Factual and Procedural Background
The Defendant, Oxfordshire County Council ("Oxfordshire CC"), applied to strike out claims brought by two claimant care homes, known as the Julie Richardson Limited ("the Julie Richardson") and Banbury Heights Limited ("Banbury Heights"), pursuant to CPR 3.4(2)(a), or alternatively sought summary judgment under CPR 24.2(a)(i) and (b). The claimants sought permission to amend their pleadings under CPR 17.
The Julie Richardson and Banbury Heights are nursing homes located in Banbury, Oxfordshire, registered to provide accommodation and personal and nursing care. The Care Quality Commission (CQC) rated the Julie Richardson as "outstanding" and Banbury Heights as "good". Oxfordshire CC is the local authority responsible for adult social care services under the Care Act 2014.
The claims concern unpaid care home fees for two residents, Mrs Hayward and Mrs Smith, who received care at the respective homes. The claimants assert Oxfordshire CC was statutorily obliged to pay for the care provided once the residents met the financial threshold, but payments were not made, leaving the care homes to cover the shortfall.
The claim was issued in August 2021 in the Oxford District Registry, with Oxfordshire CC filing a Defence in September 2021. Subsequent procedural steps included requests for further information, applications to strike out, and an application to amend the Particulars of Claim. The case was allocated to the multi-track and underwent multiple listing adjournments. The claim was eventually transferred to the King's Bench Division in May 2024, with a hearing scheduled for November 2024. The case has seen minimal substantive progress over more than three years.
The claimants assert a longstanding commissioning relationship with Oxfordshire CC since 2003, based on a statutory obligation of the Defendant to provide accommodation and care services for persons in need.
Mrs Hayward was assessed by Oxfordshire CC in 2015 as requiring full personal care and was placed initially in NHS-funded care before moving to the Julie Richardson. Oxfordshire CC made payments for part of her care, but after her funds were exhausted, the care home continued to provide services pending financial assessment.
Mrs Smith was admitted to Banbury Heights in 2018, initially funded by NHS intermediate care and subsequently by Oxfordshire CC under a property disregard. Payments ceased in August 2019 pending notification that she had reached the financial threshold in May 2020. Banbury Heights continued to provide care in the interim.
The claimants seek declarations that Oxfordshire CC had statutory duties under the Care Act 2014 to assess and meet the needs of Mrs Hayward and Mrs Smith from specified dates and that Oxfordshire CC is liable to pay the outstanding care fees.
The amended Particulars of Claim allege that Oxfordshire CC was under a statutory duty to meet the care needs of the residents and that the care homes provided these services on behalf of Oxfordshire CC. The claim is advanced on a restitutionary basis, asserting that Oxfordshire CC has been unjustly enriched at the expense of the claimants and must make restitution.
Oxfordshire CC denies any "underlying contract" with the claimants and disputes any statutory obligation to pay fees directly to the care homes. The Defendant argues that the claimants bear the risk of private funding running out and that the claim is an abuse of process as it should have been brought by judicial review, which provides procedural safeguards for public authorities.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Oxfordshire County Council had a statutory duty under the Care Act 2014 to meet the care and accommodation costs for Mrs Hayward and Mrs Smith from specified dates.
- Whether the claimants, as private care home providers, have a restitutionary remedy against Oxfordshire CC for payments made on its behalf.
- Whether the claimants are entitled to amend their Particulars of Claim to include claims based on estoppel or restitution.
- Whether the claim against Oxfordshire CC is an abuse of process for failing to bring judicial review proceedings.
- The applicability of the exclusivity principle from O'Reilly v Mackman and its exceptions in the context of private law claims against public bodies.
Arguments of the Parties
Claimants' Arguments
- The claimants have fulfilled Oxfordshire CC's statutory duties by providing care and accommodation to Mrs Hayward and Mrs Smith after the exhaustion of private funds.
- Oxfordshire CC has been unjustly enriched as a result of the claimants covering the shortfall in payments.
- They seek declarations that Oxfordshire CC had a duty to meet the residents' needs from the relevant dates and restitution for the unpaid fees.
- The claimants rely on equitable principles and argue that the claim in restitution is at least seriously arguable.
- The claimants contend that the exclusivity principle does not bar their claim because it involves private law rights and it would be unjust to require judicial review.
Defendant's Arguments
- There is no enforceable underlying contract between Oxfordshire CC and the claimants; the idea of such a contract is "fictitious".
- Oxfordshire CC denies any statutory obligation to pay fees directly to the care homes, as the Care Act 2014 does not create such funding obligations.
- The claimants bear the risk of private funding running out; the Defendant is not liable for unpaid fees.
