Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

Banner Universal Motion Pictures Ltd v. Endemol Shine Group Ltd & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This case concerns a claim involving a television gameshow format called "Minute Winner," devised and documented in 2005 by an individual referred to as the Creator. The Claimant company, Company A, an English company formed by the Creator, claims to be the assignee of rights relating to this format. Company A alleges that the Minute Winner Document is a dramatic work protected by UK copyright and that it was disclosed confidentially to Defendant Company B, a Swedish television production company, at a meeting in Stockholm in November 2005. Company A contends that Defendant Company B and other Defendants subsequently misused this information in the UK and internationally, including through the broadcast of a game show called "Minute to Win It" on ITV2 in England in 2011, and licensing it worldwide.

The Defendants deny the claims and have applied for declarations of non-jurisdiction as well as summary dismissal or striking out of the claim on several grounds, including that the Minute Winner Document does not qualify for copyright protection, that Company A is estopped from bringing breach of confidence claims due to prior Swedish court decisions, and that there is no goodwill in the UK to support passing off claims.

Company A sought permission to amend its claim to add or substitute additional Defendants based on new information about corporate involvement in the development and licensing of the allegedly infringing game show. The court considered draft amendments and submissions in a case management conference context.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Minute Winner Document qualifies for copyright protection as a dramatic work under UK law.
  2. Whether the Defendants infringed any such copyright by producing or licensing the "Minute to Win It" game show.
  3. Whether the claim for breach of confidence is barred by prior Swedish court judgments and/or constitutes an abuse of process.
  4. Whether Company A has goodwill in the UK sufficient to sustain a passing off claim based on the Minute Winner format and name.
  5. Whether the court has jurisdiction over the added or substituted Defendants and whether permission should be granted for service out of jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimant's Arguments

