Factual and Procedural Background
On 28 November 2014, Plaintiff suffered a major cardiac arrest resulting in a 25-minute period before spontaneous circulation was restored. This caused hypoxic brain damage, leaving Plaintiff with a profound and prolonged disorder of consciousness, wholly dependent on intensive care for all aspects of care. On 20 January 2015, Company A, responsible for Plaintiff's care, applied for declarations regarding Plaintiff's capacity, the lawfulness of withholding cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), and whether renal replacement therapy (RRT) could lawfully be discontinued, which would lead to Plaintiff's death.
Multiple hearings were held, including a judgment on 13 March 2015 concerning press notification and reporting restrictions. The relationship between Company A and Plaintiff's family became increasingly polarized, with the family asserting Plaintiff was in a minimally conscious state (MCS) and opposing withdrawal of treatment, while Company A considered Plaintiff to be in a permanent vegetative state (VS). Video evidence submitted by the family provided significant insight, influencing the court's assessment.
The hearing spanned five days, with expert assessments using structured tools (SMART) confirming Plaintiff's diagnosis as MCS. Despite initial conflicting opinions, the treating neurologist revised his diagnosis to align with the MCS finding. The court ultimately concluded it was lawful and necessary to continue RRT, reversing the initial application for its discontinuance.
Legal Issues Presented
- Does Plaintiff lack capacity to make decisions regarding medical treatment, specifically renal replacement therapy?
- Is it lawful and in Plaintiff's best interests to withhold cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the event of cardiac arrest?
- Is it lawful and in Plaintiff's best interests to continue or discontinue renal replacement therapy given Plaintiff's disorder of consciousness and prognosis?
Arguments of the Parties
Company A's Arguments
- Plaintiff lacks capacity, which is uncontentious.
- It is not in Plaintiff's best interests to receive CPR; this is now uncontentious.
- RRT should be discontinued as life-sustaining treatment, leading to Plaintiff's death.
- Initially, diagnosis was considered permanent vegetative state, supporting withdrawal of treatment.
- Concerned about privacy and dignity regarding family video recordings but opposed reliance on them.
- Later sought to withdraw a broader range of treatments after diagnosis shifted to MCS without further application.
Plaintiff's Family's Arguments
- Plaintiff is in a minimally conscious state, not vegetative state.
- Family witnesses purposeful responses and submitted video evidence showing conscious awareness.
- Discontinuation of treatment would contravene Plaintiff's personal and religious views and not be in best interests.
- Family is articulate, well-informed, and consistently maintained their position.
- Expressed that Plaintiff would want life-preserving treatment to continue.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Portsmouth Hospitals NHS Trust v Wyatt [2005] 1 WLR 3995 |
Best interests must be given a generous interpretation; recognition of the infinite variety of human condition defeating precise definition. |
Used to emphasize holistic, individualized best interests assessment and caution in making declarations. |
| Lincolnshire NHS Trust v N [2014] EWCOP 16 |
Application of Mental Capacity Act principles and best interests in withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment. |
Referenced for principles guiding best interests evaluation. |
| Aintree University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v James [2013] UKSC 67 |
Clarification of best interests test under MCA including substituted judgment and importance of patient's wishes and values. |
Heavily relied upon for interpreting MCA section 4 and the approach to best interests balancing. |
| Re B (A Minor) (Wardship: Medical Treatment) [1981] 1 WLR 1421 |
Test of intolerability of life to patient as a factor in treatment decisions. |
Discussed in context of balancing treatment burdens and quality of life. |
| Re J (Wardship: Medical Treatment) [1991] Fam 33 |
Consideration of pain, suffering, and quality of life in best interests analysis. |
Supported approach to holistic welfare assessment and quality of life considerations. |
| Re F and Re S (Adult Patient: Sterilisation) [2001] Fam 15 |
Rejection of Bolam test for best interests decisions; focus on patient as individual. |
Referenced to reject reliance solely on medical opinion and emphasize patient-centered approach. |
| Re M [2012] 1 WLR 1653 |
Balancing burdens and benefits in best interests under MCA. |
Applied in weighing treatment burdens against benefits of continued life. |
| W v M (Adult Patient) [2012] 1 WLR 1653 |
Necessity of standardized assessment (SMART) before withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment applications. |
Emphasized importance of structured and repeated assessments prior to court applications. |
| Re B (A Child) (Care Proceedings: Appeal) [2013] UKSC 33 |
Appellate court's deference to trial judge's findings in sensitive medical decisions. |
Supported court's caution in interfering with trial judge's best interests decision. |
| Bland [1993] AC 789 |
Sanctity of life principle and circumstances allowing withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment. |
Underpinned the presumption in favor of preserving life but acknowledged exceptions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began with the uncontested finding that Plaintiff lacks capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA). The primary legal framework applied was MCA sections 1, 2, 3, and 4, focusing on best interests determinations for persons lacking capacity. The court emphasized the necessity of a holistic, individualized assessment including medical evidence, family views, and independent expert opinions.
Diagnosis was critical: whether Plaintiff was in a permanent vegetative state (VS) or minimally conscious state (MCS) affected the legal approach. Initial clinical opinions conflicted, but structured assessments using the SMART tool and video evidence demonstrated Plaintiff was in MCS, consistent with family accounts. The court highlighted the high rate of misdiagnosis in disorders of consciousness and the paramount importance of rigorous, repeated assessments before making life-ending decisions.
The court weighed whether RRT was futile, overly burdensome, or without prospect of recovery. It found RRT was not futile as it preserved Plaintiff's life and was not overly burdensome given Plaintiff's low level of consciousness and lack of evidence of pain. Prognosis was poor, but some possibility of improved awareness remained. The court gave significant weight to Plaintiff's prior expressed wishes, religious beliefs, and family testimony, which strongly supported continuation of life-sustaining treatment.
Legal precedents and the MCA Code of Practice guided the court's approach, emphasizing the sanctity of life as a strong but not absolute presumption, the importance of considering the patient's own values and wishes, and the necessity to avoid decisions motivated by a desire to cause death. The court was critical of the Trust's application to withdraw treatment without further application following the revised diagnosis and stressed the importance of clear diagnosis and structured assessments before such applications.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: It is declared that Plaintiff lacks capacity to conduct proceedings and to make decisions about renal replacement therapy. It is lawful and in Plaintiff's best interests for renal replacement therapy to continue. The application to discontinue life-sustaining treatment is refused.
Company A is ordered to pay half of the Official Solicitor's costs, with detailed assessment for the second respondent's publicly-funded costs. No other costs orders were made.
The decision directly affects the parties by requiring continuation of life-sustaining treatment for Plaintiff. No new legal precedent was established; rather, the ruling applied established principles emphasizing rigorous diagnosis, holistic best interests assessment, and respect for the sanctity of life. The judgment underscores the necessity of structured, repeated assessments (such as SMART) before applications to withdraw life-sustaining treatment in patients with disorders of consciousness.