Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

Kohler Mira Ltd v. Bristan Group Ltd

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This case concerns design rights relating to electric shower units. The Plaintiff relies on two Registered Community Designs (RCDs) Nos. 000578463-0001 and 000578463-0002, and a UK unregistered design right (UDR) related to the Plaintiff's "Azora" product. The Defendant's three products, named Glee, Joy, and Smile, are alleged to infringe these rights.

The Plaintiff contends that all three Defendant products infringe both RCDs and the UK UDR. The Defendant denies infringement, argues independent derivation of the designs in relation to the UDR claim, and challenges the validity of the RCDs on grounds of lack of individual character. The Defendant also contends that certain design elements relied on by the Plaintiff are commonplace in the relevant design field.

The Plaintiff called an expert witness who designed the Plaintiff's products and gave evidence regarding the design corpus and commonality of features. The Defendant called several witnesses, including experts and employees involved in the design process of the Defendant products. Some witnesses were not cross-examined and provided evidence on market availability of certain products.

The dispute involves interpretation of the RCDs, assessment of individual character and novelty, and issues of copying and infringement under UK UDR law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Defendant's products infringe the Plaintiff's Registered Community Designs Nos. 000578463-0001 and 000578463-0002.
  2. Whether the Defendant's products infringe the Plaintiff's UK unregistered design right relating to the "Azora" product.
  3. Whether the RCDs possess individual character and are valid in light of prior art.
  4. Whether the Defendant independently derived their designs or copied the Plaintiff's design for the purposes of UK unregistered design right infringement.
  5. How to interpret the dashed lines in the RCD images and their effect on the scope of protection.
  6. The proper identification and scope of design aspects relied on under UK unregistered design right law.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Defendant products infringe both RCDs and the UK unregistered design right.
  • The RCDs possess individual character and are novel over the prior art cited by the Defendant.
  • The dashed lines in RCD 0002 indicate a transparent or translucent front face, which is a key distinguishing feature.
  • The overall impression of the RCD 0002 design is striking and distinct, particularly due to the transparent front plate and arrangement of controls.
  • There is a strong inference of copying of the Plaintiff's UK UDR design by the Defendant, given the significant similarities and market context.
  • The Defendant’s argument that certain features are commonplace is challenged, especially as some prior art relied on by the Defendant is old or obscure.
  • The flat front face and "tombstone" appearance are not commonplace in the relevant design field.
  • The Defendant products are made substantially to the Plaintiff’s UK UDR designs.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Defendant denies infringement of the RCDs and UK UDR.
  • The RCDs lack individual character and are invalid due to prior art including bathroom cabinets, picture frames, and light fittings.
  • The designs were independently derived, not copied, particularly with evidence from the Defendant’s design engineer.
  • The dashed lines in RCD 0002 indicate that the front piece is transparent or translucent, as supported by the Plaintiff’s product.
  • Certain design features relied on by the Plaintiff are commonplace in the design field.
  • Some differences in the Defendant products, such as opaque front panels and rounded corners, distinguish them from the Plaintiff’s designs.
  • The Defendant contests the Plaintiff’s characterization of aspects of the designs, including the scope of protection and interpretation of dashed lines.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Samsung v Apple [2012] EWHC 1882 (Pat); [2012] EWCA 1339 Definition and characteristics of the informed user; overall impression test for designs The court applied the approach to assessing overall impression and characteristics of the informed user as summarized in this case.
PepsiCo v Grupo Promer (C-281/10P) [2012] FSR 5 Definition of informed user and overall impression in design law Used as part of the distillation of legal principles regarding design infringement and individual character.
Grupo Promer v OHIM [2010] ECDR 7 Design law principles on individual character and novelty Considered in the court's assessment of individual character of the designs.
Shenzhen Taiden v OHIM, T-153/08 (22 June 2010) Overall impression and use of the product by the informed user Referenced regarding the importance of product use in forming overall impression.
Gimex v Chillbag [2012] EWPCC 31 Interpretation of overall impression and design features Used to support the court's approach to overall impression and design scope.
Sphere Time v OHIM (General Court T-68/10, 14 June 2011) Interpretation of dashed lines in design registrations as features not protected The court relied on this precedent to interpret dashed lines in RCD 0001 as indicating features for which no protection is sought.
Albert Packaging v Nampak [2011] EWPCC 15; [2012] EWCA Civ 143 Summary of UK unregistered design right law including originality and infringement The court adopted the legal approach to UK UDR infringement and originality as summarized in this case.
Ocular Sciences v Aspect Vision Care [1997] RPC 289 Commonplace combinations of features and originality under design right law Applied to assess whether combinations of features in the Plaintiff’s design were commonplace or original.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the designs of the Plaintiff and Defendant products, focusing on the overall impression on the informed user, the design corpus, and the prior art. The court interpreted the dashed lines in RCD 0002 as indicating a transparent or translucent front face, a key distinguishing feature that contributes to the individual character of that design. The court rejected the Defendant’s argument that the front face was opaque, finding that the dashed lines show visible features through the transparent plate.

Regarding RCD 0002, the court found that the design produces a striking, bold impression with sharp edges, flat surfaces, and a floating transparent front plate with aligned control knobs, which was a significant departure from prior art. The Defendant’s products lack the transparent front plate and have other differences such as rounded corners and no pips, leading the court to conclude that they do not produce the same overall impression and thus do not infringe RCD 0002.

For RCD 0001, the court interpreted the dashed lines as indicating features for which no protection is sought, specifically the knobs and power switch. The court found that RCD 0001 has individual character over the prior art cited but that the Defendant’s products produce a different overall impression due to differences including the absence of pips, thinner front plates with curved corners, and no recess. Consequently, no infringement of RCD 0001 was found.

On UK unregistered design right, the court identified specific aspects of the Plaintiff’s design relied upon, including the whole unit, the rectangular "tombstone" front appearance, and the arrangement of control knobs and power switch. The court found that the "tombstone" aspect and combinations including it were not commonplace in the relevant design field, while aspects relating solely to control knobs and power switch were commonplace.

The court assessed the evidence relating to copying and found a strong inference that the Defendant copied the Plaintiff’s design, given the significant similarities and market context. The Defendant’s evidence of independent design, including testimony from the design engineer, was found credible but insufficient to rebut the inference of copying. The court noted the involvement of multiple Bristan staff and the influence of existing market designs, including the Plaintiff’s Azora.

The court concluded that the Defendant’s products were made substantially to the Plaintiff’s UK UDR designs, despite some differences, and that copying had occurred. The differences were not sufficient to avoid infringement under UK UDR law.

Holding and Implications

The court held that Registered Community Designs Nos. 000578463-0001 and 000578463-0002 were not infringed by any of the Defendant's Glee, Joy, or Smile products.

The court held that the Defendant's Glee, Joy, and Smile products infringe the Plaintiff's UK unregistered design right.

The direct consequence is that the Defendant is found liable for infringement under UK unregistered design right but not under the Community registered designs. No new precedent was established, and the decision reflects the application of existing design law principles to the facts. The ruling underscores the distinction between registered and unregistered design rights, particularly regarding the significance of material features such as transparency and the scope of protection for design elements like control knobs.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Kohler Mira Ltd v Bristan Group Ltd

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Kohler Mira Ltd v Bristan Group Ltd
(Jan 28, 2013)