Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute arises from a series of nine contracts ("the Contracts") entered into between Company A and Defendant, a retail bank incorporated in the Russian Federation which later became insolvent. Under these Contracts, Company A sold Defendant certain credit linked notes issued by a third-party bank's London branch. The Contracts included arbitration agreements governed by English law and specifying London as the seat of arbitration under LCIA Rules.
Following regulatory intervention by the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, Defendant was placed into provisional administration and subsequently declared insolvent. Bankruptcy proceedings commenced before a court in The City of St Petersburg. Defendant, represented by a state corporation acting as its official receiver, initiated proceedings in the St Petersburg court seeking invalidation of the Contracts on grounds of alleged asset siphoning and breach of Russian bankruptcy law.
Company A contended that the St Petersburg proceedings breached the LCIA arbitration agreements and applied to the English court for an interim anti-suit injunction (ASI) under the Senior Courts Act 1981 to restrain the foreign proceedings. Defendant responded with an application challenging the English court's jurisdiction and sought permission to rely on expert evidence on Russian law.
The English court expedited the hearing of these applications and considered submissions from both parties' counsel. The matter raised significant issues regarding the scope and arbitrability of claims under foreign insolvency law and the enforcement of arbitration agreements in the context of foreign insolvency proceedings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the English court should exercise its jurisdiction to grant an interim anti-suit injunction restraining the St Petersburg proceedings as being in breach of the LCIA arbitration agreements.
- Whether the claims brought in the St Petersburg proceedings fall within the scope of the LCIA arbitration agreements as a matter of English law construction.
- Whether the claims in the foreign insolvency proceedings are arbitrable under English law, considering the public policy implications of insolvency-related claims.
- Whether there exist strong reasons not to grant the anti-suit injunction, including considerations of comity, foreign insolvency policy, and risk of inconsistent decisions.
- Whether it is just and convenient to grant the interim anti-suit injunction.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Company A)
- The St Petersburg Action breaches the LCIA arbitration agreements, which are governed by English law and specify London as the seat of arbitration.
- The claims in the foreign proceedings are contractual in nature and fall within the scope of the arbitration agreements.
- The claims are arbitrable under English law, including insolvency-related avoidance claims, given that the arbitration tribunal can grant the relief sought.
- There are no strong reasons not to grant the anti-suit injunction; comity and foreign insolvency policies do not override the parties' agreement to arbitrate in London.
- The risk of inconsistent decisions does not justify refusing the injunction, particularly as some claims by third parties in the foreign proceedings are parasitic and may not proceed if the main claim is pursued in arbitration.
- Company A offered undertakings not to challenge the arbitrability of the claims in the arbitration tribunal.
Respondent's Arguments (Defendant)
- The English court is not the natural or appropriate forum to determine the dispute; the St Petersburg court should decide issues of jurisdiction and arbitrability.
- The claims in the St Petersburg Action are brought by the official receiver (a state corporation) on behalf of Defendant, not by Defendant itself, and thus fall outside the arbitration agreements.
- The claims do not fall within the scope of the arbitration agreements as a matter of construction, particularly insolvency avoidance claims.
- The claims are not arbitrable under English law because they involve matters of public interest and insolvency law which cannot be properly determined within arbitration.
- The policy of supporting foreign insolvency proceedings and comity constitute strong reasons not to grant the anti-suit injunction.
- The risk of inconsistent decisions in parallel proceedings and the burden of pursuing claims in arbitration independently from the collective insolvency process weigh against granting the injunction.