- The claim is an abuse of process as it should have been brought by judicial review, which requires leave and compliance with strict time limits.
- The proposed amendments introduce a new cause of action beyond the original claim and should not be permitted.
- The Defendant argues there are no enforceable rights between the parties giving rise to a cause of action and that the declarations sought are otiose.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| O'Reilly & Ors v Mackman & Ors [1983] 2 AC 237 |
Exclusivity principle requiring public law claims to be brought by judicial review, barring private law claims that seek to circumvent procedural safeguards. |
The court considered the principle but acknowledged exceptions where private law rights are involved and judicial review would cause injustice; thus, exclusivity did not bar the claim here. |
| Richards v Worcestershire CC, South Worcestershire Clinical Commissioning Groups [2017] EWCA Civ 1998 |
Private law restitutionary claims can be brought against public bodies in appropriate cases, even where public law duties are involved. |
The court relied on this case to find that it was seriously arguable that the Defendant had been unjustly enriched, supporting the claimants' position. |
| Surrey County Council v NHS Lincolnshire Clinical Commissioning Group [2020] EWCA Civ 3550 |
Recognition of restitution claims by local authorities against NHS bodies for costs incurred due to unlawful refusal to provide care. |
The court applied the principle that a public body can be unjustly enriched when another body discharges its statutory duties, supporting the claimants' restitution claim. |
| Pearce v East and North Hertfordshire NHS Trust [2020] EWHC 1504 (QB) |
Guidance on the court's discretion to grant permission to amend pleadings, requiring amendments to be arguable and properly supported. |
The court applied this standard in considering whether to allow the claimants to amend their Particulars of Claim. |
| CIP Properties (AIPT) Limited v Galliford Try Infrastructure Limited [2015] EWHC 1345 (TCC) |
Principles on permission to amend pleadings and the overriding objective to deal with cases justly and proportionately. |
Referenced as part of the test for granting permission to amend. |
| Quah v Goldman Sachs International [2015] EWHC 759 (Comm) |
Standards for amendment of claims including coherence and factual basis requirements. |
Referenced in assessing the amendment application. |
| Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Limited v James Kemball Limited [2021] EWCA Civ 33 |
Requirement that amendments be coherent, properly particularised, and supported by evidence establishing a factual basis. |
Applied by the court to assess the amendment's validity. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the statutory framework under the Care Act 2014, particularly sections 9, 13, 14, 17, and 18, which impose duties on local authorities to assess and meet eligible adults' care needs and provide for charging mechanisms.
It was established that both Mrs Hayward and Mrs Smith met the eligibility criteria and were ordinarily resident within Oxfordshire CC's area, triggering statutory duties on Oxfordshire CC to meet their needs during the relevant periods.
The court accepted that the care homes provided the necessary care and accommodation services on behalf of Oxfordshire CC and that the claimants covered the shortfall in payments after private funds were exhausted.
Oxfordshire CC's argument that the claimants bear the risk of private funding running out was rejected on the basis that the alternative to the care homes providing care was removal of the residents from settled accommodation, which was not practical or humane.
The Defendant's reliance on the exclusivity principle from O'Reilly v Mackman was considered, but the court found exceptions applied because the claim involved private law rights and it would be unjust to require judicial review.
The court drew on the Court of Appeal's decision in Richards v Worcestershire CC and Surrey County Council v NHS Lincolnshire Clinical Commissioning Group, which recognised restitutionary claims against public bodies in similar contexts.
The court held that it was strongly arguable that Oxfordshire CC had been unjustly enriched at the expense of the claimants, who had fulfilled Oxfordshire CC's statutory duties.
The right to restitution and the obligation to make restitution were identified as private law obligations, distinct from public law procedural requirements such as time limits for judicial review.
Applying the principles governing amendments to pleadings, the court found the claimants’ proposed amendments to plead unjust enrichment and estoppel to have sufficient prospects of success and to be coherent and properly particularised.
Accordingly, the court determined that the applications to strike out and for summary judgment could not succeed on the amended pleadings and that the claimants should be permitted to amend their claim.
Holding and Implications
The court GRANTED PERMISSION to the claimants to amend their Particulars of Claim to plead claims in unjust enrichment and estoppel against Oxfordshire CC.
The applications by Oxfordshire CC to strike out the claim and for summary judgment were DISMISSED.
The direct effect of this decision is that the claimants may proceed with their amended claims, allowing the case to move forward to substantive consideration of the merits. No new binding precedent was established, but the decision affirms that restitutionary claims against public bodies for statutory duties discharged by private parties can be seriously arguable and that procedural safeguards of judicial review do not necessarily bar such private law claims.