Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates

BELL AGAINST ALLIANCE MEDICAL Ltd AND JACKIE McCOLL AND FORTH VALLEY HEALTH BOARD

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff underwent an MRI scan at a hospital operated by the Health Board on 26 January 2009, during which a cannula was inserted into her left arm by an employee of the Defendant Company A. The cannula was intended for venous access but was inadvertently inserted into the brachial artery, causing an arterial occlusion and subsequent ischemia in the Plaintiff's arm. The Plaintiff alleges negligence in the handling of the cannula, particularly the failure to recognize and respond to a spurt of blood upon removal, indicative of arterial puncture. The Defendants deny liability and seek indemnification from the first third party, the employee who performed the cannulation, who in turn seeks contribution from the Health Board, the second third party. Damages of £700,000 were agreed, leaving liability and causation as the central issues for determination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the first third party was negligent in failing to recognize and appropriately respond to a spurt of blood upon removal of the cannula.
  2. Whether such negligence caused or materially contributed to the Plaintiff’s injury.
  3. Whether the Defendant Company A is entitled to indemnification from the first third party for any liability arising from the employee’s negligence.
  4. Whether the first third party is entitled to contribution from the Health Board under section 3 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Scotland) Act 1940.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff asserts that a spurt of blood occurred upon removal of the cannula, indicative of arterial puncture, which was ignored by the first third party.
  • The first third party had a duty to recognize this sign and seek immediate medical assistance to prevent further injury.
  • Failure to act on the spurt of blood caused the Plaintiff’s ischemic injury.
  • The Plaintiff’s evidence is credible and consistent with expert medical opinion supporting the occurrence of the spurt and negligence.

Defendant Company A's Arguments

  • The Defendant denies that a spurt of blood occurred and disputes negligence.
  • The Defendant contends that even if the cannula was inadvertently inserted into the artery, this alone does not constitute negligence.
  • The Plaintiff failed to call a key witness, the recommending neurologist, whose letter did not corroborate the spurt of blood.
  • The Defendant submits that the first third party is liable and seeks indemnification or contribution from her.

First Third Party's Arguments

  • The first third party denies liability and the occurrence of a spurt of blood.
  • She asserts that she would have recognized and acted upon any arterial spurt if it had occurred.
  • She seeks contribution from the Health Board, arguing the Board owes the Plaintiff a non-delegable duty of care.
  • She challenges the application of the indemnification principle relied upon by the Defendant Company A.

Health Board's Arguments

  • The Health Board acknowledges a non-delegable duty of care to the Plaintiff.
  • However, it denies liability for contribution, submitting that any breach arose solely from the first third party’s negligence.
  • It argues that allowing contribution would permit the first third party to rely on her own wrongdoing, which is unsupported by precedent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hunter v Hanley 1955 SC 200 Standard of care test for professional negligence in Scotland. Accepted by parties that ignoring a spurt of blood would meet the test of negligence.
Joyce v Merton, Sutton and Wandsworth Health Authority [1996] PIQR 121 Weight to be given to professional’s evidence when contradicted by other evidence. Referenced in assessing credibility of the first third party’s denial of negligence.
Bolitho v City & Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232 Test for causation and the role of expert medical opinion on omissions. Distinguished by the court as not directly applicable to the facts of this case.
Lister v Romford Ice and Cold Storage Co Ltd [1957] AC 555 Employer’s right to indemnity from negligent employee for damages paid. Applied to hold that the Defendant Company A is entitled to indemnification from the first third party.
Morris v Ford Motor Co Ltd [1973] 1 QB 792 Limits and interpretation of Lister regarding indemnity claims between employer and employee. Considered in submissions; court upheld Lister as still good law despite criticisms.
Woodland v Swimming Teachers Association [2013] UKSC 66 Non-delegable duty of care owed by health boards. Accepted that the Health Board owed a non-delegable duty to the Plaintiff.
Farstad Supply AS v Enviroco Ltd 2010 SC(UKSC) 87 Doctrine of frustra petis (claims that are doomed to fail). Applied to reject the claim for contribution by the first third party against the Health Board.
Lister v Hesley Hall Ltd [2001] UKHL 22 Expansion of vicarious liability to include intentional wrongs by employees. Referenced in the discussion of developments in vicarious liability but not directly applied.
Majrowski v Guy’s and St Thomas’s NHS Trust [2007] 1 AC 224 Further developments in vicarious liability law. Referenced in submissions about the evolving nature of vicarious liability.
London Drugs Ltd v Kuehne & Nagel International Ltd [1992] 3 SCR 299 Canadian approach to employer and employee liability and indemnity. Considered in submissions on the policy underpinning indemnity claims.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully evaluated the credibility of the Plaintiff’s evidence regarding the spurt of blood and the first third party’s denial of its occurrence. While acknowledging some inconsistencies and exaggerations in the Plaintiff’s account, the court found her generally credible and accepted that the spurt of blood likely occurred. The first third party’s refusal to accept any error was noted as dogmatic and troubling, suggesting an inability to acknowledge a mistake.

Medical expert evidence indicated that arterial puncture usually results in a spurt of blood, though exceptions exist depending on the cannula’s position and artery size. The court found the medical evidence marginally supportive of the Plaintiff but not decisive, concluding on balance that a spurt occurred.

On causation, the court rejected the applicability of the Bolitho test, as there was no dispute about what should have been done had the spurt been recognized. The court found that had the arterial puncture been detected and treated promptly, the Plaintiff’s injury would likely have been substantially mitigated.

Regarding indemnification, the court considered the principles established in Lister v Romford Ice and Cold Storage Co Ltd, affirming that the Defendant Company A is entitled to indemnification from the first third party as an implied term of employment. Although recognizing criticisms and policy considerations challenging Lister’s modern applicability, the court held it remains good law in Scotland.

On the claim for contribution from the Health Board, the court accepted that the Board owed a non-delegable duty of care but declined to allow contribution from the Board to the first third party, reasoning that permitting such would allow a party to rely on their own wrongdoing, contrary to principle and precedent.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the first third party was negligent in failing to recognize and act upon the spurt of blood, that this negligence caused the Plaintiff’s injury, and that the Defendant Company A is vicariously liable for this negligence.

The court further held that the Defendant Company A is entitled to indemnification from the first third party for any damages paid to the Plaintiff. However, the first third party’s claim for contribution from the Health Board was refused.

The direct effect is that the Plaintiff will receive damages as agreed, the Defendant Company A bears liability, and the first third party bears financial responsibility to indemnify the Defendant. No new precedent was established, but the decision reaffirms the continued applicability of Lister and the limits on contribution claims against health boards in similar contexts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

BELL AGAINST ALLIANCE MEDICAL Ltd AND JACKIE McCOLL AND FORTH VALLEY HEALTH BOARD

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

BELL AGAINST ALLIANCE MEDICAL Ltd AND JACKIE McCOLL AND FORTH VALLEY HEALTH BOARD
(Apr 2, 2015)