- The injunction would interfere with the duties of the official receiver in the foreign insolvency proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Enka Insaat Ve Sanayi v OOO "Insurance Co Chubb" [2020] EWCA Civ 574 |
English court as the seat of arbitration is appropriate to grant anti-suit injunctions; forum conveniens does not displace this. |
Supported the court's jurisdiction to grant ASI despite Defendant's forum non conveniens argument. |
| Ust-Kamenogorsk Hydropower Plant JSC v AES Hydropower Plant LLP [2013] UKSC 35 |
Power to grant injunctions restraining breach of arbitration agreements under Senior Courts Act 1981 s.37. |
Confirmed the court's power to grant ASI even if no arbitration proceedings are on foot. |
| The Angelic Grace [1995] 1 Lloyd's Rep 87; Dell Emerging Markets (EMEA) Ltd v IB Maroc.com SA [2017] EWHC 2397 |
Applicant must show high probability of breach of arbitration agreement to obtain ASI. |
Guided the court's assessment of the "Breach Issue". |
| The Epsilon Rosa [2003] 2 Lloyd's Rep 50 |
Respondent must show strong reason why ASI relief should not be granted. |
Framed the "Strong Reason Issue" analysis. |
| Through Transport Mutual Assurance v New India Assurance Co [2004] EWCA Civ 1598 |
Characterisation of claims for arbitrability and scope of arbitration clause depends on the substance of the claim under English law. |
Applied to determine whether claims fell within arbitration agreements. |
| BNP Paribas SA v Open Joint Stock Company Russian Machines [2011] EWHC 308 (Comm) |
Characterisation of claims under English law relevant to arbitrability and scope of arbitration agreement. |
Considered in assessing the nature of the claims in the foreign proceedings. |
| Nori Holding Ltd v PJSC Bank Otkritie Financial Corp [2018] 2 Lloyd's Rep 80 |
Claims under Russian Bankruptcy Law and Civil Code are arbitrable and fall within LCIA arbitration agreements. |
Strongly relied upon as analogous and persuasive precedent. |
| Larsen Oil and Gas Pte Ltd v Petroprod Ltd [2011] 3 SLR 414 |
Arbitration clauses generally do not cover insolvency avoidance claims; insolvency claims may be non-arbitrable. |
Considered and distinguished; English law does not adopt Larsen's presumption. |
| Donohue v Armco Inc [2001] UKHL 64 |
Claims which English courts cannot entertain do not fall within English jurisdiction clauses. |
Applied to construction of arbitration clauses and arbitrability. |
| Fulham Football Club (1987) Ltd v Richards [2011] EWCA Civ 855 |
Arbitrators may lack power to grant all remedies courts can; this does not negate arbitration agreement validity. |
Supported the court's view that arbitration can cover claims even if some relief is unavailable. |
| Société Commerciale de Reassurance v Eras International Ltd [1992] 1 Lloyd's Rep 570 |
Stay in arbitration is mandatory unless arbitration agreement is null or inoperative; limited remedies do not negate arbitration. |
Informed the court's approach to arbitrability and enforcement of arbitration agreements. |
| Rubin v Eurofinance SA [2013] 1 AC 236 |
Distinction between company claims and statutory claims by liquidators; insolvency claims may be non-arbitrable; limits on recognition of foreign insolvency judgments. |
Central to public policy and arbitrability analysis of insolvency claims. |
| Jefferies International Ltd v Landsbanki HF [2009] EWHC 894 (Comm) |
Strong presumption to enforce forum selection agreements even in insolvency context; stay requires strong and compelling reasons. |
Supported enforcement of arbitration agreement despite foreign insolvency. |
| Singularis Holdings Ltd v PricewaterhouseCoopers [2014] UKPC 36 |
English courts may assist foreign insolvency proceedings but limits apply when conflicting with English public policy. |
Considered in balancing cooperation and enforcement of arbitration agreements. |
| OT Africa Line Ltd v Magic Sportswear Corporation [2005] EWCA Civ 710 |
Comity is subordinate to upholding parties' agreed jurisdiction; injunctions enforce forum selection agreements. |
Supported the court's view that enforcing arbitration agreements is paramount. |
| Verity Shipping SA v NV Norexa [2008] EWHC 213 (Comm) |
Risk of inconsistent decisions may constitute strong reason not to grant ASI if injustice to third parties arises. |
Considered in assessing the risk of inconsistent outcomes. |
| Joint Stock Asset Management Co Ingosstrakh-Investments v BNP Paribas SA [2012] EWCA Civ 644 |
