFP 1 by September 2, 2022. Plaintiff shall review Defendants' production and, on or before October 14, 2022, shall identify the documents it deems relevant to its claims.

3. On or before September 2, 2022, Defendants shall produce all documents responsive to Plaintiff's RFP 8 seeking all communications between Defendants and Decadian customers relating to the Complaint.

4. The deposition and summary judgment deadlines are stayed pending the completion of written discovery, and will be reset during the planning conference set on October 14, 2022.

PLAINTIFF'S SUMMARY OF PARTIES' DISCOVERY DISPUTE

Plaintiff Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) hereby submits this summary of the parties' discovery dispute, which is based upon Defendants' refusal to produce documents responsive to two of the CFTC's Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents. Both requests are narrowly tailored, proportional, and relevant to the claims and defenses in this case.

See attached Exh. 1, Defs.' Resp. to Plaintiff's Second Set of Reqs. for Produc. of Docs. In addition, with respect to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories, Defendants have failed to submit a written response. Therefore, once Defendants respond, the parties may have additional discovery disputes that require the Court's assistance.

1. Request No. 1: “All communications between you and Doug Hays, who is identified as Senior Market Analyst for Decadian in CENTURION 000045, relating to Decadian.”

Defendants have refused to produce communications with Doug Hays, arguing that this request seeks irrelevant information. However, documents produced by Defendants establish that Mr. Hays is a key witness in this matter. Decadian marketing materials identify Mr. Hays and Mr. Svejda as Decadian's two primary employees operating the Decadian business. The same marketing materials state that Hays is a “senior market analyst and research analyst.” Defendants sent such materials to actual and prospective commodity pool participants. Moreover, internal Decadian documents show Hays was a registered agent for one of the commodity pools identified in the same marketing materials, as well as the intended manager of the pool. The existence of these commodity pools is a key fact disputed by Defendants. Communications between Mr. Svejda and Mr. Hays relating to the Decadian business therefore are indisputably relevant to this litigation.

Defendants' relevance argument is undercut by their production of several communications with Mr. Hays. See, e.g., CENTURION 019574, attached as Exh. 2.

The Commission did not learn of Mr. Hays' involvement in Decadian until after reviewing documents produced by Defendants, because Defendants did not identify Mr. Hays in their Rule 26 Initial Disclosures or Supplemental Disclosures. See Exh. 3.

See, e.g., CENTURION 000025, attached as Exh. 4, at 10.

See, e.g., id. at 1.

See CENTURION 019326 and CENTURION 019536, attached as Exh. 5; Exh. 4 at 9.

See March 8, 2022 correspondence from defense counsel, attached to ECF #34, at 1 (“Despite now knowing that Defendants explicitly told investors that their funds would be used for purposes other than operating a commodities pool, the CFTC has persisted in its misguided claims.”)

Significantly, the Court previously ordered Defendants to produce documents responsive to a similar document request. Request No. 7 of Plaintiff's First Set of Document Requests sought “[a]ll communications between you and Mark D. Svejda, and all documents sent to or received from Mark D. Svejda, relating to Centurion and/or Decadian.” Like Hays, Mark Svejda was identified in the Decadian marketing materials as having “involvement in the Decadian business.” [ECF #34] Accordingly, this Court overruled Defendants' relevance objections to this Request, and the District Court affirmed that ruling. [ECF #34, 44] For the same reasons, Defendants' relevance objections to Request No. 1 of Plaintiff's Second Set of Document Requests should also be overruled.

Defendants further assert that this request is overbroad and not proportional to the needs of the case. The CFTC attempted to resolve Defendants' proportionality concerns by agreeing to limit Request No.1 to email communications in which Mr. Hays appears in the To/From/CC/Bcc fields, and which also include the term “Decadian.” Moreover, the CFTC encouraged Defendants to make additional proposals to further narrow the search, but Defendants did not provide any such proposals. Accordingly, Plaintiff requests that the Court overrule Defendants' proportionality objections, and order Defendants to produce documents responsive to Request No. 1.

2. Request No. 8: “All communications between you and any Decadian customers, relating to the Complaint filed in the present action.”

Plaintiff issued Request No. 8 after learning that Mr. Svejda recently attempted to communicate with at least some of the 27 Decadian customers identified in the Complaint about the merits of this action. The Commission is concerned that Svejda may have made additional misrepresentations to one or more of the Decadian customers. Defendants have produced text messages responsive to this request, but have declined to produce responsive emails.

Defendants' production of text messages responsive to Request No. 8 reflects their acknowledgement that such communications are relevant to the claims and defenses at issue. Moreover, there can be no meaningful argument that producing a small number of emails, from a brief time period, will unduly burden Defendants. Accordingly, the Commission requests that the Court overrule Defendants' relevance and proportionality objections to Request No. 8, and order Defendants to produce responsive email communications with Decadian customers that relate to the Complaint in this action.

Dated: July 29, 2022

Respectfully submitted, Aimee Latimer-Zayets, DC Bar No. 476693

Glenn I. Chernigoff, D.C. Bar No. 488500

Sean P. Hennessy, DC Bar No. 1011564

COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION

(EXHIBIT OMITTED)

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Commodity Futures Trading Comm'n v. Svejda
(Aug 1, 2022)