Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates

Fox v. Wiggins & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, a well-known musician, singer, and songwriter, initiated proceedings against multiple Defendants, including the Sixth Defendant, for defamation and harassment. The Plaintiff alleges that from late March 2016 onwards, the Defendants engaged in a coordinated campaign of harassment involving false and defamatory publications and other hostile acts. The Sixth Defendant, an ex-partner of the Plaintiff, was involved in this alleged campaign, including publishing a defamatory blog accusing the Plaintiff of serious misconduct.

The Sixth Defendant failed to file a Defence within the permitted time, resulting in default judgment entered against her. Her mother, acting as litigation friend, later applied for a declaration that the Sixth Defendant lacks capacity under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and sought to set aside the default judgment and obtain relief from sanctions. The case against other Defendants is ongoing, and the Plaintiff has settled with one Defendant. Issues relating to costs arising from the Sixth Defendant's defaults and adjournments are also before the court.

The Sixth Defendant's mother became her litigation friend in December 2018, filing a certificate of suitability on the basis that the Sixth Defendant was a protected party due to incapacity. The Sixth Defendant contends that if incapacity is established, steps taken prior to the appointment of a litigation friend (including the default judgment) may be of no effect unless regularised by the court. The hearing was adjourned from a damages trial to determine the capacity and set aside applications.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence displaces the presumption that the Sixth Defendant has capacity to conduct proceedings, and if she lacked capacity at the relevant time when default judgment was entered (the Capacity Issue).
  2. If the Capacity Issue is not resolved in the Sixth Defendant's favour, whether the court should grant relief from sanctions by setting aside the default judgment (the Set Aside Issue).
  3. If relief is granted, which procedural steps taken prior to the appointment of the litigation friend should be retrospectively regularised under CPR rule 21.3(4) (the Regularisation Issue).
  4. Subsidiary consideration of costs related to the Sixth Defendant's defaults and adjournments.

Arguments of the Parties

Sixth Defendant's Arguments

  • The Sixth Defendant submits that she lacks capacity within the meaning of CPR Part 21, supported by psychiatric evidence and her mother's witness statements describing her mental and physical health conditions and inability to engage with the litigation.
  • She contends that her evidence meets the legal test for incapacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA 2005) and that the court should accept the appointment of her litigation friend and declare her a protected party.
  • The Sixth Defendant argues that the Plaintiff's criticisms of the psychiatric evidence are unfounded and that the Plaintiff has failed to provide contrary medical evidence.
  • Regarding the set aside application, she claims a real prospect of successfully defending the claim, denying the alleged coordinated campaign and asserting defences under the Defamation Act 2013 and the Protection from Harassment Act 1997.
  • She submits that the default judgment should be set aside for good reason, including the serious nature of the allegations and the need for the claim to be tried on the merits against all Defendants to avoid inconsistent outcomes.
  • She asserts that the delay in applying to set aside was due to lack of legal representation and that the procedural defaults were matters of form rather than substance, justifying relief from sanctions under the Denton test.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff contends that the evidence submitted by the Sixth Defendant is sparse, outdated, and insufficient to rebut the statutory presumption of capacity under the MCA 2005.
  • He highlights inconsistencies between the Sixth Defendant's medical evidence and her observed social activity and employment, undermining claims of incapacity.
  • The Plaintiff argues that the Sixth Defendant has failed to serve any Defence or draft Defence despite ample time and assistance, and thus cannot show a real prospect of successfully defending the claim.
  • He submits that there is no good reason to set aside the default judgment and that the procedural defaults cannot be excused by lack of legal knowledge or representation, referencing recent Supreme Court authority limiting indulgence to unrepresented litigants.
  • The Plaintiff emphasizes the prejudice he would suffer if relief were granted, including loss of finality and the burden of protracted litigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co (Nos 1 and 2) [2003] 1 WLR 1511 Power under CPR r 21.3(4) to regularise steps taken before appointment of litigation friend if done in good faith and no manifest disadvantage. Referenced in assessing the effect of procedural steps taken prior to appointment of litigation friend and the need for fact-specific determination of regularisation.
Dunhill (a protected party by her litigation friend) v Burgin (No 2) [2014] 1 WLR 933 Retrospective validation of steps taken before appointment of litigation friend is discretionary and may exclude settlement. Used to illustrate that some steps may be validated retrospectively but settlement may not be.
Berezovsky v Russian Television and Radio [2009] EWHC 1733 In defamation claims, it is in the interests of justice for pleas of justification to be properly addressed and claims not to be decided solely on default judgment. Supported the court's decision to set aside default judgment to allow full defence on the merits in serious defamation allegations.
Hussain v Birmingham City Council [2005] EWCA Civ 1570 Discretion to set aside default judgment is unconditional and exercised to avoid injustice, not to punish incompetence. Guided the court's approach to relief from sanctions and setting aside default judgment.
Denton v TH White (Practice Note) [2014] 1 WLR 3926 Three-stage test for relief from sanctions: seriousness of breach, reasons for breach, and all circumstances of the case. Applied in assessing whether to grant relief from sanctions in setting aside default judgment.
Gentry v Miller [2016] 1 WLR 2696 Interrelationship between CPR r 13.3 and Denton test for setting aside default judgment. Clarified the application of legal tests in the context of default judgment relief.
Majrowski v Guys and St Thomas's [2007] 1 AC 224 Definition of harassment requiring conduct capable of sustaining criminal liability. Referenced in arguments regarding the nature and seriousness of alleged harassment.
Trimingham v Associated Newspapers [2012] 4 All ER 717 Difficulty in succeeding in harassment claims by publication. Supported the Sixth Defendant's contention on the challenges of harassment claims.
Barton v Wright Hassall [2018] 1 WLR 1119 Represented litigants are not entitled to greater indulgence than represented parties in compliance with court rules. Supported the Plaintiff's submission limiting indulgence to unrepresented parties.
EDF Energy Customers Ltd v Re-Energised Ltd [2018] EWHC 652 Limited leeway for litigants in person in relief from sanctions unless rules are obscure or hard to find. Applied in evaluating the Sixth Defendant's procedural defaults and excuses.
LBL v RYJ [2010] EWHC 2664 (Fam) Capacity requires comprehension and weighing of salient details relevant to the decision. Used in summarising the legal test for capacity under the MCA 2005.
A Local Authority v P [2018] EWCOP 10 Detailed explanation of the two-stage capacity test (diagnostic and functional) and evidential considerations. Provided key principles guiding the court's assessment of capacity in this case.
CC v KK [2012] EWHC 2136 (COP) Warning against 'protection imperative' bias in capacity assessments. Informed the court's caution in assessing evidence of incapacity objectively.
London Borough of Hackney v SJF and JJF [2019] EWCOP 8 Clarified statutory test for incapacity requiring causative nexus between impairment and inability to decide. Guided the court's interpretation of the MCA 2005 test for incapacity.
PC & NC v City of York Council [2013] EWCA Civ 478 Interpretation of the MCA 2005 statutory test for incapacity. Supported the court's understanding of the legal framework for capacity.
A County Council v KD and L [2005] EWHC 144 (Fam) Role of court in weighing expert evidence on capacity. Reinforced the court's responsibility to assess expert evidence in context.
R (Hysaj) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2015] 1 WLR 2472 Unrepresented litigants are not entitled to lower standards of compliance with court rules. Referenced in assessing procedural defaults by the Sixth Defendant and her litigation friend.
Nata Lee Ltd v Abid [2015] 2 P & CR 3 Limits on indulgence to litigants in person in relief from sanctions applications. Applied in evaluating the Sixth Defendant's conduct.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the Capacity Issue, applying the presumption under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 that the Sixth Defendant has capacity unless proven otherwise on the balance of probabilities. The court reviewed the psychiatric evidence, consisting of two brief letters from the treating psychiatrist, and the witness statements from the Sixth Defendant's mother describing her mental and physical health conditions and difficulties engaging with the litigation.