Joinder of third parties in LCIA arbitration possible; connected parties may be joined to avoid parallel proceedings. |
Discussed in context of potential joinder of third parties to arbitration. |
| Skype Technologies SA v Joltid Ltd [2009] EWHC 2783 (Ch) |
Forum conveniens arguments have limited weight against agreed neutral forum. |
Applied to reject burden arguments against arbitration in agreed forum. |
| Mobile Telecommunications Co v HRH Prince Hussam Bin Saudi Bin Abdulaziz Al Saud [2018] EWHC 1469 |
Mandatory injunctions are unusual at interim stage; caution in granting mandatory relief. |
Supported refusal of mandatory injunction at interim stage. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by addressing Defendant's challenge to the English court's jurisdiction under Part 11, rejecting the argument that the Russian forum was the natural and appropriate forum. It relied on established principle that the court of the seat of arbitration is appropriate to grant anti-suit injunctions enforcing arbitration agreements, and that the parties had agreed to submit to English jurisdiction for such matters.
Regarding the scope of the arbitration agreements, the court applied English law to construe the LCIA arbitration clauses broadly, including claims to invalidate contracts in insolvency proceedings. It followed the approach in Through Transport and Nori Holding that the substance of the claims governs arbitrability and scope, rather than the legal form or statutory vehicle under foreign law.
The court found that the claims in the St Petersburg Action, brought by the official receiver on behalf of Defendant, were effectively claims of Defendant itself and thus fell within the arbitration agreements. It rejected the argument that insolvency avoidance claims are per se non-arbitrable, distinguishing the Singapore Larsen decision and relying on English authorities supporting arbitrability of such claims when the tribunal can grant the relief sought.
The court considered public policy and the principle of modified universalism, concluding that enforcing the arbitration agreement would not conflict with the foreign insolvency process or the collective distribution of assets. It recognized the strong international public policy supporting arbitration and the parties’ agreement to arbitrate disputes.
On the "strong reason" stage, the court rejected Defendant's arguments that comity, foreign insolvency policy, and risk of inconsistent decisions justified refusal of the injunction. It noted that the injunction would not interfere with the official receiver's duties, and that the risk of inconsistent decisions was mitigated by the centrality of Defendant's claims and the parasitic nature of third-party claims. The possibility of joinder in arbitration was discussed but not decisive.
The court also rejected arguments that the burden and expense of arbitration were disproportionate, given the amount at issue and the parties' agreement.
Finally, the court considered discretionary factors, including the risk that the injunction might not be obeyed, but found no sufficient prejudice to Defendant to deny the injunction. It declined to grant a mandatory injunction at this interim stage due to the complexity of arbitrability issues and the usual approach to mandatory relief.
Holding and Implications
The court dismissed Defendant's Part 11 application challenging jurisdiction.
The court granted Company A's application for a negative interim anti-suit injunction restraining continuation of the St Petersburg proceedings in breach of the LCIA arbitration agreements.
The court refused Company A's application for a mandatory injunction requiring immediate withdrawal of the foreign proceedings.
The decision enforces the parties' arbitration agreement and confirms that insolvency-related avoidance claims brought by an official receiver on behalf of an insolvent entity can be subject to arbitration under English law, provided the tribunal can grant the relief sought. The ruling underscores the strong English public policy in favor of upholding arbitration agreements, even in the context of foreign insolvency proceedings, and clarifies that considerations of comity and foreign insolvency policy do not automatically override such agreements.
No new precedent was established beyond affirming and applying existing principles on arbitrability, scope of arbitration agreements, and the circumstances in which anti-suit injunctions should be granted.