  • The Minute Winner Document is an original dramatic work protected by UK copyright as it sets out a distinctive action framework for a television gameshow format.
  • The format includes distinctive features such as the title, catchphrases, minute-long tasks using ordinary household items, and the use of sponsored prizes, which together form a coherent structure.
  • There was an obligation of confidence arising from the disclosure of the Minute Winner Document to Defendant Company B at the November 2005 meeting, despite refusal to sign NDAs.
  • The Defendants' "Minute to Win It" game shows are substantially derived from and constitute "slavish copying" of the Minute Winner format.
  • Company A has goodwill in the UK through a website and inquiries from UK television networks relating to the Minute Winner format.
  • Permission should be granted to add or substitute new Defendants based on further information about their involvement.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The Minute Winner Document does not meet the legal requirements for copyright subsistence as a dramatic work because it lacks sufficient certainty, unity, and a coherent framework capable of performance.
  • The Swedish courts have already conclusively determined that the Minute Winner format was not disclosed at the November 2005 meeting and that the information does not qualify as a trade secret under Swedish law.
  • Company A is estopped from pursuing breach of confidence claims in England due to cause of action estoppel, issue estoppel, and abuse of process doctrines.
  • There is no arguable case that the Defendants misused confidential information, and any such claim is barred by limitation.
  • The passing off claim fails because the Creator and Company A never had goodwill or customers in the UK in relation to the Minute Winner format or name.
  • The "Minute to Win It" show differs materially in concept, format, contestant selection, production, and content from the Minute Winner Document.
  • The proposed amendments to add or substitute Defendants lack proper pleading and realistic basis, and permission should be refused.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
EasyAir Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch) Framework for summary judgment: realistic prospect of success; no mini-trial; consideration of evidence available at trial. Guided the court’s approach to the summary determination application.
SAS Institute Inc. v World Programming Ltd [2014] RPC 8 Originality requirement: expression of author's own intellectual creation. Applied to assess whether the Minute Winner Document met originality threshold.
Ladbroke v William Hill [1964] 1 WLR 273 Copyright protection can arise from skill and judgment in arrangement of the whole work, not merely individual parts. Considered in evaluating the collective distinctiveness of the Minute Winner format.
Norowzian v Arks Limited (No 2) [2000] EMLR 67 Definition of dramatic work as a work of action capable of performance before an audience. Used to clarify the nature of copyright protection for television formats.
Green v Broadcasting Corporation of New Zealand [1989] RPC 700 Whether a television show format can constitute a dramatic work; requirement of unity and certainty. Principal authority; court found no realistic prospect of copyright subsistence for the Minute Winner format based on Green.
Nova Productions Ltd v Mazooma Games Ltd [2006] RPC 379 Application of Green and Norowzian to video games and dramatic work protection. Supported the court’s view on the lack of copyright protection for formats lacking unity.
The Ukulele Orchestra v Clausen [2015] EWHC 1772 (IPEC) Copyright as dramatic work does not arise for elements of performance presentation lacking sufficient unity. Reinforced the court’s analysis of what constitutes a dramatic work.
Meakin v BBC [2010] EWHC 2065 (Ch) Assessment of similarity for copyright infringement claims. Applied in rejecting the claim that the Minute to Win It show copied the Minute Winner Document.
Virgin Atlantic Airways v Zodiac Seats UK [2014] AC 160 Explanation of res judicata, cause of action estoppel, issue estoppel, and abuse of process. Guided the court’s conclusion that the breach of confidence claim was barred by prior Swedish judgments.
Arnold v National Westminster Bank plc [1991] 2 AC 93 Distinction between cause of action estoppel and issue estoppel. Used to analyze estoppel arguments arising from foreign judgments.
Johnson v Gore Wood [2002] 2 AC 1 Abuse of process and Henderson v Henderson doctrine explained. Supported the court’s finding of abuse of process in pursuing repeated claims.
The Sennar (No.2) [1985] 1 WLR 490 Application of issue estoppel to foreign court judgments. Confirmed that issue estoppel applies to foreign court decisions recognized as competent.
Coco v Clarke [1969] RPC 41 Requirement that information must have necessary quality of confidence for breach of confidence claims. Referenced in assessing whether Minute Winner Document contained protectable confidential information.
Fraser v Thames Television [1984] QB 44 Confidential information must be sufficiently developed to be protectable. Applied to determine the sufficiency of detail in the Minute Winner Document.
de Maudsley v Palumbo [1996] EMLR 460 Further explanation of confidential information requirements. Supported the court’s analysis of confidentiality standards.
Wade v BSkyB Limited [2014] EWHC 634 Clarification of confidential information quality requirements. Referenced in context of breach of confidence claim assessment.
Thomas Marshall (Exports) v Guinle [1979] Ch 227 Four elements identifying confidential information or trade secrets. Used to evaluate the nature of the information in the Minute Winner Document.
Starbucks (HK) Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Group (No 2) [2015] 1 WLR 2628 Requirement of actual goodwill involving presence of customers in the jurisdiction for passing off claims. Applied to reject goodwill claim in the UK for passing off.
Tate v Fulbrook [1908] 1 KB 821 Requirement of certainty in subject matter of copyright monopoly. Referenced in the analysis of copyright subsistence in the format.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first considered whether the Minute Winner Document qualifies as a dramatic work protected by copyright. Drawing on authorities including Green v Broadcasting Corporation of New Zealand, the court acknowledged that while it is conceptually possible for a television gameshow format to be protected, the work must exhibit a coherent framework of distinctive features capable of repeated performance. The court found that the Minute Winner Document was vague, lacking specificity and a unifying structure. The features identified were commonplace and did not amount to a sufficiently certain or unified work. The court therefore concluded there was no realistic prospect that copyright subsisted in the document or that infringement could be established given the material differences with the Minute to Win It shows.

Regarding breach of confidence, the court emphasized the prior Swedish proceedings in which the Swedish District Court found that the only information communicated was by email after the meeting and that the information did not constitute a trade secret under Swedish law. Applying principles of res judicata, issue estoppel, and abuse of process, the court held that Company A was barred from relitigating these issues in England. Additionally, the court found the information in the Minute Winner Document insufficiently developed to be protectable confidential information under English law.

On passing off, the court applied the requirement for actual goodwill in the UK and found that Company A failed to demonstrate any such goodwill or reputation beyond mere advertisement. The court also found no likelihood of confusion given the differences between the two shows.

Finally, the court declined to consider in detail the applications to add or substitute Defendants, finding no proper pleading or realistic basis to support such additions or service out of jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED all claims brought by Company A against the Defendants.

The dismissal was based on the absence of a realistic prospect of success for the copyright, breach of confidence, and passing off claims, and the application of estoppel and abuse of process doctrines due to prior foreign judgments. The decision directly affects the parties by terminating Company A's claims but does not establish new legal precedent beyond reaffirming established principles on copyright subsistence for television formats, the effect of foreign judgments on related claims, and the requirements for passing off in the UK.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Banner Universal Motion Pictures Ltd v Endemol Shine Group Ltd & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Banner Universal Motion Pictures Ltd v Endemol Shine Group Ltd & Anor
(Oct 19, 2017)