Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns two related applications made by Defendant under sections 70(6) and 70(7) of the Arbitration Act 1996 ("the 1996 Act") in relation to challenges brought by Plaintiff against an arbitration award dated 6 January 2014 ("Second Award"). Plaintiff and Defendant are companies incorporated in the Republic of Zambia, engaged in mining and mining contracting respectively. Their contractual relationship, covering mining services, led to disputes resolved initially by a Settlement Agreement in 2012, which Plaintiff later sought to rescind alleging fraudulent misrepresentation by Defendant.
Subsequent arbitration proceedings before a tribunal under the London Court of International Arbitration ("LCIA") rules resulted in multiple awards, including a First Award in November 2013 confirming the Settlement Agreement and ordering Plaintiff to pay Defendant substantial sums, and the Second Award in January 2014 ordering interim payments and addressing outstanding invoices. Plaintiff challenged the Second Award in this Court under sections 67 and 68 of the 1996 Act, alleging lack of jurisdiction and serious irregularity.
Defendant applied for security for costs relating to Plaintiff's challenges under s70(6) and for security for sums due under the Second Award under s70(7). The hearing of these applications occurred on 20 June 2014, with the substantive challenge hearing scheduled for July 2014.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court should order security for costs under section 70(6) of the Arbitration Act 1996 in respect of Plaintiff's challenges to the Second Award.
- Whether the Court should order security under section 70(7) of the Arbitration Act 1996 for sums allegedly payable under the Second Award pending determination of the challenges.
- The proper legal test and principles applicable to applications under sections 70(6) and 70(7) of the Arbitration Act 1996, including the relevance of the merits of the challenge and the risk of prejudice to enforcement.
- The nature of the Second Award, specifically whether parts of it constitute a final award or only interim or procedural orders.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- There is a real risk that Plaintiff will be unable to pay Defendant's costs if ordered to do so, justifying security for costs under s70(6).
- Evidence, including independent reports and witness statements, shows Plaintiff's financial position is precarious, with substantial liabilities, delayed payments to creditors, and risk of asset dissipation.
- Challenges to the Second Award are "flimsy" and do not justify withholding security; the Tribunal's orders, including the "show cause" provision, do not negate the award's binding nature.
- Security under s70(7) is appropriate because Plaintiff's challenges prejudice Defendant's ability to enforce the award, and there is a real risk of dissipation of assets.
- Vedanta, Plaintiff's parent company, has not provided security and its financial strength cannot be relied upon to support Plaintiff's position.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- Plaintiff is a major mining company with substantial assets and significant contributions to Zambia's economy, including employment and public revenue.
- Financial difficulties are largely due to external factors such as weak copper prices, increased production costs, and disputes with tax authorities, but Plaintiff remains solvent and has taken steps to improve its financial position.
- Security for costs is not justified because Plaintiff's assets are primarily located in Zambia, where enforcement of any costs order can be pursued under applicable laws.
- The application under s70(7) is inappropriate because the sums claimed are not "money payable under the award" as they are provisional or contingent, and the challenges are serious and arguable.
- Defendant's evidence is often based on media reports and politically motivated sources, which Plaintiff contends are unreliable and outweighed by Plaintiff's own audited financial statements and government support.
