JAMES CARR, District Judge
This is an FELA case in which the plaintiffs, crew members of a CSX Transportation train involved in a fatal grade-crossing collision, have sued the railroad, the estate of the pickup truck driver killed in the collision, and the administrator of his estate. In an earlier order, I granted summary judgment in favor of the estate and its administrator on the basis that timely notice of the plaintiffs' claim against them had not been made.
Plaintiffs have filed a motion for clarification. They acknowledge in their motion (as they did not in their response to the defendants' original motion for summary judgment) that any motor vehicle insurance policy that may have covered the decedent and his vehicle is not an asset of his estate. In view of that acknowledgment, the prior ruling, granting summary judgment in favor of the estate and the administrator, was correct.
At issue, therefore, is plaintiffs' ability to recover the proceeds of the insurance policy. So far as I can tell, they can do so, provided that there are not other defenses, which are for the insurance company to assert, available to the insurer. I note, however, that the insurer is not a defendant in this action.
Because, at the present moment, neither the estate nor its administrator is a party, it remains unnecessary to resolve their challenge to the claims for emotional distress and punitive damages. Though CSX suggests in its response to the motion for clarification that resolution of such claims is appropriate, I disagree. There is no pending case or controversy between the plaintiffs and the estate and its administrator; therefore, any decision would be advisory and thus improper under Article III of the United States Constitution.
It is, therefore,
ORDERED THAT plaintiffs' motion for clarification be, and the same hereby is granted; prior order confirmed as stated herein.
So ordered.