Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

Cartier International AG & Ors v. British Sky Broadcasting Ltd & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff group ("Richemont") owns numerous United Kingdom Registered Trade Marks for luxury brands such as CARTIER, MONTBLANC, and IWC. The Defendants ("the ISPs") are the five principal retail internet service providers in the UK, collectively serving approximately 95% of broadband users. Richemont applied to the Court seeking orders requiring the ISPs to block or impede access by their subscribers to six websites ("the Target Websites") that advertise and sell counterfeit goods infringing Richemont's Trade Marks. The ISPs are not alleged to have infringed the Trade Marks themselves or to be liable for infringements by the website operators.

The application raised five main questions: the Court's jurisdiction to make such orders; the threshold conditions to be met; whether those conditions are satisfied in this case; the principles guiding the exercise of discretion to grant such orders; and the application of those principles to the present facts.

The Court noted prior related orders requiring ISPs to block websites under section 97A of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 ("the 1988 Act") concerning copyright infringement. However, this case differs in that it concerns trade mark infringement, for which no statutory counterpart to section 97A exists. The Court approached the application afresh while considering relevant principles and experience from previous copyright-related website blocking cases.

The case is a test case, reportedly the first in the European Union seeking website-blocking orders against ISPs to combat trade mark infringement. The Open Rights Group was permitted to intervene to make submissions regarding third-party interests potentially affected by the orders.

The Court received extensive evidence, including technical descriptions of the ISPs' blocking technologies and cost estimates, as well as expert reports from representatives of both parties analyzing the effectiveness and implications of website blocking.

The factual background includes detailed information on the scale and impact of counterfeit goods trade, particularly online, and the damage caused to trade mark owners like Richemont. The Target Websites each focus on replicas of a single Richemont brand and target UK consumers, with evidence of test purchases confirming the counterfeit nature and inferior quality of the goods sold.

The Court also described various website blocking techniques available to ISPs, the ease of circumvention by users and operators, and the existing blocking regimes such as that operated by the Internet Watch Foundation.

The ISPs have developed and deployed various blocking systems over the years, initially to comply with child protection and copyright-related blocking orders, and have invested significantly in these technologies. The Court outlined the costs and practicalities of implementing and updating blocking orders.

Previous section 97A orders have been granted against websites infringing copyright by film studios, record companies, and the FA Premier League. The Court reviewed the costs and practical experience of implementing those orders, including challenges such as overblocking and cyber-attacks.

Several pending applications for further section 97A orders remain under consideration, with the Court deferring decisions pending this judgment.