- Security offered by Plaintiff was less than Defendant's claimed amount, and Defendant's calculations of costs were excessive and inadequately supported.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Republic of Kazakhstan v Istil Group Inc [2006] 1 WLR 596 |
Principles governing security for costs under s70(6) of the Arbitration Act 1996, including the requirement to act in accordance with the overriding objective and the analogy to CPR 25.12 and 25.13. |
Court applied the principles to assess whether there was a real risk Plaintiff could not pay Defendant's costs, justifying security. |
| Azov Shipping Co v Baltic Shipping Co [1999] 2 Lloyd's Rep 39 |
Discretionary principles for ordering security for costs in the context of arbitration challenges, including consideration of the availability of assets for satisfaction of costs. |
Court relied on these principles to exercise discretion in favour of ordering security for costs given Plaintiff's financial position and conduct. |
| X v Y [2013] 1 Lloyd's Rep 230 |
Test for security for costs under s70(6) and s70(7): existence of a real risk that assets are not readily available for costs, and consideration of whether the challenge prejudices enforcement. |
Court adopted the "real risk" test and the requirement that security under s70(7) is justified only if the challenge prejudices enforcement. |
| A v B [2011] 1 Lloyd's Rep 363 |
Threshold requirement that challenges to awards must be shown to be flimsy or lacking substance to justify security under s70(7); security not to be ordered unless challenge prejudices enforcement. |
Court followed this approach, finding Plaintiff's challenges to be flimsy and that there was no evidence that challenges prejudiced enforcement, thus rejecting s70(7) security. |
| Danko International v Faucon Investment Co [2006] EWHC 3729 (Comm) |
Assessment of the general strength of serious irregularity claims under s68 and its relevance to ordering security. |
Court considered the strength of Plaintiff's challenges but noted no hard rules; applied with caution. |
| Terna Bahrain Holding Company WLL v Ali Marzook, Ali Binkamil & Ors [2012] EWHC 4395 (Comm) |
Consideration of whether challenges diminish the ability to honour awards and the appropriateness of security under s70(7). |
Court applied the principle that security should not be ordered merely to assist enforcement unless the challenge diminishes ability to honour award. |
| Peterson Farms v C&M Farming Limited [2003] EWHC 2298 (QB) |
Limits on using s70 jurisdiction to improve enforcement ability rather than preventing diminution of ability to honour awards. |
Court referenced this principle to reject security under s70(7) where challenges did not prejudice enforcement. |
| Sucafina S.A. v Rotenberg [2012] EWCA Civ 637 |
Clarification on the use and meaning of "interim award" in arbitration context. |
Court noted ambiguity of "interim award" term and used it to interpret the nature of the Second Award. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first confirmed jurisdiction to order security for costs under s70(6) and applied established principles analogous to CPR rules, focusing on whether there was a real risk Plaintiff could not pay Defendant's costs if ordered to do so. The Court found compelling evidence, including independent expert reports and witness statements, indicating Plaintiff's financial position was precarious, with liabilities exceeding liquid assets, evidence of delayed payments to creditors, and risk of asset dissipation. The Court rejected Plaintiff's reliance on its audited accounts and government support as insufficient to dispel this risk.
On the quantum of security, the Court found Defendant's updated claim excessive and inadequately supported, settling on a figure of £300,000 as reasonable security for costs, with liberty to apply.
Regarding security under s70(7) for sums payable under the Second Award, the Court examined whether the sums claimed were "money payable under the award" and whether Plaintiff's challenges prejudiced Defendant's ability to enforce the award. The Court noted the "show cause" provision rendered the sums provisional rather than finally adjudged. It also considered authoritative case law establishing that security under s70(7) should not be ordered unless the challenge is flimsy and prejudices enforcement.
The Court found Plaintiff's challenges to be "flimsy," given Plaintiff's failure to engage with the tribunal, withdrawal from a hearing, and lack of substantive reasons for non-payment. However, there was no evidence that the challenges themselves prejudiced enforcement in Zambia, where enforcement proceedings would occur. Although the Court accepted there was a real risk of dissipation of assets generally, it rejected the contention that this risk was linked to the challenges before it.
Consequently, the Court exercised its discretion to refuse security under s70(7) while emphasizing the importance of supporting the arbitral process but adhering to the statutory limits on ordering security.
Holding and Implications
The Court GRANTED Defendant's application for security for costs under section 70(6) of the Arbitration Act 1996 in the sum of £300,000, reflecting a real risk that Plaintiff would be unable to pay Defendant's costs if ordered to do so and the justness of such an order in all circumstances.
The Court REFUSED Defendant's application for security under section 70(7) of the 1996 Act for sums claimed under the Second Award, concluding that the challenges to the award, though "flimsy," did not prejudice Defendant's ability to enforce the award and that the sums claimed were not finally adjudged payable under the award.
The decision directly affects the parties by imposing a security for costs requirement on Plaintiff in respect of its arbitration challenges, but does not set new precedent beyond the application of established legal principles governing security for costs and security for sums payable under arbitration awards pending challenge.