Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

AAA & Ors v. Unilever Plc & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This case concerns an attempt to bring a tort claim in England against a parent company (Company A), registered in England, and one of its operating subsidiaries (Company B), registered in Kenya. The claimants are employees and former employees of Company B or residents living on a plantation operated by Company B at the relevant time. The claimants must establish a good arguable claim against Company A to treat it as an anchor defendant in England, allowing claims against Company B to be included as a necessary or proper party.

The claimants allege they were victims of serious inter-tribal violence during the 2007 presidential election in Kenya, targeted by mobs on the plantation where they worked and lived. They claim both Company A and Company B owed them a duty of care in tort to protect them from this violence, which was breached.

The appeal arises from a decision by Judge [Last Name], who held there was no arguable duty of care owed by either Company A or Company B. Applying the three-part test for duty of care from Caparo Industries Plc v Dickman, the judge found the harm was not foreseeable and that it would not be fair, just, and reasonable to impose such a duty on Company A, which had been entitled to rely on local authorities to maintain law and order. The judge did find a sufficient degree of connection (proximity) between Company A and the claimants to satisfy the test but only hesitantly and on that basis allowed the claim to proceed if viable. The judge also ruled England was the proper forum if viable claims existed.

Company A contested the duty of care on additional grounds, arguing no proximity existed. Both companies challenged the forum decision and sought to stay claims against Company A pending trial in Kenya against Company B.

The appellate court, with three judges in agreement, dismissed the appeal on the basis that no proximity existed between Company A and the claimants, meaning no anchor defendant in England. The court declined to address other issues, deferring to the Kenyan courts on matters of foreseeability, fairness, and local statutory provisions. Any trial must take place in Kenya.

Factual background includes that Company B has operated a large plantation in Kenya for decades, employing a diverse workforce living on-site. The 2007 election led to widespread violence, including on the plantation, with serious assaults and deaths among the claimants. The claimants assert Company A and Company B failed to have adequate crisis management plans for foreseeable election-related violence.

Company A was the ultimate holding company of Company B in 2007 and 2008, owning a controlling interest. Company B was managed locally, with no relevant expertise or management input from Company A regarding local political or ethnic issues. Company A operated under a group governance and risk management framework, with policies mandating local units to maintain crisis plans and report compliance upward. Company B had its own crisis management policy and training, prepared locally without specific advice from Company A.

The evidence showed that Company B managed its own risk and crisis response, including during the 2007 election violence, and that Company A did not provide relevant advice or instructions about political risks or crisis management on the plantation. Risk consultancy advice received by Company A was general, national-level, and not directed specifically at Company B’s local circumstances. The claimants’ attempt to rely on external consultancy reports not used by Company A did not assist their case.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Company A owed a duty of care in tort to the claimants in respect of harm suffered during the 2007 election violence in Kenya.
  2. Whether the claimants have a good arguable case against Company A sufficient to treat it as an anchor defendant in England for proceedings including claims against Company B.
  3. Whether England is the appropriate forum to hear claims against Company A and Company B.
  4. Whether the claim against Company A should be stayed pending trial of claims against Company B in Kenya.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Company A and Company B owed a duty of care to take effective steps to protect claimants from foreseeable post-election violence on the plantation.
  • Company A provided advice or guidance to Company B on managing political risks and crisis management which created proximity and justified a duty of care.
  • Inadequate crisis management plans were in place, breaching the duty of care.
  • England is the proper forum for trial of claims against both companies.

Respondents' Arguments

  • No duty of care was owed by either Company A or Company B because the harm was not foreseeable and it would not be fair, just, and reasonable to impose such a duty on Company A.
  • Company A and Company B are separate legal persons; Company B managed its own affairs locally without relevant advice or control from Company A.
  • There was no proximity between Company A and the claimants sufficient to impose a duty of care.
  • Claims against Company A should be stayed pending trial in Kenya against Company B.
  • If there is a trial, it should take place in Kenya, where courts are better placed to assess local issues and legislation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Caparo Industries Plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605 Three-part test for duty of care: foreseeability, proximity, and whether it is fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty. The judge applied this test and found damage was not foreseeable; the appellate court accepted the judge’s approach but dismissed the appeal on proximity grounds.
Chandler v Cape Plc [2012] EWCA Civ 525; [2012] 1 WLR 3111 Guidance on when a parent company may owe a duty of care for the activities of its subsidiary, focusing on proximity and control. The court used this to assess whether Company A had sufficient proximity to the claimants to impose a duty of care, concluding it did not.
Lungowe v Vedanta Resources Plc [2017] EWCA Civ 1528 Consideration of parent company liability for subsidiary’s operations abroad and criteria for duty of care. Referenced as a similar case pattern; helped frame the legal context for claims against parent companies.
Okpabi v Royal Dutch Shell Plc [2018] EWCA Civ 191 Further elaboration on parent company duty of care, including management control and advice as bases for proximity. Guided the court’s analysis of categories of cases where a parent may owe a duty; the claimants’ case did not fall within these categories.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that under English law, there is no special doctrine imposing liability on a parent company for its subsidiary’s activities; duties of care arise only under ordinary tort principles requiring foreseeability, proximity, and that it be fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty.

The court identified two categories where a parent might owe a duty: (i) where the parent has taken over management of the subsidiary’s relevant activity, and (ii) where the parent has given relevant advice to the subsidiary about managing a particular risk.

The appellants accepted their claim did not fall within category (i), as the subsidiary managed its own affairs. They relied on category (ii), arguing Company A advised Company B on political risk management.

The court found the evidence did not support this. Company B had sole responsibility for crisis management and risk policies, devised locally without specific or detailed advice from Company A. Risk consultancy advice received by Company A was general and national in scope, not directed at the plantation or local circumstances. The court found no sufficient proximity between Company A and the claimants to impose a duty of care.

Given the absence of an anchor defendant in England, the court concluded the claims should be tried in Kenya, deferring to Kenyan courts on issues of foreseeability, fairness, and local statutory interpretation.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED THE APPEAL on the basis that Company A owed no duty of care to the claimants, as there was insufficient proximity between Company A and the claimants in respect of the harm suffered.

The direct consequence is that Company A cannot serve as an anchor defendant for proceedings in England, meaning the claimants cannot maintain their claim against Company B in England joined with Company A. Any trial must take place in Kenya against Company B, and possibly Company A if joined there.

No new precedent was established; the decision applies existing principles of tort law relating to parent company liability and duty of care in the context of foreign subsidiaries and cross-jurisdictional claims.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

AAA & Ors v Unilever Plc & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

AAA & Ors v Unilever Plc & Anor
(Jul 4, 2018)