The court found the psychiatric evidence insufficiently detailed and outdated, lacking a proper assessment against the statutory diagnostic and functional tests for capacity. The evidence did not adequately address practical steps taken or considered to assist the Sixth Defendant in decision-making. The mother's evidence, while credible, was recognized as partial and did not conclusively establish incapacity. Contradictory evidence from the Plaintiff concerning the Sixth Defendant's social activities and employment further undermined the incapacity claim.

Consequently, the court concluded that the Sixth Defendant failed to discharge the burden of proof to establish lack of capacity at the relevant time, and thus the Capacity Application failed.

Turning to the Set Aside Issue, the court applied CPR rule 13.3, requiring either a real prospect of successfully defending the claim or some other good reason to set aside default judgment, alongside the Denton three-stage test for relief from sanctions.

The court found no real prospect of successfully defending the claim on the material before it, noting the absence of any Defence or draft Defence and the serious nature of the allegations which had not been addressed substantively. However, the court accepted that there was another good reason to set aside the judgment: the serious defamation and harassment claims, the nature of the allegations, and the risk of inconsistent outcomes if the Sixth Defendant were excluded from trial while co-Defendants proceed.

Applying the Denton test, the court found the procedural breaches serious and significant, but accepted that the defaults resulted from lack of legal representation and illness. The court rejected arguments that the Sixth Defendant and her litigation friend were unaware of their obligations, emphasizing the need for compliance regardless of representation status.

Balancing all factors, the court exercised its discretion to grant relief from sanctions and set aside the default judgment to allow the Sixth Defendant to file a Defence and defend the claim on the merits, prioritizing justice and consistency.

The court deemed it unnecessary to decide in detail on the Regularisation Issue, noting uncertainty about the continuation of the litigation friend's appointment.

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision was to SET ASIDE THE DEFAULT JUDGMENT entered against the Sixth Defendant and to grant relief from sanctions, permitting her to file a Defence and participate in the substantive proceedings.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Sixth Defendant may now defend the defamation and harassment claims on their merits alongside the other Defendants, ensuring consistency and fairness in the litigation process. No declaration of incapacity was made, and the presumption of the Sixth Defendant's capacity remains intact. The court did not establish any new legal precedent but applied established principles to the facts before it. Costs related to the Sixth Defendant's procedural defaults were reserved for further submissions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Fox v Wiggins & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Fox v Wiggins & Ors
(Oct 16, 2019)