Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal by the Appellant against a decision of HM Revenue & Customs dated 25 May 2016, which held that the Appellant ought to have been registered for VAT with effect from 16 December 2014. This decision was confirmed following a review on 21 September 2016. The dispute arises from funds raised by the Appellant through a crowdfunding platform known as Kickstarter. The Appellant received funds amounting to £672,447 (less Kickstarter's fees) on 6 January 2015. The central question is whether the Appellant was liable to account for output tax in relation to supplies of services at the time it received payment.
The Appellant initially disputed that the payments constituted consideration for a taxable supply, arguing they were risk funding. However, the Appellant conceded there was a taxable supply in the form of future rewards to backers. The dispute centers on the timing of the supply.
The legal issues concern whether the sums received represent prepayments for services or consideration for face value vouchers and, if vouchers, whether these are single purpose vouchers under Schedule 10A of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (VATA 1994). If the sums are prepayments, the tax point is the date of receipt; if they are face value vouchers, the tax point depends on whether the vouchers are single purpose or not.
The Appellant bears the burden of proving that the Kickstarter funding was not a prepayment or that it was consideration for non-single purpose face value vouchers. The parties provided documentary evidence but no witness testimony. The Tribunal made findings of fact based on the documentary record and the contractual relationship between the Appellant and backers.
The crowdfunding campaign offered various rewards depending on pledge amounts, with pledges of £60 or more entitling backers to a voucher for a digital memory box in a lunar time capsule, with the option of physical space for a strand of hair or a combination thereof. The campaign acknowledged significant uncertainties regarding the project's success and the precise benefits to be delivered.
Legal Issues Presented
- Do the sums received by the Appellant represent a prepayment of consideration for supplies of services, or consideration for supplies of face value vouchers?
- If the sums received were consideration for a supply of face value vouchers, were those vouchers 'single purpose vouchers' within Schedule 10A VATA 1994?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The principal benefits to a backer pledging at least £60 were the right to upload digital information to a digital memory box and/or the right to include a strand of hair in the time capsule.
- The payment of £60 was not a prepayment for a future supply of services because it was uncertain what the backer would receive, including the quantity of digital or physical space, and whether any supply would occur given the uncertainties of the mission.
- The backer receives a face value voucher satisfying the requirements of paragraph 1(1) Schedule 10A.
- The face value voucher is not a single purpose voucher because it represents a right to receive more than one type of service, namely digital space and physical space.
Respondents' Arguments
- Backers were contractually entitled only to digital space in a digital memory box; there was no contractual entitlement to physical space.
- The payment of £60 was a prepayment for a future supply of services, making section 6(4) VATA 1994 applicable and the tax point the date of payment.
- Backers do not receive a face value voucher because the conditions in paragraph 1(1) Schedule 10A are not satisfied.
- If there is a face value voucher, it is a single purpose voucher because the contractual entitlement is limited to digital space or because digital and physical space are to be regarded as one type of supply.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Leisure Pass Group Ltd v Revenue & Customs Commissioners [2008] EWHC 2158 (Ch) |
Definition of face value voucher; vouchers without monetary limit are not face value vouchers. |
The Court distinguished the London Pass as not a face value voucher because it lacked a monetary limit. |
| Findmypast Ltd v Revenue Customs Commissioners [2017] CSIH 59 |
Interpretation of prepayments under section 6(4) VATA 1994 and face value vouchers under Schedule 10A; conditions for face value vouchers; application of single purpose voucher rules. |
The Court held payments were not prepayments due to uncertainties and that credits were not face value vouchers as they failed certain conditions. |
| Skyview Ballooning Ltd v Revenue & Customs Commissioners [2014] UKFTT 32 (TC) |
Face value vouchers and tax point; vouchers with identifiable value recorded in a code are face value vouchers. |
The FTT found customers were provided with face value vouchers redeemable up to a cash value, not merely evidence of prepayment. |
| Lebara Limited C-520/10 (CJEU) |
Definition and VAT treatment of single purpose vouchers. |
Single purpose vouchers are taxed at the time of issue because the goods or services and VAT rate are identifiable at that time. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal first identified the contractual terms between the Appellant and backers, derived from the Kickstarter website. It found that the Appellant was contractually bound to provide digital space and/or physical space in the lunar time capsule in return for pledges, subject to project completion. The evidence supported that a £60 pledge entitled a backer to a voucher redeemable for digital memory box space and/or physical space for a strand of hair, with the possibility to top up pledges.
Regarding prepayments under section 6(4) VATA 1994 and Article 65 Principal VAT Directive, the Tribunal applied the principles from Findmypast Ltd. It concluded that the sums received did not constitute prepayments because there was no precise identification of the goods or services to be supplied at the time of payment, and significant uncertainties existed, including whether the mission would succeed.
On the question of face value vouchers, the Tribunal accepted the Appellant's submission that backers received face value vouchers representing the right to receive services up to the value of the pledge. It distinguished this case from Leisure Pass Group Ltd, noting that the vouchers here had a monetary limit and were redeemable for services up to that value.
The Tribunal then considered whether the vouchers were single purpose vouchers under paragraph 7A Schedule 10A. It interpreted "type" of goods or services purposively, in light of the legislative context and CJEU case law. The Tribunal found no relevant distinction between digital space and physical space for these purposes, as digital space requires a physical medium and both represent space in the time capsule. Consequently, the vouchers were single purpose vouchers, representing a right to receive one type of service (space in the time capsule) subject to a single VAT rate.
Therefore, the consideration paid for these vouchers was taxable at the time of issue, consistent with the treatment of single purpose vouchers.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal DISMISSED THE APPEAL.
The Appellant was liable to be registered for VAT with effect from 16 December 2014 and to account for output tax at the time the funds were received. The sums received were not prepayments but consideration for single purpose face value vouchers. The decision confirms the application of Schedule 10A to crowdfunding arrangements involving vouchers redeemable for services of one type. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.