Richemont seeks orders against the ISPs in a form substantially similar to the prior section 97A orders, tailored to the ISPs' technologies, requiring blocking of access to the Target Websites and their domains, with provisions for updates, safeguards, and rights of affected parties to apply to vary or discharge the orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Does the High Court of England and Wales have jurisdiction to grant website-blocking injunctions against ISPs in cases of trade mark infringement?
  2. If jurisdiction exists, what threshold conditions must be satisfied before such injunctions can be granted?
  3. Are those threshold conditions satisfied on the facts of this case?
  4. What principles must guide the Court’s discretion in deciding whether to grant such orders?
  5. Applying those principles, should the Court grant the orders sought by Richemont?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
20C Fox Film Corp v British Telecommunications plc [2011] EWHC 1981 (Ch) and (No 2) [2011] EWHC 2714 (Ch) Principles for website blocking injunctions under section 97A of the 1988 Act and Article 8(3) of the Information Society Directive Established framework and experience relevant to website blocking orders; informed the Court’s approach to the present trade mark case.
Dramatico Entertainment Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2012] EWHC 268 (Ch) and (No 2) [2012] EWHC 1152 (Ch) Application of website blocking injunctions in copyright cases Supported the development of principles for granting blocking orders and cost regimes.
EMI Records Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 379 (Ch) Website blocking injunctions and proportionality considerations Provided analysis of blocking order effectiveness and proportionality.
Football Association Premier League Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 2058 (Ch) Blocking injunctions in sports broadcasting copyright infringement Reinforced principles related to intermediary liability and injunction scope.
Paramount Home Entertainment International Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 3479 (Ch) Website blocking injunctions and CJEU case law interpretation Considered impact of CJEU judgments on blocking orders and intermediary duties.
Case C-466/12 Svensson v Retriever Sverige AB [EU:C:2014:76] Interpretation of intermediary liability and injunctions under EU law Guided interpretation of EU directives relevant to injunctions against intermediaries.
Case C-324/09 L'Oréal SA v eBay International AG [2011] ECR I-6011 Scope of injunctions against intermediaries for intellectual property infringement Clarified that injunctions may be granted to prevent future infringements by intermediaries not themselves infringing.
Case C-557/07 LSG-Gesellschaft zur Wahrnehmung von Leistungsschutzrechten GmbH v Tele2 Telecommunication GmbH [2009] ECR I-1227 Definition of intermediaries under Article 8(3) of the Information Society Directive Confirmed ISPs providing internet access are intermediaries whose services can be subject to injunctions.
Case C-314/12 UPC Telekabel Wien GmbH v Constantin Film Verleih GmbH [EU:C:2014:192] Use of ISP services by third parties to infringe copyright; proportionality and fundamental rights balance Confirmed ISPs’ role in infringement and set principles for balancing rights and proportionality.
Case C-70/10 Scarlet Extended SA v SABAM [2011] ECR I-11959 Proportionality and fundamental rights in website blocking injunctions Addressed the balance between copyright enforcement and freedom of information.
Case C-360/10 Belgische Vereniging van Auteurs, Componisten en Uitgevers CVBA v Netlog NV [2012] Costs and proportionality in intellectual property injunctions Supported consideration of costs and proportionality in injunction orders.
20C Fox Film Corp v British Telecommunications plc (No 2) [2012] Costs regime and practical implementation of website blocking injunctions Framework for costs allocation and monitoring of blocking orders.
R (British Telecommunications Plc) v Secretary of State for Business, Innovation & Skills [2011] EWHC 1021 (Admin) Judicial review of Digital Economy Act provisions on site blocking Confirmed legal context of site blocking provisions and government approach.
Regina (British Telecommunications plc and another) v Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport [2012] EWCA Civ 232 Appeal concerning Digital Economy Act site blocking provisions Supported government decisions on site blocking legislation.
Gouriet v Union of Post Office Workers [1978] AC 335 High Court’s jurisdiction to grant injunctions Historical context for injunction powers under section 37(1) of the Senior Courts Act 1981.
Fourie v Le Roux [2007] UKHL 1 Scope of court’s jurisdiction to grant injunctions and distinction from discretion Confirmed broad jurisdiction of the Court to grant injunctions where it has personal jurisdiction.
Broadmoor Special Hospital Authority v Robinson [2000] QB 775 Equitable jurisdiction to grant injunctions and its breadth Supported the wide scope of injunction powers subject to equitable principles.
Samsung Electronics (UK) Ltd v Apple Inc [2012] EWCA Civ 1339 Jurisdiction to grant publicity orders as a form of injunction Confirmed the Court’s power to grant injunctions in new categories to avoid injustice.
Yildirim v Turkey (ECtHR, Application No. 3111/10) Requirements for Internet blocking measures to be "prescribed by law" Discussed criteria for lawful internet blocking measures under human rights law.
Marleasing SA v La Comercial Internacional de Alimentación SA Case C-106/89 [1990] ECR I-4135 Principle of interpreting domestic law consistently with EU directives Applied to interpret section 37(1) in conformity with EU law obligations.
Vodafone 2 v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2009] EWCA Civ 446 Duty to interpret domestic legislation in conformity with EU directives Supported Marleasing principle in UK law interpretation.
Actavis UK Ltd v Eli Lilly & Co [2014] EWHC 1511 (Pat) Broad power of the Court to grant declarations and injunctions Confirmed wide scope of remedies available for intellectual property rights.
Norwich Pharmacal Co v Customs & Excise Commissioners [1974] AC 133 Equitable protective duties of intermediaries aware of infringement Analogous principle supporting injunctions against intermediaries with knowledge of infringement.
Arsenal Football plc v Reed Case C-206/01 [2002] ECR I-10273 Conditions for trade mark infringement under EU law Applied to confirm infringement by use of identical signs without consent affecting trade mark functions.
Blomqvist v Rolex SA Case C-98/13 [EU:C:2014:55] Effect of sales to consumers within the EU on trade mark infringement Confirmed that dispatch from outside the EU to consumers within the EU constitutes infringement.
Google Spain SL v Agencia Española de Protección de Datos Case C-131/12 [EU:C:2014:317] Power of courts to order de-indexing of webpages Discussed limits of court orders for search engines regarding intellectual property.
Rugby Football Union v Viagogo Ltd [2012] UKSC 55 Balancing competing rights under the Charter and proportionality Approved principles for balancing intellectual property rights with other fundamental rights.
UPC Telekabel Wien GmbH v Constantin Film Verleih GmbH [2014] Bus LR 541 Proportionality and fundamental rights balance in injunctions against ISPs Provided detailed guidance on balancing trade mark rights, ISP business freedom, and user freedoms.
Scarlet Extended SA v SABAM Case C-70/10 [2011] ECR I-11959 Proportionality and fundamental rights in intellectual property injunctions Framework for assessing injunctions balancing rights and freedoms.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by addressing the jurisdictional question, concluding that the High Court of England and Wales has jurisdiction under section 37(1) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 to grant injunctions against ISPs in trade mark infringement cases. The Court rejected the ISPs' contention that the absence of specific statutory provisions analogous to section 97A of the 1988 Act for trade marks precluded jurisdiction. It held that section 37(1) confers broad equitable powers to grant injunctions, including in new categories of cases, subject to equitable principles and discretion.

