Factual and Procedural Background
The Appellant, a non-practising barrister called to the Bar of England and Wales in 1986 and a registered foreign lawyer who founded a firm in 1998, was charged with professional misconduct before a Disciplinary Tribunal of the Council of the Inns of Court ("the Tribunal") in May and June 2010. The charge alleged that while practising as a registered foreign lawyer regulated by the Law Society and subject to the jurisdiction of the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal ("SDT"), the Appellant dishonestly misled the solicitors' regulatory body by falsely asserting that a certain individual had been in partnership with her, which was untrue. The Appellant had previously been struck off the Roll of Solicitors in 2005 for conduct unbecoming a solicitor related to this matter.
The Tribunal, composed of five members including a retired circuit judge as chairman, lay members, and barristers, found the charge proved by majority and imposed a two-year suspension from practice on the Appellant.
The Appellant appealed, raising preliminary issues about the constitution of the Tribunal, specifically the participation of one barrister member whose appointment had expired. The Visitors, a judicial body reviewing such appeals, upheld the Tribunal's constitution and the de facto authority of the member in question in a reserved judgment in July 2012.
The appeal process involved amendments to the petition of appeal and was conducted with legal representation for both parties. The appeal concerned both substantive decisions of the Tribunal and procedural issues related to the conduct and constitution of the Tribunal and the appeal process.
The case involved detailed consideration of the relevant Disciplinary Tribunals Regulations 2009 and the Hearings before the Visitors Rules 2010, including the nature of appeals to the Visitors as appeals by way of re-hearing rather than mere reviews.
Central factual disputes included whether the Appellant was in partnership with the individual in question during 1998 and whether she made false assertions about that partnership to a solicitors' investigator. The Respondent intended to call the individual as a witness, but he was reluctant to attend and delayed signing a witness statement. The Tribunal considered applications related to his attendance, including refusal to dismiss the case or exclude his evidence despite his initial non-attendance.
Eventually, the witness appeared and gave evidence after the Respondent was permitted to reopen its case. The Tribunal found the charge proved and issued a written judgment and report explaining its decisions. The Appellant challenged aspects of the Tribunal's conduct, including the chairman's remarks and the sending of a letter requesting the witness's attendance, the refusal to make a debarring order excluding the witness's evidence, and the decision to allow the witness to give evidence after the Appellant had given hers.
The appeal also addressed issues relating to the appointment and independence of Tribunal members, including the role and composition of the Tribunals Appointment Body ("TAB"), the involvement of members of the Respondent in COIC, and allegations of apparent bias or lack of impartiality under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights ("ECHR").
After extensive submissions and consideration of the relevant law and facts, the Visitors dismissed the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Disciplinary Tribunal was validly constituted, specifically regarding the participation of a barrister member whose appointment had expired.
- Whether the Tribunal exceeded its powers or acted with bias by making exhortatory remarks and sending a letter inviting a reluctant witness to attend.
- Whether the Tribunal erred in refusing to make a debarring order excluding the evidence of the reluctant witness.
- Whether the Tribunal was correct to permit the Respondent to reopen its case and call the reluctant witness after the Appellant had given evidence.
- Whether the Tribunal members, including lay and barrister members, were independent and impartial as required by Article 6 of the ECHR, given the appointment processes and connections with the Respondent.
- Whether there was actual or apparent bias on the part of a barrister member of the Tribunal based on subsequent conduct related to the appeal process.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The chairman of the Tribunal improperly exceeded his function by making remarks that were tantamount to veiled threats to a witness, thereby entering the arena and undermining impartiality.
- The Tribunal acted ultra vires by sending a letter on official headed paper inviting the witness to attend, equating to an unauthorized witness summons.
- The refusal to make a debarring order excluding the witness's evidence was unjustified given the witness's reluctance and non-attendance at key stages.
- The decision to permit the Respondent to reopen its case and call the witness after the Appellant had given evidence deprived the Appellant of a fair opportunity to make a no case to answer submission and to assess whether to give evidence.
- The Tribunal failed to consider that the Respondent could have sought a witness summons to compel the witness's attendance, which vitiates the exercise of discretion in allowing late evidence.
- The Tribunal was tainted by apparent bias and lacked independence and impartiality due to the appointment and review processes of Tribunal members, including the involvement of members of the Respondent in COIC and TAB.
- Specific allegations of actual bias were made against a barrister member of the Tribunal based on his subsequent engagement with the Respondent in preparing a witness statement during the appeal.
Respondent's Arguments
- The chairman's remarks and the letter were legitimate and constituted robust but proper encouragement to a solicitor to assist the Tribunal; no veiled threats or partiality existed.
- The Tribunal acted within its powers as it made no order or direction compelling attendance but merely requested the witness's cooperation.
- The refusal to make a debarring order was a reasonable exercise of discretion given the witness's importance and the possibility of his attendance.
- The Tribunal correctly applied the rules of natural justice and the Regulations in permitting the Respondent to reopen its case, aligning the approach with criminal procedural principles requiring exceptional or special circumstances.
- The Respondent reasonably believed it could not obtain a witness summons and took all reasonable steps to secure attendance; failure to seek a summons does not render the decision unfair.
- The appointment and review processes of Tribunal members, including lay and barrister members, were conducted with safeguards ensuring independence and impartiality; the involvement of members of the Respondent in COIC did not create a real risk of bias.
