Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

The Republic of Mozambique v. Credit Suisse International & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment concerns two related sets of proceedings initiated by the Plaintiff against multiple Defendants, including Company A entities, individuals formerly employed by one of those entities (the "Team Defendants"), and a group of companies collectively referred to as "the Privinvest Defendants." The first claim (the "Main Action") was issued in early 2019 and consolidated with a subsidiary claim. The second claim is against the controlling individual of the Privinvest group (the "Safa Action"), which is not directly relevant here.

The Main Action arises from three written supply contracts ("the Supply Contracts") entered into between certain Privinvest Defendants as suppliers and special purpose vehicles (SPVs) owned by the Plaintiff's state, created for these contracts. The contracts involved supply of ships, aircraft, and infrastructure for policing territorial waters, a fishing fleet, and shipyard and related services. Each Supply Contract contained arbitration clauses governed by Swiss law, while related sub-contracts and financing agreements were governed by English law with exclusive jurisdiction in English courts.

The Plaintiff guaranteed the SPVs’ loan obligations under sovereign guarantees governed by English law. Allegedly, the Suppliers received full payment from financiers, but the Plaintiff accrued significant liability under the guarantees, amounting to approximately $2.1 billion. The Plaintiff alleges payments of bribes totaling at least $143 million, paid to various individuals including the Team Defendants and certain officials of the Plaintiff's state, with some admissions of illicit payments by the Team Defendants in separate US criminal proceedings.

The Plaintiff's claims include allegations that the guarantees are null and void, liability for bribery, conspiracy to injure by unlawful means, dishonest assistance in breaches of fiduciary duty, knowing receipt of proceeds, proprietary claims, and deceit (the latter not relevant here). The Privinvest Defendants applied to stay the proceedings against them pursuant to section 9 of the Arbitration Act 1996, arguing that the claims fall within the scope of the arbitration clauses in the Supply Contracts.

Five related arbitrations have been commenced in Switzerland, including ICC and Swiss Chambers Arbitration Institution (SCAI) proceedings, involving many of the same parties and issues. The arbitrations address, among other points, whether the Plaintiff is party to the arbitration agreements and the validity of the Supply Contracts. Procedural orders have refused bifurcation of jurisdiction and merits and scheduled hearings in 2021 and 2022.

The court was tasked with determining the "Scope Issue"—whether the claims made by the Plaintiff against the Privinvest Defendants fall within the scope of the arbitration clauses, to decide the extent to which the stay application should be granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arbitration clauses in the Supply Contracts cover the claims made by the Plaintiff against the Privinvest Defendants (the "Scope Issue").
  2. Whether the Plaintiff, although not an express party to the Supply Contracts, is bound by the arbitration clauses as a beneficiary under Swiss law (the "Beneficiary Issue").
  3. Whether certain Defendants who subcontracted the Suppliers' roles can invoke the arbitration clauses under Swiss law due to their involvement (the "Interference Issue").

Arguments of the Parties

Privinvest Defendants' Arguments

  • The Instrument of Fraud Allegation ("IFA") is covered by the arbitration clauses.
  • The IFA is an essential element of all claims against the Privinvest Defendants.
  • Therefore, all claims fall within the arbitration clauses, entitling them to a stay of proceedings.
  • Alternatively, even if only the IFA is covered, a mandatory stay of that issue should be granted, potentially followed by a case management stay of remaining claims.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The IFA is not caught by the arbitration clauses.
  • None of the substantive claims fall within the scope of the arbitration clauses.
  • Accordingly, no part of the Main Action is subject to arbitration.
  • Alternatively, if only the IFA is covered, any case management stay of the remainder would be resisted; the Privinvest Defendants must defend the Main Action.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tomulugen v Silica [2015] SGCA 57 Two-stage process for identifying "matter" for arbitration: (1) identify the matter(s) in the proceedings; (2) determine if matter(s) fall within the arbitration clause. The matter must be reasonably substantial and not overly broad or narrow. The court applied this approach to reject an overly broad characterization of the claims, distinguishing between elements within and outside arbitration scope.
Sodzawiczny v Ruhan [2018] 2 Lloyds Rep 280 Any issue capable of constituting a dispute within arbitration scope should be stayed pro tanto. The court looks at substance over form and accepts fragmentation of proceedings as a consequence of arbitration agreements. The court endorsed this principle and emphasized the importance of respecting party autonomy and the need to stay proceedings only as to issues within arbitration scope.
Autoridad del Canal v Sacyr [2017] 2 Lloyds Rep 351 Endorsed the requirement that issues for arbitration must be "reasonably substantial" and supported the approach in Tomulugen. Cited with approval to support the court’s approach on the scope of arbitration clauses.
China Export v Emerald [2018] EWHC 1503 Supported the approach that the court should identify issues within the scope of arbitration and stay proceedings accordingly. Used to reinforce the principle that the court should consider the substance of claims when determining arbitration scope.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by outlining the objective principles of Swiss law governing the interpretation of arbitration clauses, emphasizing that the interpretation is objective, contextual, and includes the principle in favorem arbitri (favoring arbitration), but this principle cannot override clear language or context.

The court noted the existence of multiple arbitration clauses across related contracts, which militates for a narrower interpretation of the connection required to bring claims within each clause. The multiplicity of clauses suggests each clause is principally intended for disputes relating to its particular contract, limiting the scope for claims broadly connected to the contracts.

Applying English law principles, the court considered the two-stage process for identifying the "matter" subject to arbitration: identifying the issues in the claim and then determining whether those issues fall within the arbitration clause. The court emphasized that the matter must be reasonably substantial and not artificially broad or narrow.

Analyzing the Plaintiff’s claims individually, the court found:

  • Bribery Claim: Although the IFA forms part of the background, bribery is a tort independent of contract, and the claim is not sufficiently connected to the arbitration clauses.
  • Dishonest Assistance Claim: Similarly, this claim depends on breaches of fiduciary duty and is only loosely connected to the contracts; it falls outside the arbitration clauses.
  • Knowing Receipt and Proprietary Claims: These claims relate to monies actually received and do not concern proceeds of the Supply Contracts; they fall outside the arbitration clauses.
  • Conspiracy Claim: Although it includes the IFA as one of several unlawful means, the claim as a whole is broader and not sufficiently connected to the arbitration clauses.

The court rejected the Privinvest Defendants' overarching argument that the entire case is "all about" the Supply Contracts, emphasizing that the claims are tortious and equitable in nature and do not seek relief under the contracts themselves.

Turning to the IFA itself, the court acknowledged it is a discrete matter that could be arbitrated, but found it is not sufficiently connected to the arbitration clauses to warrant a stay. The court highlighted that the IFA involves no direct contractual claim or relief and that arbitrating it separately would cause serious fragmentation of proceedings without a clear objective intent by the parties to arbitrate only that issue.

In conclusion, the court held that none of the claims, including the IFA, fall within the scope of the arbitration clauses, and therefore the stay application must be dismissed.

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision is that the application for a stay of proceedings pursuant to section 9 of the Arbitration Act 1996 is DISMISSED.

The direct consequence is that the claims against the Privinvest Defendants will proceed in the court rather than being referred to arbitration. The court found no "matter" in respect of which the proceedings are brought that falls within the arbitration clauses. No trial on the remaining issues related to the application is necessary.

No new legal precedent is established beyond the application of existing principles to the particular facts of this case. The decision clarifies the limits of arbitration clause scope in complex multi-contract, multi-claim disputes involving tort and equitable claims alongside contract claims.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

The Republic of Mozambique v Credit Suisse International & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

The Republic of Mozambique v Credit Suisse International & Ors
(Jul 30, 2020)