| Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Total Network [2008] 1 AC 1174 |
Definition and scope of conspiracy to injure by unlawful means; criminal conduct can constitute unlawful means. |
Supported the proposition that breaches of WFO (contempt) can amount to unlawful means; court relied on reasoning of Lords regarding unlawful means including crimes and torts. |
| Surzur Overseas Limited v Koros [1999] 2 Lloyd's Rep 611 |
Conspiracy to injure by unlawful means involving false documents and abuse of court process. |
Provided authority that conspiracy to abuse court process is actionable; suggested (but did not decide) breaches of freezing orders could be unlawful means. |
| Digicel (St. Lucia) Limited v Cable & Wireless [2010] EWHC 774 (Ch) |
Non-actionable breaches of non-criminal statutes do not constitute unlawful means. |
Court held it was not applicable to breaches of court orders; did not assist in deciding whether contempt can be unlawful means. |
| Customs and Excise Commissioners v Barclays Bank [2007] 1 AC 181 |
No duty of care owed by third party bank informed of freezing order; court orders enforceable only by contempt sanctions. |
Cited to support that damages are not available for contempt; court followed House of Lords' view that contempt jurisdiction is punitive, not compensatory. |
| Chapman v Honig [1963] 2 QB 502 |
Contempt jurisdiction protects administration of justice, not individuals; damages generally not available for contempt. |
Outlined arguments for and against damages for contempt; court did not decide definitively; supported the principle that contempt is not for private compensation. |
| Couling v Coxe (1848) 6 CB 703 |
Damages can be awarded for breach of witness summons. |
Recognized as an exception; court noted this authority but considered it inconsistent with more recent principles. |
| Fairclough v The Manchester Ship Canal (1897) 41 Sol. Journal 225 |
Obiter suggestion that damages could be awarded for contempt. |
Supported argument that damages may be available in some contempt cases; not binding but considered persuasive. |
| In re Mileage Conference Group of the Tyre Manufacturers' Conference Ltd.'s Agreement [1966] 1 WLR 1137 |
Obiter recognition that damages could be awarded for contempt. |
Used to support possibility of damages in contempt cases; not decisive. |
| The Messiniaki Tolmi [1983] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 666 |
Arguable civil cause of action for damages for aiding and abetting contempt. |
Supported Company's argument that damages may be recoverable for contempt-related conspiracy. |
| Midland Marts v Hobday [1989] 1 WLR 1143 |
Damages can be awarded where breach of court undertaking also breaches contract; contempt alone does not give rise to damages. |
Court found that damages for contempt alone are not established; distinguished cases where contractual breach exists. |
| Nunes v Agrawal (unreported, 1999) |
Contempt does not itself give cause of action; obiter comments on contempt and damages. |
Court found obiter comments not authoritative; did not preclude damages for contempt in other contexts. |
| Parker v Rasalingham (unreported, 2000) |
Some authority for court jurisdiction to award damages for breach of injunction. |
Supported Company's position that damages may be available for breach of court orders in certain circumstances. |
| Jeningon v Assaubayev [2010] EWHC 2351 (Ch) |
Procedure for ordering cross-examination on compliance with freezing orders. |
Referenced for procedural guidance on cross-examination related to WFO compliance. |
| Canada Trust v Stolzenberg (No.2) [1998] 1 WLR 547 |
Standard for establishing "much the better argument" under Lugano Convention jurisdiction provisions. |
Applied to evaluate jurisdictional arguments under Articles 5 and 6 of Lugano Convention. |
| Lady Brownlie v Four Seasons [2015] EWCA Civ 665 |
Clarification of jurisdictional tests under Lugano Convention. |
Supported analysis of jurisdiction under Articles 5 and 6; court applied its principles. |
| Petrotrade Inc. v Smith [1999] 1 WLR 457 |
Relevant date for domicile assessment under Lugano Convention is date of proceedings commencement. |
Applied to determine domicile date for Defendant in jurisdiction analysis. |
| Bank of Dubai v Fouad Haji Abbas [1997] ILPr 308 |
Definition of residence and domicile for jurisdictional purposes. |
Used to assess Defendant's domicile status in England. |
| R v Barnet LBC ex p. Shah [1983] 2 AC 309 |
Residence must be voluntarily adopted with a settled purpose. |
Guided court's assessment of Defendant's domicile given his flight and custody status. |
| Handelskwekerij GJ Bier v Mines de Potasse d'Alsace SA [1978] 1 QB 708 |
Interpretation of "place where harmful event occurred" in tort jurisdiction. |
Court applied principles to determine jurisdiction under Lugano Convention Article 5(3). |
| AMT Futures Ltd. v Marzillier [2015] QB 699 |
Clarified meaning of "place where damage occurred" for jurisdictional purposes. |
Guided court's evaluation of where damage was sustained for jurisdictional analysis. |
| Domicrest v Swiss Bank Corpn. [1999] QB 548 |
Place of event giving rise to damage in negligent misstatement cases. |
Considered but distinguished; court held conspiracy damage occurs on implementation, not hatching. |
| ABC1 v BFT [2003] EWCA Civ 205 |
Application of place of event giving rise to damage in conspiracy cases. |
Not directly helpful as conspiracy and damage occurred in same jurisdiction. |
| Sunderland Marine Mutual Insurance v Wiseman [2007] 1 CLC 989 |
Conspiracy to defraud and place of event giving rise to damage. |
Distinguished; did not resolve dispute on jurisdiction in present case. |
| Shevill v Presse Alliance [1995] 2 AC 18 |
Defamation jurisdiction principles. |
Rejected as analogy for conspiracy to injure by unlawful means. |
| Z Bank v D1 [1994] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 656 |
Freezing order breach and order for sequestration with possibility of compensation. |
Referenced in discussion on contempt sanctions and possible compensation. |