Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

PETITION TO THE NOBILE OFFICIUM BY SU

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the mother of four children, who are parties in referral proceedings initiated under section 67 of the Children's Hearings (Scotland) Act 2011 ("the 2011 Act"). The first respondent is the Locality Reporter Manager for Glasgow within the Scottish Children's Reporter Administration. The second respondent is the petitioner's partner and father of the children. The children are subject to interim compulsory supervision orders, with one child's case serving as the lead.

The Principal Reporter issued grounds of referral alleging repeated assault and wilful ill-treatment of the children by the petitioner and the second respondent. Both deny the allegations. Proceedings related to these grounds are pending in Glasgow Sheriff Court.

Evidence from the lead child was taken by commission through interrogatories. The petitioner and second respondent are also subject to criminal proceedings concerning the same conduct. Initially summary proceedings, these were discontinued and replaced by petition proceedings.

In mid-2021, the petitioner's agents sought clarification from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service ("the Service") regarding the continuation of the summary proceedings and any potential requests for information under section 179 of the 2011 Act. The Service indicated the criminal proceedings would proceed on petition and did not rule out making such a request, but expressed no objection to the civil case preceding the criminal case.

Proof hearings in the referral proceedings were scheduled across several dates in 2021. The petitioner sought to discharge and sist (suspend) the proof diet pending the criminal case's completion, but the sheriff refused. The petitioner then sought an undertaking from the Service not to request information under section 179; this was declined.

The petitioner unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal the sheriff's refusal. The sheriff subsequently discharged some proof hearings and assigned a new proof diet for February 2022.

The petitioner invoked the court's nobile officium, arguing that the prospect of the Service exercising section 179 powers infringed her rights under articles 6 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), thereby impeding her effective participation in the referral proceedings and harming the children's best interests. She contended that the sheriff's refusal to discharge and sist was unjust and that the nobile officium was her only remedy. She also claimed section 179 was beyond the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament, though this was not pursued in the prayer of the petition.

The first, third, and sixth respondents challenged the petition's competency, leading to a hearing to determine this issue.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition invoking the court's nobile officium is competent and appropriate to challenge the sheriff's interlocutory decision refusing to discharge and sist the referral proceedings pending criminal proceedings.
  2. Whether section 179 of the 2011 Act, allowing the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service to request information from the Principal Reporter, infringes the petitioner's rights under articles 6 and 8 ECHR.
  3. Whether section 179 is outside the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament.
  4. Whether the petitioner has any alternative remedies available other than the nobile officium, such as reduction, suspension, or judicial review of the sheriff's interlocutor.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 163 of the 2011 Act excludes any right of appeal or other remedies against interlocutory decisions like the sheriff's refusal to discharge and sist, making the nobile officium the only available remedy.
  • The circumstances are unusual and unforeseen (casus improvisus) due to the gravity of the criminal charges and the prospect of the Service exercising section 179 powers.
  • The possibility of the Service requesting information under section 179 would likely cause the petitioner to limit or avoid participation in the referral proceedings, harming both her interests and the children's welfare.
  • Section 179 is incompatible with articles 6 and 8 ECHR, infringing the petitioner's rights to a fair trial and private and family life.
  • The court should discharge and sist the referral proceedings until the criminal case concludes or until the Crown undertakes not to request information under section 179.

Second Respondent's Arguments

  • Adopted the petitioner's submissions regarding the constraint on participation caused by section 179 and the consequent breach of articles 6 and 8 ECHR.
  • Argued the situation was unforeseen and exceptional, making resort to the nobile officium appropriate.

Fourth Respondent's Arguments

  • Acknowledged the petition might be competent but argued the prayer should be refused as unnecessary.
  • Denied the circumstances were exceptional or unforeseen.
  • Asserted proceeding with the referral proof would not breach the petitioner's or second respondent's ECHR rights.
  • Emphasized the fourth respondent's interest in concluding the referral proceedings without delay, noting she had already given evidence by commission.

First Respondent's Arguments

  • Contended the petition is incompetent and should be dismissed.
  • Asserted the petitioner has an alternative remedy by way of reduction of the sheriff's interlocutor.
  • Argued section 163 does not exclude common law remedies such as reduction or suspension.
  • Maintained the concurrence of criminal and referral proceedings is common and foreseeable, and section 179 contemplates this.
  • Asserted the petitioner's interests conflict with the children's best interests and that the parens patriae jurisdiction is not engaged.

