Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

VLM Holdings Ltd v. Ravensworth Digital Services Ltd

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This case concerns whether a copyright sub-licence granted by a licensee can survive the termination of the head licence, and if so, the effect of that sub-licence on a subsequent exclusive licence granted by the head licensor. Holdings, the copyright owner of software facilitating online printing services, granted an informal licence to UK, a subsidiary, to exploit the copyright in the UK. UK then licensed the software to an estate agency (referred to as Spicerhaart) for printing property particulars and other documents. UK went into liquidation, prompting Holdings to terminate UK’s licence rights, claiming this also ended any licences UK had granted. Holdings subsequently granted an exclusive licence over the software to Ravensworth, a competing printing company.

Spicerhaart continued to rely on its licence, but Ravensworth contended that this negated its exclusivity and constituted a material breach of its exclusive licence, entitling Ravensworth to cease royalty payments and to claim beneficial ownership of the copyright under the licence terms. The central legal questions arose as to whether the Spicerhaart sub-licence survived the termination of the Holdings/UK licence, and the materiality and remediability of any breach resulting from this.

The software at issue (the VS system) was developed and exploited by the VLM group, including Holdings (the holding company), UK (the UK operating company), and Content (an Irish company for tax purposes). The VS system allowed users, including estate agencies, to design printed materials online and have them printed by VLM or Ravensworth. Spicerhaart was a major customer, heavily reliant on the VS system.

UK experienced financial difficulties in 2008-2009 leading to liquidation. Holdings terminated UK’s licence rights by board resolution in March 2009. Holdings then granted Ravensworth an exclusive licence and conditional assignment of the software rights on 23 March 2009. Ravensworth began using the software, including for Spicerhaart’s business. Disputes arose when Spicerhaart asserted its licence rights post-liquidation, leading to correspondence and claims of breach and termination between Holdings and Ravensworth.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Did the board resolution of Holdings of 18 March 2009 terminate the Spicerhaart licence?
  2. If not, was the Spicerhaart licence terminated by the winding up of UK?
  3. If the Spicerhaart licence survived, was the resultant breach of the Ravensworth licence material?
  4. If material, was the breach remediable?

Arguments of the Parties

Claimant's (Holdings) Arguments

  • The termination of UK's licence by Holdings' board resolution also terminated the Spicerhaart sub-licence.
  • The winding up of UK further terminated the Spicerhaart licence.
  • Ravensworth’s failure to pay royalties due to the existence of the Spicerhaart licence was a material breach justifying termination.

Defendant's (Ravensworth) Arguments

  • The Spicerhaart licence survived the termination of the Holdings/UK licence and the winding up of UK.
  • The existence of the Spicerhaart licence negated the exclusivity of Ravensworth’s licence and was a material breach.
  • The breach was irremediable as Spicerhaart would not relinquish its licence.
  • The loss of Spicerhaart’s business was due to factors other than the breach, including Ravensworth’s own conduct.
  • The Spicerhaart licence was for business resilience and did not permit competing printing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Austin Baldwin v Magnetic Car Company (1925) 42 RPC 454 Effect of termination of a head licence on sub-licences in a chain of licences. Held that termination of a licence higher in the chain brought sub-licences to an end; the case was considered fact-specific and limited in principle.
Allen & Hanburys v Generics UK Ltd [1986] RPC 203 Licence as permission, not a proprietary right; distinction between licences and leases. Supported the proposition that licences do not create proprietary rights and their termination depends on authority granted by the owner.
Pickard v Sears (1837) 6 Ad & E 469 Estoppel by conduct where owner allowed another to hold out as owner, precluding assertion of contrary title. Applied analogy to Holdings’ conduct allowing UK to represent ownership, estopping Holdings from denying the licence’s validity to Spicerhaart.
Mediterranean Salvage and Towage Ltd v Seamar Trading and Commerce Inc [2009] EWCA 531 Test for implying terms in contracts – necessity to make the contract work. Rejected implication that winding up of UK terminated the Spicerhaart licence as not necessary for the contract to work.
Phoenix Media Ltd v Cobweb Information, unreported, 16 May 2000 Criteria for materiality of breach of contract. Applied criteria as checklist to determine that breach was material in this case.
Gallagher International Ltd v Tias Enterprises Ltd [2008] EWHC 804 Materiality of breach analysis. Agreed with use of Phoenix Media criteria as useful framework.
Crosstown Music Company v Rive Droite Music [2009] EWHC 600 Materiality of breach analysis. Also endorsed Phoenix Media criteria for assessing materiality.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by framing the key question as the effect of termination of the head licence on the sub-licence granted by UK to Spicerhaart. It rejected a simplistic view that the sub-licence automatically ended with the head licence, emphasizing that the outcome depends on the terms of the original licence, the sub-licence, and the scope of authority granted by the copyright owner (Holdings) to the sub-licensor (UK).

The court examined the informal licence from Holdings to UK, noting the near complete identity of directors and shared business aims, concluding that Holdings implicitly authorised UK to grant the Spicerhaart licence. This implied authority meant that the permission to use the software under the sub-licence came from Holdings as well as UK. The court also considered estoppel, finding that Holdings’ conduct in allowing UK to represent ownership estopped Holdings from denying the licence's validity to Spicerhaart.

Therefore, the termination of the informal licence between Holdings and UK by board resolution and UK’s liquidation did not terminate the Spicerhaart licence. The court rejected the implication of a term that winding up UK would terminate the sub-licence, reasoning that such implication was not necessary for the contract to work and would undermine commercial reality.

On materiality, the court applied established criteria considering the breach’s consequences, the explanation for the breach, and the contractual context. It found the breach plainly material. The Spicerhaart licence deprived Ravensworth of exclusivity over a major customer, which was a key reason for entering into the Ravensworth licence. The loss of Spicerhaart’s business was substantial and directly linked to the breach.

Regarding remediability, the court acknowledged that while theoretically remediable if Spicerhaart could be persuaded to surrender its licence, in reality the breach was unremedied and effectively irremediable.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the Spicerhaart licence survived the termination of the Holdings/UK head licence and the winding up of UK, thereby rendering the Ravensworth licence non-exclusive. This constituted a material and unremedied breach by Holdings.

The claim by Holdings fails and the counterclaim by Ravensworth succeeds.

The direct effect is that Ravensworth is entitled to terminate the licence and claim the rights conferred under the licence, including beneficial ownership of the copyright. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts. Further argument on the form of relief was reserved.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

VLM Holdings Ltd v Ravensworth Digital Services Ltd

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

VLM Holdings Ltd v Ravensworth Digital Services Ltd
(Feb 13, 2013)