Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Emmett, R v

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 29th January 1999, the Appellant appeared before a Crown Court charged with five offences of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The prosecution proceeded on two counts, resulting in conviction on one count by jury direction and a guilty plea on the other after the judge ruled no defence of consent was available. The Appellant was sentenced on 23rd February 1999 to two consecutive suspended prison terms of nine months each. The appeal concerns whether consent is a valid defence where two adults engage in private sexual activity that causes or risks actual bodily harm, with foreseen potential harm.

The incidents involved the Appellant and his partner, who cohabited and subsequently married. The evidence included medical testimony describing injuries sustained during consensual sexual activities involving partial asphyxiation with a plastic bag and burning with lighter fuel. The injuries included conjunctival hemorrhages and a serious burn requiring medical attention. The Appellant admitted the activities were consensual but accepted they pushed boundaries of safety.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Does consent constitute a defence to a charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm under section 47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 where two adults consent to private sexual activity that causes or risks actual bodily harm, with the risk foreseen by both parties?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Appellant submitted that the activities were consensual and part of an energetic sexual relationship.
  • He relied on precedents such as R v Wilson, arguing that consensual bodily harm in private, particularly between spouses, should not constitute a criminal offence.
  • He contended that some sexual activities involving actual bodily harm should be viewed as rough love play, not criminal conduct.
  • He raised an argument based on the Local Government (Miscellaneous) Provisions Act, suggesting Parliament’s licensing of sex shops implied tolerance of certain sexual aids and practices.
  • He also invoked Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, arguing that criminal prosecution of consensual private sexual conduct breached rights to private and family life.

Crown's Arguments

  • The Crown maintained that consent is not a defence to assault occasioning actual bodily harm where the harm or risk is significant and foreseeable.
  • They relied on the House of Lords decision in R v Brown, which held that public policy forbids consent as a defence in sadomasochistic acts causing actual bodily harm.
  • The Crown argued the injuries and risks in this case exceeded those in R v Wilson, justifying criminal intervention.
  • They rejected the Local Government Act argument as irrelevant and absurd if construed as permitting actual bodily harm.
  • The Crown contended that enforcement of criminal law in such cases does not breach Article 8, citing the House of Lords and European Court of Human Rights rulings affirming the state's interest in preventing violence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R v Brown [1994] AC 212 Consent is not a defence to assault occasioning actual bodily harm in sadomasochistic acts causing non-trivial injury. The court relied heavily on this authority to hold that consent could not form a defence where actual or potential serious harm was involved.
Attorney-General's Reference No 6 of 1980 73 Cr App R 63 Public interest requires that causing actual bodily harm for no good reason is unlawful, regardless of consent. Referenced to support the principle that consent does not justify causing actual bodily harm outside lawful exceptions.
R v Jones (1988) 83 Cr App R 335 Rough and undisciplined horseplay without intent to injure is not criminal assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The Appellant relied on this case to argue for a similar approach; the court distinguished it from the present facts.
R v Wilson [1996] 2 Cr App R 241 Consent may be a defence to bodily harm in private consensual acts between spouses if injury is not serious. The court distinguished this case, noting that the injuries and risks in the present case were far more serious.
Laskey v United Kingdom 24 EHRR 39 Enforcement of laws prohibiting intentional bodily harm does not violate Article 8 rights to private life. Used to reject the argument that prosecution of consensual sadomasochistic acts breaches human rights protections.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the facts, emphasizing the seriousness and foreseeability of the injuries sustained during consensual sexual activities involving partial asphyxiation and burning. It acknowledged the Appellant’s acceptance that the activities pushed boundaries and involved significant risk.

The court then analyzed relevant legal authorities, primarily the House of Lords decision in R v Brown, which held that consent is no defence to assault occasioning actual bodily harm in sadomasochistic contexts due to public policy concerns. The court noted that the injuries in the present case were at least as serious as those in Brown, involving real risk of severe injury or death.

The court distinguished R v Wilson, where consensual branding between spouses was held not to constitute an offence, on the basis that the injuries here were more serious and the risk greater. It rejected the Appellant’s argument that the activities were merely rough love play, concluding that the degree of harm and unpredictability warranted criminal law intervention.

Regarding the Local Government Act argument, the court dismissed it as irrelevant and absurd to suggest Parliament intended to permit actual bodily harm in sexual contexts by licensing sex shops.

On the human rights argument invoking Article 8, the court relied on the House of Lords and European Court of Human Rights decisions to hold that protecting society from intentional bodily harm justifies interference with private life rights. It concluded that prosecution in these circumstances does not breach Article 8.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal, affirming the conviction and the principle that consent is no defence to assault occasioning actual bodily harm where the harm or risk is significant and foreseeable in consensual sexual activity.

The direct effect of this decision is to uphold the criminal law’s intervention in private sexual conduct that causes or risks actual bodily harm beyond trivial injury, reinforcing the precedent set in R v Brown. The court clarified that the exceptions recognized in previous cases, such as tattooing or consensual branding between spouses, do not extend to activities carrying serious risk of harm. No new legal precedent was established beyond affirming existing principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Emmett, R v

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Emmett, R v
(Jun 18, 1999)