Factual and Procedural Background
The Company A, a business engaged in planning, creating, and delivering both printed and digital communications, provided certain printed items (the Printed Items) to Company B. These Printed Items consisted of multiple sheets of information about individual insurance policies, stapled and bound in covers. On 12 December 2014, Company A sought a ruling from HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) on whether these supplies were zero-rated for VAT purposes as booklets.
HMRC decided on 29 December 2014 that the supplies were standard rated services. This decision was confirmed upon reconsideration and statutory review. Company A appealed to the First-tier Tribunal. Additionally, HMRC issued an assessment on 21 December 2016 for VAT relating to supplies made to Company B, which Company A also appealed. The appeals were consolidated.
The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the Printed Items were zero-rated supplies of goods, as contended by Company A, or standard rated supplies of services, as contended by HMRC. The assessment also included other supplies zero-rated by Company A: standard terms and conditions documents (T&Cs), Appraisals detailing individual policy information and asset valuations, and related envelopes and postage. The Tribunal referred collectively to the Printed Items, T&Cs, and Appraisals as the Disputed Items. The C5 packs, containing renewal and terms letters, were accepted by Company A as standard rated and not under dispute.
The Tribunal identified two main issues: first, whether Company A was making a single composite supply of goods or services to Company B; second, if goods, whether the Disputed Items qualified as zero-rated booklets or standard rated printed matter.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the supply by Company A to Company B constituted a single composite supply of goods or a single composite supply of services.
- If a supply of goods, whether the Disputed Items qualified as zero-rated booklets under VAT law.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The supply was a single composite supply of goods, with the Disputed Items as the principal element and related services as ancillary.
- The contractual provisions, particularly Clause 6.1 and Clause 6.2 of the Framework Agreement and Clause 4 of Statement of Work 3 (SoW3), specify the supply of goods, including the Disputed Items and C5 packs.
- The term "services" in the contracts includes the production of goods, so terminology alone is insufficient to classify the supply as services.
- The printing, stapling, enveloping, and related processes are part of a single indivisible economic supply of goods.
- Delivery and despatch services are ancillary, analogous to precedents where delivery was subordinate to the supply of goods.
- Pricing and invoicing reflect a cost-plus basis for goods supplied; no separate charge for services exists, supporting the view of a single supply of goods.
- Some contractual terms do not reflect commercial reality and are standard templates not fully operative in practice.
- The Disputed Items have the physical characteristics of booklets: multiple stapled pages with covers, intended to be read by policyholders, and thus qualify for zero-rating.
- Content or personalization does not affect the classification as booklets.
- The VAT treatment follows the actual supply made, not hypothetical alternative forms such as letters or loose pages.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Framework Agreement imposes broad and onerous obligations, indicating a comprehensive service supply rather than merely goods.
- Goods are defined within the services in the contract, suggesting the supply is of services encompassing goods.
- Contractual clauses require coordination with third-party suppliers, extensive background checks on staff, and compliance with governance, environmental, and benchmarking requirements, evidencing a wide service package.
- The supply includes liaison, data checking, reporting, and administration beyond mere printed material.
- The contractual terms have not been varied; all obligations remain enforceable.
- There is no principal or predominant element in the composite supply, contrary to the appellant's assertion.
