AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates
Judges

THE PEOPLE, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. DAVID EARL BILLOUPS, Defendant and Appellant.

Duarte, J.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115. (Super. Ct. No. 15F06568)

A jury found defendant David Earl Billoups guilty of the willful and malicious torture of an animal, and the trial court found true allegations that defendant had served two prior prison terms. (Pen. Code, §§ 597, subd. (a), 667.5, subd. (b).) The court subsequently sentenced defendant to an aggregate term of five years in county jail. Defendant's sole claim on appeal is that insufficient evidence supports his conviction. Disagreeing, we affirm.

Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code. All references to dates are in 2015 unless otherwise specified. --------

FACTS

In February 2015, Lynda Witherspoon lived with her mother (Diana Atkins) and Ladasha Allen. Although he was apparently married to another woman, defendant lived with Ms. Witherspoon "on and off." Witherspoon owned a two-month-old puppy named Baby.

On the morning of February 19, Allen was in her room when she heard defendant and Witherspoon arguing. Defendant accused Witherspoon of loving Baby more than she loved him. Allen "heard the dog . . . go oof, like when a dog gets kicked, like, an arr and boom." Then she heard the dog hit her door and fall to the floor. Allen immediately opened her door; she saw blood splattered on her door and Baby twitching on the floor in a puddle of blood with his tongue out. She heard Witherspoon say to defendant, "[Y]ou killed him, you killed my Baby." Defendant was already gone. As he rode away on his bicycle, Witherspoon ran after him, screaming: "You killed him."

At 10:36 a.m., Witherspoon called 911. Crying and upset, Witherspoon reported that her ex-boyfriend came over and, when she said she did not want to get back together with him, had killed her puppy. Witherspoon then called Sacramento Animal Service (SAS) and reported that her dog had been killed. Still upset and crying, she told SAS that her ex-boyfriend kicked her brand new puppy with a steel-toed boot and the puppy died. She repeatedly said he "killed" her puppy, and that she wanted to press charges.

Animal Control Officer Jace Huggins met with Witherspoon later that day and took a recorded statement from her. Witherspoon said defendant walked down the hallway and kicked her dog. Defendant later called Witherspoon and threatened to make her life miserable if she pressed charges. Witherspoon also played Huggins a voice message defendant left on the morning of February 19 in which he said, "I will kill your fucking dog." Huggins contacted the district attorney's office.

District Attorney Investigator Joyce Thogrimson first contacted Witherspoon on February 23. Witherspoon told Thogrimson she did not want to press charges because defendant "had promised her a new dog" and hung up on her. Thogrimson contacted Witherspoon again on February 27. Witherspoon said she did not want to press charges because she did not want to "stir things up" and again hung up on Thogrimson.

Witherspoon testified to the jury that Baby's death was an accident, saying that she and defendant fell on him. She did acknowledge defendant was angry with her on February 19, and he did leave a message on her phone that morning threatening to kill her dog, but she testified she had no memory of telling officers that defendant kicked her dog. She did, however, recognize her own voice in the recorded conversation with Officer Huggins where she told Huggins defendant killed her dog. Witherspoon explained she had been using drugs for nearly 30 years, primarily crack cocaine. She said she did not remember much of what happened around February 19, including calling 911 or speaking with Huggins, because she was likely under the influence.

Witherspoon said she and defendant fought about her drug use and defendant's marriage, but testified that their fights were never physical. Witherspoon loved defendant and wanted to marry him. Before trial, defendant bought Witherspoon a new dog.

Dr. Laura Warner performed the necropsy on Baby. She determined that Baby died from blunt force trauma to the spinal cord consistent with having been kicked. When asked if the injury could have been caused by a person falling on the puppy, she responded: "That's possible, yes." She could not determine precisely what caused the blunt force trauma that killed Baby, but she determined Baby died from that trauma.

The jury found defendant guilty of cruelty to an animal (§ 597, subd. (a)) and not guilty on a charge of making criminal threats (§ 422). The trial court subsequently found true allegations that defendant served two prior prison terms. After finding defendant ineligible for probation, the trial court sentenced him to an aggregate term of five years in county jail.

DISCUSSION

Defendant contends insufficient evidence supported the jury's finding that he had the requisite intent for animal cruelty because the evidence did not establish "beyond a reasonable doubt that [he] acted maliciously in the death of the dog . . . as required under . . . section 597, subdivision (a)."

Section 597, subdivision (a) states, "[E]very person who maliciously and intentionally maims, tortures, or wounds a living animal, or maliciously and intentionally kills an animal, is guilty of a crime . . . ." Section 597, subdivision (a) is a general intent crime. (People v. Alvarado (2005) 125 Cal.App.4th 1179, 1190.) The expressions " 'intentionally,' and 'maliciously' are expressions of general, not specific, intent when used in a penal statute." (Id. at p. 1188.) The defendant, therefore, must intend the wrongful act, but is not required to have intended the result. (People v. Iraheta (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th 611, 621.)

Viewing the evidence presented at trial in the light most favorable to the judgment, as we must (People v. Osband (1996) 13 Cal.4th 622, 690), we find sufficient evidence to support a conviction for animal cruelty.

Defendant contends the People failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Baby's death resulted from a criminal act. In support of his contention, defendant relies on Witherspoon's testimony that Baby died when she and defendant accidentally fell on the puppy. That testimony, however, is wholly inconsistent with the numerous contemporaneous statements Witherspoon made at the time of Baby's death, which we have detailed ante. Moreover, Allen testified to hearing defendant and Witherspoon arguing, and then heard the dog being kicked and its body hitting her door, which we have also detailed ante. She told the jury how Witherspoon ran after defendant screaming that he had "killed my Baby." Finally, Dr. Warner determined that Baby died as a result of blunt force trauma to the spinal cord consistent with being kicked. All of the testimony heard by the jury, with the exception of Witherspoon's backing away from her previous claims, was consistent with defendant's having maliciously kicked Baby, thereby killing him, as he had told Witherspoon he would do earlier that same day. The jury was entitled to disbelieve Witherspoon's inconsistent trial testimony and believe the rest of the evidence, all of which pointed toward defendant's guilt. Ample evidence supports the jury's verdict.

DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

/s/_________


Duarte, J. We concur: /s/_________
Hull, Acting P. J. /s/_________
Mauro, J.


Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

People v. Billoups
(Jul 6, 2017)