Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
A and B (Child Arrangements: Parental Alienation)
Smart Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns the welfare of two children, A (aged 10) and B (aged 7), whose parents are involved in protracted family proceedings. The mother has been represented by counsel throughout, while the father initially had senior legal representation but chose to appear unrepresented at a hearing in January 2022. The father unilaterally took the children to Australia in late December 2021 without the mother's consent or prior notification, breaching existing court orders requiring the children to reside in England and attend school there. Interim orders were made requiring the father's return of the children to England and their school attendance. The father refused to comply and later sought various applications including permission to appeal the interim orders, all of which were refused. The mother alleges the father has engaged in a deliberate campaign of parental alienation causing serious emotional harm to the children and seeks a residence order for the children to live with her. The father denies alienation, claims to promote contact, and asserts the children wish to remain with him in Australia. Expert evidence, including psychological reports and social worker assessments, have been provided. The court proceeded with the hearing despite the father's refusal to participate fully and ultimately made findings and orders based on the evidence before it.
Legal Issues Presented
- Why has the children's relationship with their mother deteriorated?
- Has the father alienated the children from their mother, either deliberately or through his expressed hostile views?
- Can the children's rejection of the mother be explained by the mother's own conduct or other factors?
- Have the children suffered harm in the care of either parent, and how capable are the parents of meeting the children's needs, including facilitating a relationship with the other parent?
- What weight should be given to the children's wishes and feelings, considering their age, understanding, and any alienation or adverse parental influence?
- What are the appropriate future living arrangements for the children, and is further expert advice required?
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| R v Lucas [1981] Q.B. 720 |
Guidance on assessing witness credibility and lies. |
The court applied the Lucas direction to assess the father's credibility, recognizing that a witness may lie for various reasons and that a finding of dishonesty on one matter does not imply dishonesty on all matters. |
| Re A,B and C (Children) [2021] EWCA Civ 451 |
Recent discussion on the Lucas direction and witness credibility. |
Referenced to support the approach to assessing witness statements and the father's evidence. |
| Re S [2020] EWCA Civ 568 |
Emphasis on timely intervention in cases of parental alienation to prevent irreparable damage to parent-child relationships. |
The court relied on this precedent to stress the importance of swift action to protect the children’s welfare and prevent further alienation. |
| Re A (Intractable Contact Dispute: Human Rights Violations) [2013] EWCA Civ 1104; [2014] 1 FLR 1185 |
The court’s duty to determine child welfare issues effectively and with paramount consideration to the child's interests. |
Applied to underline the court’s responsibility in managing complex family disputes to protect children’s welfare. |
| Re B (A Child) (Abduction: Habitual Residence) [2020] 4 WLR 149 |
The purpose of the Hague Convention to secure the prompt return of wrongfully removed children to prevent consolidation of unlawful situations. |
Used to reject the father's argument that English proceedings should be stayed pending Australian Hague Convention proceedings. |
| SS (Sri Lanka) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2018] EWCA Civ 1391 |
Assessment of evidence based on consistencies, inconsistencies, and objectively verifiable facts. |
Referred to in evaluating the father’s evidence and overall credibility. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully considered extensive documentary and oral evidence, including expert psychological reports and social worker assessments. It applied the Lucas direction in evaluating witness credibility, particularly the father's inconsistent and evasive testimony. The court found the father’s conduct to be calculated and deliberate in alienating the children from their mother, causing them serious emotional harm. The expert evidence established that the children’s hostility towards the mother was not justified by her conduct but was the product of psychological manipulation by the father. The court rejected the father's unilateral removal of the children to Australia and his refusal to return them as breaches of court orders and harmful to the children’s welfare. The court assessed the children’s wishes and feelings but gave them limited weight due to the impact of alienation and their young ages. It concluded that the children’s welfare required their immediate return to England and a transfer of residence to the mother, subject to a carefully managed transition plan. The court also considered the father’s lack of insight and motivation to change, the mother’s capacity to meet the children’s needs with professional support, and the need for further expert evidence to guide the transition. The court refused to stay the English proceedings pending Australian Hague Convention proceedings, emphasizing the English court’s jurisdiction and the urgency of resolving welfare issues without delay.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF
The court ordered that the children shall live with their mother, with implementation deferred until a transition plan is approved by the court. Permission was granted for joint expert instruction to advise on the transition and therapeutic support. The local authority was directed to investigate the children’s current circumstances and report on any public law applications or support measures. A prohibited steps order was made preventing either parent from communicating the decision to the children without court approval. The father was ordered to file a statement indicating whether he accepts the court’s findings. The court emphasized the urgent need to restore the children’s relationship with their mother and to mitigate the harm caused by the father’s alienating behaviour. No new legal precedent was set beyond the application of established principles concerning parental alienation, jurisdiction, and child welfare. The judgment is to be disclosed and may be relied upon in related Australian Hague Convention proceedings.
Click here to read the full judgment