Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
- The
claimant was present and represented himself.
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
Holscher v. University of Ulster
Smart Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns a claim brought by the Plaintiff against Company B alleging detriments on the ground of making a protected disclosure under Part VA of the Employment Rights (Northern Ireland) Order 1996. The tribunal unanimously decided that the Plaintiff's claim was out of time and thus outside the tribunal's jurisdiction. Additionally, the claim was dismissed on further substantive grounds as detailed in the tribunal's conclusions. The Plaintiff unsuccessfully sought a review of this decision but did not appeal. Subsequently, Company B applied for a costs order against the Plaintiff related to the claim proceedings. The substantive hearing took place over multiple days in December 2013. Prior to the hearing, Company B's solicitors formally warned the Plaintiff's solicitors that if the claim was not withdrawn due to lack of reasonable prospects of success and vexatious conduct, Company B would seek to recover costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Plaintiff acted unreasonably, vexatiously, or misconceived the claim in bringing or conducting the proceedings.
- Whether it was appropriate for the tribunal to exercise its discretion to award costs against the Plaintiff under the Industrial Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2005.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Plaintiff complained about the large volume of documentation received shortly before the hearing and the lateness of Company B’s submissions for the costs hearing.
- The Plaintiff emphasized that Company B did not seek to strike out the claim or apply for a deposit order hearing.
- The Plaintiff maintained he had appropriate legal advice, acted in good faith, and that the claim concerned treatment by Company B after raising serious issues, not related to a separate matter involving a third party.
- The Plaintiff argued it was difficult to prove conspiracy due to the nature of evidence and that it was unreasonable to expect hard proof of such allegations.
- The Plaintiff sought to challenge aspects of the tribunal’s decision related to involvement of certain individuals until objected to by Company B’s counsel.
Company B's Arguments
- Company B acknowledged the case was not suitable for strike-out or deposit order but contended that time limitation and public interest disclosure issues required evidence to resolve.
- Company B submitted the claim was misconceived because the Plaintiff knew or ought to have known it was out of time.
- The Plaintiff’s conduct was unreasonable and vexatious, demonstrated by serious allegations against senior members of Company B that were not pursued in cross-examination or referenced in the claim documentation.
- The Plaintiff was fixated on unrelated issues and used the tribunal proceedings to publicize those concerns, including attempts to ensure media coverage during the hearing.
- Company B submitted the Plaintiff’s credibility was questionable and urged the tribunal to exercise its discretion to award costs up to the maximum amount.
- Company B highlighted the Plaintiff had access to legal assistance throughout the proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Paul Keogh v Banbridge and District Citizens Advice Bureau |
Summary of law on costs under Industrial Tribunal Rules |
Tribunal used this case as guidance on awarding costs but did not replicate full summary. |
| Peifer v Castlederg High School and Western Education and Library Board (2008) NICA 49 |
Encouragement for tribunals to use costs powers to penalise time wasting and unfair cost increases |
Tribunal mindful of this principle when considering costs against the Plaintiff. |
| ET Marler Ltd v Robertson (1974) ICR 72 |
Definition of vexatious conduct as bringing hopeless claims with improper motives |
Tribunal noted serious nature of finding vexatious conduct and exercised discretion sparingly. |
| McPherson v BNP Paribas [2004] EWCA Civ 569 |
No need for direct causal link between unreasonable conduct and costs incurred |
Tribunal considered this when assessing unreasonable behaviour without requiring precise causation. |
| Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council v Yerrakalva [2011] EWCA Civ 1255 |
Discretion to award costs requires consideration of whole picture of conduct |
Tribunal applied a holistic approach to determine unreasonable conduct and its effects. |
| Peat & Others v Birmingham City Council (UKEAT 0503/11) |
Costs may be awarded for unreasonable conduct even if no lack of reasonable prospects of success |
Tribunal recognized that unreasonable conduct alone can justify costs. |
| Criddle v Epcot Ltd (UKEAT/0275/05) and Khan v Kirklees BC (2007) EWCA Civ 1342 |
Two-stage process for awarding costs: establish unreasonable/vexatious conduct or misconceived claim, then decide on discretion |
Tribunal followed this process before making costs order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The tribunal began by reviewing the legal framework governing costs awards under the Industrial Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2005, focusing on circumstances justifying costs such as vexatious, abusive, disruptive, or otherwise unreasonable conduct, or where the claim is misconceived (i.e., lacking reasonable prospects of success).
It acknowledged that costs orders are compensatory, not punitive, and are exceptions rather than the rule. The tribunal considered the parties’ submissions and evidence, including the Plaintiff’s retention of experienced solicitors and access to legal assistance during the hearing.
The tribunal found no sufficient evidence that the Plaintiff acted vexatiously or that the claim was misconceived at the outset. However, it concluded that the Plaintiff acted unreasonably in conducting the proceedings. This was based on serious allegations made against senior members of Company B which were not pursued in cross-examination or documented formally in the claim or witness statements. The Plaintiff’s fixation on unrelated matters and use of the tribunal proceedings to publicize these issues, including attempts to attract media attention, further evidenced unreasonable behaviour.
This unreasonable conduct prolonged the proceedings and caused unnecessary additional costs to Company B. Having established the Plaintiff’s ability to pay, the tribunal exercised its discretion to order costs against the Plaintiff but limited the amount to £5,000, reflecting the nature and extent of the unreasonable conduct rather than a punitive measure.
Holding and Implications
The tribunal ordered the Plaintiff to pay costs to Company B in the sum of £5,000.
The direct effect of this decision is a financial obligation on the Plaintiff to reimburse Company B for part of the costs incurred due to the Plaintiff’s unreasonable conduct in the proceedings. The tribunal did not find the claim to be vexatious or wholly misconceived, and the costs award reflects a measured exercise of discretion rather than establishing new legal precedent.
Click here to read the full judgment