Factual and Procedural Background
This judgment follows a disposal hearing of a Part 8 claim concerning the estate of the deceased, who died on 25 May 2016. The deceased left a will dated 8 July 2012, which bequeathed the entire estate to his two sons, the Claimants. The will appointed an executrix, the Defendant, who obtained a grant of probate on 19 December 2016. Although the grant indicated the estate’s net value was about £1.9 million, the actual net value appears to be closer to £1.3 million, with the principal asset being the deceased's home.
The Claimants, as beneficiaries under CPR Part 64, brought the Part 8 claim seeking directions from the Court due to an impasse in finalising the estate. The Defendant claims fees for work undertaken in administering the estate. The Court was asked to determine two principal questions: whether the Court should permit the Defendant to be remunerated under its equitable discretion, and if so, in what amount. A subsidiary issue concerned whether penalty fees imposed by HMRC, allegedly due to lack of reasonable diligence in administration, should be borne personally by the Defendant.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under equitable discretion, the Court should permit the Defendant (executrix) to be remunerated for work done on the estate in the absence of a charging clause in the will.
- If remuneration is permitted, what is the appropriate quantum of such remuneration?
- Whether penalty fees imposed by HMRC due to alleged lack of reasonable diligence should be borne personally by the Defendant.
- Whether there was an agreement or understanding between the parties that would override the general principle barring executor remuneration absent a charging clause.
- Whether alternative legal bases such as estoppel by convention or unjust enrichment apply to allow remuneration.
Arguments of the Parties
Claimants' Arguments
- The Claimants accept, in principle, that some remuneration might be paid as a matter of good faith but assert there was never any agreement on a specific sum, hourly rate, or clear basis for charging.
- They contend that the Defendant is not entitled to charge fees absent a charging clause in the will or a clear agreement.
- They dispute any estoppel or unjust enrichment claims, emphasizing the lack of clear evidence supporting such doctrines.
Defendant's Arguments
- The Defendant claims there was a verbal agreement with the Claimants in August 2016 allowing her to charge an hourly rate of £250 (later discounted to £230) for her work on the estate.
- She asserts that the Claimants requested her to dedicate professional time to the estate and accepted the proposed charging arrangement.
- The Defendant relies on her witness statement describing these discussions and emails purportedly evidencing acceptance of her fees.
- She also argues alternatively that estoppel by convention applies or that denying remuneration would unjustly enrich the Claimants.
- The Defendant cites her negotiation with HMRC which saved the estate approximately £60,000 as evidence of the value of her work.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Boardman v Phipps [1966] UKHL 2 |
Equitable jurisdiction allowing the Court to authorise remuneration to an executor in absence of charging clause or agreement, exercised sparingly and in exceptional circumstances. |
The Court considered this principle but declined to exercise the discretion in Defendant's favour due to unsatisfactory and fanciful evidence, despite acknowledging the services provided. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court carefully evaluated the evidence, particularly the Defendant’s witness statement and relevant correspondence. It noted the established legal principle that, absent a charging clause or agreement, an executor is not entitled to remuneration beyond reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses.
The Defendant claimed a verbal agreement existed permitting remuneration at a specified hourly rate. However, the Court found this evidence to be inconsistent and lacking in necessary particulars, including failure to specify essential contractual details such as who, when, and where the agreement was made. The Defendant did not provide her occupation or professional qualifications, which undermined the credibility of her claim to be a professional entitled to charge fees.
The Court observed that the Defendant’s initial communication about charging came only after substantial work had been done and was couched in tentative language expressing hope that the Claimants would accept the charge, inconsistent with a prior binding agreement.
Subsequent emails from the Claimants expressed frustration and did not confirm any agreement to pay fees. The Court concluded the Defendant’s evidence regarding an agreement was fanciful and would not meet the threshold for summary judgment in her favour.
Alternative arguments advanced by the Defendant, such as estoppel by convention and unjust enrichment, were rejected due to insufficient evidence and because unjust enrichment does not arise if the self-dealing rule is not displaced.
Regarding the Boardman v Phipps principle, the Court acknowledged that while the Defendant’s efforts produced a saving to the estate, the discretion to award remuneration under this equitable jurisdiction is to be exercised sparingly. Given the unsatisfactory nature of the Defendant’s evidence and concerns about the honesty and care in her witness statement, the Court declined to exercise discretion in her favour.
On the subsidiary issue of HMRC penalties or interest, the Court found no evidence that penalties had been charged to the estate and declined to make any adjustment on that basis.
Holding and Implications
The Court held that the Defendant is not entitled to remuneration for her work on the estate. There was no agreement or charging clause to permit fees, and the evidence supporting an agreement was found to be fanciful and insufficient.
The Court declined to exercise its equitable discretion to authorise remuneration under the Boardman v Phipps principle due to concerns about the quality and credibility of the Defendant’s evidence.
The Defendant’s alternative claims based on estoppel and unjust enrichment were rejected. No adjustment was made regarding HMRC penalties or interest.
The direct effect is that the Defendant must administer the estate without charging fees beyond reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses. No new precedent was established by this decision.