Factual and Procedural Background
On 17 February 2020, a four-month-old baby boy, the sixth child of the Defendant parents, was found to have multiple posterior rib fractures. Subsequent medical examinations revealed bruising to his feet and lower spine, and further x-rays confirmed additional rib fractures. The baby had been born prematurely at 31 weeks gestation and suffered feeding difficulties linked to a rare chromosomal abnormality called Tetrasomy 18p. The family had been known to social services since 2017, with prior concerns about the parents' mental health, home conditions, neglect, and supervision leading to Child in Need plans for the older children. The eldest child alleged an assault by the father in late 2019.
The Local Authority, Derby City Council, initiated care proceedings following a fact-finding hearing. The core issue was the cause and timing of the baby's rib fractures, considering factors such as his genetic condition, possible inadvertent injury by healthcare professionals, and potential non-accidental injury by the parents. The family comprises the mother, father, and six children, with varying living arrangements including foster care and supervised contact. The Royal Derby Hospital NHS Trust intervened due to concerns about healthcare professionals' involvement. The hearing involved extensive evidence, including oral testimony from family members, social workers, and multiple expert witnesses, alongside voluminous documentary and medical records.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the baby’s rib fractures were caused accidentally or non-accidentally.
- The timing of the rib fractures and whether they occurred on one or multiple occasions.
- The impact of the baby's genetic condition (Tetrasomy 18p) and other factors on bone strength and vulnerability to fractures.
- Whether healthcare professionals could have inadvertently caused the fractures during medical procedures.
- Whether the parents inflicted the injuries deliberately or through excessive force without awareness.
- Whether the threshold under section 31(2) of the Children Act 1989 was met for making care or supervision orders in relation to the children.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments (Local Authority)
- The baby’s rib fractures and bruising were non-accidentally inflicted by one or both parents through excessive force.
- The fractures occurred on at least two separate occasions by squeezing the baby’s chest with high force beyond normal handling.
- The parents failed to meet the health needs of their children, including neglecting medical appointments and failing to provide necessary equipment like EpiPens and special footwear.
- The father assaulted the eldest child and slapped another child, and the children were exposed to domestic abuse.
- The parents’ explanations for the injuries, including allegations against healthcare professionals, were inconsistent and not credible.
- Given the evidence, the Local Authority contended that the threshold for care or supervision orders was met due to significant harm or risk of harm.
Respondents' Arguments (Parents)
- There are many unknowns regarding the timing of fractures, the effect of the rare genetic condition, extent of bone weakness, and degree of force required to cause fractures.
- The parents asserted they were caring and experienced, denying deliberate harm.
- The occurrence of fractures on two occasions suggests the baby may have had an inherent vulnerability to fractures.
- The Local Authority failed to prove on the balance of probabilities that the parents caused the baby’s rib fractures non-accidentally.
- The parents challenged the credibility of some allegations and raised concerns about the handling of the baby by healthcare professionals.
Children's Guardian and Other Parties
- The Guardian adopted a neutral stance, acknowledging stresses in the household but noting positive evidence of care for the baby.
- The intervening NHS Trust facilitated expert evidence and did not dispute the medical findings but raised concerns about the timing and cause of injuries.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Re B [2008] UKHL 35 |
Standard of proof in family proceedings is the balance of probabilities. |
The court applied the binary standard of proof as clarified by Lord Hoffman, requiring facts to be either proved or not. |
| Re A (A child) (Fact Finding Hearing: Speculation) [2011] EWCA Civ 12 |
Findings must be based on evidence, not speculation. |
The court emphasized reliance on concrete evidence when making findings of fact. |
| A County Council v KD & L [2005] EWHC 144 (Fam) |
The court weighs expert evidence against other evidence; the judge makes the final decision. |
The court applied this principle in assessing medical expert opinions in the context of all evidence. |
| R v Lucas [1981] QB 720 |
Witnesses may lie for various reasons; lying about some matters does not imply lying about all. |
The court considered the possibility of partial untruthfulness by witnesses without dismissing all their evidence. |
| Re SB (Children) [2009] EWCA Civ 1048 |
Identification of perpetrator based on balance of probabilities; avoid straining to find a perpetrator. |
The court applied the “real possibility” test to identify potential perpetrators without overreaching. |
| Re J (Children) [2013] UKSC 9 |
Threshold for care orders involves satisfying the court of significant harm and its attribution to inadequate care. |
The court applied the statutory threshold in evaluating whether harm or risk of harm justified intervention. |
| Re H (Minors) (Sexual Abuse: Standard of Proof) [1996] AC 563 |
"Likely" in s.31(2) means a real possibility, not more likely than not. |
The court accepted that risk of harm under the Children Act means a possibility that cannot be ignored. |
| The Poppi M, Rhesa Shipping Company SA v Edmunds [1985] 1 WLR 948 |
A judge is not compelled to choose between improbable explanations and may find the burden of proof unmet. |
The court recognized that it may be appropriate to find insufficient evidence rather than choosing between unlikely scenarios. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a detailed and careful evaluation of extensive evidence, including medical expert opinions, witness testimonies, and documentary records. It applied established legal principles governing fact-finding in family proceedings, notably the burden of proof resting with the Local Authority and the standard of proof being the balance of probabilities.
The medical evidence established that the baby's rib fractures occurred on two separate occasions, with timing windows identified between early and late January 2020 for the right ribs, and early to mid-February 2020 for the left ribs. The fractures were caused by bilateral compression of the chest, likely by adult hands applying force exceeding normal handling. The baby’s genetic condition, prematurity, feeding difficulties, and medication (Omeprazole) likely contributed to a reduced bone mineral density, increasing susceptibility to fractures. However, the extent and timing of any bone weakening were uncertain.
The court found no evidence that healthcare professionals deliberately inflicted injury or handled the baby with excessive force capable of causing fractures, though it could not exclude the possibility that the attempted MRI scan on 23 January 2020 involved robust handling that might have contributed to the right rib fractures.
The parents were found to have cared for the baby with affection and generally appropriate handling, supported by positive assessments from health visitors and social workers. Neither parent was found to have deliberately inflicted the fractures, nor to have knowingly handled the baby with excessive force causing injury. The possibility that the fractures resulted from inadvertent excessive force during times when the baby was distressed was accepted, particularly given the baby’s increased vulnerability due to bone weakness from mid to late January 2020 onwards.
The court carefully considered the credibility of the parents and other family members, noting some untruthfulness by the parents regarding an assault by the father on the eldest child but finding no evidence that they lied to cover up deliberate harm to the baby. The court also noted the father’s mental health issues and the family’s social difficulties but found these did not amount to significant harm or risk of harm to the children warranting care orders on those grounds.
Ultimately, the court balanced the expert medical evidence and all other evidence to conclude that the baby’s rib fractures were accidental, caused by inadvertent application of excessive force during care, without awareness by the handler of the injury caused, and that the parents had not met the threshold for care orders on the basis of non-accidental injury.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED
The court dismissed the Local Authority’s central allegations that the baby's rib fractures were non-accidental injuries inflicted by the mother and/or father. It held that the fractures were caused accidentally through inadvertent excessive force applied during care, likely when the baby was distressed and vulnerable due to reduced bone strength. There was no evidence that either parent deliberately inflicted injury or knowingly caused harm.
The court found that other allegations of neglect and assault were not proven to the threshold of significant harm, and that the children were not at risk of significant harm in the care of their parents on that basis.
The direct consequence is that the threshold for making care or supervision orders based on non-accidental injury was not established. No new precedent was set, and the court emphasized the need for continued support and cooperation among the family, social services, and healthcare professionals for the welfare and potential reunification of the family.