Further, the Court applied the Marleasing principle to interpret section 37(1) consistently with the third sentence of Article 11 of the Enforcement Directive, which requires Member States to enable injunctions against intermediaries whose services are used by third parties to infringe intellectual property rights. This interpretation aligns domestic law with EU obligations.

The Court identified four threshold conditions for granting website blocking injunctions in trade mark cases, analogous to those in copyright cases under section 97A: (1) the ISPs must be intermediaries within the meaning of Article 11; (2) the users or operators of the Target Websites must infringe the Plaintiff's trade marks; (3) the infringing activity must use the ISPs' services; and (4) the ISPs must have actual knowledge of the infringement.

It was undisputed that the ISPs are intermediaries and that the Target Websites infringe the Trade Marks by using identical signs without consent, targeting UK consumers. The Court accepted that the operators use the ISPs' services to infringe and that the ISPs have actual knowledge, based on notifications and evidence served.

The Court then examined the principles guiding the exercise of discretion under Article 3 of the Enforcement Directive and related EU law, including necessity, effectiveness, dissuasiveness, proportionality, fairness, avoidance of unnecessary cost and complexity, and avoidance of barriers to legitimate trade. It emphasized the need to strike a fair balance between the rights engaged: the Plaintiff’s trade mark rights, the ISPs' freedom to conduct business, and internet users' freedom of information.

On necessity and alternative measures, the Court considered various options available to Richemont, including action against website operators, notice and takedown requests to hosts, payment freezing, domain name seizure, de-indexing by search engines, and customs seizure. The Court found that many of these alternatives are ineffective or only provide short-term disruption, particularly due to jurisdictional challenges and the ability of operators to relocate websites. Notice and takedown, while less burdensome for ISPs, is less effective long-term than website blocking orders with update mechanisms. De-indexing and payment freezing have practical limitations. Customs seizure addresses goods but not websites.

Regarding effectiveness, the Court reviewed evidence from prior section 97A orders, including expert analyses showing significant reductions in UK traffic to blocked websites compared to global trends. While circumvention and substitution occur, blocking orders have a worthwhile impact, particularly on casual users. The Court found no reason to believe that blocking the Target Websites would be less effective, possibly more so given lower brand loyalty to infringing sites.

The Court acknowledged the dissuasive effect of the orders in discouraging access to infringing websites and informing users of the reasons for blocking.

On costs, the Court accepted the established cost regime whereby the Plaintiff bears application and monitoring costs, and ISPs bear implementation costs. While acknowledging the cumulative cost burden on ISPs and potential for increased applications, the Court found current implementation costs modest relative to ISPs’ overall business costs but recognized the need to monitor cost implications over time. The economic principle that ISPs are "lowest cost avoiders" supports the allocation of implementation costs to ISPs, who may pass these costs to customers.

The Court considered the impact on lawful users, noting that most Target Websites share IP addresses with other sites, many of which are also infringing or unavailable. Where legitimate websites share IP addresses, blocking should be limited to DNS blocking to avoid affecting lawful users. The Court found that, with appropriate targeting and safeguards, adverse effects on lawful users can be minimized.

The Court recognized the substitutability of infringing websites but noted evidence that blocking a small number of sites could render many search results ineffective. The Court expressed some skepticism regarding the extent of this effect but accepted it as a relevant factor.

Overall, the Court concluded that the proposed orders are proportionate and strike a fair balance between the rights involved. The Court emphasized the importance of safeguards against abuse, including the ability for ISPs, Target Website operators, and affected subscribers to apply to vary or discharge the orders. The Court also considered the need for improved user notification about blocking orders and proposed a "sunset clause" limiting the duration of orders unless renewed, to allow review in light of experience.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision is to grant the website blocking orders sought by Richemont, subject to modifications incorporating additional safeguards as described above.

HOLDING: The Court has jurisdiction under section 37(1) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 to grant website blocking injunctions against ISPs in trade mark infringement cases, and it is just and convenient to do so on the facts presented.

Implications: The orders will impose obligations on the ISPs to block access to the specified Target Websites infringing Richemont’s Trade Marks. The decision establishes a principled basis for website blocking injunctions in trade mark cases in the UK, consistent with EU directives and fundamental rights. The ruling recognizes the balance between intellectual property enforcement and the rights of ISPs and internet users. It introduces procedural safeguards to protect against abuse and ensure proportionality. No new precedent limiting the Court’s discretion or jurisdiction is established; rather, the Court confirms and extends its existing equitable jurisdiction to this new context. The decision may lead to further similar applications by Richemont and other trade mark owners, with attendant cost and operational implications for ISPs and internet users.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Cartier International AG & Ors v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Cartier International AG & Ors v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd & Ors
(Oct 17, 2014)