- The conduct of the barrister member during the appeal process was appropriate and did not demonstrate actual bias at the time of the Tribunal hearing.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| R v Visitors to the Inns of Court ex parte Calder [1994] QB 1 |
Appeal to Visitors is by way of re-hearing, not mere review. |
The court adopted the principle that appeals to the Visitors involve a fresh examination of the matters in dispute, guiding the approach to the appeal in this case. |
| G v G (Minors: Custody Appeal) [1985] 1 WLR 647 |
Appellate courts should only interfere with discretionary decisions if the lower court exceeded the ambit of reasonable disagreement. |
The court applied this principle to exercise restraint in overturning Tribunal's discretionary decisions. |
| Phonographic Performance Ltd v AIE Rediffusion Music Ltd [1999] 1 WLR 1507 |
Appellate interference requires error in principle or unfair balancing of factors. |
Used to assess the reasonableness of the Tribunal's discretionary decisions. |
| James v South Glamorgan CC [1994] 99 Crim.App. R.321 |
General rule that prosecution must call all evidence before closing case, with exceptions. |
Informed the court's evaluation of the Tribunal's discretion to admit late evidence. |
| R v Francis [1990] 91 Cr.App. R 271 |
Discretion to admit late prosecution evidence beyond established exceptions but to be exercised judicially. |
Guided the Tribunal's and court's approach to reopening the case to call late evidence. |
| Malcolm v Director of Public Prosecutions [2007] 1 WLR 1230 |
Modern criminal procedure requires identification of special circumstances to justify reopening prosecution case. |
The Tribunal applied this principle, requiring exceptional or special circumstances to admit late evidence. |
| Porter v Magill [2002] 2 AC 357 |
Test for apparent bias: whether a fair-minded and informed observer would conclude a real possibility of bias. |
Applied to assess allegations of bias and impartiality of Tribunal members. |
| Helow v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] 1 WLR 2416 |
Definition of the fair-minded and informed observer in bias analysis. |
Used to clarify the standard for assessing apparent bias claims. |
| Re P (a Barrister) [2005] 1 WLR 3019 |
Automatic disqualification where a tribunal member acts as judge in own cause. |
Considered in assessing whether TAB membership created disqualification or bias. |
| R (Kaur) v Institute of Legal Executives Appeal Tribunal [2011] EWCA 1168 |
Overlap of automatic disqualification and apparent bias doctrines; appearance of bias due to personal interest. |
Informed the court’s approach to perceived conflicts of interest in Tribunal appointments. |
| Findlay v United Kingdom (1997) 24 EHRR 221 |
Independence and impartiality under Article 6 ECHR require safeguards including appointment method and security of tenure. |
Applied to evaluate the Tribunal’s independence and impartiality. |
| Starrs v Ruxton 2000 SLT 42 |
Security of tenure is essential for judicial independence; temporary appointments lacking security may not be independent. |
Guided assessment of Tribunal members’ security of tenure and independence. |
| Clancy v Caird [2000] UKHRR 509 |
Security of tenure for temporary judges can satisfy independence if guaranteed against arbitrary removal. |
Considered in determining independence of Tribunal members with fixed terms. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a meticulous analysis of the procedural history, factual background, and relevant legal principles. It began by confirming the validity of the Tribunal's constitution, including the de facto authority of the barrister member whose formal appointment had expired, relying on prior findings of the Visitors.
Regarding the conduct of the Tribunal, the court examined the chairman's remarks and the letter sent to the reluctant witness. It concluded these were robust but proper encouragements aimed at securing attendance, not threats or orders exceeding jurisdiction. The court rejected claims of partiality or bias arising from this conduct, holding that a fair-minded observer would not perceive a real possibility of bias.
The refusal to make a debarring order excluding the witness's evidence was upheld as a reasonable exercise of discretion, taking into account the witness's importance and the possibility of his late attendance. The court acknowledged that although a different Tribunal might have decided otherwise, the decision was within the generous ambit of reasonable disagreement.
The court carefully considered the Tribunal's decision to permit the Respondent to reopen its case and call the witness after the Appellant had given evidence. It affirmed that the Tribunal correctly applied the rules of natural justice and the relevant Regulations, adopting an approach aligned with criminal procedural principles requiring exceptional or special circumstances to justify such an admission of late evidence. The Tribunal's detailed reasoning and balancing of factors were found unimpeachable.
The court addressed the Appellant's argument that the Respondent should have sought a witness summons to compel attendance. It found that the Respondent genuinely believed such a step was unavailable and took reasonable measures to secure attendance. The failure to seek a summons did not render the Tribunal's decision unfair.
On the issue of apparent bias and independence, the court examined the appointment and review processes of Tribunal members, the role of TAB, and the involvement of members of the Respondent in COIC. It applied the test from Porter v Magill and related authorities, concluding that there was no real possibility of bias. The safeguards in the appointment process, including assessment against written criteria, training, and the role of a distinguished judge as President of COIC, ensured adequate independence and impartiality.
The court further rejected allegations of actual bias against a barrister member based on his subsequent cooperation with the Respondent during the appeal. It found no evidence that this conduct demonstrated bias at the time of the Tribunal hearing.
Overall, the court found the Appellant's submissions insufficient to undermine the validity of the Tribunal's decisions or its constitution and dismissed the appeal.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is DISMISSED.
The court upheld the decisions of the Disciplinary Tribunal and confirmed the validity of its constitution, the propriety of its procedural decisions, and the independence and impartiality of its members. The direct effect is that the findings of professional misconduct and the sanction imposed on the Appellant remain in force. The judgment does not establish new legal precedent but reinforces established principles regarding the conduct of disciplinary tribunals, the scope of appeals to the Visitors, and the standards for assessing bias and independence under Article 6 of the ECHR.