- The appellant’s reliance on precedents such as Harrier is misplaced due to the detailed service obligations in this case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| WHA v HMRC [2013] UKSC 24 |
Contractual position as starting point to determine taxable supplies. |
Contract terms are useful but not conclusive; economic and commercial reality must be considered. |
| HMRC v Newey (Case C-653/11) [2013] STC 2432 |
Importance of contractual terms and economic reality in VAT supply classification. |
Contractual terms normally reflect economic reality, but artificial arrangements may be disregarded. |
| Secret Hotels2 v HMRC [2014] UKSC 16 |
Interpretation of agreements to identify legal and commercial nature. |
Agreements must be interpreted holistically; subsequent conduct may evidence variation or sham. |
| Card Protection Plan Ltd v C&E Comrs (Case C-349/96) [1999] STC 270 |
Definition of composite supply with principal and ancillary elements. |
Ancillary supplies serve to better enjoy the principal supply; applied to identify composite supply nature. |
| Levob Verzekeringen BV v Staatssecretaris van Financiën (Case C-41/04) [2006] STC 766 |
Composite supply as single indivisible economic supply. |
Supply elements closely linked form a single supply; important to identify predominant element. |
| College of Estate Management v C&E Commrs [2005] UKHL 62 |
Distinction between principal and ancillary supplies in composite supply. |
Ancillary means subordinate; some supplies cannot be split into principal and ancillary. |
| Honourable Society of Middle Temple v HMRC [2013] UKUT 250 |
Guidance on identifying single or multiple supplies. |
Factors include inseparability, indispensability, customer perspective, and invoicing practices. |
| British Telecommunications v C&E Comrs [1999] STC 758 |
Delivery ancillary to supply of goods. |
Delivery services can be ancillary to goods supply; transport costs may be incidental expenses. |
| Purple Parking v HMRC (Case C-117/11) [2012] STC 1680 |
Composite supply where one element is predominant. |
Parking was predominant supply; transport was ancillary. |
| Globe Motors v TRW Lucas [2016] EWCA Civ 396 |
Validity of contract variation by conduct despite written variation clause. |
Contract variation by conduct can be effective even if not in writing. |
| Colour Offset v HMRC [1995] STC 85 |
Definition of "book" and "booklet" for VAT zero-rating. |
Books and booklets must have leaves held together by covers and be intended to be read or looked at. |
| Harrier v HMRC [2011] UKFTT 725 |
Composite supply of photobooks as goods with ancillary services. |
Principal supply was goods; production services were ancillary; binding considered essential. |
| Magic Memories v HMRC [2013] UKFTT 730 |
Photobooks with spiral binding can qualify as booklets. |
Stapling or spiral binding sufficient permanence; covers may be paper; content personalization irrelevant. |
| HMRC v Metropolitan International Schools [2017] UKUT 431 |
Possibility of composite supply with no predominant element. |
Where no predominant element exists, supply may not qualify for certain exemptions. |
| C&E Comrs v Cantor Fitzgerald (Case C-108/99) [2001] STC 145 |
VAT treatment based on actual supply, not hypothetical alternatives. |
Classification follows the objective nature of the transaction made. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal began by examining the Framework Agreement, recognizing it as a broad contractual structure covering multiple types of supplies, not a supply contract itself. The specific supplies arise from individual Statements of Work (SoWs), with SoW3 being the relevant document for the supplies in question.
The Tribunal noted the confusing and overlapping contractual definitions of goods and services, with goods defined as part of services and services including the production of goods. Therefore, contractual terminology alone could not resolve the classification issue.
Analysis of SoW3 revealed that the Disputed Items and C5 packs were printed matter, clearly goods for VAT purposes. The services described in SoW3 mainly detailed the production process and quality controls, which the Tribunal found to be inseparable and indispensable elements ancillary to the supply of goods.
The Tribunal rejected HMRC's argument that the Company had broad service obligations including coordination with third parties, finding that no such obligations were imposed or requested in SoW3. The only third party supplier involved was the IT provider facilitating data transfer, with no contractual coordination obligations.
Regarding delivery, the Tribunal found that although delivery is a service, it was provided under the same contract and was ancillary to the supply of goods, consistent with established case law. The parties' conduct indicated a variation of contract terms to reflect this.
Considering the surrounding circumstances and commercial common sense, the Tribunal concluded that Company B contracted for goods (the Disputed Items and C5 packs), not a service package including coordination and administration.
The Tribunal distinguished the C5 packs as a separate, distinct supply and did not determine their VAT classification.
On the second issue, the Tribunal applied established case law to determine whether the Disputed Items met the physical characteristics of booklets: multiple stapled pages with covers, intended to be read or looked at. The Tribunal found all Disputed Items met these criteria and were intended for reading by policyholders, supported by explicit instructions within the documents.
The Tribunal rejected HMRC's arguments that the nature of content or the possibility of alternative forms affected classification, emphasizing that VAT treatment depends on the actual transaction.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal held that Company A was making a single composite supply of goods to Company B, with the Disputed Items as the predominant and principal element. The related delivery was ancillary to this supply. Each of the Disputed Items qualified as booklets within the meaning of VAT law and were therefore zero-rated supplies. The appeal was allowed accordingly.
The appeal against the VAT assessment was also allowed except for the C5 packs, which were accepted as standard rated supplies. The parties were directed to agree on the portion of the assessment related to the C5 packs, with recourse to the Tribunal if agreement could not be reached.
No broader legal precedent was established beyond the direct effect on the parties. The decision clarifies the application of composite supply principles and booklet classification in the context of printed insurance documents.