Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Advocates H. Eliot Kaplan for Arthur J.W. Hilly, Corporation Counsel ( J. Joseph Lilly, Arthur Sweeny Cornelius Bregoff of counsel), for Municipal Civil Service Commission of the City of New York, Frederick A. Keck for James C.A. Hennessey, John J. Bennett, Jr., Attorney-General ( Patrick H. Clune of counsel), for the State of New York, See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. OPINION In the Matter of VINCENT J. GIANATASIO, Appellant, v. ABRAHAM KAPLAN et al., Composing the Municipal Ci Order affirmed, with costs; no opinion. Concur: CARDOZO, Ch. J., POUND, LEHMAN, KELLOGG, O'BRIEN and HUBBS, JJ. Not sitting: CRANE, J.