AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Advocates

Domingo ARDON v. COMMITTEE FOR PUBLIC COUNSEL SERVICES.

NOTICE: The slip opinions and orders posted on this Web site are subject to formal revision and are superseded by the advance sheets and bound volumes of the Official Reports. This preliminary material will be removed from the Web site once the advance sheets of the Official Reports are published. If you find a typographical error or other formal error, please notify the Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Judicial Court, John Adams Courthouse, 1 Pemberton Square, Suite 2500, Boston, MA 02108-1750; (617) 557-1030; SJCReporter@sjc.state.ma.us

Constitutional Law, Assistance of counsel. Committee for Public Counsel Services. Mandamus. Practice, Civil, Action in nature of mandamus. Practice, Criminal, Capital case, Postconviction relief, Appeal. Supreme Judicial Court.

The case was submitted on briefs.

Domingo Ardon, pro se.

Jennifer L. Sullivan, Assistant Attorney General, for the respondent.

RESCRIPT

In 1996, the petitioner, Domingo Ardon, was convicted of murder in the first degree. This court affirmed the conviction. Commonwealth v. Ardon, 428 Mass. 496 (1998). The petitioner has filed multiple pro se motions for a new trial in the Superior Court since then, and has sought appointment of counsel with respect to these postconviction, postappeal claims. After consideration, the Committee for Public Counsel Services (CPCS), declined to appoint counsel. Likewise, the trial judge denied the petitioner's motion for appointment of counsel. Thereafter, the petitioner filed a petition, pursuant G.L. c. 249, § 5, in the county court seeking relief in the nature of mandamus. He challenged both CPCS's decision not to appoint counsel and the trial judge's denial of his motion for appointment of counsel. The single justice properly denied relief.

"A complaint in the nature of mandamus is 'a call to a government official to perform a clear cut duty,' and the remedy is limited to requiring action on the part of the government official." Simmons v. Clerk-Magistrate of the Boston Div. of the Hous. Court Dep't, 448 Mass. 57, 59-60, (2006), quoting Doe v. District Attorney for the Plymouth Dist., 29 Mass.App.Ct. 671, 675 (1991). Such an action "is appropriate to compel a public official to perform an act which the official has a legal duty to perform." Lutheran Serv. Ass'n of New England, Inc. v. Metropolitan Dist. Comm'n, 397 Mass. 341, 344 (1986). It is not appropriate in these circumstances. The petitioner has no constitutional or statutory entitlement to the "assistance of appointed counsel in preparing or presenting a postconviction motion for a new trial." Parker v. Commonwealth, 448 Mass. 1021, 1023 (2007). See G.L. c. 211D, § 5 (CPCS obligation to assign or appoint counsel limited to proceedings where the "laws of the commonwealth or the rules of the supreme judicial court require that [the] person in such proceeding be represented by counsel"). Because there is no "clear cut duty" to appoint counsel in this situation, Montefusco v. Commonwealth, 452 Mass. 1015, 1015 (2008), mandamus is not proper; mandamus cannot be used to compel a public agency to perform a discretionary act. See Anzalone v. Administrative Office of the Trial Court, 457 Mass. 647, 655 (2010). The single justice therefore properly declined to issue a writ of mandamus to CPCS. ,

Likewise, mandamus was not available to compel the trial judge to appoint counsel. Mandamus will not "issue to direct a judicial officer to make a particular decision or to review, or reverse, a decision made by a judicial officer on an issue properly before him or her." Mack v. Clerk of the Appeals Court, 427 Mass. 1011, 1012 (1998), quoting Callahan v. Superior Court, 410 Mass. 1001, 1001 (1991). See Mains v. Commonwealth, 433 Mass. 30, 35 (2000) (assignment of counsel pursuant to Mass. R.Crim. P. 30[c][5], 379 Mass. 900 [1979], is "by discretion of the judge ... and not by right"); Commonwealth v. Conceicao, 388 Mass. 255, 263-264 (1983) (same).

We decline to address additional issues and arguments raised on appeal that were not properly raised before the single justice.
--------

Extraordinary relief in the nature of mandamus was also unwarranted for the additional reason that the petitioner failed to demonstrate the absence of adequate alternative remedies. See Murray v. Commonwealth, 447 Mass. 1010, 1010 (2006). Because the defendant stands convicted of murder in the first degree, "he could have sought leave, pursuant to [the gatekeeper provision of] G.L. c. 278, § 33E, to appeal from the denial, in the trial court," of his motion for appointment of counsel. Birks v. Green, 462 Mass. 1013, 1013 (2012). See Commonwealth v. Davis, 410 Mass. 680, 683 (1991) ("gatekeeper" provision of G.L. c. 278, § 33E, applies to "any motion" filed in Superior Court after plenary review).

Judgment affirmed.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Ardon v. Comm. for Pub. Counsel Servs.
(Dec 18, 2012)