Third Respondent's Arguments

  • Asserted the petition is incompetent because the omission of appeal rights against interlocutory decisions was deliberate and should not be overridden by the court.
  • Argued the parens patriae jurisdiction does not apply as the petitioner has an alternative remedy and the petition primarily protects the petitioner's interests, not the children's.

Sixth Respondent's Arguments

  • Submitted that the nobile officium is only available in exceptional, unforeseen circumstances where no other remedy exists.
  • Argued the circumstances here are neither exceptional nor unforeseen, and the petitioner has remedies such as reduction or suspension.
  • Noted that section 179 anticipates concurrent criminal and referral proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
H(N) v HM Advocate 2019 SLT 943 Illustrates concerns about the use of section 179 information requests affecting participation in proceedings. Referenced to support petitioner's argument about potential adverse effects on participation due to section 179.
Ferguson v P; Ferguson, Petitioner 1989 SC 231 Emphasizes the importance of referral proceedings being conducted in closed court and restricting disclosure of material. Used to support the argument that disclosure under section 179 may undermine confidentiality and effective participation.
Cumbria County Council v X 2017 SC 451 Addresses the exercise of parens patriae jurisdiction to safeguard children's welfare. Invoked by petitioner to justify resort to the court's inherent jurisdiction to protect children's interests.
Prior v Scottish Ministers 2020 SC 528 Discusses appropriate procedural vehicles for seeking reduction of interlocutors. Referenced to discuss whether reduction should be sought by ordinary action or judicial review.
Glasgow City Council, Petitioners 2004 SLT 61 Opinion on remedies available against interlocutory decisions. Mentioned in submissions regarding procedural options.
D, Petitioner 2011 SLT 101 Discusses procedural remedies against interlocutory decisions. Referenced in submissions concerning availability of reduction or suspension.
R v Kennedy 1993 SC 417 Emphasizes legislative primacy and limits on court intervention in statutory schemes. Used to argue against court's intervention on interlocutory decisions.
Man Hen Liu v Andersons Solicitors LLP [2017] CSIH 45 Reduction or suspension of interlocutors to avoid miscarriage of justice. Applied to confirm availability of reduction remedy in interlocutory decisions.
Lamb v Thompson (1901) 4 F 88 Supports reduction or suspension of interlocutory orders. Referenced to support availability of reduction remedy.
Principal Reporter v K 2011 SC (UKSC) 91 Confirms procedural remedies available in children's hearings cases. Used to support argument that section 163 does not exclude reduction or suspension.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the competency of the petition invoking the nobile officium to challenge an interlocutory sheriff's decision refusing to discharge and sist the referral proceedings pending criminal proceedings. The court rejected the petitioner's submission that section 163 of the 2011 Act excludes all remedies against interlocutory decisions, including reduction, suspension, or judicial review. The court held that section 163 neither expressly nor impliedly excludes such common law remedies.

The court emphasized that interlocutory decisions may be amenable to reduction if necessary to avoid miscarriage of justice or to achieve substantial justice, referencing established case law. It rejected the petitioner's argument that only final decisions on the merits are subject to reduction.

The court found that the concurrence of criminal and referral proceedings is a foreseeable and common occurrence contemplated by the legislature in section 179. Therefore, the circumstances are not exceptional or unforeseen, negating the basis for resorting to the nobile officium or parens patriae jurisdiction.

Regarding the petitioner's Convention rights claims, the court noted the complaint centers on the sheriff's refusal to discharge and sist amidst the prospect of a section 179 information request. However, the court concluded that since the petitioner is not without alternative remedies, invoking the nobile officium is inappropriate.

The court observed that the petition primarily advances the petitioner's personal interests rather than those of the children, a factor weighing against the exercise of inherent jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the petition invoking the nobile officium and sustained the first respondent's plea-in-law challenging the petition's competency.

The direct effect is that the petitioner must pursue alternative remedies, such as reduction or suspension of the sheriff's interlocutor, if she wishes to challenge the interlocutory decision. The court's ruling clarifies that section 163 does not exclude such remedies and confirms that the concurrence of criminal and referral proceedings is anticipated by statute. No new precedent altering the availability of remedies or the interpretation of section 179 was established.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

PETITION TO THE NOBILE OFFICIUM BY SU

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

PETITION TO THE NOBILE OFFICIUM BY SU
(Dec 7, 2021)